TODAY -
✦

E-Pao! Essays - I,robot....you,robot?

I,robot....you,robot?

By: James Vaiphei *



Why are we so interested in robots?
To be honest, when you come to think about it, It's a bit odd that we are. Robots of the kind shown in the newly-released film I,Robot don't exist in the real world,and aren't likely to for quite some time. Yet robots have been a staple of science fiction, and things very like robots have haunted people's imaginations since long before science fiction.

The thirteenth-century magician Albertus Magnus was a reputed to have built a brass head that talked. The Jewish legend of the golem-a clay man. said to have been built by the Rabbi of Prague is just as medieval. Tom standage's wonderful book The Mechanical Turk tells the story of the many 'automata' built in the eighteenth century, one of which-the chess-playing mechanical man of the title-entertained and baffled the crowned heads of Europe. It was a clever fake, but the lessons learned in building such ingenious contraption become an engine of the Industrial Revolution.

Science fiction actually can't tell us very much about robots in the real world. Reading Isaac Asimov won't help you design a production line, but from its themes we can work out what our interest in robots tells us about ourselves.

Our ancestors were predators who had to avoid becoming prey. This makes us pattern-recognising animals,and easily-startled animals. The patterns we are best equipped to recognise are those distinctive of other animals, and especially other humans.

We see faces in fires, in clouds, in leaves. We're language-using animals, social and sociable, and our faces and their expressions literally mean a lot to us. We're also tool making animals,with an opposable thumb and flexible hand unique in the animal kingdom.

So the idea of a tool, a machine, that mimics our most distinctive features-a machine with a face, a voice, a mind, a hand is disturbing and uncanny. I recently visited an exhibition with many toy robots, and it was interesting to see how much design effort had gone into making them less frightening, indeed cute, for young children, and how easy it was to make those for older children look scary. Robots can give us the creeps.

Where did they come from?
The robot in sci-fi has a double ancestry.One forebear is the monster in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. The other is the real practice of building automata. The Frankenstein motif of creation that destroys its creators appeared in Karel Capek's play R.U.R ( for 'Rossum's Universal Robots', which is where the word 'robot' comes from) and rampaged through early SF.

A more sympathetic portrayal came with the half-forgotten writer Eano Binder's I,Robot and was carried forward in Asimov's stories under the same title. Asimov, you might say, wrote the book on robots, but other stories also stand out.

Anthony Boucher's brilliant theological fable The Quest For St Aquin asked whether a robot could be religious. Brain Aldiss's hilarious and elegiac But Who Can Replace a Man? asked whether robots would miss us if we went. From the 1950s to the 1970s,robots carried a heavy weight of themes-humanity,identity,labour,slavery-on uncomplaining metal shoulders.

The emergence of Al
And then they went away. They become,as sci-fi writer Paul MacAuley once said,dead tech,an outworn idea that serious sci-fi writers couldn't write about with a straight face. They died and went to heaven, which for robots is the silver screen.In satirical series like Red Dwarf and sci-fi movies like Star Wars, they can entertain a whole new audience from whom the robot is still new.

What's replaced the robot as a serious topic is Artificial Intelligence. The research into cognitive science that underlies Al gives us a deeper answer to the question I started with. It tells us that minds are built out of mindless little bits.

Synapses in our brains and logic gates in computers are doing the same kind of job. Computer don't have minds yet, but some day they may. If we choose to give them machines to move around in, we'll have robots.

Until then, one place where you can see a body controlled by machine that thinks for itself is in the mirror we are interested in robots because we are robots.




* James Vaiphei, Student and Member of Institute for the Management of Information System (IMIS) writes regularly for e-pao.net.
He can be contacted at [email protected]

