TODAY -

Internment by non-State armed groups : Legal and practical complexities

MC Meetei *



Internment and detention by non-State armed groups (NSAGs) represent some of the most challenging legal and humanitarian issues in contemporary non-international armed conflicts (NIACs). These practices, widespread across conflict zones globally, are fraught with instances of arbitrary detention, inadequate conditions, and violations of international humanitarian law (IHL).

Understanding the legal framework governing such actions and the humanitarian concerns they raise is imperative for addressing their implications and ensuring better compliance with IHL principles.

The Legal Framework for Detention by Non-State Armed Groups

Detention – by States and non-State armed groups (NSAGs) – is a reality in armed conflict. In 2021, the ICRC estimated that over 145 armed groups were holding detainees. It occurs under circumstances that vary from the detention of small numbers of adversary combatants to large-scale internment of civilians.

Notably, IHL does not categorically prohibit detention by NSAGs; rather, it assumes that all parties to a conflict will detain individuals as part of military operations. Consequently, IHL sets out limitations and procedures to govern detention practices to avoid abuse and arbitrariness.

A critical provision in this context is Common Article 3 of the Four Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, which outlines minimum standards of humane treatment. Additional Protocol II to the Geneva Conventions, applicable to NIACs, also provides further procedural and substantive safeguards. For instance, it prohibits arbitrary detention, which is defined under customary IHL as any detention carried out without a legitimate legal basis or regulatory framework.

The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) plays a pivotal role in interpreting and disseminating IHL standards related to detention. Its 2024 Challenges Report emphasises the need for NSAGs to establish clear grounds and procedures for internment to avoid arbitrary practices.

Grounds and Procedures for Internment

Under IHL, internment is an exceptional measure that must be justified on a case-by-case basis. The ICRC underlines that NSAGs should adopt a codified framework—such as a code of conduct or set of rules—detailing the legitimate grounds for internment and procedural safeguards. These grounds generally include individuals posing imperative security threats, such as combatants, spies, or those actively supporting adversary forces.

However, unlawful grounds for internment persist. For example, individuals cannot be detained solely for their familial ties to adversaries, political ideologies, or provision of non-combat support such as food or medical aid. Such practices constitute violations of IHL and undermine the principle of necessity central to lawful detention.

The lack of procedural safeguards compounds the issue of arbitrary detention. Detainees are often left in legal limbo, unaware of the reasons for their internment or the duration. The ICRC recommends mechanisms such as independent review boards to regularly assess the necessity of continued detention. However, the implementation of such reviews by NSAGs remains sparse due to resource constraints and operational limitations.

Humanitarian Concerns and Violations

The humanitarian impact of detention by NSAGs is profound. Detainees often face poor living conditions characterised by congestion, insufficient food, lack of medical care, and exposure to violence and abuse. These conditions are aggravated by the absence of oversight mechanisms and judicial review, leaving detainees entirely dependent on their captors.

Furthermore, specific groups—such as women, children, and the elderly—are particularly vulnerable to mistreatment. Reports have documented cases of sexual violence, enforced disappearances, and extrajudicial killings perpetrated against detainees held by NSAGs. These practices not only violate IHL but may also constitute war crimes under international criminal law.

The recent killing of six innocent civilians, including women, children, and an 8-month-old infant, after being held hostage for five days on 15 November 2024—now referred to as the Jakuradhor Massacre—by Kuki mercenaries in the Jiribam District of Manipur, India, stands as a glaring example of war crimes.

The stress and anxiety experienced by detainees are intensified when they are held without clear information about their status or recourse to legal remedies. Families of detainees also endure severe emotional and financial hardships, often compounded by a lack of communication or information about the detainees’ well-being.

Challenges in Ensuring Compliance

Ensuring NSAGs compliance with IHL poses significant challenges. Unlike state actors, NSAGs often lack the administrative capacity and resources to implement procedural safeguards. Their motivations and operational contexts vary widely, further complicating the enforcement of standardised norms.

The ICRC has sought to address these challenges through direct engagement with NSAGs, emphasising the benefits of adhering to IHL principles for gaining legitimacy and support from local populations. The organisation’s operational dialogue with NSAGs often includes leveraging religious laws and local cus- toms to align detention practices with humanitarian standards.

Role of Supporting States and International Actors

States that support or partner with NSAGs bear a legal responsibility to prevent and address arbitrary detention practices. This responsibility extends to ensuring that their partners comply with IHL through capacity-building initiatives, training programs, and conditional support mechanisms.

