TODAY -

We found Paragonimus westermani in Manipur !

Dr T Shantikumar Singh *



Life Cycle of Paragonimus Westermani
Life Cycle of Paragonimus Westermani - Pix: parasitesinhumans.org



Lung fluke infection or Oriental lung fluke infection also known as endemic haemoptysis (coughing up blood) is one of the most important parasitic diseases widely distributed in Asia, Africa, America and former USSR, but not known to occur in Europe, Australia, and Antarctica. The medical terminology of the lung fluke infection is pulmonary paragonimiasis which will be used in the text subsequently. The disease is endemic in China, Japan, Korea, Vietnam, Indonesia, Taiwan, Thailand, Philippines, Belgium Congo, Nigeria, Cameroon, Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, Venezuela and Mexico. It has been estimated that about 293 million people are at risk and 20 million people are affected by paragonimiasis in the world. In India, paragonimiasis was reported in many mammals such as mongoose, dogs, cats, panther and tigers.

However, human paragonimiasis was not considered as an important parasitic zoonosis and never even included in the medical curriculum in India. Most medical doctors were unaware of the prevalence of paragonimiasis in India until recently. Even those few who are aware of the disease would dismiss it as just another rare member of the constellation of parasitic zoonosis, occurring only in the Orient.

The parasite

The lung flukes are the trematode (Flat, leaf like) parasites of the genus Paragonimus. About 50 species including synonyms are distributed in tropical, temporal and sub-arctic zones worldwide. In Asia alone, 23 Paragonimus species have been described of which P. westermani Kerbert, 1878, is the most widely distributed and common human pathogen except in Thailand, Vietnam, Laos and recently India where P. heterotremus has been recognized as the human pathogen.

Life cycle

The parasites require a variety of snail species and mountainous crustaceans (crabs and crayfish) as first intermediate and second intermediate hosts for development of various larval stages respectively and complete the life cycle in mammals and humans as definitive hosts which harbor adult worms. The adult worms usually in pairs remain encysted in the lungs of the definitive hosts and discharge eggs. The eggs are excreted through the sputum and faeces to the external environment. For the continuation of life cycle the eggs have to enter water in the mountain stream or river and hatch miracidium which infect snail hosts. In the snail hosts the miracidia develop into cercariae. The cercariae infect crabs and crayfish and develop into metacercariae (larval stage) which is infective to human and mammalian hosts when ingested.

Infection in humans

Humans acquire infection after the consumption of raw or inadequately cooked crabs and or crayfish that harbor metacercariae. The metacercariae are killed if the crabs or crayfish are adequately cooked, so ingestion after proper cooking will not cause infection. Infection is common in countries where people consume raw or inadequately cooked crabs and crayfish.

In Manipur raw or improperly cooked crabs are consumed for a variety of reasons, as delicious dish, dietary supplement of protein, to enhance physical strength and immunity and as folk medicine. In the market fried crabs are commonly sold along with other dishes which have attracted many people after day's work or office. A popular Manipuri dish, "Waikhu ametpa or Waikhu Singju" wherein raw or roasted crabs are crushed with chilies, onion, garlic and ginger specially made at home, or local liquor vendors is a delicacy taken with alcoholic beverage.

In addition, local customs and superstitious beliefs that ingestion of raw crab extract as folk medicine will cure certain ailments such as fever, allergy, asthma, malnutrition and skin diseases as practiced by some tribal communities contributed to high rate of infection. Interestingly, similar preparation and practice are found in other countries for example, in China "drunken crab" (live crabs soaked in wine overnight), in China and Korea "Kejeng" (live crustaceans are eaten with soy bean sauce), in Japan "Oboro-kiro" (crab juice with bean paste soup), and in Philippine "kilano" (raw crabs with citrus fruit juice and coconut milk taken with alcoholic drinks).

Crayfish juice is given orally in the treatment of measles as folk medicine in Korea and raw crabs are eaten for boosting fertility in women in Cameroon, Africa. These practices are important causes of paragonimiasis. Consumption of raw or insufficiently cooked meat of paratenic hosts such as wild boar and pig is another possible mode of transmission of infection.