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • 228th Bheigyachandra @Nabadwip #1: Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2026 : Timeline
  • Wildlife Week Celebration at Thanga
  • Evolving women's role in Manipur tourism
  • Where do we go from here ?
  • Training Programme on Mushroom
  • Festival look for Navratras
  • Condolence : Demise of Adino Phizo
  • Significant Delhi invite to 3 leaders
  • Heterogeneous Structure of Meitei Society
  • Concert @ 18th Orange Fest #1: Gallery
  • When water management was Statecraft
  • Who switched off the respect :: Poem
  • All is not yet lost for Manipur
  • Wildlife Conservation: Securing the Future
  • Exam : Post of Under Secretary (Law)
  • Understanding narco-terrorism
  • 1500 Burma Refugees Families in 1968-1973
  • 17th World Bamboo Day : Gallery
  • Land affected families: NH-202 in Ukhrul
  • Training Programme on PCB Repair
  • World Habitat Day 2026
  • AMR survivor & WHO call to protect medicines
  • Cut fuel taxes, not food
  • Creating chaos on roads of Imphal
  • Sushila & Bichu @Airport #1: Gallery
  • Manipuri Pony: Case for Animal Science Univ
  • Hemp plant for sustainable textile & Manipur
  • Flame of the lamp & our cultural sensibility
  • Without you :: Poem
  • Welcomes Lalremsiami, Lalthantluangi
  • On the growing roadside eateries
  • Naga Peace Process: Indo-Naga Talk: Timeline
  • 36 Names: Manipur at the Asian Games
  • Khawungsing, Lumlaola : Eming
  • Abok Ki Singju to Premiere
  • A vision fragmented by corruption :: Poem
  • Gandhi Ji's 3 monkeys and Manipur
  • AI-powered X-Rays are helping find TB
  • Mizoram Reward Lalremsiami, Lalthantluangi
  • 15 years in power Vs 10 years in power
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #13
  • US-Manipur Digital Archiving Workshop
  • 8th Cultural/ Freshers' Meet for Rongmei
  • The Same Smoke :: Poem
  • Supriya looks at HYROX World C'ships
  • AI4SEVA Hackathon @IT SEZ, Mantripukhri
  • 38th Foundation Day- NIELIT Imphal #2
  • Heikru Hidongba @Bijoy Govinda : Gallery
  • Manipur's Indigenous Natural Farming System
  • Basic human needs a struggle for Sinakeithei
  • Demise of Pame, Marinmai, Lianvela
  • When I met the pugilist Sarita
  • 38th Foundation Day of NIELIT Imphal #1
  • Mizoram's Anthurium Festival Returns
  • Poll fever seems to be catching up
  • My attempt - Meiteilon is not Tibeto-Burman
  • XXXII National Thang-Ta C'ship concluded
  • One Village One Product: A better alternative
  • When machines can answer, who will judge ?
  • Explain motive- Tronglaobi Terror Attack
  • Merger of 5 elected members of NPP
  • Namghar Unites Assam & Maharashtra
  • Trade and commerce : In a limbo
  • 130th Irawat Anniversary : Gallery
  • Lamyanba Irabot Day at Itanagar
  • Irabot's Ideals Remembered at Mumbai
  • Coffee as a sustainable alternative to poppy
  • Her Godname :: Poem
  • Polyendocrine Metabolic Ovarian Syndrome
  • Rejoinder to NPCC
  • Need to get priorities right
  • Irawat and Meetei National question
  • XXXII National Junior Thang-Ta C'ship
  • World Heart Day 2026: Don't miss a beat
  • Science in everyday life
  • Nature Education Workshop
  • Rejoinder to Dr S C Jamir
  • Daslakshan Mahaparva: Festival of 10 supreme
  • Focus back on SoO camps
  • Raengdai Vs NEROCA : Durand Cup : Gallery
  • October Calendar for Year 2026 : Tools
  • Lebensraum or ethnic cleansing
  • World Alzheimer's Day 2026
  • Sensitization Workshop on POSH
  • Mourns Passing of Aribam Shantimo
  • Lecture on 'Indigenous Knowledge Systems'
  • Rejects allegations by NPCC President
  • The narrative Manipur needs
  • Tour Diaries of Maxwell & Higgins #2
  • Laitonjam Rishikanta @ Asian Bodybuilding
  • First poster of Interlude released
  • In the womb of time :: Poem
  • Running an abnormal State
  • Khunung Eshei & Mukna competitions
  • Conference: Challenge in Sustainable Science
  • Rolling back the highway blockade