The ICRC’s recommendations for supporting states include fostering respect for detainees’ rights and facilitating the implementation of safeguards. Accordingly, India is accountable for the war crimes perpetrated in Manipur by the Kuki NSAGs under the Suspension of Operation (SoO) Pact with the Government of India.

The SoO, being a political pact implying a ceasefire, obligates both parties to adhere to the principles of IHL, including the protection of civilians and their properties, prohibition of targeting non-combatants, and prevention of indiscriminate violence, regardless of the operational context.

Moreover, impartial humanitarian organisations like the ICRC play a vital role in advocating for humane treatment of detainees. Their work includes monitoring detention conditions, providing material assistance, and engaging in dialogue to ensure compliance with IHL.

Towards Ending Arbitrary Detention

Ending arbitrary detention by NSAGs requires a multifaceted approach that prioritises the dignity and rights of detainees. Key measures include

1. Establishing Legal Frameworks: NSAGs must codify clear rules and procedures governing detention practices.
2. Implementing Procedural Safeguards: Regular reviews, transparency, and opportunities for detainees to challenge their internment are essential.
3. International Support and Monitoring: States and humanitarian organisations should collaborate to enhance compliance and accountability.
4. Advocacy and Awareness: Raising awareness about IHL standards among NSAGs, communities, and international stakeholders is crucial for long-term change.

Conclusion

Internment by NSAGs stresses the complex interplay between legal norms, humanitarian concerns, and the realities of armed conflict. While IHL provides a framework for regulating detention practices, achieving full compliance remains a formidable challenge.

Strengthened engagement by international actors and regional humanitarian organisations, coupled with a commitment to procedural safeguards and humane treatment, can mitigate the suffering of detainees and uphold the principles of IHL in NIACs.


Views are writer’s own.


