TODAY -
✦

ATLCC Tribal leaders committee refutes Govt's clarification
PMP Bill, 2015, MLR and LR (7th Amendment) Bill, 2015 Bill and MSE (Second Amendment) Bill, 2015 are not Money Bills
Source: The Sangai Express

Imphal, September 13 2015: The All Tribal Leaders Consultative Committee has issued a rejoinder to the point by point clarification issued by the Secretary to the Chief Minister on Protection of Manipur People's Bill, 2015, Manipur Land Revenue and Land Reforms (7th Amendment Bill, 2015) and Manipur Shops and Establishments (Second Amendment) Bill, 2015 .

Giving a point by point rebuttal the Committee in a statement enumerated their stand under separate headings.

1 The Protection of Manipur People Bill, 2O15: .

(1) Question whether this is a Money Bill : The Government introduced this Bill as a Money Bill and obtained recommendation of the Governor under Clauses (1) and (3) of Article 207 of the Constitution of India.

(a) The Preamble to the Bill spells out the objective - "to provide protection, maintenance of socio-economic and cultural balance of the Manipur People and for maintenance of peace and public order...and regulation of entry into and exit from Manipur for Non-Manipur persons and tenants" .

(b) Area of coverage : Clause (2) of Section 1.It shall extend to the whole of the State of Manipur.

(c) Statement of Objects and Reasons - Manipur is a small Hill State is objectionable as this is nowhere mentioned in the Constitution.

With geographical area of 22,327 Sq Km, the Hill Area covers 20,089 Sq Km and the valley has only 2,238 Sq Km.

The fear of influx of outsiders caused panic in the mind of the people of Manipur.

Hence the need for regulation and control.

(d) Expenditure (Money) involved: Reference to Financial Memorandum: For infrastructure development which is a non-recurring expenditure an amount of Rs 10.00 crore has been earmarked.

An approximate sum of Rs 80.00 lakh per annum earmarked for salaries, maintenance etc.



File photo of Churachandpur town after a number of protestors were killed
File photo of Churachandpur town after a number of protestors were killed


Money Bill is defined under Clauses (1) and (3) of the Constitution of India.

Money Bill relates to imposition of taxes and expenditures likely to involve transaction affecting the Consolidated Fund of the Union or the State.

In the above Bill, the Preamble, the Objectives and Reasons and coverage of area are not at all related to any taxation or expenditure matters which will affect the Consolidated Fund of the State Government.

The very title of the Bill ie Protection of Manipur People Bill - itself suggests the social security objectives and not taxation/monetary objective.

The expenditure involved for development of infrastructure, salaries and maintenance are secondary which will affect the Consolidated Fund of the State involving financial expenses both recurring and non-recurring.

But the spirit of the Bill has its social security objectives.

Hence the Bill fails to fulfil the criteria of a Money Bill.

Moreover, since the Act shall extend to the whole State of Manipur it invariably affects the hill people.

Therefore, the State Government by not referring the Bill to HAC violates the provisions of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business of Assembly - Rules 159 and 160 .

By introducing the said Bill in the Assembly and deliberately by-passing the Hill Areas Committee is in violation of the provisions of - The Manipur Legislative Assembly (Hill Areas Committee) Order, 1972 .

Article 4 Clause (1) - All Scheduled matters in so far as they relate to the Hill Areas shall be within the purview of the HAC and Clause (2) - Every Bill, other than a Money Bill affecting wholly or partly the Hill Areas and containing mainly provisions dealing with any of the Scheduled matters shall, after introduction in the Assembly, be referred to the HAC for consideration and report to the Assembly.

Hence, the claim of the Government that the said Bill is Money Bill is totally untenable as per law and absolutely misleading to the people.

The Other Aspect of the Bill : The Government has clarified that Sub-section (b) of Section 2 is intended for outsider/Non-Manipur persons who migrated into the State since 1951 and does not apply to the people of Manipur who were born, are born, lived and living in the State and protected under Clause (b) of Section 8 being - "Native People of the State of Manipur" .

The Govt has also clarified that under Clause (a) of Section 8 that "Native People" includes all sections/tribes living in Manipur (Hills & Valley) .

But on closer examination it is revealed that those persons who fulfil the three criteria under Clause (b) of Section 2 will be Native people of the State as inserted under Clause (a) of Section 8 of the already passed Bill, 2015.The term Native people is nowhere defined in the Act and does not come within the purview of Clause (b) of Section 2 of the said Bill passed by the Manipur Assembly on 31-08-2015.If the State Government intends to exclude the Tribals from the provision of Clause (b) of Section 2, the term "Non-Tribal residents of Manipur" should have been used instead of "Persons of Manipur" .

In essence, if the Act is to be implemented almost 70 % of the Tribal population in the hill areas will be excluded from the purview of Section 2 (b) of the Act and will be treated as Non-Manipur persons under Section 2 (c) of the Act with disastrous consequences.