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #12
  • Manipur Mesopotamia Force WWI : Gallery
  • PhD in Manipur : Fund it, Fix it
  • Many Voices, One State: Manipur's dilemma
  • Me and Moon: Both do the night shift : Poem
  • Putting rights: Body autonomy & sexual health
  • Green Tea for beauty
  • Yaoshang Thabal @Khurai #2: Gallery
  • AI = Arangpham Intelligence, the Frankenstein
  • World Pharmacists' Day 2026
  • Tapes of 1979 Film 'Ashroy' Discovered
  • From Pangaea to the unpredictable Earth
  • In a Crooked Room :: Poem
  • Debt recovery should be done, but within law
  • Regionalism : New political flavour
  • Chali-Saba - Kang Ningol Palli #1: Gallery
  • Book Release: Exploring The Vanishing Self
  • The Echo After Forever :: Poem
  • The paradox of Kukiland
  • Dr Wairokpam Yaiphaba : Fulbright Fellowship
  • Essay, Painting & Speech Competitions
  • Manipur : Mixture of opposites
  • Naothingkhong & Pitanga #1: Hearthside Story
  • Meiteilon is still not a Tibeto-Burman language
  • 52nd Foundation Day of AMWJU : Gallery
  • The chokehold on Manipur's potential
  • Another Langban has com :: Poem
  • Ageing needs a gendered human rights
  • Mizoram's 2026 festival season opened
  • Inspect the SoO camps
  • 61st Hunger Marchers' Day #2 : Gallery
  • lEkoLdugi warisiH :: Seireng
  • Can Strong Anti-Racism Law save NE Indians
  • Before Building a Viksit Bharat, Learning
  • Quality planting for Pineapple & Banana
  • Seminar: Career Options in Life Sciences
  • Fitclass Gym Moti Nagar Opens
  • Burning hills of Manipur
  • Culturals @Beating of Retreat #4 : Gallery
  • Memo to Union Home Minister
  • Recollections: My past experience & episode
  • The tragedy of the thinking mind
  • Rejoinder to K. Therie
  • Four MCS Officers appointed to IAS
  • International Day of Peace
  • Namghar, to be inuagarated at Sarhad
  • Time for people to lay down the agenda
  • Justice for 6 Liangmai Nagas #2 : Gallery
  • 17th World Bamboo Day 2026
  • 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly : Gallery
  • The 731, and those who may follow
  • Reflecting on 21st September
  • BRICS India 2026 : Role of India
  • If BJP/NDA wants to come back
  • Marking comeback of loadshedding
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #11
  • Little Flower School, 1973 batch : Gallery
  • Bichu Kharibam: FIH Magic Skill Award
  • The Symphony of the Stain :: Poem
  • Moringa seeds of hope take root
  • Job Plan : The major job of Govt of Manipur
  • Training Programme on Mushroom
  • Tour Diaries of Maxwell & Higgins #1
  • BRICS at New Delhi 2026
  • Reimagining Manipur: Hackathon Competition
  • NE - heavier downpours & longer dry spells
  • A new dawn after your departure :: Poem
  • Hindi Pakhwada 2026 concluded
  • Seminar on Scientific Writing
  • Happy tidings for scribes of Manipur
  • Ningol Phida - Shumang Leela #2 : Gallery
  • Study: Social Worker on Counselling Practice
  • Foreigner's Tribunal: A solution for Manipur
  • India-Myanmar boundary : Mistakes of 1967
  • Which one is which ? :: Poem
  • The EMI generation: Young people on credit
  • Radio E-pao: 5 new songs updated
  • Chiru Maroi : Scientific Documentation
  • BRICS Summit 2026: The rise of global south
  • Manipur- Best Performing State- IEMI 2025
  • Academic Administration Course @MU
  • World Ozone Day 2026
  • Lakshadweep's #endTB blueprint for India
  • 'Othering' the North East folks
  • To our star Tamo Vicky, Vikram Chongtham
  • Vice President visited Manipur : Gallery
  • Celebrating the architect of our future
  • Cost of complacency- Manipur must demand
  • Condemns Recent Killings & Violence
  • Thadou Martyrs' Day observed
  • North East Creator Circuit 2026 Debut
  • From Feb to Sep: What is happening ?
  • Langban Tha Katchaba @Haying #1 : Gallery
  • Targeting 1 Naga voice stirred Naga solidarity
  • Mushroom Cultivation Training concluded
  • 59th Engineers' Day Celebration
