TODAY -

Did we glorify the UNC highway blockade?

Raj Singh *

UNC's indefinite economic blockade on NHs
UNC's indefinite economic blockade on NHs :: Pix - TSE



We all celebrated ending of the 139 day UNC Highway Blockade in Manipur on March 19, 2017 with a sigh of relief and praise for the new government in Manipur. But, did we have time to reckon with what price we freed Manipur from the UNC stranglehold?

Highway blockade is effectively used as a protest not only by the United Naga Council (UNC) but elsewhere in the world also by various indigenous ethnic groups. It certainly draws the attention of the government and the public to the cause.

But here is how the UNC blockade in Manipur is different from those in other parts of the world.

In December 2012, the Native Indians in Alberta province of Canada wanted to stop the Canadian government to pass Bill C-45 concerning the land rights of the natives and staged a blockade on Highway 2 in Alberta. About 400 people came out to stand on the highway and distributed pamphlets to the waiting motorists with apologies for the temporary traffic disruptions caused by their action. The leaders spoke to the media – "It is the First nations people (indigenous) standing up for what they know is right and just. The government need to start speaking with us like we are regular human beings."

The cause was important and sentiments were high.

The Alberta blockade was legal. Their blockade lasted two hours only as pre-determined. They did not serve the government with any ultimatum. They did not wait for any decision or assurance of any kind on their demands before they ended the blockade. The blockade was at a single point and there were other roads to bypass the blockade point and motorists used them without attracting wrath of the blockade volunteers. There was no violence. The purpose of the blockade was to popularise the demands of the natives and no condition was set for ending it.

As a difference, the UNC Highway blockade in Manipur was declared illegal by the courts of India. But the UNC highway blockade in Manipur on two lifeline highways lasted 139 days (more than 3000 hours as compared to 2 hours of Alberta Blockade). The blockade volunteers destroyed vehicles that violate the blockade. The UNC bargained meeting their conditions for ending the blockade holding the entire population of the hilly landlocked state to ransom.

A protest is an expression of dissent on certain policies and actions of the authority for seeking attention and sympathy of the authority and other public so that the cause gets due consideration. A protest is not essentially an ultimatum. As such, a condition like – "blocking the highway until demands are met" is unethical and illegal.

Why couldn't UNC highway blockade be a token disruptive protest for a few hours or one day? The obvious reason is that UNC is fighting for a cause the legitimacy of which is still questionable. Their cause is linked to legal and constitutional issues. The question of Naga versus state over land ownership is not settled.

The Nagas denying ownership rights to the Kukis in Naga dominated areas is disputable. The validity of the district creation order argued by each side linking to the land ownership and decision making procedures has not been put to legal scrutiny. Nagas have not challenged the district creation orders at the court and instead looking for settlement through negotiation.

How can a legal or constitutional matter be settled at the negotiation table without adjudication by legal authorities? Can such a negotiated settlement be considered a precedential law in future? If not, what will be its repercussions on similar issues with other ethnic groups in the state?

When these questions remain unanswered, the UNC blockade has been handled by all concerned in the worst possible manner with so many harmful effects on the society like, killing the rule of law, polarising people, causing ethnic hatred and the worst of all – glorification of the blockade.

When both the central government and the state government focused more on outwitting each other before the poll, the blockade was left unattended. The central home minister boasted that he had provided enough armed forces for the state government to use in opening the highway. All electioneering BJP leaders taunted the Congress government about the inability of the latter to remove the blockade despite the huge force provided. They kept challenging that the new BJP government would remove it within 48 hours.

The blockade was declared illegal by the Manipur High Court in congruence with the Supreme Court ruling. Two leaders of the UNC were in jail under a legal action of the previous government for their activities linked to the blockade. The Congress Party while in power before the election wrote to the central government to declare UNC as outlaw. A score of peoples' organizations pleaded the UNC for lifting the blockade.

After all these hullabaloo, the new BJP government with all supports of the union government and all its armed forces took a decision to "appeal/request" the UNC to lift the blockade. Both the state government and the central government yielded to the UNC condition that the meeting should be in Senapati, not in the state capital where the seat of the government is located.

Creating a negotiating space by way of stepping back from the hard stand is understandable as a method of conflict management. But it should not be at the cost of the authority of the government over its subjects. I do not think the state government will be going to Ukhrul, Churachandpur or Tamenglong to meet other CSOs for negotiation of other issues in future.

There are further signs of the UNC bringing the government to its knees while signing the agreement. For instance, agreement number one registered that the government "recognized the grievances of UNC vis-a-vis the non-adherence to four previous MOUs" and agreed to consult stakeholders to redress these grievances. This means, the agreement reaffirms the original demands of the UNC on district creation without a saving clause of examining the demands in the light of constitution and administrative law.

Similarly, at agreement number four, while committing unconditional release of the UNC leaders, the government did not use any words of respect for independence of the judiciary thereby diluting the sanctity and authority of the judiciary system.

The agreement number three records that the next tripartite meeting will be held at the "political level". This raises questions if a dialogue between the government and a CSO can be technically a political one or the discussion on an executive order of creation of new districts a political agenda.

Nowhere in the agreement, UNC or the government reckoned the public grievances during the long spell of the illegal blockade.

The last line of appreciation of UNC praising the government for coming out to address the "core issue" wears expression of a dominant UNC in its official communique of the organization.

The requirement of the meeting to be a tripartite involving the central government on an internal matter of the state is questionable and it sets a bad precedence of governance in the state. This amounts to the disrespect of the state government by a CSO in the state. If it was required for breaking the stalemate, settlement of the problem should be left to the state government.

Emboldened by the spineless, disorganized and insincere efforts of both the union and state governments during the past four months of the blockade, the UNC is very likely to ask for roll back of the district creation orders in the next negotiation. The new government will set a very bad precedent of invalidation of a government order at the pressure of a Civil Society Organization. It should be done only when the legitimacy of the district creation order is decreed by a court negatively after litigation. The government can encourage UNC to challenge the orders at an appropriate court if the latter sticks to its original demands.

The new Chief Minister declaring removal of the Highway Blockade as his priority number one showed his disorientation of vision and action only to glorify the illegal highway blockade. There are other much more significant constructive agenda like viz., resuscitation of Autonomous District Councils and Block Panchayats for development of hills and rural areas; implementation of Lok Ayukta Act for eradication of corruption; setting up of Staff Selection Commission for bribery-free recruitment etc. that should lay the foundation for actions to fulfil his promises of a corruption-free and equitably developed society in Manipur.

It is understandable that the new BJP led coalition government was caught unprepared for a dignified dealing of the horrendous and irresponsible form of protest. But, we need to be cautioned that glorifying an illegal protest can invite a longer blockade in future in the sequence of championing 121 days by Kukis in 2011, 139 days by Nagas in 2016-17 and another longer.