Hence, the Protection of Manipur People Bill, 2015, passed by the Manipur Legislative Assembly is indicative of the deliberate intention of the Government to infringe on the rights and privileges of the Tribal people and gross violation of Article 371 C of the Indian Constitution.

.2The Manipur Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Seventh Amendment Bill, 2015): Evidence is on record that the Manipur Land Revenue and Land Reforms Act, 1960 has already been extended to the Hill Areas from time to time under Section 1(2) of the MLR & LR (Amendment) Act, 1975 in violation of Sub-section (2) of Section 1 of the Act.

Already large pockets of plain areas of Churachandpur, Ukhrul, Senapati (including Sadar Hills) and Tamenglong districts under wetland cultivation and whole of international border town - Moreh and the district capital Churachandpur and its vicinity have been brought under the MLR & LR Act, 1960 by virtue of insertion of "Proviso to sub-section of Sect 1" as per Manipur Act No 13 of 1976 published in the Manipur Gazette dated 24-05-76.Therefore, the insertion of the new Section 14A and 14B after Section 14 of the Principal Act in the present Amendment Bill is nothing but a ploy to further extend the MLR & LR Act to the whole hill areas of Manipur.

Interestingly, a critical analyses and legal interpretation will reveal that the permission for transfer of land from tribal to non-tribal can be given by the Deputy Commissioner subject to the consent of the District Council as per Clause (b) of Section 158 of the Principal Act of the MLR & LR Act, 1960 which says that - "where the transfer is to a person who is not a member of any such tribe, it is made with the previous permission in writing to the Dy Commissioner, provided that the DC shall not give such permission unless he has first secured the consent thereto of the District Council within whose jurisdiction the land lies" .

to be continued .


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • 24 hrs general strike [Nov 16]: Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2026 : Timeline
  • 3rd Ningol Chakouba 2026 in Bengaluru
  • Mizo Film 'Rini Leh Rina' : Edge of Limbo
  • Delhi sleepwalks through Naga-Kuki conflict
  • Misrepresentation of Thadou War
  • Ningol Chakouba in UAE
  • Literary Excellence with Book Releases
  • Electoral Literacy Club launched
  • Killings, violence continue
  • Sinai Camp Debacle: Unmasking Rotten Core
  • Kashopapu brings Sumi folklore, wisdom
  • Nashon Pikna @ 31st Int'l Film Fest Kerala
  • Myanmar, Manipur & price of engagement
  • Legal Services Day, 2026 observed
  • Conference on 'Bridging Technoscience'
  • Condemns Ongoing Violence
  • Environment for education
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #19
  • 228th Bheigyachandra @Nabadwip #4: Gallery
  • The Quiet Shelter of Her Smile :: Poem
  • Swedish filmmaker Mattias in Manipur
  • Competition: Are we striving together ?
  • Love in various guises :: Poem
  • Declining fertility rates & population policy
  • The King Who Bound Gods & Men: Story
  • Ningol Chakouba celebrated at Bangalore
  • The Way of the Mithun: Tribal Frames Manipur
  • Is Japan the answer for Nagaland youth
  • Wakhalgee - Powering Maniwood Global Pulse
  • Call for early action on diabetes
  • Leitlangpui Music Festival 2026
  • Time to disarm everyone
  • Ningol Chakouba @ Imphal : Gallery
  • Tribal Frames Manipur 2026 opens in Imphal
  • Indo Bangladesh Art Exhibition
  • Can MU lead a fish revolution ?
  • One Awakened Man :: Poem
  • Jiribam : Cleanest town in Manipur 2026
  • Surviving in relief centres
  • Ningol Chakouba- Mapam Lamdam #1: Gallery
  • Significance of Ningol Chakkouba Festival
  • Ningol Chakouba at Mumbai
  • Visit to Darul Uloom Banskandi - Barak Valley
  • Why Gen Z men experience early hair loss
  • Russia-India eco and biz ties
  • Ningol Chakkouba Fish Fair: Gallery
  • Nongsum killings put fragile truce to the test
  • 6th North East Fiesta 2026
  • Unfinished promise to our children
  • Tribal Futures 3.0 : Day 7 Report
  • Market for storytellers & business of faith
  • Of noise pollution and more
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping #1: Gallery
  • Sinalei, Lansinngam, Yaipuba : Eming
  • Catholic School Alumni Reunite in Celebration
  • Chenglou Henbi- Full-On Kangleiwood Dance
  • Science behind 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics
  • Suffering of people living in red & buffer zone
  • Open Letter of Appreciation & Solidarity
  • The answered questions
  • Rally - End proxy war in Manipur #2: Gallery
  • Myth Behind E W Dunn's 1881 Survey Data
  • Warmest greetings on Ningol Chakkouba
  • Ajay Bhalla's soft power
  • A maiden on the roadside :: Poem
  • Martin Garrix to perform in Shillong
  • Agrivoltaics can put the farmer at centre
  • Creating the right ambience
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #18
  • Enoong Ngallamdai Film Scenes: Gallery
  • Pat Jasan movement: Lessons from Kachin
  • Democracy :: Poem
  • Bharat Ratna LK Advani Ji at 100 !
  • Abhigyanm Stages 2 Productions
  • Health & Rights Observatory exposes gaps
  • Scholarship Exam in B'desh (Manipuri areas)
  • We can begin again :: Poem
  • MoU to Strengthen Academic Cooperation
  • Awareness Program on role of MSCW
  • Food Safety Drive at Thoubal
  • What nature knows that humanity has forgotten
  • The Gati Shakti mindset : Thinking citizen-first
  • Ineffective Govt, unthinking people
  • Ibudhou Nongda Lairen Haraoba #2 : Gallery
  • Roadmap for peace: Abrogate SoO Agreement
  • Former Minister Mohd Alauddin passes away
  • 11th General Elections of NESOJ
  • Conference: Modern Day Sustainable Science
  • Aizawl International Half Marathon 2027
  • Skin detox tips to follow post-Diwali
  • Politics of peace pact
  • Declassified Files : Death of Hijam Irawa
  • Raas Leela @Tirupati Dasara : Gallery
  • Narengbam Maxson: National Cycling Record
  • Common things about Chikungunya & Dengue
  • How public can preserve crime scene evidence
  • Educational empowerment: 12 years of access
  • Cutting off Imphal-Ukhrul road
  • Naga Peace Process: Indo-Naga Talk: Timeline
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @ Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur: A Generation Growing Up in Unrest
  • Chemistry Nobel Prize - 2026
  • Tribal Futures 3.0 : Day 1 Report
  • For future generations :: Poem
  • District Level Peace Committees
  • Thakhaisida Manipuri Theatre
  • Run up to the Assembly elections
  • Tharoi Yonbigi Macha #1: Gallery
  • fulN AmsuH mnorama :: Seireng
  • Clarification on Liangmai position
  • An Appeal for Peace & Reconciliation
  • Targeting the State or the people ?
  • Condemns ongoing killings in Manipur
  • Harshit Dhingaun Meets Meghalaya CM
  • More or less a free for all in the hills
  • 228th Bheigyachandra @Nabadwip #3: Gallery
  • First Convocation of NIELIT held
  • Thingujam Diana: Sabre Int'l Referee Exam
  • Compassion or something else ? :: Poem
  • Ecology Day 2026 is for safety of organisms
  • 9 Dan and Laxmi Maa
  • Detection of Breast & Cervical Cancer
  • Rising call to abrogate SoO pact
  • Rally - End proxy war in Manipur #1: Gallery
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #17
  • Indigenous Leaders Convene in New York
  • Contribution of Wetlands towards Agriculture
  • National Unity Day 2026
  • When the sirens stop :: Poem
  • ESTIC 2026: Connecting Science with Viksit
  • Hotel Cachar Club, erstwhile Silchar Polo Club
