TODAY -

Debates on Article 3 on status of Indian States, focusing on historical context of Manipur
Historical context of Manipur and the Indian Constitution

Birendra Laishram *



Manipur established it Constitution before joining India, making it the second region in South East Asia to do so after Sri Lanka (1931). Upon joining the Indian Union in 1949, Manipur was designated as a Part-C State, contrary to 8 Part-B States with elected Rajmukh leaders. This decision was influenced by concerns over its size and self-governance capabilities without considering the pre merger status of being an independent sovereign kingdom.

The Central Govt appointed a Chief Commissioner to directly manage Manipur, reflecting strategic considerations and integration challenges. The term Maharaja and Rajmukh illustrate different historical roles, with Maharajas having governed autonomously before losing power through accession to India.

I argue for a re-evaluation of Mani-pur’s status to acknowledge its unique history and ensure the protection of its territorial integrity and ethnic rights. This historical perspective emphasizes the need to recognize and address the specific dynamic that shaped Manipur’s governance and political status within India.

The Indian Constitution was drafted and completed prior to the annexation of Manipur on 15 October, 1949, which held its own Constituent Assembly. The Constitution was adopted on November 26, 1949, without any discussions or amendments during the intervening period, (15/10/1949 to 26/11/1949) suggesting that Manipur’s specific situation was overlooked during the Consti- tution’s creation as the framing of Constitution was completed before Manipur was a part of India.

Debates on Article 3 were held during November 17 to November 18, 1948. Article 3 mandates consultation with State legislatures for any Bill affecting a State’s area, boundaries, or name, initiated by the President’s recommendation.

KT Shah proposed that these Bills should originate in the State legislature, while Dr BR Ambedkar, the architect of Indian Constitution argued that Parliament should address these issues, requiring consent from ‘sovereign States’ alongside provincial input.

HN Kunzru insisted that both sovereign States and provinces be consulted before such Bills were introduced. Ultimately, Ambed- kar’s more comprehensive approach was preferred, cla-rifying the distinction be- tween provinces and States.

Sovereign States vs. Provinces

Princely States operated semi-autonomously under British suzerainty, while British provinces were directly governed with less autonomy (eg, Bihar and Uttar Pradesh). Dr Ambedkar highlighted that princely States had a degree of sovereignty, making their consent essential for boundary changes, while the boundaries of provinces, directly controlled by the British, could be altered without their consent. This distinction influenced the post-independence reorganization of States and Union Territories.

Application of Article 3

For sovereign and princely States, Article 3 requires consultation with the State Assembly. In contrast, for provincial States, the Centre can invoke Article 3 without needing to consult the State Government. Further debate on Article 3 was held on 13th day of October, 1949 but did not significantly amend Article 3.

The focus remained on ensuring changes to State boundaries, names, or areas necessitated consultation with the affected States, yet Manipur’s unique context was not addressed of being its sove- reignty before annexation to the Indian Union.

Specific Case of Manipur

As a sovereign princely State, Manipur’s consent is essential for any changes under Article 3(a) that affect its boundaries or status, unlike areas of Pondicherry, a French colonial settlement until 1954, and Kashmir, which chose to join India in October 1947 for protection against invading tribesmen from Pakistan and were treated differently.

Conclusion

The limitations of Article 3 of the Indian Constitution highlight its varying applications to States with distinct historical and political contexts. The essential distinction between sovereign princely States and British provincial States shaped the post-independence reorganization of States.

Manipur, as a sovereign princely State, should have had its consent sought for any alterations under Article 3, underscoring the necessity for a nuanced application of Constitutional provisions.

Implications of Non-Consultation

The abrupt recognition of Manipur’s incorporation into the Indian Union led to long-standing grievances among its populace. The lack of consultation not only undermined the historical sovereignty of Manipur but also set a precedent where the unique needs and aspirations of princely States were inadequately represented in the broader framework of Indian federalism.

Political Mobilization and Demand for Autonomy

In the decades following its annexation, the people of Manipur mobilized politically to voice their discon- tent regarding the erosion of their distinct identity and autonomy. Various movements emerged, advocating for greater political representation and administrative autonomy.

These movements highlighted the sentiment that any alterations to State status or boundaries should respect the historical context and rights of the indigenous people. The tension resulting from perceived neglect by the Central Government has fueled demands for greater autonomy and self-governance, reflecting a broader Nationwide struggle for State rights.

The Role of Article 3 in Ongoing Debates

Criticisms regarding the application of Article 3 emphasize the concern that the Constitutional framework often overlooks the complexities of individual identities and rights within the Union. In the case of Manipur, there are calls to revise Article 3 to ensure genuine consultation about its status and to prevent occurrences similar to the unauthorized transfer of the Kabaw Valley to Myanmar, as well as to address the tendency to disregard the local population. /

Recommendations for Redress

To address the historical oversight regarding Mani-pur, legal scholars and local leaders advocate for amendments that explicitly recognize the necessity of local consent for any future changes impacting State boundaries or governance structures. Such amendments would not only honor the intentions of the original drafters of the Cons- titution but also align with contemporary understanding of democracy, where local voices and agreements are paramount to fostering a cooperative federal structure.

Conclusion on Historical Context and Future Implications

The historical context of Manipur’s integration into the Indian Union highlights the intricacies of implementing Constitutional pro- visions such as Article 3, which was established prior to the annexation of Manipur—a sovereign princely State with its own Constitution before India’s independence.

Recognizing the importance of unique historical and cultural narratives can facilitate the evolution of the Indian Cons- titution to more accurately represent the varied ambitions of its States. This involves special provisions safeguarding Manipur’s integrity against the implications of Article 3, fostering a more balanced and representative federal structure.


* Birendra Laishram wrote this article for The Sangai Express
This article was webcasted on November 04 2024 .