* MC Meetei wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer is a Coordinator of Manipur International Youth Centre.
He can be reached at mcbm17(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on January 19 2025.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2025 : Timeline
  • Extrajudicial Execution & Charge Sheets
  • MoU: Healthcare Access in Bangalore
  • Still Waiting :: Poem
  • Resuming border trade : Misplaced priority ?
  • President's Rule in Manipur : 1967 - 2025
  • Manipur Medal Tally : 38th National Games
  • Navigating Weird Realities of Corporate World
  • The Power of Poppy - 69 :: Poem
  • Expected floods of beggars to arrive
  • Rh Incompatibility during pregnancy
  • Cherrapunji Craft Gin Raises 1.2 Million
  • Explaining 11th President's Rule in Manipur
  • Lui-Ngai-Ni - Naga Seed Sowing Fest : Book
  • 'Ensure Tamei board exams centre operates'
  • Manipur & her trysts with destinies
  • Kitovi-led NNPGs question Rajya Sabha MP
  • One should always speak of life, not marks
  • Farce of a reason for PR
  • After PR all eyes on ending conflict
  • Draft plan for employment generation #1
  • Loingambi, Mingyashin, Chingri : eMing
  • World Radio Day at Rongdai
  • Focus on present challenges for bright future
  • Ed Sheeran brings India Tour to Shillong
  • Beauty tips for Valentine's Day
  • President's Rule has come !
  • No takers for the hot seat!
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • 50 years of Pebet @MCA #1 : Gallery
  • Kwatha Pham Kaaba :: Movie Review
  • Calls for Resignation of Amit Shah
  • Meitei eschatological belief & ethnic struggle
  • Stop border fencing & restore FMR
  • Failing in a competitive exam is not the end
  • Patra, Bhalla : Men of the moment
  • Warning to social media users amid unrest
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chaopok village #2 : Gallery
  • Imagi Sorat :: Shumang Leela Synopsis
  • Daily Habits & Mindsets of High Achievers
  • Coerced legislators' resignations
  • Right wing policies threaten gender equality
  • The fall of the AAP
  • Moving fast but to which direction
  • Onus on centre to restore order in state
  • 5 flowering plants newly recorded
  • Kangleipak's Unwavering Soul :: Poem
  • Make books & newspapers your companions
  • Pulses for a diverse agriculture
  • Exam warriors redefined
  • Sheeba Chaddha at Guwahati Asian Film Fest
  • Resignation of CM sinking in
  • Resignation unlikely to help restore normalcy
  • Manipur Statehood Day @ 1st MR : Gallery
  • Mahakumbh : Not just a religious gathering
  • Nepal with largest pictorial health warnings
  • Is war profitable market for arms manufacturer
  • Our CM & party resurrected BJP in Delhi
  • Assamese Play 'Comfort Women'
  • Reading into the resignation reality
  • No stormy session for now
  • Tarao Harvesting Fest @Chandel #6 : Gallery
  • 'Vande Bharat' Dream
  • NSS Orientation Programme at MU
  • The influence of the Golden Triangle
  • The Power of Poppy - 68 :: Poem
  • Prasanna Vithanage at Guwahati Film Fest
  • Md Alimuddin, celebrated Sagol Kangjei player
  • Condemnation of Armed Football Match
  • Webinar: KM3NeT Mediterranean experiment
  • Redefining Cancer care: People-centered
  • How thought leadership can propel your career
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #3
  • Guwahati Asian Film Fest : Day 1
  • Of guns and football
  • Armed men playing football, taunting Govt
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #3 : Gallery
  • Epom Amadei Ithak - A theatrical revisit
  • Economy of the dynamic global landscape
  • Is the Bhagavad Gita relevant today ?
  • Healthy hair in Winter
  • Guwahati Asian Film Festival (GAFF) 2025
  • From the battlefields to Delhi
  • Speculations on replacement of Chief Minister
  • 12th Legislative Assembly #2 : Gallery
  • Education & its disjuncture in Manipur
  • HUN-Thadou Cultural Fest 2025 : Theme
  • Coo :: Poem
  • Agartala Coach : India U-19 Women Cricket
  • The story of the village of hope
  • Career choice in wetlands
  • CM in Delhi to meet Shah
  • After failed plastic ban bid, on brickfields
  • New catfish species discovered in Chakpi
  • Love, Unsure :: Poem
  • Manipur's border battles: Deeper conflict
  • A world without leprosy
  • Origin of corruption & possible remedies
  • The question of life
  • 'Sereki' unveils Majuli-themed campaign
  • Posers over summons to Delhi
  • Addiction-free campaign
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @Kangla #5 : Gallery
  • Manipur : Champions Jr Natl Sepaktakraw
  • Effective Unified Command approach
  • Saurashtrian Tamils
  • Accepting the change :: Poem
  • From Kumbh to heaven direct
  • Edge of the seat suspense
  • Wetlands revival efforts reaping fruit
  • Natambakta : Play by JNMDA #4 : Gallery
  • EIIFF 2025 unveils Festival Memento
  • Climate change & plant diseases
  • Shija Hospital- AHPI Healthcare Award
  • Budget 2025: A big gift for middle-class
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #2
  • Cakeology 2025: India's largest cake expo
  • Need to stick to a consistent narrative
  • Leniency on tobacco ban aiding demographic
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • Pheiroijam Christina - 21st Miss North East
  • Manipur: Gold at 28th Jr National Sepaktakraw
  • Clarion call for redeeming our rightful future
  • The Power of Poppy - 67 :: Poem
  • Clean energy for sustainability
  • Union Budget: Industrialists from NE speaks
  • Balaram Sougaijamba: General of Manipur
  • Nikhil Okram crowned 14th Mister North East
  • Chadong village: Rising from waters with hope
  • Financial literacy for common man
  • Obituary: (L) Pu Thangkholen Sitlhou
  • Nail care in Winters
  • State of war since 2023: No winner, only losers
  • Talks on new district row
  • Radio E-pao: 1000+ songs from Manipur
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Kwak Tanba : Gallery
  • February Calendar for Year 2025 : Tools
  • Ballad of Letting Go :: Poem
  • 2nd Eikhoigi Imphal International Film Fest
  • Deeper exploration of term 'Hill-Valley Divide'
  • Children's Book to adopt 'Look East Policy'
  • Pony registration & conservation
  • Endless suffering of internally displaced child
  • 21st Ningtham Kumhei Fest #2 : Gallery
  • Thiyam Suryamukhi conferred Padma Shri
  • Isolate Kuki Militants by facilitating safe return
  • Sports Meet held at Rongdai Village
  • Eco-Apocalypse: Prevent collapse with Green
  • Grand Finale : 21st Mega Miss North East
  • Time to give more teeth to ST demand
  • 5 years of ILP; what about NRC demand ?
  • Remembering Md Ladu, celebrated polo player
  • The Lament of Love's Deceit :: Poem
  • Need for inculcating value based education
  • Royte - Times Young Entrepreneur Award
  • Glass Child Syndrome ! 'Sibling rivalry'
  • 6 Films for NE Section at GAFF 2025
  • Pony registration & conservation
  • Impartial anti-extortion cell need of the hour
  • 76th Republic Day @ Kangla #1 : Gallery
  • Conservation Strategies of Pethia manipurensis
  • Remembers 13 Brave Indian Soldiers
  • Workshop: Intl Year of Quantum Science
  • Governor's role and discretionary powers
  • Physics workshop for educators at Agartala
  • Who wins Delhi - Daru or Dharma
  • War on Drugs: A war Manipur cannot loses
  • NE turning into transnational drug hub
  • Essence of Gaan-Ngai #2
  • Manipur's dystopian reality
  • The day Light reached the hills
  • 2nd Eikhoigi Imphal Intl Film Fest 2025
  • Why is depreciation of rupee not stopping ?
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #5
  • Thoithoiba Yelhou Yangkok Artist #2 : Gallery
  • Republic Day Titbits
  • NIT Manipur: Best Design Award @VLSI Design
  • The Power of Poppy - 66 :: Poem
  • Grand Finale: 14th Mega Mister North East
  • Application : FILMART, Hong Kong
  • The Science of Success : Attitude #1
  • 21st Ningtham Kumhei Fest #1 : Gallery
  • Demographic for balkanisation of Manipur
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation at Nambol
  • Jugeshwor Kshetrimayum receives GELA 2025
  • Construction Committee of Meetei Yumpham
  • Call against misuse of social media
  • Positive & negative aspects of social media
  • In Search of Peace in Manipur
  • Embracing the Shadows :: Poem
  • Dr Manmohan Singh will live on
  • Rise in the price of medicines
  • Respecting the dead- Denying is a disgrace
  • Winter skin care tips for oily skin
  • Illegal immigrants :: Of FMR & border fencing
  • JD-U row exposes national parties' apathy
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #2 : Gallery
  • On 'Only BJP can save Manipur'
  • Frontline health workers dispelling darkness
  • 14th East Himalayan Trade Fair
  • Life is plastic
  • Killers on the road : 834 lives lost
  • Call to action to save State's wetlands
  • Essence of Gaan-Ngai #1
  • The Taste of Dreams wins @Red Intl Film Fest
  • Science: 3rd eye for Meitei-Kuki reconciliation
  • Northeast flies high in direct selling
  • Mastering focus amidst distractions
  • An introduction to Rabies (Hydrophobia) #4
  • BJP : Tepid response from the hills
  • BABINA Hospital sets example in healthcare
  • Nitya Ras @Nongmeibung #1 : Gallery
  • Agonizing reality of our country's veteran elites
  • Historicising the colonial narratives
  • NSS Team Departs for National Integration
  • HUN-Thadou Cultural Festival 2025
  • Time to recreate Naga Peoples Convention 2.0
  • Career in nutrition
  • Need to give more meaning to War on Drugs
  • Time for real action not empty rhetoric
  • Foundation: Manipur Press Club #2 : Gallery
  • "Aronba Wari" :: Shumang Leela Synopsis
  • Tripura's livelihoods challenges
  • Archaeological Exhibition @ Kangla : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chaopok village #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur needs to affirm her tribal roots
  • Madras/Chennai- 1989 till 2024 : Gallery
  • Investigate "arms recoveries" in Mizoram
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation
  • NE Direct Selling Conference & Expo
  • Response of Delhi in last 20 months
  • Regulated entry after FMR scrap, border
  • Mutua Bahadur : Preserving Manipuri culture
  • Competitive Altruism: Resolving ethnic conflict
  • Pithe Puli Utsav at Agartala
  • Building the best version of yourself
  • Guwahati Asian Film Festival 2025
  • Tips to keep your lips soft & smooth in winter
  • Subsidised flight tickets for all
  • MCPCR alert on child trafficking fear
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni @ Wangkhei : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai celebrating Culture in Delhi NCR
  • 2nd Emoinu Fish Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Nupilal Ningshing Lamjel #2 : Gallery
  • Licypriya Kangujam: Nat'l Youth Day Award
  • State Gaan-Ngai @Sagolband #1 : Gallery
  • Hingminashi Eikhoi : Call for unity in diversity
  • Misna Chanu aids to Jiribam IDPs : Gallery
  • Mega Protest Rally, end AFSPA #2: Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Delhi #3 : Gallery
  • AIR Radio Imphal Station - Live streaming
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #2 : Gallery
  • The historical account of Kabaw Valley #3
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2024 #6: Gallery
  • E-Pao.net : 25th Anniv & 2025 Wishes
  • Protest @Delhi - Murder of Meiteis #2: Gallery
  • Observance of Thang-Ta Day #1 : Gallery
  • Nupi Lal Memorial @Pune #1 : Gallery
  • Meitei Mayek Tamba : Online Classroom #5
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Mera Houchongba: Gallery
  • Ta Ta TabuHtoN :: Seireng
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar :: 2025
  • GHOST of PEACE :: Download Booklet