Ban on smoking in public places
- laudable but pointless -
By Rajesh Khongbantabam *
The ban on smoking in public places is a laudable initiative but since violations attract a penalty of just 200 Indian Rupees—a meagre amount compared to what people spend on smoking—the move will likely prove pointless.
The states of Bihar and Maharastra have already expressed their inability to impose the ban. The Minister of Health, Dr Ramadoss, appears ironically unaware that a government-sponsored board established in 1976 to carry out the "planned development of the tobacco industry in India" still exists.
This situation is absurd, with some people fighting to discourage tobacco consumption while others work to encourage production. The ban will save some non-smokers from the effects of passive smoking but the practice will continue unabated in most bars and cafes.
Disapproving looks from fellow passengers on buses and trains may discourage some smokers but while public figures and the chief ministers of some states continue to smoke it is unlikely that attempts to discourage it will be successful.
Dr Ramadoss may also have overlooked a number of other key health problems crippling India. Each passing year brings with it more cases and HIV and AIDS-related deaths along with increases in the rates of opportunistic infections.
Even critics of the law may agree that something is better than nothing and that trying to make a start is not completely pointless. But the 'point' they have chosen to address is 'less' important than a number of other key health issues.
I smoke and am aware that excessive smoking is bad for my health and may lead to cancer. I also believe that smoking in moderation is harmless and can provide a sense of pleasure and relaxation to those who indulge in it.
If a person chooses to smoke, it is none of my business and in my opinion is not the government's business either. The smoking ban will not work and will simple provide the police with an excuse to harass people and try to extract money from them.
Most smokers are aware of the risks associated with their habit but are unable to quit. We know that eating fatty foods can increase our chances of having a heart attack but we don't stop buying potato chips.
We need persuasion, raising awareness and education, But not legal action.
|
* Rajesh khongbantabam is a key correspondent of HDN (Health & Development Network, Thailand) and writes about AIDS inflicted and help available for them. He is based at Imphal, Manipur.
This article was webcasted at e-pao.net on 24th September 2009.
* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.