  • We, the only protectors :: Poem
  • Hiring @ 4-Star Hotel in Udupi
  • Rejoinder to Dr S C Jamir & CNFN
  • Guns and arson in the hills
  • Ibudhou Pakhangba Haraoba #1 : Gallery
  • Why Manipur Govt has no power in hills
  • Anti-Rabies Vaccination Camp
  • 2026 NAMA Research Grant
  • Why Gor and Gori were in Manipur ?
  • My Run :: Poem
  • Support Flood-Affected Families in Sivasagar
  • Reeling under one issue & the other
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #10
  • Protest by Researchers @DM Univ : Gallery
  • Rs 5.20 Crores settled in 3rd Lok Adalat
  • Coins of Morning :: Poem
  • Dengue Fever : Diagnosis | Prevention
  • Observance of Thadou Martyrs' Day 2026
  • Condemns Tragic Loss of Chongtham Vikram
  • Meitei Esei
  • US Ambassador @ CM Mantripukhri : Gallery
  • Chongtham Vikram: Delhi Cannot Explain Away
  • A teacher does not leave when his classroom
  • Advanced Bootcamp on Swarm Drones
  • Solidarity With Naga Community
  • Dikho abstains from Cabinet Meeting
  • Blockade hurts no one but common man
  • 'Meeyamgi Khollao Khongchat' #1 : Gallery
  • Users and Abusers of Words
  • Suicide Prevention in the age of social media
  • The red junglefowl: The principal wild ancestor
  • Condemns Killing of Chongtham Vikram
  • Defending women rights against anti-rights
  • Grade-A Mall & Hotel in Guwahati
  • On having completed 27 years in print
  • Candle Light- Chongtham Vikram : Gallery
  • Manipuri Pony Heritage Talk to Students
  • Souls with no sacred flame :: Poem
  • International Primate Day 2026
  • Misuse of Tapentadol: A grave danger
  • Colonial records: Hill Areas, 1891-1947
  • Joint Resolution: Abrogation of SoO
  • NRC in Manipur : Time for 'walk the talk'
  • Elimination of Racial Discrimination
  • Manipur after conflict: Shared hope
  • Condemn Arson at Lhungjang Primary School
  • International Literacy Day 2026
  • Demands Abrogation of SoO
  • Decision to stay away from Assembly
  • Justice for 6 Liangmai Nagas #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur Can Simply Be Manipur
  • PhD Admission at Assam University
  • What delimitation could mean for Manipur
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #9
  • Teachers' Day Celebration : Gallery
  • Census 2027 for Manipur deferred
  • Read Meitei Mayek news in romanized English
  • NEROCA Vs Navy : Durand Cup : Gallery
  • 24-hour Gen Strike (Sep 1) : Gallery
  • Panthoibi Anoi Khuthek #1 : Gallery
  • Book on the History of Manipur released
  • 48-hour General Strike by JFD #3 : Gallery
  • Culturals from Manipur at Delhi Fashion Week
  • The flame of Haipou Jadonang
  • Kang Khichri Chaba #2 : Gallery
  • Census deferred & NRC begins
  • Relevance of NRC, 1951 for immigrants
  • 61st Hunger Marchers' Day #1 : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2026 #4: Gallery
  • The King Who Caught a Bird : Konthoupa
  • Meira Rally 'No NRC, No Census' : Gallery
  • FC Reangdai Vs TRAU : Durand Cup : Gallery
  • 48-hour General Strike by JFD #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur Expeditionary Force, World War I
  • Waqf Amendment Act: An Analysis
  • 135th Patriots' Day @ Thangal Tomb : Gallery
  • 48-hour General Strike by JFD #1 : Gallery
  • 35th Manipuri Language Day, 20 August
  • 135th Patriots' Day @ Hicham : Gallery
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #2 : Gallery
  • Wakol Laoba : A Philosophical Analysis
  • Lifetime Achievement Award for 4 Scientists
  • 13th CM Kang Tournament : Gallery
  • The chappals we leave behind
  • Search 25 years of e-pao.net
  • North East India Fest @ London : Gallery
  • Colonial Knowledge Production in NE India #23
  • 360° panoramic view of spots in Manipur
  • Final Merit List : Manipur Civil Services 2022
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #3
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #2
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #1