Justice beyond revenge - Lessons from Manipur on addressing root causes and strengthening institutions to combat vigilantism

Yenning *

Whether vigilantism emerges during social and political unrest is a multifaceted question with no easy answer. Its rise hinges on a complex interplay of factors, making generalisations elusive. However, scholars acknowledge the intensity of unrest as a key contributing factor.

When violence and disorder escalate, desperation and perceived self-protection needs can drive individuals towards vigilantism. This phenomenon intricately connects to the nature and severity of the unrest, suggesting a possible correlation between chaos and its extrajudicial response.

Viet Thanh Nguyen's acclaimed novel, "The Sympathizer" (2015), offers a powerful case study exploring the complexities of vigilantism during the Vietnam War and its aftermath. We witness firsthand how desperation and a perceived lack of justice can fuel individuals to take the law into their own hands.

These groups, often fuelled by fear and anger, targeted suspected communists and sympathisers, leading to violence and extrajudicial killings. The novel also portrays vigilante activity within the North Vietnamese regime, highlighting the complex power dynamics and internal struggles of the war.

"The Sympathizer" explores the moral ambiguity inherent in vigilantism. The novel blurs the line between good and evil, showcasing how individuals on both sides of the conflict resorted to violence in the name of their beliefs. It challenges simplistic narratives of heroes and villains, forcing readers to grapple with the ethical complexities of wartime actions. The protagonist's internal conflict, torn between loyalties and witnessing the consequences of vigilante actions and war violence, reflects the broader moral dilemmas faced during such periods.

Crucially, the novel does not romanticize vigilantism. It emphasizes the dangers of such actions, showcasing how they often escalate violence and inflict suffering on innocent individuals. The long-term repercussions, haunting characters and societies even after the war, highlight the cyclical nature of violence and the difficulty of achieving true peace and reconciliation.

Overall, "The Sympathizer" offers a nuanced and thought-provoking exploration of vigilantism, challenging readers to think critically about its motivations, complexities, and potential dangers. This fictional lens sheds light on real-world scenarios like violence-torn Manipur, urging us to examine the root causes of unrest and seek alternative solutions that uphold justice and prevent the allure of extrajudicial action.

Most importantly, it avoids romanticising vigilantism, showcasing its dangers and long-term repercussions, including the cyclical nature of violence and the difficulty of achieving true peace and reconciliation.

The prevalence of vigilantism varies across societies, shaped by historical events and cultural values. As historian Howard Zinn noted, "We can't be neutral on a moving train," underlining the impact of historical trajectories on shaping societal norms, including attitudes towards vigilantism.

For example, in former colonies, vigilantism may have roots in a history of weak or oppressive colonial rule, compelling communities to develop alternative means of maintaining order. This is evident in regions like Asia, Africa, and Latin America, where the legacy of colonialism has contributed to the emergence of vigilantism as a response to perceived injustices.

Certain cultures emphasise collective responsibility and community justice, potentially fostering acceptance of vigilante action under specific circumstances. This can manifest in various ways, including honour killings or self-defence groups in conflict zones. While problematic in many contexts, these practices stem from deeply ingrained cultural values around maintaining order and upholding community norms.

When public faith in law enforcement or judicial systems erodes due to corruption, inefficiency, or perceived bias, individuals may turn to vigilantism as a perceived alternative. This is observed in countries with high crime rates, weak governance, or a history of police brutality. In these contexts, the perceived failure of official systems fuels the allure of taking justice into one's own hands, regardless of the risks and potential for further chaos.

Understanding vigilantism's historical and cultural contexts allows us to move beyond simplistic judgments and engage in more productive discussions. By exploring these interconnected factors, we can understand why and how vigilantism emerges and work towards addressing its root causes, such as lack of access to justice, police brutality, or societal alienation.

Let's delve deeper into the case of Manipur. The complexities of vigilantism don't exist solely in fiction, as illustrated by Nguyen. Manipur has a long-standing tradition of vigilante groups, taking on various roles, including combating perceived immoral activities, fighting against drug and alcohol abuse, and forming watch groups to protect human rights.

While some view this as a necessary response to perceived gaps in law enforcement or to build a national character, others criticise the potential for abuse and violation of individual rights. This highlights the dangers of romanticising vigilantism, even when seemingly motivated by noble intentions.

The interplay of the historical, cultural and weak governance factors is vividly visible in Manipur. The colonial policy of "divide and rule" sowed seeds of distrust among the diverse communities inhabiting the hills and valleys. Furthermore, the influx of "immigrants" during the colonial era, often used as pawns in divide-and-rule tactics, challenged established notions of indigeneity and further fuelled tensions.

Those who dared to resist this unjust system were often exiled to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, further eroding trust in formal institutions. In response to this perceived injustice and lack of effective governance, vigilante groups flourished.

Additionally, the constant threat of conflict in the region has led many communities to prioritise self-defence, with some self-determination movements even transforming into ethnic-centric armed militias. Finally, the weakness of formal institutions has created a vacuum, allowing for the emergence of "Kangaroo Courts" extrajudicial bodies often delivering brutal punishments for perceived offences.

This lack of due process and accountability fuels fear and further entrenches the allure of vigilante action. The case of Manipur highlights how historical legacies, cultural dynamics, and ineffective governance can create a complex environment where vigilantism thrives, posing a significant challenge to upholding the rule of law and achieving lasting peace.

While vigilantism may provide a fleeting sense of order or justice in some instances, it poses significant dangers. It undermines the core principles of the legal system, potentially escalating violence and perpetuating injustice. This erosion of the rule of law puts innocent lives at risk, as vigilantes often act on incomplete information or personal biases.

As Martin Luther King Jr. poignantly stated, "Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that". The outcomes of vigilantism often contribute to cycles of violence and retribution, creating a challenging environment for restoring peace and order.

Determining whether vigilantism is considered "normal" during unrest is challenging due to its complex nature. The advantages and disadvantages, influenced by various contextual factors, necessitate a comprehensive and nuanced examination.

Sociologist Emile Durkheim's assertion that "Crime is integral part of all healthy societies" prompts a critical evaluation of vigilantism within the broader societal context during the unrest. This holistic approach allows for a more thorough understanding and facilitates the development of effective strategies for addressing the complexities associated with vigilantism.

The question of vigilantism's "normalcy" during unrest remains open-ended. Its justifications and dangers intertwine, demanding nuanced analysis beyond simplistic judgments. As Howard Zinn reminds us, we are not neutral observers. Engaging in critical dialogue about historical legacies, cultural values, and the effectiveness of official systems is vital.

By acknowledging the complexities and exploring alternative solutions, such as strengthening formal institutions and addressing the root causes of injustice, we can move beyond the allure of vigilantism.

Just as historical injustices and weak institutions fuelled vigilantism in Manipur, similar efforts are needed across societies to combat this phenomenon and build a sustainable future where justice prevails. This requires individual commitment and collective action to hold institutions accountable and advocate for reforms that ensure equal access to justice for all.

* Yenning wrote this article for The Sangai Express
This article was webcasted on 06 February 2024 .

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Save Manipur : Protest [Feb 15] #2 : Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2024 : Timeline
  • Agro forestry for sustainable agriculture
  • Relief materials & interaction at Kangpokpi
  • Exodus from Myanmar justify 'border fencing'
  • Earth Civilization :: Poem
  • Enhancing domestic fish consumption in India
  • Growing call to abrogate SoO pact
  • Acquitting the criminal, penalising the victim
  • Nupi Landa Thaunaphabishing #7 :: Book
  • Recipe for a full fledged civil war
  • Health Camp at Santhong Relief Camp
  • Farming- loss-making but MSP is not practical
  • Magic ingredients for radiant & flawless skin
  • First Assam LitArt Festival concludes
  • Silence of the guns, for the moment
  • A brighter side of the conflict
  • Interview with Naorem Roshibina (Wushu)
  • Memo to Chief Minister : The Way Forward
  • Best wishes to all students of classes 10th
  • The Power of Poppy - 20 :: Poem
  • Boost student retention power for board exam
  • Claiming ancestral rights over Thangjing
  • Indeed, no comparison with Manipur violence
  • Radio E-pao :: Contemporary (350+ songs)
  • Arambai Tengol & SFs #4 : Gallery
  • Rising above adversity for excellence
  • 7 facts about Meitei Goddess Nganu Leima
  • 149 experts call to find all TB to stop TB
  • Resilient tourism for vibrant career
  • Non-stop assault on Sugnu : The pattern
  • Nearly 5mn candidates for 60k posts
  • Folktales of Manipur 2.0
  • Nothing to kill or die for
  • The Kutsapo Proclamation
  • Nagas oppose border fencing with Myanmar
  • Great game for peace and security
  • IIT Delhi at Abu Dhabi
  • Restraining armed forces vis- Kuki militants
  • Drawing the battle line for Moreh at last
  • Descent of Radha-Krishna #23: Download
  • Aira Thoudam - coveted scholarship in Egypt
  • Condemns violence committed in CCpur
  • Last Smile of our Fallen Comrade : Poem
  • Sachinker ties knot with Raina Rajkumari
  • Complex challenges & calls for resolution
  • Save Manipur : Protest [Feb 15] #1 : Gallery
  • Sonia Nepram at 74th Berlinale, Germany
  • Manipur: Best AIFF Grassroots Award 2024
  • Children struggling tough competition
  • Reliance Foundation partners with NSDC
  • Bigger agenda behind CCpur protest
  • When Frankenstein acts as a law unto itself
  • A Cloud in Trousers : A translation #4
  • Manipur imbroglio and our lessons
  • The Living Song :: Poem
  • Entries : Mumbai International Film Festival
  • MG Motor India's new facility in Silchar
  • Self-funded Rail budget earns profits
  • Points Imphal should lay before Delhi
  • Dissenters not to go down without a fight
  • Art Exhibition @ RKCS Museum #5 : Gallery
  • Article 371 C aggravates ethnic divide
  • Into the lap of nature : Udupi #2
  • Delhi's dance with Meitei-Kuki conundrum
  • 'Vividhata ka Amrit Mahotsav' in Delhi
  • 2024 may pose challenges in 11 States
  • FMR scrapped, border fencing assured
  • Time to take a final call
  • Legacies of the Khamba-Thoibi classics
  • Transforming education in Manipur
  • The Power of Poppy - 19 :: Poem
  • Beauty tip to look awesome- Valentine's Day
  • Towards understanding of human journeys
  • If them then why not the Meiteis ?
  • Ensuring basic rights of conflict children
  • 75th Republic Day @ Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • Bambam Thounaojam - MMA World Champion
  • Distress Relief @ Sugnu [Jan] : Gallery
  • Manipur's struggle for peace amidst tension
  • Hold govts to account for ending tobacco
  • Meghalaya Cancer Conclave 2024
  • Not the time to take political mileage
  • Way off the mark
  • Abnormal population growth of Kuki from 1881
  • May 3 violence :: Poem
  • Bharat-Burma border barbed
  • Importance of STEM careers for girls
  • Development of mental health in school
  • Displaced children in relief camps
  • Is it the end of Kuki-AR honeymoon period ?
  • Descent of Radha-Krishna #22: Download
  • Manipur Technology Innovation Hub Startup
  • As Time Ticks Away :: Poem
  • Architecture & design confluence - BAIC
  • UG Scholarships 2023-24 results announced
  • Occupational therapy role in erb's palsy
  • National Voters' Day @ Lamphel : Gallery
  • Into the lap of nature : Udupi #1
  • Stop disrespect for places of worship
  • IBSD & NBRC joined hand for research
  • MedTech Mitra : A facilitation highway uptake
  • First edition of Assam LitArt Festival
  • Weed out the illegal immigrants
  • Behind and beyond the rhetoric
  • Nupi Landa Thaunaphabishing #6 :: Book
  • Training on cultivation of mushroom at Tera
  • Workshop: Exploring genomic resources of NE
  • India-Australia Partnership in Education
  • Why a new dawn of development in NE
  • Healthy Hair : keep it healthy
  • Beyond scrapping FMR
  • The letter of WKZIC to ADB
  • A Northeasterner's Reflection on India
  • Feathers of different birds flock together
  • Manipur : 9 months into endless killings
  • Call to make Big Tobacco pay for health
  • Mahotsav : Richness of Northeast India
  • Noting the call from AMCO
  • Not enough to rest assured anyone
  • Resilience in adversity | Kumbi : Gallery
  • Why effective treatments for TB not out
  • Cease the strife :: Poem
  • Balancing mental well-being of students
  • FM Hi debt funds Rs 45 tr budget
  • Submission of admission, apology
  • Unveiling the mask of Kuki MLAs once again
  • Arambai Tengol & SFs [24 Jan] #3 : Gallery
  • Lessons from Manipur on vigilantism
  • Exposure to air pollution can lead to cancer
  • Interim budget: Need comprehensive reforms
  • From exam stress to success
  • Adding more teeth to the silence
  • Still, a far-off land for Mr Prime Minister
  • A Cloud in Trousers : A translation #3
  • Dissecting the strength of Kukis #2
  • Self Defence Training : for school girls
  • Bharat Ratna for the Mandir man
  • Desi remedy for farm sector
  • Noting the words of caution from UNC
  • The best way to settle Thangjing issue
  • Descent of Radha-Krishna #21: Download
  • Maharaj Gambhir Singh #2: Gallery
  • To Our Fallen Village Volunteers :: Poem
  • "It's Not My Choice" triumphs in every aspect
  • Jamir congratulates Advani for Bharat Ratna
  • Climate change needs to be taught
  • 75th Republic Day @ Kangla #1 : Gallery
  • Management fest at Assam University
  • Transformation from adulthood to parenthood
  • NEP's vision is to make India competitive
  • 35th Road Safety Campaign in North East
  • Budget - Welfare with Fiscal Discipline
  • Understanding call against lifting FMR
  • Nine months and counting
  • Statue in front of Western Gate, Kangla ?
  • My memories of Imphal from 1941 : Review
  • Auditions: 20th Mega Miss North East
  • Face scrubs for glowing skin
  • Auditions: 13th Mega Mister North East
  • Seaweed: Sea of opportunities
  • Continuing clash: Dialogue the way forward
  • The truth behind the objection
  • Gaan-Ngai at Keishamthong #2 : Gallery
  • Dissecting the strength of Kukis #1
  • Gandhiji's Three Monkeys
  • 8th Northeast Fashion Week concludes
  • The Power of Poppy - 18 :: Poem
  • Career in clean energy for sustainability
  • State's response vis-a-vis Manipur crisis
  • The cries of crisis-hit farmers
  • February Calendar for Year 2024 : Tools
  • Parental support to manage children's stress
  • Stop construction of oil Depot in Kangchup
  • Ramji's consecration may calm us
  • JioAirFiber services to cover entire NE
  • State & war on civilians : Failures
  • Trying to stay relevant
  • Protests attack @ Moreh [18 Jan] #2: Gallery
  • Seeking solutions, not scapegoats: Response
  • Gaan-Ngai celebration at Delhi
  • Citizens Action for Manipur : Launch
  • Support & Distress Relief at Sugnu
  • Bijou Thaangjam announces Film with Yogesh
  • Redefining matrimony: Prioritizing character
  • Digital Dentistry launched in Guwahati
  • Demand for ST tag: Let authority decide
  • A 'silly' option to end crisis
  • Handloom- loom other than Powerloom #4
  • Support of 8 murdered civilians : Gallery
  • Rs 6.48 lakh to families of 8 murdered civilians
  • Hiring: Hostel Wardens at SAS Manipur
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • Clarion call to Hon'ble CM
  • Blame on State forces: Propaganda warfare
  • The declarations of ITLF
  • Descent of Radha-Krishna #20: Download
  • Release of Annual Calendar 2024 at Pune
  • Machihan Sasa honoured with Padma Shri
  • Painting : World Cervical Cancer Month
  • Where Do We Stand Now? :: Poem
  • Scope as Asst Enforcement Officer
  • Gaan-Ngai at Keishamthong #1 : Gallery
  • Relief Service @ 16 relief camps : Gallery
  • Lan Nangda Loiroba ! A musing
  • 75th Republic Day at Lamphel Court
  • Manipuri Dance at Republic Day at Chennai
  • Transforming education, building our future
  • Arambai Tengol & SFs [24 Jan] #2 : Gallery
  • Journey of a TB survivor
  • Kangla Congregation & Resolutions endorsed
  • Old age always 15 winters away !
  • 4th North East Foodtech starts
  • Already 25 days into 2024 : Silence continues
  • Listen to the cries of conflict-hit people
  • Arambai Tengol & SFs [24 Jan] #1 : Gallery
  • Arjun Tapas- A classic tourist attraction
  • 13th Mega Mister North East 2024
  • The Power of Poppy - 17 :: Poem
  • Career & job scope in event management
  • PM JANMAN's pioneering efforts for tribes
  • The Kangla meeting
  • Needed steps for normalcy to return
  • Protests attack @ Moreh [17 Jan] #2 : Gallery
  • Final Photo Electoral Rolls for 2024
  • Respect Netaji through deeds
  • "Women is Power" Calendar 2024 unveiled
  • Early Detection Program at Thongju
  • Teacher resource repository
  • Heavy security bandobast ! Indifferent Delhi
  • The resolve of 35 legislators
  • A Cloud in Trousers : A translation #2
  • Gaan-Ngai : Read all about it
  • Alarm bells: Antibiotic abuse
  • Foundation of artificial intelligence
  • Nature - The mother
  • Powerful statement from CM : Partisan CF
  • Feigning sick to seek medical asylum
  • Protests attack @ Moreh [18 Jan] #1: Gallery
  • Guard of honor - W Somorjit : Gallery
  • Protests attack @ Moreh [17 Jan] #1 : Gallery
  • Aribam Syam's masterpiece, Ishanou : Gallery
  • A Tribute to Dr Adhikarimayum Surjalal
  • 13 martyrs brought to JNIMS : Gallery
  • Mangani Leihul of 13 martyrs #2 : Gallery
  • The Listener: Nagaland 2023 : Download
  • Oinam Chaoba Devi: Sepak Takraw : Gallery
  • Ayekpam Maipak (Sepak Takraw) : Gallery
  • Shanglakpam Nilakanta (Hockey) : Gallery
  • List of Kings of Manipur: 33 - 1984 AD