Public talk stresses on 'asymmetrical federalism'
Source: The Sangai Express
Imphal, September 19 2023:
A public talk on "Understanding Asymmetrical Federalism: Spatial Identity & Constitutional Exceptionalities in North East" was organised by Meitei Students, JNU on September 15 at the School of International Studies- II, JNU campus.
The talk was addressed by Prof M Amarjit Singh (Centre for North East Studies and Policy Research, Jamia Millia Islamia) and Sapam Biswajit Meitei (Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India) .
It was moderated by Elangbam Ashakiran Chanu (PhD Scholar, CPS, JNU) with introductory remarks by Sophia Lisam (PhD Scholar, CSSS, JNU).
Prof M Amarjit Singh began the discussion by stating that ADCs were conceived as mechanisms for self-governance/management by tribes/ community and local socio- economic development.
In the context of Manipur, he reminded that there has been demand for implementation of sixth schedule based on the argument that existing ADCs are not properly functioning.
He argued against implementation of sixth schedule in Manipur and suggested that existing ADCs can be further empowered by entrusting them with more functions in important sectors like education, health and connectivity.
Sapam Bishwajit, on the other hand, emphasised that Manipuris (inclusive of all communities) are entitled to special rights and protection by virtue of the Merger Agreement, 1949 and that various constitutional amendments and special statutes should be put in place to give effect to the special status of Manipur.
On special provisions for hill areas of Manipur, he contended that Article 371 (c) already exists to protect the interests of hill areas and there is no need to implement the fifth and sixth schedule.
He suggested that Article 3 should be amended to safeguard the territorial integrity of Manipur, and stressed that it is high time to demand special provisions and statutes to safeguard Manipur, its diverse communities and their peaceful co- existence.