Unlike tuberculosis paragonimiasis does not spread directly or indirectly from person to person as the eggs passed in the sputum are not infective to human and animal hosts. Also, the larval stage found in the snail hosts is not infective to humans; therefore, consumption of snails does not cause infection in man.

Disease

The disease caused by the lung flukes is called paragonimiasis which is classified into two broad groups, pulmonary paragonimiasis (infection in the lungs) and extrapulmonary paragonimiasis (infection in sites other than the lungs). Pulmonary paragonimiasis is the commonest form of paragonimiasis but infection in brain and subcutaneous tissue are not infrequent. Majority of patients are asymptomatic, few patients may have mild to moderate symptoms for several months or even years before they visit doctors, if they ever seek medical treatment at all.

Despite the mild nature of the infection, pulmonary paragonimiasis remains as important cause of chronic morbidity. Death may occur due to severe recurrent haemoptysis and infection involving brain and heart. Chest pain, cough, spiting of blood or recurrent haemoptysis and difficult breathing are the most common symptoms of pulmonary paragonimiasis.

The respiratory symptoms and chest x-ray findings are similar to pulmonary tuberculosis often leading to misdiagnosis and treatment of pulmonary paragonimiasis for pulmonary tuberculosis. This diagnostic confusion between pulmonary paragonimiasis and pulmonary tuberculosis will have significant impact on the outcome of the RNTCP in Manipur. Cerebral paragonimiasis with symptoms similar to space occupying lesion in the brain and cutaneous form presenting as migratory subcutaneous nodule are common extrapulmonary paragonimiasis.

Differential diagnosis

All the patients presented with spitting of blood or recurrent haemoptysis should be investigated for paragonimiasis, tuberculosis, pneumonia, brochiectasis, aspergillosis, hydatid disease, cystic fibrosis and cancer.

Diagnosis

A positive history of consumption of crabs and crayfish in a patient of haemoptysisis is a sufficient clue to investigate for paragonimiasis. A definitive diagnosis can be made by the microscopy demonstration of the characteristic Paragonimus eggs in the sputum and or stool samples. Nowadays, highly sensitive and specific serological tests including rapid tests are available for the diagnosis of paragonimiasis. The serological tests are useful for the diagnosis of paragonimiasis in which Paragonimus eggs are absent or cannot be demonstrated in the clinical specimens, however, the availability of the tests are restricted to the countries like Japan and China where these are produced.

Treatment and prevention

There are three major antihelminthic drugs namely; Praziquantel, Bithionol and Triclabendazole currently available for use in the treatment of paragonimiasis. Of these, Praziquantel (eg Biltricide manufactured by Bayer) is the drug of choice for the treatment of paragonimiasis. The recommended dose is 25 mg per kg body weight 3 times a day after meals for three days. The author found relapse in 2% of the cases with the 3-day regimen and has recommended for 5-day regimen for almost a 100% cure. The drug is not easily available in the market in Manipur and expensive for the poor patients to afford.

Research on Paragonimus and paragonimiasis in Manipur

In India, the first human case of paragonimiasis was reported from RIMS, Manipur in 1982. Thereafter, a serological survey conducted in the Imphal East district in 1993 had revealed a prevalence rate of 6.7% and over the years through 2010 about 300 parasitologically confirmed cases have been detected. Since 1990s, paragonimiasis has striven to gain recognition as a significant food borne parasitic zoonosis in India, especially in the northeast States.

There seems to be little justification for this neglect by the health department and public health providers, however, since there have been growing evidence of endemic areas not only in Manipur, but also in Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh. The data available on the prevalence and incidence of the disease, till today, may be just the tip of an iceberg as the study areas covered are few and limited and many cases have remained undiagnosed.

The first scientific research work on paragonimiasis in Manipur was conducted in the Regional Institute of Medical Sciences where all the patients who were attending RIMS Hospital with haemoptysis were investigated for paragonimiasis during the period from 1983 to 1986. The investigation revealed that almost all the patients who were diagnosed and treated for smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis were in fact suffering from pulmonary paragonimiasis. The findings were published in the Transactions of Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene (1986) which attracted researchers from abroad, mainly Japan and China for a joint research on Paragonimus and paragonimiasis in Manipur, India.

In 1990, the first Indo-Japan joint research work on Paragonimus and paragonimiasis was conducted in the department of microbiology, RIMS, Imphal. The results of the collaborative and independent research studies in Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh and Nagaland have revealed valuable information in understanding the parasite and the disease. For the first time in India, the fresh water crabs, Indochinamon manipurensis (formerly Potamiscus maipurensis) in Manipur and Nagaland and Barytelphusa lugubris in Arunachal Pradesh were found to harbor more than one type of Paragonimus metacercariae. The occurrence of P. miyazakii manipurinus n. sub sp., P. hueit'ungensis, P. skrjabini, and P. heterotremus were reported from Manipur.

Of these P. heterotremus has been confirmed as the agent causing infection in humans in Manipur, Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh. We were amazed by this discovery as we expected P. westermani would be the causative agent of human paragonimiasis in India from where the species was first described by Kerbert in 1878 in the lungs of a Bengal tiger which was captured in India and died in the Amsterdam zoological garden in Holland more than a century ago. Also, P. westermani infection in mammals in India is common. However, our interest in P. westermani persisted because this species has been described as the commonest human pathogen and widely distributed in Asia.

In June 4-6, 2011 Dr. H. Sugiyama from NIID Tokyo, Japan and I travelled to Moreh to investigate paragonimiasis. With the help Dr. Nandakishor and his team of doctors posted at Moreh hospital and local Kuki student volunteers we have conducted the research work on May 5, 2011. We found few seropositive paragonimiasis patients and could isolate a dozen of Paragonimus metacercariae from the crabs collected at lailok mountain streams.

We brought back the metacercariae for further morphological and molecular characterisation and laboratory animal infection. Dr. Sugiyama is responsible for molecular characterisation (DNA sequencing of worms at various developmental stages) and Dr. T. Shantikumar is responsible for morphological characterisation of the worms and case studies in India.

"We found Paragonimus westermani in India: Sugi@Tokyo" was the email message received from Dr. Sugiyama on June 2011.

Conclusion

We are extremely happy and so excited to discover this species after about two decades of our relentless pursuit for P. westermani in Manipur. Our next research plan will be morphological and molecular characterization of adult worms and eggs of P. westermani and its association in human paragonimiasis in India.

The main purpose of publishing this piece of work is to generate knowledge of paragonimiasis (lung fluke infection) among health care professionals and public health officials in Manipur for appropriate action for detection and treatment of cases and its preventive measures. Paragonimiasis is an important food borne parasitic zoonosis which in most instances are subclinical, however, chronic infection causes high morbidity and sometimes, severe infections may cause death. The disease is otherwise curable and preventable.

Acknowledgement

We thank Dean, SMIMS, Sikkim, Director, RIMS, HOD Microbiology, RIMS, Manipur, Doctors and staff of Moreh hospital, Moreh, and Director, NIID, Tokyo, Japan for permission and assistance in conducting the research work. Thanks are due to security personnel, Government officials, friends and local people in Moreh who help us in many ways the research program a success.




