CSCHR Statement on Chandel Ambush and search operations
Imphal, 09 June 2015
The Civil Society Coalition on Human Rights in Manipur and the UN (CSCHR), a coalition of
twenty-three (23) indigenous peoples’ human rights organizations of Manipur in India’s North
East region, is extremely concerned with the deepening political instability in Manipur and
particularly with the situation of open armed conflict on the eastern flank of Manipur, in
Chandel District bordering with Myanmar’s Sagaing Division. It has been widely reported that
after the 4th June lethal apparently pre-planned ambush of a convoy of the 6th Dogra Regiment
of the Indian Army near Paraolon Village by unidentified cadres of an armed opposition group
or organisation that left at least 18 army personnel dead and many more injured, General
Dalbir Singh Suhag, chief of the Army and top commanding generals of the Eastern Command
gathered in Imphal the next day to initiate activities to “sanitise the area completely”.
CSCHR is a coalition that upholds the principles and statutes of humanitarian and human rights
law that are established worldwide, to which members of the United Nations Organisation
(UNO) including India are state parties. The coalition does not believe in armed conflict and
militaristic solutions aimed at objective of peace and development as a final solution to
intractable and sensitive political situations. In this context, and in solidarity with many civil
society organisations that have voiced their disapproval in strongest terms, CSCHR does not
support or condone in any way, the escalations of armed violence and confrontations between
government and non-state armed forces in Manipur and the North East Region of India.
We
strongly disapprove of the de facto “state of siege” that exists in Chandel district today, which is
beyond the “Rule of Law” and the gaze of the public through the media. We grieve for those
who have lost precious lives unnecessarily, as no line of duty in this modern world should
involve the grave risk of such violence and untimely death.
Considering that the State of Manipur, for several decades, has been continuously declared a
“disturbed area”, with the imposition of the Armed Forces [Special Powers] Act of 1958
(AFSPA) to manage the law and order situation, this abrupt development augurs ill for the
State and central governments’ views and policies pursued to maintain peace and tranquillity
in Manipur. It is far from clear who is in control of the situation in the localities around the
ambush site in Chandel District, with the 3 Corps GOC Lt. Gen. Bipin Rawat stating that a
“people friendly” operation is being carried out to flush out the non-state opposition groups
from Manipur completely. Surprisingly, the State government and the district administration
seem to have no visible or vocal role in this sanitisation exercise, except for a tacit
acquiescence.
With more dead bodies, some suspected to be civilians, being still found from the area, the
perceptible lack of involvement or coordination between the central armed and paramilitary
forces and the Chandel District administration is underlined by the Deputy Commissioner of
Chandel having reportedly to seek “permission” in writing from the army for the families of
missing persons to carry out search and identification procedures.
It is perplexing how the Chief Minister of Manipur, who is the chairman of the Unified
Command structure of Manipur under the jurisdiction of AFSPA, does not consider he is
accountable for the activities of the central armed and paramilitary forces in Chandel District. It
is unacceptable that neither he nor the Deputy Chief Minister in charge of home affairs in the
State have visited the district immediately after the incident to take stock of the situation, even
though top generals of India have flown in from New Delhi! If it is also true, as widely reported
that the Indian army unit, which suffered tragic fatalities and losses, had been violating
Standard Operating Procedure (SOP), the Unified Command under the chairmanship of the CM
of Manipur seems to have abdicated its role and functions totally.
There seems to be dual commands stand in this ongoing situation with the State and central
governments both announcing having launched simultaneous inquiries. This non-transparent
and dual situation, with the central authorities calling the shots, does not comply at all with a
“people friendly” operation. If the statement by Lt. Gen. Bipin Rawat is to have any credence
whatsoever, the Chandel District administration, the Manipur police including women police
officers must lead the search operations with the cooperation of central security forces. The
media must be allowed into the area unhindered as there are no more fire fights or active
hostilities as reported.
It is incumbent on the state to ensure that humanitarian laws, especially Common Article 3 of
the Geneva Conventions as the minimum standard, and human rights are respected in all
aspects of the present operation. Humanitarian law is particularly critical because of the
involvement of the Indian Army undertaking war-like operations in civilian, especially tribal
areas of Manipur. Utmost due diligence is expected from the high command under which the
central military and paramilitary forces are presently undertaking this operation. In this
context, and in cognizance of the Supreme Court of India’s rulings on such matters as
counterinsurgency operations, CSCHR views with contempt that civil administration officials
do not form a central part of the current operations being conducted in the indigenous tribal
peoples populated Chandel, as ordered by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
We concur with the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s views that “modern Constitutionalism posits
that no wielder of power should be allowed to claim the right to perpetrate state's violence
against any one, much less its own citizens, unchecked by law, and notions of innate
human dignity of every individual;” and that the state in a democracy, is not justified in
resorting to illegal means to deal with such movements, in violation of the Constitution,
statutory laws and the ‘Rule of Law’, as this would lead to ever increasing levels of escalating
violence, in particular in the face of genuine discontent as reported by official committees of
the government, reminding governments, law makers, civil and military officials and citizens.
The State Government and District administration, having declared a curfew in Chandel, must
clarify the exact geographical extent of the search operation. The Director General Police of
Manipur must update the public and media daily on the activities and developments in the area
of the operation. Civilian populations displaced and affected in any way by the search operation
must have immediate access to humanitarian and legal aid, psychosocial support and adequate
shelter including food, sanitation and safe drinking water though a procedure of direct
assessment conducted jointly by competent officers and representatives of the District
administration and non-government organisations.
The unforgettable tragedy that befell Oinam in Senapati District of Manipur in 1987, when the
civilian population was put under a state of violent siege, terrorised, tortured, killed and
subjected to the most inhuman abuses must never be repeated. The State Government has a
crucial responsibility to ensure that the civilian population of Chandel District is accorded the
fullest protection under the law; and it is unacceptable that the home minister Gaikhangam
merely spouts the usual term “unfortunate” and has not described what the “maximum efforts”
that the State government is making.
We welcome the news reported that the Indian army is being divested of counter-insurgency
duties in the North East Region of India. With such a national policy level trend within the
government of India, as reported, the AFSPA should now be seriously considered for repeal by
parliament, as recommended repeatedly at the international and national levels. The
governments of Manipur and India must leave no stone unturned to see that a peaceful and
confidence building situation is in place for a just resolution to this tragic and prolonged armed
conflict.
(Dr Laifungbam D Roy)
Convenor
On Behalf of the Civil Society Coalition on Human Rights in Manipur and the UN
Member Organisations of CSCHR are:
1. All Manipur Nupi Manbi Association (AMANA)
2. Centre of Network and Empowerment (CoNE)
3. Centre for Organisation Research & Education (CORE)
4. Centre for Research & Advocacy (CRA Manipur)
5. Citizens Concern for Dams and Development (CCDD)
6. Civil Liberties and Human Rights Organisation (CLAHRO)
7. Civil Liberties Protection Forum (CLPF)
8. Committee on Human Rights, Manipur (COHR)
9. Ethno-Heritage Council (HERICOUN)
10. Extra-judicial Execution Victim Families’ Association Manipur (EEVFAM)
11. Families of the Involuntarily Disappeared’s Association Manipur (FIDAM)
12. Forum for Indigenous Perspective and Action (FIPA)
13. Human Rights Alert (HRA)
14. Human Rights Defenders Manipur (HRD)
15. Human Rights Initiative (HRI)
16. Human Rights Law Network Manipur (HRLN-M)
17. Just Peace Foundation (JPF)
18. Life Watch
19. Manipur Alliance for Child Rights (MACR)
20. Movement for Peoples’ Right to Information Manipur (M-PRIM)
21. North East Dialogue Forum (NEDF)
22. Threatened Indigenous Peoples Society (TIPS)
23. United Peoples Front (UPF)
* This PR was sent to e-pao.net by CSCHR (Civil Society Coalition on Human Rights in Manipur and the UN) who can be contacted at cschrmanipur(aT)gmail(dot)com
This Press Release was posted on June 10 2015
* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.