* Raj Singh wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer can be contacted at rajkuss(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on March 23, 2017 and updated for editing on March 24.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • In Search of Peace in Manipur
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2025 : Timeline
  • Embracing the Shadows :: Poem
  • Dr Manmohan Singh will live on
  • Rise in the price of medicines
  • Respecting the dead- Denying is a disgrace
  • Winter skin care tips for oily skin
  • Illegal immigrants :: Of FMR & border fencing
  • JD-U row exposes national parties' apathy
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #2 : Gallery
  • On 'Only BJP can save Manipur'
  • Frontline health workers dispelling darkness
  • 14th East Himalayan Trade Fair
  • Life is plastic
  • Killers on the road : 834 lives lost
  • Call to action to save State's wetlands
  • Essence of Gaan-Ngai #1
  • The Taste of Dreams wins @Red Intl Film Fest
  • Science: 3rd eye for Meitei-Kuki reconciliation
  • Northeast flies high in direct selling
  • Mastering focus amidst distractions
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #4
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • BJP : Tepid response from the hills
  • BABINA Hospital sets example in healthcare
  • Nitya Ras @Nongmeibung #1 : Gallery
  • Agonizing reality of our country's veteran elites
  • Historicising the colonial narratives
  • NSS Team Departs for National Integration
  • HUN-Thadou Cultural Festival 2025
  • Time to recreate Naga Peoples Convention 2.0
  • Career in nutrition
  • Need to give more meaning to War on Drugs
  • Time for real action not empty rhetoric
  • Foundation: Manipur Press Club #2 : Gallery
  • Chingshanglakpa, Khuhriine : eMing
  • "Aronba Wari" :: Shumang Leela Synopsis
  • Tripura's livelihoods challenges
  • Hope Amidst Strife :: Poem
  • Railways wins race of women empowerment
  • Baatchit without precondition
  • Announced roadmap of Sep 2024: Raj Bhavan
  • Is drug money fuelling conflict ?
  • Archaeological Exhibition @ Kangla : Gallery
  • The Brass Beauties
  • Internment by non-State armed groups
  • Like people, like Government
  • Sustainable development - climate action #2
  • The Power of Poppy - 65 :: Poem
  • Road safety campaign across Northeast
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chaopok village #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur needs to affirm her tribal roots
  • Madras/Chennai- 1989 till 2024 : Gallery
  • Investigate "arms recoveries" in Mizoram
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation
  • NE Direct Selling Conference & Expo
  • Response of Delhi in last 20 months
  • Regulated entry after FMR scrap, border
  • Mutua Bahadur : Preserving Manipuri culture
  • Competitive Altruism: Resolving ethnic conflict
  • Pithe Puli Utsav at Agartala
  • Building the best version of yourself
  • Guwahati Asian Film Festival 2025
  • Tips to keep your lips soft & smooth in winter
  • Subsidised flight tickets for all
  • MCPCR alert on child trafficking fear
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni @ Wangkhei : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai celebrating Culture in Delhi NCR
  • The Weeping Gods of Manipur :: Poem
  • Disarming Kuki-Zo armed groups under SoO
  • Why nurses deserve more recognition, pay
  • The hidden truths of our social media lives
  • MMTU stand bang on target: Recapping May 3
  • Enhancing aerial options to ease travel woes
  • 2nd Emoinu Fish Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Sustainable development - climate action #1
  • RIST Talk- 62 : Artificial Intelligence (AI)
  • "Technically a BJP MLA will rule Nagaland"
  • Makar Sankranti : vibrant customs & traditions
  • Why gold is a strong hedge but ...
  • Delhi date on January 17
  • Onus of addressing tribal issues on new Guv?
  • Nupilal Ningshing Lamjel #2 : Gallery
  • Licypriya Kangujam: Nat'l Youth Day Award
  • Barak Festival advocates Peace, Progress
  • 'Yu', not fully liberalised
  • Article 355 equals Governor's Rule ?
  • Calls to vote with conscience
  • Zingtun academy leading by example
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #1 : Gallery
  • Is Kuki-Zo community pushing Nagas to edge?
  • Will drive to find-treat-prevent TB continue ?
  • Smart Cities, dustier roads ?
  • ST of NE & Dalits of mainland India
  • That May :: Poem
  • Understanding Red, Yellow, Green
  • Cong posers on Govt aid to SoO group
  • Culturals @Tri-Nation Football #1 : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai festival of Kabui/Rongmei
  • 40 Years & 04 Stations- Part IV (Madras)
  • Manipur Gold: 34th Sr Natl Sepaktakraw C'ship
  • Public Health Risk Management Training
  • The Power of Poppy - 64 :: Poem
  • The Science of Success #4
  • Hingminashi Eikhoi : Call for unity in diversity
  • A Hymn for Goddess Emoinu
  • Are the foods we eat, correct ?
  • Gangtok, Sikkim (1983 till 1988) : Gallery
  • The Taste of Dreams : Teaser Unveiled
  • Be a child of courage & conquer obstacle
  • Hans Renal Care Centre in Guwahati
  • Focus on pre-May 3, 2023 period
  • Conundrum over the genesis of crisis
  • Misna Chanu aids to Jiribam IDPs : Gallery
  • North-East Students invited to JEE Main 2025
  • Empower the State else avoid blame on CM
  • Obituary : Thaunawjam Brajamohon
  • Hope :: Poem
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #3
  • Winter makeup tips for dry skin
  • Imphal, Delhi still groping in the dark
  • Tension over assault case, land claims
  • Mega Protest Rally, end AFSPA #2: Gallery
  • Procedural mandates- Articles 118 & 208
  • Naga Hoho calls for early Solution
  • Send-off ceremony for National Youth Fest
  • Human metapneumovirus: A world of worry
  • Solution first, peace later slogan
  • Neutral communities no more safe
  • Foundation: Manipur Press Club #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur champions: 30th Natl Thang-Ta Cship
  • Futsal C'ship 2025 : Manipur runners up
  • Remembering Manmohan Singh, former PM
  • Balancing academic & professional heights
  • The Science of Success #3
  • Of siren fitted vehicles
  • Opposing CAPFs' presence to aid attacks
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Delhi #3 : Gallery
  • Apoptosis: A Lament for Kangleipak :: Poem
  • RIST Talk - 61 : Quantum entanglement
  • Most welcome Bhalla saab
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #2
  • Concerns- humans & technology in 2025
  • Indigenous Pottery Making @Imphal : Gallery
  • A memorable day for Ima Chenghi
  • Judicious use of apologies, Meitei-Kuki conflict
  • Training on Mushroom at Nagamapal
  • Atal Bihari Vajpayee: The Bhishma Pitamah
  • May 3, 2023 to Jan 3, 2025 : Kpi outrage
  • Time for centre to revisit SoO agreement
  • AIR Radio Imphal Station - Live streaming
  • The Indo-Myanmar boundary fencing
  • India shifting gears to #endTB
  • Medical Officer at RKM Hospital, Itanagar
  • The Power of Poppy - 63 :: Poem
  • The Science of Success #2
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #2 : Gallery
  • Nagaland, conservation & entrepreneurship go
  • 40 Years & 04 Stations #3 (Gangtok, Sikkim)
  • 2024: A year of loss, absurdity, & hope
  • New man at the Raj Bhavan
  • Effectiveness of deploying central force on hill
  • Natambakta Play @JNMDA #3 : Gallery
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #1
  • NEHHDC's "Eri Silk Spinning Mill"
  • Create policies for holistic life skills
  • Winter : Skincare essentials for travellers
  • 'WMCbu thugainaba kanna hotnaba'
  • Noting public apology from CM
  • Economic blockade, yet again
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Delhi #2 : Gallery
  • National Family Health Survey Report 2019-21
  • The Dark Rainbows of Manipur :: Poem
  • What will state of political differences in 2025
  • The Science of Success #1
  • The historical account of Kabaw Valley #3
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2024 #6: Gallery
  • Be still my heart :: Poem
  • Nouwa Marup Calendar 2025 released
  • New Year : Envisaging a new scenario
  • 'WMCga mari leinadaba meewoi'
  • Welcome 2025, good riddance 2024
  • Not much to hope for in year 2025
  • E-Pao.net : 25th Anniv & 2025 Wishes
  • January Calendar for Year 2025 : Tools
  • Folklore Night: Tales of Ancestors @ Noney
  • In search of the causes of conflict
  • The New Year is not just a celebration
  • Medical Assistance to Journalists
  • From 19th to 20th month of mayhem
  • Tighter ILP rules must to serve the purpose
  • Protest @Delhi - Murder of Meiteis #2: Gallery
  • Dr A Surjalal Memorial Award distributed
  • Wattaba Meitei : India's best cyclist 2024
  • Adieu to the first PM from NE
  • Cold :: Poem
  • Entrance test for Sainik Schools 2025
  • Debate over whether 2 or 3 : Discuss Manipur
  • AFSPA re-imposed in valley, onslaught from hill
  • "Connections", art exhibitt @ DC : Gallery
  • Year 2024: Unsolved tragedies & Govt inaction
  • Free one month course on DTP
  • Gita - An antidote for life in Kali #4
  • The Power of Poppy - 62 :: Poem
  • Bima Sakhi Yojana: Will empower rural women
  • Observance of Thang-Ta Day #1 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Delhi #1 : Gallery
  • Poetry Reading @RKCS Art Gallery : Gallery
  • The historical account of Kabaw Valley #2
  • Lemphu (Rhizome) of Tharo Angangba
  • Christmas Carols @ Langol : Gallery
  • Protest @Delhi - Murder of Meiteis #1: Gallery
  • "Connections", art exhibition, Washington, DC
  • Manipur Science Congress @ MU : Gallery
  • Mera Chaorel Houba #4 : Gallery
  • 62nd Mr. Manipur 2024 @ MU : Gallery
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #1 : Gallery
  • Meitei Mayek Tamba : Online Classroom #5
  • Indigenous People Cultural Fest #1 : Gallery
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Mera Houchongba: Gallery
  • Mega Protest Rally, end AFSPA #1: Gallery
  • Ta Ta TabuHtoN :: Seireng
  • Radio E-pao: 1000+ songs from Manipur
  • Mobs attack MLAs house [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Candlelight Protest @Blore [Nov 17] : Gallery
  • Protest @Seoul condemn murder : Gallery
  • Massive protests in Imphal [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Condemns Killing Children [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Ooba Video : is now relaunched !
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar :: 2025
  • GHOST of PEACE :: Download Booklet