* Dr T Shantikumar Singh wrote this article for The Sangai Express . The writer is a Professor & Head, department of Microbiology, Sikkim Manipal Institute of Medical Sciences, Gangtok, Sikkim
This article was posted on July 27, 2011.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Candle Light Vigil @Kangla : Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2026 : Timeline
  • Zomi Leaders meet CM @Imphal : Gallery
  • Honoring 3 Global Achievers from Manipur
  • Apou Koklou : Peipou, owner of Gods' Court
  • The attendance crisis in higher education
  • How does Govt view village volunteers ?
  • Feature Film 'Bokshi' to release this Oct
  • Initiating move to talk with the UNC
  • NE Book Fair Imphal @Lamphel #1 : Gallery
  • M Ranjit's book: The Long Journey West
  • Nasha Mukt Yuva at Maram
  • Leinana Yomlibi - A Dynamic Musical Offering
  • Thailand's community-led HIV revolution
  • Bridal skincare tips for the monsoon
  • Relief Team visited Mon District
  • State failure vis-a-vis extortion on highways
  • Mirabai Chanu won a gold medal
  • August Calendar for Year 2026 : Tools
  • North East India Fest @ London : Gallery
  • The Legacy & Power of the Meitei Nupi
  • Barun - 1st All-Women Vyas Ojapali Troupe
  • The Sino-Indian boundary question
  • A story of love, laughter, & society
  • Extortion & mud: Defining aspects of NH-37
  • Kang Khichri Chaba #1 : Gallery
  • Products of Artisans from Relief Camps
  • World Hepatitis Day 2026
  • When dreams stolen before they even begin
  • Moksha Panigrahi Won "Pride of India 2026"
  • Tiger, the majestic species of the planet
  • Relief efforts in flood-hit Upper Assam
  • Drug money and Manipur violence
  • Colonial Knowledge Production in NE India #23
  • 135th Durand Cup: Manipur's football empire
  • 17th Anniv of Rabina & Sanjit: Gallery
  • Sinakeithei: Firearms for Kuki narco-terrorist
  • Collateral damage :: Poem
  • CM Artistsingi Tengbang pension
  • Call for NRC & state's indifference
  • Protest - NEET 2026 leak : Gallery
  • Traffic Advisory : Durand Cup 2026
  • 10th NE Int'l Fashion Week 2026 concluded
  • Rise, Resignation of Dharmendra Pradhan
  • A classroom of dreams, a trap of neglect
  • Nature Conservation Day 2026
  • Cross-border drug networks
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #3
  • 26th Kargil Vijay Divas
  • Kargil Vijay Divas
  • Crowns built on conflict :: Poem
  • Meitei police, Naga police, Kuki police
  • 1st Foundation Day of Peerless Hospital
  • Rs 50 lakhs support for cardiac treatment
  • Kang Chingba @Kakwa, Singjamei : Gallery
  • Yaoreingam, Lamjingrenbi : Eming
  • That FB/X Post didnt come from Politician
  • Posts @ Life Sciences, Manipur Univ
  • The Blueprint of Ruins :: Poem
  • Implications of Bahuda Rath Yatra
  • Nari Shakti, from promise to delivery
  • SoO at the centre of storm
  • Flag off: 135th Durand Cup @Sendra : Gallery
  • Manipur's booming bridal makeup culture
  • Inclusive Preparedness at Ideal Blind School
  • Army brings the Durand Cup to Imphal
  • Evolving strategies- aftermath of 3 May 2023
  • Communities must be financed, says UNAIDS
  • Pro Health Physical Therapy at Guwahati
  • Make the War on Drugs meaningful
  • A rainy day @ Ima Keithel : Gallery
  • The law of Karma and Manipur
  • Awareness Programme on POSH ACT, 2013
  • Admissions @ North East Career Centre
  • Millets and Human Health
  • Poppy Cultivators & Traitor :: Poem
  • No EV Monopoly, let users pick best tech
  • Taking note of PUYA's campaign
  • Naga Peace Process: Indo-Naga Talk: Timeline
  • Ahingee Laan @ JNMDA #3 : Gallery
  • 'Homecoming Ceremony' KCP-PWG : Gallery
  • The Gates of Birahari :: Poem
  • GPF Statements for 2025-26 Available
  • Leadership at JNIMS must inspire confidence
  • Sound of happiness: What our applause says
  • DAC Meeting of MY Bharat, Imphal East
  • Silence of guns is not normalcy
  • Early History of Manipuri Sahitya Parishad #3