  • Manipur's Economic Divide: Refuse to Connect
  • A century of assertion & unfulfilled settlement
  • Supports Indigenous Rally
  • Why Manipur needs counselling in every school
  • World Stroke Day 2026
  • The heart and soul of the rally
  • Yenkhong Tamba : Mera Houchongba : Gallery
  • November Calendar for Year 2026 : Tools
  • Raas Leela @Mysore Dasara : Gallery
  • Delhi Fashion Week: Award at Needle Fest
  • Mecca Pact : A reality check
  • Pre-Diwali skincare: Prepping your skin
  • ODIIN Experiences: Nightclub of Year 2026
  • Two Deputy CMs at loggerheads
  • TRAU vs Navy: 135th Durand Cup: Gallery
  • 5 Manipuris : World Top 2% Scientists
  • Reinvent Northeast Season 9 at Russia
  • Towards a better healthcare
  • Keep on loving you :: Poem
  • Parliamentary co-operation for future
  • Cultivating friends at the right places
  • 48-hour shutdown: Sunurok Killing #2: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2026 #5: Gallery
  • Justice for 6 Liangmai Nagas #3 : Gallery
  • The night is still young
  • Hell, thy name is Manipur
  • 7th Rongmei Freshers' Meet in Delhi
  • Workshop: Conservation of Manipuri Pony
  • 140/150 cadres missing at Sinai Camp
  • Pot Lannaba : Mera Houchongba #1: Gallery
  • The Last Picnic Season 2: Micro-Series
  • Manipur's expanding conflict & solutions
  • Mushroom Training Program at Khagempali
  • Delusional normalcy: Recurring violence
  • Toy Gun : Best Short Feature Film CNFF 2026
  • Call to exempt schools from bandhs
  • 228th Bheigyachandra @Nabadwip #2: Gallery
  • Significance of Mera Hou Chongba festival
  • When the kitchen turns loud
  • Nagaland First Five-Star Hotel
  • A harmonious family :: Poem
  • Ageing with HIV must not mean invisible
  • US Midterm Polls: What they mean for Manipur
  • Politics of the SoO pact
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #16
  • The borders the Nagas never chose
  • Bend, Don't Break :: Poem
  • NE moved out of tropical climate zone
  • SoO-less Gong-sound for Peace
  • 'Soil Intelligence' is reshaping infrastructure
  • Noise protest: Manipur Violence : Gallery
  • Nasha Mukt Bharat: A message beyond slogan
  • Bringing books back to living rooms
  • Slams Govt over Escalating Violence
  • When truth becomes the enemy :: Poem
  • The neuroscience of learning
  • 'Hiraeth' at Asian Film Fest Barcelona
  • Marching towards the next Assembly polls
  • The story behind Chahi Taret Khuntakpa
  • Biofortified sweet potatoes in Manipur
  • Probe into alleged Political-militant Nexus
  • Nimai Sarungbam - Lalit Kala Akademi Award
  • "Issue is very Delicate & Sensitive"
  • Festive fitness
  • Shilp Samagam Mela 2026
  • Noting Oct 19, 20, 21 : CoBRA at Sinai camp
  • 48-hour shutdown: Sunurok Killing #1: Gallery
  • The long road without God for 75 years
  • 30 Candidates for Employment in Japan
  • Peace cannot become a political PR exercise
  • Searching for scientific consciousness
  • Time :: Poem
  • India's journey from cotton heritage to new age
  • Tragedy scripted by geo-politics
  • Northeast Book Fair Imphal #2: Gallery
  • World Space Week 2026: The rocket revolution
  • Nomination: RIST Scientist Award 2026
  • Myanmar's return from isolation
  • Deepest Solidarity to Families
  • ABHA and Medical Transcription
  • Manipur Police arrest Three Suspect
  • Sunurok massacre: Politics of selective silence
  • Langban Tha Katchaba @Haying #2 : Gallery
  • Prof Kamal Mitra Chenoy : Obituary
  • Tale of Ahu, Alang & Apapang: Amur Falcon
  • Catholic Valley Schools Sports #1: Gallery
  • Digital Revolution & MK Binodini Devi
  • Yaoshang Thabal Competition #5: Gallery
  • Orchids of Manipur
  • Athokpam Krishnakanta : World 2% Scientist
  • Yumjao Lairembi Haraoba #3: Gallery
  • 2026 NAMA Research Grant [Upd]
  • Hearthside Story of Naothingkhong #2
  • Sushila & Bichu @Airport #2: Gallery
  • 'Meeyamgi Khollao Khongchat' #2 : Gallery
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @ Kangla #1 : Gallery
  • 61st Hunger Marchers' Day #3 : Gallery
  • Manipuri Calendar for year 2027 : Download
  • Meiteilon not Tibeto-Burman language: Rvw
  • 228th Bheigyachandra @Nabadwip #1: Gallery
  • 1500 Burma Refugees Families in 1968-1973
  • 17th World Bamboo Day : Gallery
  • Sushila & Bichu @Airport #1: Gallery
  • US-Manipur Digital Archiving Workshop
  • Heikru Hidongba @Bijoy Govinda : Gallery
  • My attempt - Meiteilon is not Tibeto-Burman
  • XXXII National Thang-Ta C'ship concluded
  • 130th Irawat Anniversary : Gallery
  • Lamyanba Irabot Day at Itanagar
  • Irabot's Ideals Remembered at Mumbai
  • Tour Diaries of Maxwell & Higgins #2
  • Manipur Mesopotamia Force WWI : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Thabal @Khurai #2: Gallery
  • Chali-Saba - Kang Ningol Palli #1: Gallery
  • Naothingkhong & Pitanga #1: Hearthside Story
  • 61st Hunger Marchers' Day #2 : Gallery
  • lEkoLdugi warisiH :: Seireng
  • Little Flower School, 1973 batch : Gallery
  • Study: Social Worker on Counselling Practice
  • Radio E-pao: 5 new songs updated
  • To our star Tamo Vicky, Vikram Chongtham
  • Langban Tha Katchaba @Haying #1 : Gallery
  • Colonial records: Hill Areas, 1891-1947
  • Joint Resolution: Abrogation of SoO
  • Census 2027 for Manipur deferred
  • Read Meitei Mayek news in romanized English
  • Relevance of NRC, 1951 for immigrants
  • Final Merit List : Manipur Civil Services 2022
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #3
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #2
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #1