TODAY -

Forest Rights and Injustices

Jiten Yumnam *

Rhah Khul, place in Ukhrul which is projected to be under-water once Mapithel Dam becomes operational
Rhah Khul, place in Ukhrul which is projected to be under-water once Mapithel Dam becomes operational :: Pix - Ibomcha Yumnam



Many rejoiced at the adoption of Forest Rights Act in 2006 as an ultimate beginning to undo historical injustice for indigenous communities living in and depending on forest for survival. Across India, hopes filled the hearts and minds of many, firmly confident the Act can deliver justice for them for the injustice perpetrated for so long. One wonders if the Indian State actually is keen on undoing historical injustice for indigenous and other marginalized communities, especially in a context where India's corporate greed is fast expanding, in its move for super power status globally.

A glimpse of FRA implementation in selected places across India would expose grim realities and unfolds multiple challenges. While several states implements FRA, such as Orissa, Andhra Pradesh , most North East States are reluctant to implement the Act and States like Tamil Nadu are stuck in legal entanglements, as several opposed the implementation.

In Manipur, indigenous communities affected by the Mapithel Dam of the Thoubal Multipurpose Hydroelectric Project, during the according of "Forest Clearance" on 31 December 2013 after thirty three years of project approval, urged upon the Government of India to implement the Forest Rights Act, 2006 to ensure project authorities comply requirements to take 'consent' of affected communities through their traditional institutions.

With these untimely demands, both the Government of India and the Government of Manipur were caught unaware as the project is already in advanced stage of construction, envisaged for completion in March 2015. The matter reach the National Green Tribunal, which sought the opinion of the Ministry of Tribal Affairs (MoTA) and Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), whether FRA should apply or not in the case of Mapithel Dam. MOTA and MoEF clearly understands that for any recommendation to implement FRA would mean the project would be delayed inconsiderably and the investment of Government to the tune of 1387 Crores by 2011 count will simply be in a limbo.

What followed is history as MoTA wrote two contrasting letters to MoEF, one to comply FRA and second not to comply, referring to a controversial 1993 agreement for rehabilitation and according it's directions to MoEF as an 'exceptional', 'unique' and "not to set as precedent" tag. So, in the case of Mapithel dam, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs upheld an agreement, which affected communities classified as historical injustice. In a glaring instance of connivance between the Government of Manipur, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs and the Ministry of Environment and Forest of the Government of India, the later Ministry, in its hastiness and to save the project from FRA implementation, accorded the much pending "Forest Clearance" on 31st December 2013, without even conducting a site visit for Mapithel Dam from its regional office. In Manipur, with respect to FRA implementations, interesting precedents has already been set while trying not setting 'precedents'. The sincerity of the Government of India to undo historical injustice is lucid clear in the context of Mapithel Dam and its affected peoples.

In Andhra Pradesh, the FRA implementation in forest areas near Vishakhapatnam and Srikakolam Districts, rather than serving as a means to promote indigenous peoples access to traditional forest land, rather promotes alienation and detachment from it, especially in community settings, where communities traditionally managed and used their forest land. The combination of meagre allocation of land to those claiming traditional forest land and the unusually high number of rejections of claims only legitimize the conscription of land and expansion of Reserve forest areas. The focus on individual claims and limited efforts for community claims and the high rejection of community claims, poses another huge challenges for communities in accessing their traditional forest land. The FRA implementation process itself constitutes another form of land grabbing in many parts of India.

Corporate interest on forest land runs extremely high in Andhra Pradesh. In many areas where there are corporate interests, such as those demarcated in exclusive processes for Bauxite mining and also for construction of Polavaram dam in Khammam District, the State Government refuses to implement FRA. It's key to establish the underlying links between the meagre allocation of land to tribal, the high rejection of claims, the extensive consolidation of land by Forest Department and the increasing corporate interest and corporatisation of land and resources in places like Andhra Pradesh with the World Bank, assuming an interesting role in the process of problematic land allocations.

The overwhelming yearnings for land titles in Andhra Pradesh and other region is quite understandable given the historical injustice and processes of usurping of forest land by the Forest Department and denying communities rights and access over forest land under V th Schedule of Indian Constitution. However, given the current pattern of land allocation, it has become an urgent issue to address the injustice and violations involved in undoing historical injustice.

One may also ponder as to why Forest Department, the Revenue Department usually rejects claims and allocates meagre land, as in Andhra Pradesh. One may also introspect as to whether there are other hidden agendas? India is embarking aggressively on polices and action plans to mitigate climate change and it already subscribed to a regime of false climate change, such as REDD +, reducing emission from deforestation and degradation, targeting forest and degraded land for carbon trading under the Clean Development Mechanism of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. There seems to be relevance with consolidation of forest land and global carbon trading. Andhra Pradesh's State Climate Change Action Plan emphasized on REDD+ targeting forest land.

The state of affairs on undoing "historical injustice" is far from satisfactory and need a serious review. The FRA implementation process cannot be allowed to become another part of perpetuating historical injustices. One wonders if the issue is the problem with the law, or the problem with the implementation, or the problem with the forest dwellers, due to their ignorance of the complexity of the procedures. Bureaucracy runs high, corruption runs rampant. Stories of surveyors demanding bribes from communities runs high in many places where act is implemented. A serious challenge again is the clash of worldview of those conducting the surveys and decision makers, at least in Andhra Pradesh and the communities' way of life and survival dependence with their forest.

The challenge of Forest Department usurping and consolidating forest land through FRA implementation is an alarming and dangerous trend in Andhra Pradesh, which all right thinking people should be conscious of. The management of forest by Forest Department has been a long contentious issue. The management of forest by Forest department is as good as reasons for its loss. The recommendation of the Forest Departments of Manipur and Mizoram to divert 27,000 hectares and 1370 hectares of Forest land in Manipur and Manipur to be submerged for the construction of proposed 1500 MW Tipaimukh Multipurpose Hydroelectric Project only indicates the ever preparedness to sacrifice forest land to serve interest of corporate greed and power at the cost of communities survival needs. It's key to demystify as to why Forest Department seeks to consolidate forest land in its control, especially in an era of increasing of globalization and economic liberalization, where everything is perceived as sources of endless profits.

Manipur today confronts an increasing process of corporatization of our land and natural resources. India's Look East Policy after its economic liberalization actually accentuates such realities. There is increasing pressure on our forest land to the multitude of development processes and mega projects. The Trans Asian Highway, the Trans Asian Railway, the Mapithel Dam, the Tipaimukh Dam, the extensive militarization process etc, the proposed Oil exploration and the planned mega dams under the Manipur Hydroelectric Power Policy will entail huge destruction of vast forest land of Manipur, which will have serious implications on food sovereignty of indigenous communities.

It is high time to uncover the practical challenges of implementation of FRA. The act can serve as a strong deterrent against destructive development processes for communities hell bent on defending their land and forest against any forced diversion as the act elucidates the need to take 'consent' of communities affected by such decisions through their traditional institutions. That's what the communities affected by Mapithel dam opt to acheive for. And it's equally pertinent to note the hidden agenda of those with high interest on forest land, of corporate bodies interested in mines, to build dams or to trade the forest for rich profits in carbon trading mechanisms, where forest dwellers are left at sea to even understand the process.

Respecting communities' intrinsic survival rights and dependence on forest is the most fundamental need of the hour. Communities not only survive through intrinsic relationship with forest, but they are also the best guardian of forest. With it survives the multitude of diverse floral and faunal species. In North East context, adopting cautious moves before insisting on implementation of FRA and especially gaining experiences from realities beyond borders can help safeguard and promote communities' rights over forest land. The FRA should rather be a process to recognize collective rights over land and resources and not to undermine it. And this is more applicable in North East India where indigenous communities have collective ownership of their land and where their survival and way of life revolves around such land ownership pattern.


* Jiten Yumnam wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer can be reached at mangangmacha(at)gmail(dot)com
This article was posted on March 23, 2014



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Draft plan for employment generation #1
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2025 : Timeline
  • Loingambi, Mingyashin, Chingri : eMing
  • World Radio Day at Rongdai
  • Focus on present challenges for bright future
  • Ed Sheeran brings India Tour to Shillong
  • Beauty tips for Valentine's Day
  • President's Rule has come !
  • No takers for the hot seat!
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • 50 years of Pebet @MCA #1 : Gallery
  • Kwatha Pham Kaaba :: Movie Review
  • Calls for Resignation of Amit Shah
  • Meitei eschatological belief & ethnic struggle
  • Stop border fencing & restore FMR
  • Failing in a competitive exam is not the end
  • Patra, Bhalla : Men of the moment
  • Warning to social media users amid unrest
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chaopok village #2 : Gallery
  • Imagi Sorat :: Shumang Leela Synopsis
  • Daily Habits & Mindsets of High Achievers
  • Coerced legislators' resignations
  • Right wing policies threaten gender equality
  • The fall of the AAP
  • Moving fast but to which direction
  • Onus on centre to restore order in state
  • 5 flowering plants newly recorded
  • Kangleipak's Unwavering Soul :: Poem
  • Make books & newspapers your companions
  • Pulses for a diverse agriculture
  • Exam warriors redefined
  • Sheeba Chaddha at Guwahati Asian Film Fest
  • Resignation of CM sinking in
  • Resignation unlikely to help restore normalcy
  • Manipur Statehood Day @ 1st MR : Gallery
  • Mahakumbh : Not just a religious gathering
  • Nepal with largest pictorial health warnings
  • Is war profitable market for arms manufacturer
  • Our CM & party resurrected BJP in Delhi
  • Assamese Play 'Comfort Women'
  • Reading into the resignation reality
  • No stormy session for now
  • Tarao Harvesting Fest @Chandel #6 : Gallery
  • 'Vande Bharat' Dream
  • NSS Orientation Programme at MU
  • The influence of the Golden Triangle
  • The Power of Poppy - 68 :: Poem
  • Prasanna Vithanage at Guwahati Film Fest
  • Md Alimuddin, celebrated Sagol Kangjei player
  • Condemnation of Armed Football Match
  • Webinar: KM3NeT Mediterranean experiment
  • Redefining Cancer care: People-centered
  • How thought leadership can propel your career
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #3
  • Guwahati Asian Film Fest : Day 1
  • Of guns and football
  • Armed men playing football, taunting Govt
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #3 : Gallery
  • Epom Amadei Ithak - A theatrical revisit
  • Economy of the dynamic global landscape
  • Is the Bhagavad Gita relevant today ?
  • Healthy hair in Winter
  • Guwahati Asian Film Festival (GAFF) 2025
  • From the battlefields to Delhi
  • Speculations on replacement of Chief Minister
  • 12th Legislative Assembly #2 : Gallery
  • Education & its disjuncture in Manipur
  • HUN-Thadou Cultural Fest 2025 : Theme
  • Coo :: Poem
  • Agartala Coach : India U-19 Women Cricket
  • The story of the village of hope
  • Career choice in wetlands
  • CM in Delhi to meet Shah
  • After failed plastic ban bid, on brickfields
  • New catfish species discovered in Chakpi
  • Love, Unsure :: Poem
  • Manipur's border battles: Deeper conflict
  • A world without leprosy
  • Origin of corruption & possible remedies
  • The question of life
  • 'Sereki' unveils Majuli-themed campaign
  • Posers over summons to Delhi
  • Addiction-free campaign
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @Kangla #5 : Gallery
  • Manipur : Champions Jr Natl Sepaktakraw
  • Effective Unified Command approach
  • Saurashtrian Tamils
  • Accepting the change :: Poem
  • From Kumbh to heaven direct
  • Edge of the seat suspense
  • Wetlands revival efforts reaping fruit
  • Natambakta : Play by JNMDA #4 : Gallery
  • EIIFF 2025 unveils Festival Memento
  • Climate change & plant diseases
  • Shija Hospital- AHPI Healthcare Award
  • Budget 2025: A big gift for middle-class
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #2
  • Cakeology 2025: India's largest cake expo
  • Need to stick to a consistent narrative
  • Leniency on tobacco ban aiding demographic
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • Pheiroijam Christina - 21st Miss North East
  • Manipur: Gold at 28th Jr National Sepaktakraw
  • Clarion call for redeeming our rightful future
  • The Power of Poppy - 67 :: Poem
  • Clean energy for sustainability
  • Union Budget: Industrialists from NE speaks
  • Balaram Sougaijamba: General of Manipur
  • Nikhil Okram crowned 14th Mister North East
  • Chadong village: Rising from waters with hope
  • Financial literacy for common man
  • Obituary: (L) Pu Thangkholen Sitlhou
  • Nail care in Winters
  • State of war since 2023: No winner, only losers
  • Talks on new district row
  • Radio E-pao: 1000+ songs from Manipur
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Kwak Tanba : Gallery
  • February Calendar for Year 2025 : Tools
  • Ballad of Letting Go :: Poem
  • 2nd Eikhoigi Imphal International Film Fest
  • Deeper exploration of term 'Hill-Valley Divide'
  • Children's Book to adopt 'Look East Policy'
  • Pony registration & conservation
  • Endless suffering of internally displaced child
  • 21st Ningtham Kumhei Fest #2 : Gallery
  • Thiyam Suryamukhi conferred Padma Shri
  • Isolate Kuki Militants by facilitating safe return
  • Sports Meet held at Rongdai Village
  • Eco-Apocalypse: Prevent collapse with Green
  • Grand Finale : 21st Mega Miss North East
  • Time to give more teeth to ST demand
  • 5 years of ILP; what about NRC demand ?
  • Remembering Md Ladu, celebrated polo player
  • The Lament of Love's Deceit :: Poem
  • Need for inculcating value based education
  • Royte - Times Young Entrepreneur Award
  • Glass Child Syndrome ! 'Sibling rivalry'
  • 6 Films for NE Section at GAFF 2025
  • Pony registration & conservation
  • Impartial anti-extortion cell need of the hour
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #1 : Gallery
  • Conservation Strategies of Pethia manipurensis
  • Remembers 13 Brave Indian Soldiers
  • Workshop: Intl Year of Quantum Science
  • Governor's role and discretionary powers
  • Physics workshop for educators at Agartala
  • Who wins Delhi - Daru or Dharma
  • War on Drugs: A war Manipur cannot loses
  • NE turning into transnational drug hub
  • Essence of Gaan-Ngai #2
  • Manipur's dystopian reality
  • The day Light reached the hills
  • 2nd Eikhoigi Imphal Intl Film Fest 2025
  • Why is depreciation of rupee not stopping ?
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #5
  • Thoithoiba Yelhou Yangkok Artist #2 : Gallery
  • Republic Day Titbits
  • NIT Manipur: Best Design Award @VLSI Design
  • The Power of Poppy - 66 :: Poem
  • Grand Finale: 14th Mega Mister North East
  • Application : FILMART, Hong Kong
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #1
  • 21st Ningtham Kumhei Fest #1 : Gallery
  • Demographic for balkanisation of Manipur
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation at Nambol
  • Jugeshwor Kshetrimayum receives GELA 2025
  • Construction Committee of Meetei Yumpham
  • Call against misuse of social media
  • Positive & negative aspects of social media
  • In Search of Peace in Manipur
  • Embracing the Shadows :: Poem
  • Dr Manmohan Singh will live on
  • Rise in the price of medicines
  • Respecting the dead- Denying is a disgrace
  • Winter skin care tips for oily skin
  • Illegal immigrants :: Of FMR & border fencing
  • JD-U row exposes national parties' apathy
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #2 : Gallery
  • On 'Only BJP can save Manipur'
  • Frontline health workers dispelling darkness
  • 14th East Himalayan Trade Fair
  • Life is plastic
  • Killers on the road : 834 lives lost
  • Call to action to save State's wetlands
  • Essence of Gaan-Ngai #1
  • The Taste of Dreams wins @Red Intl Film Fest
  • Science: 3rd eye for Meitei-Kuki reconciliation
  • Northeast flies high in direct selling
  • Mastering focus amidst distractions
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #4
  • BJP : Tepid response from the hills
  • BABINA Hospital sets example in healthcare
  • Nitya Ras @Nongmeibung #1 : Gallery
  • Agonizing reality of our country's veteran elites
  • Historicising the colonial narratives
  • NSS Team Departs for National Integration
  • HUN-Thadou Cultural Festival 2025
  • Time to recreate Naga Peoples Convention 2.0
  • Career in nutrition
  • Need to give more meaning to War on Drugs
  • Time for real action not empty rhetoric
  • Foundation: Manipur Press Club #2 : Gallery
  • "Aronba Wari" :: Shumang Leela Synopsis
  • Tripura's livelihoods challenges
  • Archaeological Exhibition @ Kangla : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chaopok village #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur needs to affirm her tribal roots
  • Madras/Chennai- 1989 till 2024 : Gallery
  • Investigate "arms recoveries" in Mizoram
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation
  • NE Direct Selling Conference & Expo
  • Response of Delhi in last 20 months
  • Regulated entry after FMR scrap, border
  • Mutua Bahadur : Preserving Manipuri culture
  • Competitive Altruism: Resolving ethnic conflict
  • Pithe Puli Utsav at Agartala
  • Building the best version of yourself
  • Guwahati Asian Film Festival 2025
  • Tips to keep your lips soft & smooth in winter
  • Subsidised flight tickets for all
  • MCPCR alert on child trafficking fear
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni @ Wangkhei : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai celebrating Culture in Delhi NCR
  • 2nd Emoinu Fish Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Nupilal Ningshing Lamjel #2 : Gallery
  • Licypriya Kangujam: Nat'l Youth Day Award
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #1 : Gallery
  • Hingminashi Eikhoi : Call for unity in diversity
  • Misna Chanu aids to Jiribam IDPs : Gallery
  • Mega Protest Rally, end AFSPA #2: Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Delhi #3 : Gallery
  • AIR Radio Imphal Station - Live streaming
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #2 : Gallery
  • The historical account of Kabaw Valley #3
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2024 #6: Gallery
  • E-Pao.net : 25th Anniv & 2025 Wishes
  • Protest @Delhi - Murder of Meiteis #2: Gallery
  • Observance of Thang-Ta Day #1 : Gallery
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #1 : Gallery
  • Meitei Mayek Tamba : Online Classroom #5
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Mera Houchongba: Gallery
  • Ta Ta TabuHtoN :: Seireng
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar :: 2025
  • GHOST of PEACE :: Download Booklet