  • Oken Amakcham (1962 - 2026)
  • Tribute to football coach Oja Kamini Kumar
  • Tobacco products demand in Manipur
  • Live Laser Proctology Surgery performed
  • Film Appreciation Course at MSFTI
  • Tripura Wins Best National Costume 2026
  • Demonstrating merit of team work
  • The Forgotten Kings : A Hearthside Story
  • Linthoi Chanambam : Gold at Asian Judo
  • 4th Phase "Ningol Van" at Golapati Hatta
  • We are just 33 lakh
  • Monsoon skincare tips for babies
  • Call for closed door meeting with CSOs
  • Trouble makers with an agenda
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #2
  • The politics of devotion & syncretism
  • Sunita- Best Manipuri Film @72nd Nat'l Award
  • China-Myanmar with a Shared Future
  • North East India Festival 2026 at UK
  • A gory slaughter :: Poem
  • Kang Chingba @Thangal Keithel : Gallery
  • A World Cup football final 40 years ago
  • Manipur needs a livelihood policy, not relief
  • The Puzzle Unsolved :: Poem
  • IndiGo from T2 Terminal Guwahati Airport
  • Manipur Electricity Regulations, 2026 draft
  • India's Tribal Perspective to 19th UN EMRIP
  • Imphal, Delhi : Losing the plot
  • Kang Chingba @Govindajee Temple : Gallery
  • Kanto Sabal & security questions
  • Rights of Freedom of religions & beliefs
  • Lord Jagannatha's processional chariot fest
  • Condemns Kanto Sabal Arson Attack
  • Love Will Find a Way :: Poem
  • The killing and anti-AFSPA stand
  • 77th Republic Day @ Kangla #3: Gallery
  • 2004 Kangla Protest: Anti-Repression Day
  • Make every effort to do what leads to peace
  • 'Trust Deficit Towards Govt of India'
  • On the grand road of Puri
  • Day 2: Hands On Training- Yelhou Hidak 2026
  • 23rd Technothlon at Techniche IIT Guwahati
  • Playing the victim card will not do
  • 63rd Mr Manipur @ MU #5 : Gallery
  • Thank you, Cristiano Ronaldo
  • Ethics of financing armed groups in Manipur
  • Dylan Thokchom @ Badminton Asia C'Ship II
  • What do recent initiatives of young people say?
  • Day 1: Hands On Training- Yelhou Hidak 2026
  • Of health, water & power supply
  • Cultural @ Beating of Retreat #3 : Gallery
  • Underpaid nurses : A look at pathetic salaries
  • Manipur : Living under shadow of violence
  • Wild Nature :: Poem
  • Fulfil the 2027 #EndTB commitments
  • Walking Lens 3.0 concluded
  • Up in flames since May of 2023
  • Seasonal Fishes @Ima Keithel #3: Gallery
  • Meetei Mayek High School : Subroto Cup
  • Trend of mislabelling in recent times
  • AI revolutionize early disease detection in crop
  • Khemchand the Sardar Patel
  • 4-year integrated teacher education (ITEP)
  • Fibre Economy: India's next big opportunity
  • Right under the nose of Army : Leimakhong
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #1
  • The names behind the arrest
  • 2026 FIFA World Cup - new global standard
  • 10th NE Int'l Fashion Week 2026 announced
  • A girl in the temple :: Poem
  • 'Overwhelming Meetei Support For ST Status'
  • Oncology OPD Services launched
  • 77th Republic Day @ Kangla #2: Gallery
  • National Drone Innovation Challenge 2025-26
  • The Next Market Day :: Poem
  • Manipur airfare crisis: Way out is beyond reach
  • Posts @ Dept of Art & Culture, Manipur
  • Monsoons beauty
  • Transformative journey on Reform Express
  • Reading the stand of the Kuki CSO leader
  • Early History of Manipuri Sahitya Parishad #2
  • 35th NAMA Annual Convention at New Jersey
  • British Coin Puzzle
  • The story of Citrus
  • Pride Ride 2026 Pedals in Agartala
  • BRICS & the New Geography of Agri-Trade
  • Seeing, treating all as equals
  • Unravelling the knot: Reclaiming Thaksi-Khasi
  • The making of a Social Worker
  • Enough is Enough :: Poem
  • Online submission- Class XI & XII to COHSEM
  • Rising above HIV diagnosis
  • 12 years of Science in service of India
  • Six Naga men : The hurt, pain still lingers
  • Solo Dance: Wahengbam Debina #2: Gallery
  • Dylan Thokchom @ Badminton Asia C'Ship