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Mera Houchongba: Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2024 : Timeline
  • Observance of Nupi Lal / Protest at Delhi
  • "Political will for Solution to Naga issue"
  • Sessions in Parliamentary democracy
  • Failure to find all TB cases defeats in #endTB
  • Collective actions on climate change needed
  • International Anti-Corruption Day 2024
  • 'Will take time to resolve crisis'
  • Observance of Human Rights Day in Manipur
  • Mega Protest Rally, end AFSPA #1: Gallery
  • UN Human Rights Day @ Lilong: Gallery
  • Time :: Poem
  • Charity Program at Urup Relief Camp
  • Human Rights Day at Lamphel Court
  • UN Human Rights Day at Lilong
  • Art & Calligraphy in Constitution
  • Five years of ILPS in Manipur
  • Apex court intervenes as state, centre fail
  • Natambakta Play @JNMDA #2 : Gallery
  • Ta Ta TabuHtoN :: Seireng
  • Loingamba, Reipao, Theithei : eMing
  • Echoes of Unheard Voices :: Poem
  • Day 3 : 9th Brahmaputra Valley Film Fest
  • NER's Renaissance: Isolation to integration
  • Hunger caused by hormonal imbalance
  • Snuffing the life out of ISBT
  • Govt must look beyond internet ban
  • 78th Independence Day of India #3 : Gallery
  • Binoranjan Oinam: Best Director at 9th BVFF
  • Three children by Mohan Bhagwat
  • 'Horn of Nagaland' title goes to Rio
  • Biomedical waste is dangerous
  • Understanding the gifted child
  • Suspending internet since Nov 16
  • From dismissal to revelation: Drone bombings
  • Who are the Rongmeis ?
  • Assam Handicrafts - Rhino & much more!
  • The Power of Poppy - 59 :: Poem
  • Soil: Earth's skin is key for environment
  • Day 2 : 9th Brahmaputra Valley Film Fest
  • Teaching teens financial responsibility
  • Sagol Kangjei Esei @Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • Mushroom cultivation training at Bishnupur
  • Turning a blind eye to mayhem in Manipur
  • Enforced disappearance by Armed Forces
  • Memo to PM : Restore peace in Manipur
  • Remembering Dr Rajendra Prasad
  • Can you understand the truth of life ?
  • Many continue to eye indifferent Delhi
  • Bid to wake up quiescent PM
  • Maring dance @ Mera Houchongba : Gallery
  • A Traveler's Musings by Imphal River :: Poem
  • Why such divisive thoughts ?
  • 9th Brahmaputra Valley Film Festival begins
  • Medifacials for inner glow
  • Case of Kamalbabu since Nov 25
  • Securing highways must for MST bus service
  • Mera Chaorel Houba #3 : Gallery
  • NE forests are vulnerable to non-native tree
  • Still, I Wondered Upon :: Poem
  • Reaching the unreached to find missing TB
  • Naga Solution- Salvation route for PM Modi
  • The siren's song: A story of worldly temptation
  • Dissenting voices from within
  • Futile search for missing person
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping #2 : Gallery
  • Price people have to pay for conflict
  • Wildlife conservation is for human existence
  • When embracing a sense of oneness
  • Viksit Bharat Young Leader Dialogue at MU
  • 'One Nation One Subscription' will strengthen
  • Defiling the understanding of ILP
  • Poppy plantations in the hills
  • Pot Lannaba : Mera Houchongba #1: Gallery
  • Wild edible plants for sustainable livelihood
  • Challenges to education amid agitation
  • Medicines save lives but not when they stop
  • Guwahati audition: Mega Miss North East
  • Amul way: Journey of India's dairy revolution
  • Innate goodness of mankind : Kindness
  • Gunfights among peace deal signatories
  • International Dance Day #5: Gallery
  • Whispers of the Tarangmalangpal :: Poem
  • Winners: Dr A Surjalal Memorial Grant
  • Solar Mamas from Manipur graduate
  • Fencing & Constitutional solution
  • The silent language of signs
  • Changing Toys
  • Debunking the false narrative
  • Central forces under scanner
  • Meitei Mayek Tamba : Online Classroom #4
  • 40 Years & 04 Stations - Part I
  • Responsibility of the Cabinet in Parliament
  • Economy & employment in Manipur
  • The Power of Poppy - 58 :: Poem
  • 70th Wildlife Week Celebration #2 : Gallery
  • December Calendar for Year 2024 : Tools
  • Is Manipur turning into an African State ?
  • NIT Manipur signs MoA with NIT Warangal
  • India's multi-alignment diplomacy
  • Ed Sheeran to perform Shillong
  • Change your skin care routine
  • Poking into internal affairs of Manipur
  • Fictive campaign of unfriendly neighbour
  • Thang Ta @ Kwak Tanba : Gallery
  • Decades of failure to end TB & tobacco
  • Dread Life :: Poem
  • Manipur crisis: Constitutional call for justice
  • Training on Mushroom Cultivation
  • Integrated Badminton Academy launched
  • Pathetic show of Govt for over 576 days
  • Unrest situation battering education sector
  • Public Review on the Eight Point Resolution
  • Empowering Youth & Transforming Manipur
  • Inoculation for regional destabilization
  • Boro film 'Bibo Binanao' premieres at IFFI
  • How childhood abuse impacts mental health
  • Cementing UNO's role in global crises
  • Story of missing man from Army camp
  • Man gone missing from military garrison!
  • Chakkouba Annual Fish Fair #2 : Gallery
  • Discordant thought of Meiteis
  • 75th Constitution Day observed
  • AMR is not a silent pandemic
  • Killing of innocent minor Children & Women
  • Social significance of countering misinformation
  • Formula from Mizoram MP: Dangerous
  • Hostile neighbour
  • 133rd Manipur Police raising day #2 : Gallery
  • The return to monarchy from democracy
  • AMH: Fertility in women of late age
  • Carpet :: Poem
  • Bio fertilizers: Use & importance
  • Unfolding script under War on Drugs drive
  • Desperate bid to shield Kuki militants
  • False claim for Kukiland
  • Intl Day: Eliminate Violence Against Women
  • The Three 'Great Living Chola Temples
  • Violence against women
  • Sholay, Basanti & Chidambaram
  • Debut of 'Sarkari Investigator'
  • Menace of illegal immigrant, poppy plantation
  • Resign call from Khemchand to CM
  • National Press Day @DIPR : Gallery
  • An act of barbarism
  • Candle Light Solidarity Vigil at Mumbai
  • Rejoinder to 10 Non-Naga Tribal MLAs
  • Delhi : Rio must do 'better homework' with IM
  • The Power of Poppy - 57 :: Poem
  • World Antimicrobial Resistance Week
  • Meitei Mayek Tamba : Online Classroom #3
  • Discord over Reserved Forest in Manipur
  • Program to increase Tribal Participation
  • Are we on wrong side of the #endTB track?
  • No roadmap for peace restoration in Manipur
  • Agragami, to release debut album
  • Profound observation of PRCM
  • Unbreakable silence of PM Modi
  • Angakpa Mawongi Atithi Seva : Folktale
  • Dear children of Manipur
  • Fuelwood consumption in Manipur
  • Face Yoga for healthy glow
  • 9th Brahmaputra Valley Film Festival
  • Wildlife cannot be manufactured
  • Barriers to implementing primary health care
  • Radio E-pao: 1000+ songs from Manipur
  • Drugs waging a war on Manipur
  • Impressing the centre more important
  • Usman Gani: Meitei Pangal Radio Playwright
  • Crisis: Failed governance, blind Centre
  • HIV tools; is it expanding choices for people?
  • Sausage as a value-added product
  • Blessed Be a Woman :: Poem
  • Raise your voice when you have evidence
  • Davaindia Targets Expansion Drive in NE
  • Net ban continues, so does curfew
  • Slugfest over PC's post imminent
  • Kwak Tanba @Sana Konung #3: Gallery
  • Restoring Peace & Unity in Manipur
  • Address Gross Human Rights Violations
  • PIB, the silent service provider
  • The Hidden Jewel :: Poem
  • Endoscopic Spine Surgery
  • Resolutions to urge Centre
  • Entrusting NIA to deliver justice
  • Mobs attack MLAs house [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Candlelight Protest @Blore [Nov 17] : Gallery
  • 9th General Elections: NE Students Jalandhar
  • Candlelight Protest Against Brutal Killing
  • Social context of people's movement
  • Media Conclave at Barak Festival
  • Disturbing the disturbed area
  • Why is Delhi still indifferent?
  • Looting spree a blot on public movement
  • Curfew enforced in Imphal [Nov 17] : Gallery
  • Protest @Seoul condemn murder : Gallery
  • Condemn brutal murder of 6 innocent Meiteis
  • Licypriya urged world leaders to act
  • AFSPA reimposition: A setback in Manipur
  • Vision for Vikshit Bharat in Gurgaon
  • World Diabetes Day 2024
  • Dastardly killing of 3 women, 3 kids
  • Internet ban, again
  • Massive protests in Imphal [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Condemns Killing Children [Nov 16] : Gallery
  • Condemnation of Brutality, Rape, Murder
  • The Power of Poppy - 56 :: Poem
  • Appeal for Immediate Action
  • Appeals for calm, peace & justice
  • Condemns Killings of Innocent Children
  • Marup Mari #2 : Folktale
  • 1833 Jeree Treaty made Manipur's boundary
  • Yelhou Yangkok Art Exhibit #1 : Gallery
  • 24 hour shutdown [November 12] : Gallery
  • 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly #1: Gallery
  • Alangtakhou waterfall #2: Gallery
  • Ooba Video : is now relaunched !
  • Ningols to Mapam Lamdam #2 : Gallery
  • Ningols to Mapam Lamdam #1 : Gallery
  • Thadou Convention 2024 : Declarations
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar :: 2025
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2024 #5: Gallery
  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #1 : Gallery
  • Case for Manipuri as a classical language
  • Bor @Hiyangthang Lairembi: Gallery
  • Ema Panthoibi @ Mandalay, Myanmar
  • Manipur Official Phone Directory : Search
  • HSLC (Class X) 2024 : Full Result
  • HSLC 2024 : Important Info & Grading System
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Private Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Aided Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Govt Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Statistical Abstract
  • HSLC 2024 : Comparative Statement
  • Malemnganbi Laishram : Science Topper
  • Thokchom Sheityajit : Arts Topper
  • Aiena Naorem : Commerce Topper
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Science Topper
  • HSE 2024 : Subject Pass Percentage
  • HSE 2024 : District Pass Percentage
  • HSE 2024 : Candidates with Highest Marks
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Science Full Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Arts Full Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Commerce Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Arts Topper
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Commerce Topper
  • GHOST of PEACE :: Download Booklet
  • List of Kings of Manipur: 33 - 1984 AD