  • 'Imp-Jiri Highway to Be Ready by Dec 2026'
  • Reassessing Manipur's geopolitical conflict
  • A Walking Life :: Poem
  • Something on Scrub Typhus
  • Making it to the news for right reasons
  • Yumjao Lairembi Haraoba #2 : Gallery
  • Border Flames: CoBRA, Crisis in Kamjong
  • A Fool's Cry :: Poem
  • Manipur Displacement Crisis- Security Failure
  • Why are we still not on track to end TB
  • Development Vision for Assam & North-East
  • Delhi: Noting new area of conflict
  • 63rd Mr Manipur @ MU #4 : Gallery
  • Hundred Flowers Institute of Medical Sciences
  • 3rd 'Ningol Van' Tree Plantation at Kongba
  • Possible way out of festering conflict
  • Draft Electoral Rolls for Imphal West
  • 3 ACs - Draft Electoral Rolls for Senapati
  • Draft Electoral Rolls for Imphal East
  • The sunshine of civilization :: Poem
  • Working on a Saturday
  • Present signature for February 30 !
  • Boy Who Dredged the Rivers: Taothingmang
  • Day 3 : Yaoshang Festivities : Gallery
  • Golden Jubilee of JNMDA (Prod Unit)
  • Apatani's Next Top Model 2026 : Grand Finale
  • The Faithful Pen :: Poem
  • Ratify UN Convention Against Torture
  • World Environment @Lamdeng #2 : Gallery
  • Why Kuki failed to co-exist with communities
  • Admission Notice : Dhanamanjuri University
  • Ningol Phida @Shumang Leela #1 : Gallery
  • Day 3 : Yaoshang Sports : Gallery
  • World Motor Cycle Day @Andro : Gallery
  • Sillam Sintha Jagoi @ATINGA : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2026 #3: Gallery
  • 360° panoramic view of spots in Manipur
  • Tangkhul Meiphung: The wounds of Time
  • Homecoming @ Washington DC : Gallery
  • ANSAM Rally demanding justice : Gallery
  • Imokanta's Shumang Lila of Manipur : Review
  • 25th The Great June Uprising #2 : Gallery
  • Day 2 : Yaoshang Mei Loukhatpa : Gallery
  • Manipuris (Meitei) and Bishnupriyas
  • Kamesh Salam Recognized by Business Today
  • Candle Light Vigil @ New Checkon : Gallery
  • B.Sc @ CMC College of Nursing, Koirengei
  • Tree Plantation Drive @ Mekola : Gallery
  • 25th The Great June Uprising #1 : Gallery
  • Manipuri and Bishnupriya Manipuri
  • Protest erupted @RIMS [15 Jun] : Gallery
  • Massacres perpetrated by Kukis during British
  • 28th Meira Paibee Numit @Khurai : Gallery
  • 3rd anniv- Khamenlok 'massacre' : Gallery
  • Remains of 6 Naga hostages @JNIMS: Gallery
  • The Lost Paradise
  • Moirangthem Chandra's collection of Puyas
  • What Manipur conflict reveal about oppression
  • 'No NRC Update No Census' Rally : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Mei Loukhatpa #3 : Gallery
  • Showcasing Manipur @Switzerland : Gallery
  • Martyrs' Day @ Cheiraoching #3 : Gallery
  • The King Who Came from the Sky: Pakhangpa
  • Chakan Gang-Ngai 2026 : Ooba Video
  • >
  • How to Break Manipur w/o Breaking Any Laws
  • 17th Manipur State Film Awards (MSFA), 2025
  • Eid-Ul-Zuha @Sangaiyumpham : Gallery
  • 16th Manipur State Film Awards (MSFA), 2024
  • Radio E-pao: 5 new songs updated
  • Yaoshang - Cooking Competition : Gallery
  • Manipur State Award for Literature 2024
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Full Result
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Govt Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Aided Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Private Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Withheld-students
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Compartmental candidates
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Statistical Abstract
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Important Information
  • Tronglaobi: 2 children laid to rest : Gallery
  • Free Online access to 'Asangba Nongjabi
  • Final Merit List : Manipur Civil Services 2022
  • Killing of 2 children @ Tronglaobi : Gallery
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #3
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #2
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #1