TODAY -

Was it a Hindu Day in Assam’s book season

Dhruva Saikia *

 Book release  at Gauhati Press Club on November 3 2019
Book release at Gauhati Press Club on November 3 2019



Three BJP leaders, including Minister Dr.Himanta Biswa Sarma released their books on a single day in three different functions in course of the just concluded Book Fair in Guwahati that sold books worth Rs 4 crore. The release of the three books, by writers subscribing to a singular school of thought, really deserves to be tagged as Book Season Hindu Day in Assam.

But among the three books released on November 3 2019 Satyaranjan Borah’s Assamese book entitled Islam aru Quaranor Kalongkita Kotahbur (Infamous stuff contained in Islam and Quran), out shadowed the other two in terms of curiosity and controversy. The book was inaugurated at Gauhati Press Club by Maulana Mufti Abdulla Al Masud from Bangladesh and Mr Borah, in course of his speech mentioned that he had sent formal invitation to none, but expected people to come to the function willingly.

I was present at the function and was impressed with the number of people who had gathered there to listen to the Maulana, who describes himself as an atheist after disowning Islam, and Borah. The writer also had an occasion to let me know that some people shouted slogans before the function started and a top Police officer called up Bora to assess the situation.

Why this Controversy

The very title of the book, that too written by a BJP man, was enough to entail a controversy and this exactly happened when pressmen at the inauguration venue engaged themselves in a heated argument with the writer. Thankfully Borah maintained cool but the news bulletins that followed made people aware of the development. People rushed to grab a copy of the book, despite AIUDF leader Badruddin Ajmal’s letter to the Union Home Ministry for a ban on the book that ‘has severely affected the emotions and hurt religious sentiments of Muslims.’

Release of the three books by three BJP stalwarts on a single day and people’s response to these books in the Book Fair prompted Assam State Jamiat Ulema to issue a statement, on the very day the books were released, 4 November, charging the North East Book Fair as an exercise in Hinduism. Secretary of Assam State Jamiat Ulema Maulana Fajlul Karim Kasimi said in his statement that the book fair was now in the grip of RSS and so, the organizers should rein in them. The secretary made special mention of Borah’s book.

What does Borah say

The writer has, since publication of his book, been spending his time at all convenient venues to exchange views and opinions. His facebook and twitter handles are busy with charges and countercharges, or their refute. Borah’s familiarity with Islam and Quran dates back to his school education upto class VIII at a madrassah in Assam where he was barred from entering an exclusive classroom for Muslim students. He had challenged the norm at his tender age and managed to learn Arabic.

However, Borah’s inquisitiveness landed him in a pool of quandary. Borah declares his book as no part of political agenda ut an honest attempt at an academic research. The book is in Assamese and I feel an English translation of what Borah says in the preface to the book would enlighten the readers on the context. Please read the preface of the book at the peak of controversy in this book season in Assam.

The Preface

" Let me make a frank declaration that I belong to none of those two classes of people who are all-pervading in the current scenario of political, social or intellectual discourse, identified as anti-Muslim and radical Hindutwa promoters. Yes I belong to none of these two groups, but I must add that nor am I a member of that club that is used to shedding crocodile tears for the sake of Islam followers on the pretext of being a minority community. Nor such a Sanatan Dharmi I am who wears a red tilak in broad day light and indulges in vulgarism after the sun sets. So, I am what whatever I am, and wish to initiate a discourse, essentially on my individual, actual and bona fide conviction.

As I set on the work for this book, quite consciously I made an effort to rise above the limitations of religion, community and even ultimate approval or disapproval, have been willing to maintain an equal distance from all those involved and concerned, and it has truly been my ardent keenness to find the truth, to state publicly what religion is, and in order to meet this goal I dissolved myself in minute scrutiny and reasonable presentation.

Nevertheless, I can’t help being a proud Hindu and a confident Assamese too, so I risk the likelihood of being dismissed as a Hindu advocate. I would not mind this problem, because I have trained myself to overcome some troubles as I thrive to uphold my mother’s propriety.

I owe my familiarity with Islamic religious texts to my primary school education upto class VII at Laskar Pachali ME Madrassa where I learnt subjects including general science, arithmetic, English and Assamese, but the Muslim students in the school were exclusively taught another two subjects known as Arabic and Dwiniyad. Hindu students like me were not allowed to enter the classroom when our Muslim classmates used to be given lessons on these two subjects. As we enjoyed our time outside the classroom, we the Hindu students in the Madrassa hardly cared to ponder over why we were not allowed inside and what those two subjects were about.

But I have been a curious person always and a little bit of a rebel since my childhood, and I continue to be one still. So, once I refused to leave the classroom when the teacher had entered for this exclusive class for Muslim students. The Maulabi teacher was not quite happy with me for my insistence, but as he was quite aware of my father’s reputation in the society, he decided to allow me in. As a result, I learnt to read and write Arabic but the practice has vanished.

All these days in the Madassa I was asking myself why Islamic religious teaching in the Madrassa was exclusive for Muslims whereas religious lessons belonging to Hindus and other religions were meant for all students in other schools. Was it not a part of the Muslim plan for maintaining a distance from the rest of the society? Was not seed of disparity sowed when we the Hindu students were asked to leave the classroom?

Now a word about the food habit. Hindus have no objection to some hallal meat, but no Muslim would touch the meat of an animal or bird that has been killed by strangulating its neck by a Hindu man. Quran maintains that hallal is purification. Does it imply Muslims alone are purified inhabitants on the planet? Is it the Muslims only who eat purified food? Quran further states that Allah created the world, the air-water-soil, sun and moon as well as the entire lot of life. If Allah is the creator of the whole, then what justifies the classification of pure and impure among Allah’s creations?

I had an occasion to attend an invitation for dinner hosted by an Assamese Christian at his residence in Dibrugarh district. I noticed two Muslim youth, with their caps on head, were there to cull the chicken. I asked the host why these Muslim youth were there, was it not possible to prepare the food without them? The host revealed that he had some Muslim guests for the dinner who had laid a pre-condition that they would not accept the invitation if the meat was not of hallal variety.

The host was an Assamese first and a Christian then. Naturally he imbibed the values of Indian culture that looks upon a guest as god. But what is the justification of the precondition put in by the guests? Is not it just an instance of harbouring exclusivity in the name of Allah?

The world believes that religion glorifies humanity and builds a society. But is it not also a hard fact that certain conducts in the name of religion raise a question over the very essence of humanity. It is not intended at this moment to discuss about justification of exclusive religious behaviors, but won’t you agree that these kind of behaviour are an obstacle in the path of social harmony and unity?

Now let us turn to the practice of sunnat. Even we ignore the global scenario of this male organ mutilation practice, taking the Indian scene into account, we have every right to wonder that are not the Hindus, 80 per cent of Indian population leading a perfect without sunnat ? What really is sunnat? Assuming some scientific explanations are in place, yet we cannot escape the question how did the science arrive at a communal pronouncement? Perhaps sunnat is another part of the scheme to ensure an exclusive status for a group of people. People who long an exclusive status for themselves, staying away from the mainstream society, also forfeit their right for equality.

I am, therefore, at a loss to appreciate the charge of Hindus driving the Muslims away, as often uttered by mistaken Muslim citizens and their shrewd advocates. It is the Muslims who stay away from their Hindu brethren by enclosing themselves in an exclusive arena, and no Hindu is responsible this sort of affairs.

The entire population of my village, irrespective of caste, creed and religion, are welcome to enjoy a bhaona in my village namghar and Bihu celebrations. But I have never been invited to any mosque despite my early education in a madrassa. The points I have raised are precise and clear. It is therefore time to ponder if these features are not an impediment in the path attaining a harmonious state of our attitude?

I have also stated at the very beginning that neither I am anti-Muslim, nor a rigid Hindutwa follower. However, I have decided to come out with a candid, vigorous presentation of facts and figures in the interest of the country and its people. I am helpless if my work hurts anyone’s religious sentiment or challenges his social status. The discussion here is clearly academic and I would be truly happy if my discussion here turns out to be a humble dose of antidote to cure prevailing social evils and misconceptions. I would also like to recall that we ought to avoid tobacco well before its ill-effects are visible. It is high time we learn to take note of the statutory warning on cigarette packets.

Each Muslim is a human being first and my sibling therefore. I adore my village, the region and the district to which I belong much in the line I love my home and family. As I am accountable to solve my domestic, so I am responsible to be a part of the solution that my village, district or the country needs. I am not prepared to keep mum about maladies like violence and anti-social activities that afflict my fellow citizens.

I am not ready to disown certain truths and also prepared the pay the price for it. It is a noble duty and responsibility to uphold my mother’s reputation which is being threatened by a spell of evil and baseless notions. As the air-water-soil and the culture in my motherland have nurtured me, I find it difficult to passively accept the onslaught on my motherland unleashed by someone’s desire to carve out an ‘exclusive’ corner. Religion, caste or creed is hardly a pre-condition for patriotism, rather it is a moral duty for the sons of soil.

I must make it clear that no bickering or division is intended by this discussion. The discussion in the book is aimed at diagnosis of our existing malady and finding its solution, accompanied by an attempt at reappraisal that would hopefully strengthen the bond and harmony. I have studied the Quran, not in Arabic but the Assamese translation by Dr Jahrul Haque , and after reading and rereading quite a number of times, I was asking myself is this really religious teaching?

Dr Haque states in the preface to the translated Quran that he was trying his best for an accurate translation, he also took care not to add any additional word to the original text, nor to delete any. The Quran also mentions that Jiddah University, Saudi Arabia recognizes Dr Haque as the only translator of the Quran into more than two languages. Such recognition dispelled my fears about limitations of translation in this case.

Later, I decided to read two more translations of Quran, one into Bengali by Alhaj Maulana AKM Fazlur Rehman Munshi sahib and the other into English, The Holy Qur’an, by Maulabi Sher Ali. A comparison of these three translated Qurans reaffirmed my belief that though we may utter a statement, for example, that we inhale oxygen and exhale carbon-dioxide, in slightly different tones, the variation does not alter the real meaning. The varied tone or presentation does not make us inhale carbon dioxide.

I must mention that though I read three Qurans in three languages, the ayats and Arabic pronunciation in this book are from only Dr Haque’s Assamese translation. I have also taken care to follow Dr Haque for the terms and letters in the ayats. After reading the Qurans, naturally I picked up Hindu and Christian religious books such as Gita, Bhagawat and the Bible, only to discover that Quran is markedly different from the rest. Discovery of this fact has led me to initiate the discussion in this book.

Quran is way ahead from others religious texts when it comes to a discussion about community. This would be clear from a number of ayats (ayat is the Arabic word for word) in Quran Sura 11, para 12. When a religious book identifies the followers as a community, each community would find itself in an enclosure, treading a solo path, and the idea of basudhaiba kutumbakam would elude them. I have been, to tell you the truth, been sort of compelled to bring out this book and urge my readers not to misunderstand me. I deem it a part of duty for my motherland to speak out the truth and also to uphold the diversity here.

The study of Quran convinced me that Muslim society must play a bigger role than their Hindu brothers for a lasting and positive solution to the growing Hindu-Muslim disparity in the country. Muslims cannot escape the blame for their bigotry and distorted interpretation of Quran. A minute study of Quran is enough to realize this holy book is at the root of global violence and anarchy.

Here I am not making a complaint, but simply a statement about what I have leant. I believe the progressive Muslim youth and thinkers would come forward to appreciate the developments. As long as the Muslims remain confined in some exclusive berths, social harmony and equal democratic rights will not be a reality.

It is also time to understand the democratic terms in proper perspective. Democracy implies inclusiveness and discards exclusivity. This book is meaningless for those who identify democracy with the teachings and practices of Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi. This book is devoid of any political agenda, instead it wants to build a bridge between two members in a family, whose view and thoughts don’t tally, but the bridge is necessary for betterment of the household. It is too early to comment on success of my endeavour, yet I have made an attempt and now I would leave it entirely to the judgement of fellow countrymen and readers.

I must acknowledge the guidance and help from a number of Muslim veterans. I have been inspired by several renowned persons, who told me about how to treat the subject matter and present it to readers. Without naming them individually, I offer my gratitude to each of them.’- SatyaRanjan Borah.


* Dhruva Saikia wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer can be contacted at dhroovajit(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on November 18 2019.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Winter Relief @Tokpaching : Gallery
  • My way only :: Poem
  • Winter Relief Service at Arong Khunou
  • Karnataka-Manipur Cultural Festival
  • Workshop on MOOCs at NEHU
  • Reinstate workers fired in FCI
  • Significance of windows
  • Thanga Ningol to mapam #3 : Gallery
  • Xmas shopping @CCpur [Dec 6] : Gallery
  • Irawat and 1939 Women's War
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Cannot end AIDS without combating AMR
  • Power of Pranayama #2
  • Jobs @ Birla Emporiums, Khurai
  • Memo to BOSEM, Manipur
  • Appreciation to Kuki Iron Lady
  • Questions over 'instant justice'
  • Optimist perspectives
  • NE bandh call on Dec 10 against CAB
  • Football: Manipur vs Mandalay #2: Gallery
  • Flower festival at Mao : Gallery
  • #iWill :: Poem
  • H Nageshwar : Expedition to Antarctica
  • Relevance of Nehru today #2
  • Climate Change & Agricultural hurdles
  • The Rat on the Run :: Poem
  • Info from Delhi; Reading ILPS idea
  • Confusing the constitution
  • Finding on Yek of Meitei & Hao #1
  • Miss Kut at Imphal #4: Gallery
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand : Timeline
  • A Girl with Golden Hair :: Poem
  • NEP for Skill India
  • The great cosmic discovery - III
  • Interference by TA & Hills official
  • A one line statement from Amit Shah
  • Insertion of a clause to Peoples' Bill
  • RK Meghen at Imphal [28 Nov] #2: Gallery
  • Midnight drama, hush-hush swearing-in
  • Plight of peasants in the hills #2
  • Jobs @ Kanglei Khoni, Langthabal
  • Drones can be an innovative career
  • Winners @ South Asian Games
  • Winners @ Asian Athletic C'ship
  • Waiting for CBI probe
  • When the savior turns perpetrator
  • Tapta: Jayenta Loukrakpam :: A Profile
  • Destination North East @ Vanarasi : Gallery
  • Winter Book Sales at Manipur University
  • The Vow :: Poem
  • Written assurance is still not tenable
  • Protest against rape of woman vet
  • From 2012 to 2019 no change
  • The 'Trust' factor
  • NSCN (IM) clarifies on 'calendar' issue
  • Centre assures flights betn IMF & Mandalay
  • Sanathong Water Fall, Chandel : Gallery
  • Jangsat, Aton Kharaoba : eMing
  • Facts about Naga insurgency #2
  • CC Meet 2019 : Match Fixture
  • Commemoration Kuki Rebellion 1917-1919
  • Moirangthem Sushilkr : Honorary Doctorate
  • Power of Pranayama #1
  • Khumang: 'Science for Society' Report
  • A fresh look at ST demand
  • Wakching Thana Lakpada #1 :: eRang
  • Football: Manipur Vs Mandalay : Gallery
  • December Calendar for Year 2019 : Tools
  • Why not carve out a future in Chakhao ?
  • Relevance of Nehru today #1
  • The great cosmic discovery - II
  • The Killing Fields 2013-19 : News Timeline
  • Diversion - the age old shrewd game
  • Lamhui amashung Keishal : Funga
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Kut : State level @Imphal #4: Gallery
  • Sangai Festival: Extended till 2nd Dec
  • 133 months left to make U=U (on HIV)
  • Galaxy Roy & my Sainik memories
  • Need to silence the loud mouth
  • CAB issue raise in Zero Hour
  • RK Meghen at Imphal [28 Nov] #1: Gallery
  • Plight of peasants in the hills #1
  • Nawa Loude :: Poem
  • Awarded, outdated currencies & MCS/MPS
  • Social Unrest in N-E Regions
  • Winter care for beautiful hair
  • No harm but a clause needed: The absurdity
  • A blow to survival
  • Leirum- used in Luhongba : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping #2 : Gallery
  • Road safety in Manipur: need to plug gap
  • AAI steps up effort for gender equality
  • Preparing children before diagnostic test
  • Licypriya Kangujam embarks on 5 Nations
  • One Word of Truth :: Poem
  • Riders in the assurance of Amit Shah
  • GK Pillai's way out and today's Manipur
  • Mera Houchongba @Kangla #5: Gallery
  • Facts on Naga insurgency & its impact #1
  • Binodkumar: public urinal with plastic waste
  • Joining Indian Navy as sailors
  • National Constitution Day observed
  • Condemn incident of molestation in CCpur
  • After a date with Amit Shah
  • Sustaining Evening daily- challenging task
  • Culturals @ Shirui Fest #3: Gallery
  • Banana Festival @ Noney #2 : Gallery
  • Air pollution rise what do common man do
  • Conversation with Prof Rajendra Kshetri
  • 'It is a unique experience to play polo here'
  • The great cosmic discovery - I
  • Make Delhi trip meaningful !
  • Confusing stand; confusing act
  • Manipur Polo International: Opening: Gallery
  • Kut : State level @Imphal #3: Gallery
  • Kalum Kai: House of worship of Zeliangrong
  • Christian virtues
  • Blame it on Farmers for Pollution
  • Title: Square one ? :: Poem
  • Bucket of cold water after a hot shower
  • Radio-tagged Amur falcon flies to Africa
  • Myanmar Air KBZ flight to Imphal: Gallery
  • Alert Rally @ Sagolband : Gallery
  • 50th International Film Festival
  • World Antibiotics Awareness Week (WAAW)
  • CAB : Indians are not foreigners
  • Dissolution of TSA Imphal Branch
  • Anti-corruption crusade at time of CAB
  • Gandhari (Dance Drama) #2 : Gallery
  • Epilogue to Nambul Nostalgia :: Poem
  • Hostile education system in Northeast
  • Stigma and mental illness
  • Paulallungmuan: 12 yr-old at Class X exam
  • 3 from Manipur named Unsung Heroes
  • Raids at Imphal, Aizawl, Gurgaon
  • Make sure that Sangai fest is successful
  • Laonii Festival, Poumai #2 : Gallery
  • Khamba Thoibi Museum #2 : Gallery
  • Enigma of Unique Histories
  • When God's people humble
  • The great cosmic discovery - V
  • TB prevention is no longer a choice..
  • Stakeholders to be consulted: Final pact
  • The unresolved crisis
  • IM leaders camping along India-Myanmar
  • Trekking to Dzukou Valley #3 : Gallery
  • Licypriya- SDG Ambassador Award: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2019 #5: Gallery
  • Whither Pangals ?
  • Licypriya Kangujam: SDG Ambassador
  • Blood Donation Camp at Benguluru
  • The Sun on the Western Horizon :: Poem
  • Rejoinder to NDPP [20 November]
  • Regarding resignation of NPF Youth Wing
  • Rider to be exempted from CAB: ILP
  • Truth, sincerity & commitment ...
  • CAB : Total Shutdown - Nov 19 : Gallery
  • CAB : Sit In Protest - Nov 19 : Gallery
  • Dr Sanajaoba (Dr KS Singh): Reminiscence
  • Career option in technical writing
  • What Mindset does Govt of Manipur have ?
  • 12 Members resigned from NPF
  • Where is the special clause in CAB?
  • Please understand CAB; future is at stake
  • CAB protest - Nov 18 : Gallery
  • Children's Day @CM Bungalow : Gallery
  • Why CAB is being opposed in North East
  • Meeteis' paradox
  • A Vision :: Poem
  • NE development: Lean on regional planning
  • Sand War- deadly war against mother Earth
  • From 'ahead of final pact' to CAB
  • Can Meitei, Naga & Kuki jointly resist CAB?
  • Mera Houchongba @Kangla #4: Gallery
  • Ningol Chakouba Fish Fair #2: Gallery
  • History - from Obscurity to Visibility ?
  • Manipur State Journalist Awards, 2019
  • Was it a Hindu Day in Assam book season
  • Kerala's multi-layered approach to #endTB
  • Being vegetarian can fight climate change
  • Let the rivers flow uninterrupted
  • Cry of a Dying River : 100 Poems
  • MANITEX & the poor fate of weavers
  • Anecdote, Fable & Refugee Blues : Poem
  • What is pollution doing to your skin
  • Dispensation in Nagaland is rudderless
  • Resistance to CAB may fail
  • Culturals @ Shirui Fest #2: Gallery
  • Gender, Power in South Asia :: Book Rvw
  • Stop Burning of Hay- uplift Rural Economy
  • Disoriented mind :: Poem
  • What is all about a flag ?
  • Cannabis plant : Myths and facts
  • Need to be on guard against rumours
  • Smart city or smart earning...
  • Ningol Chakouba @ Pune : Gallery
  • Khumang: Conference- Science for Society
  • 7th NE Students Sports Meet at Jalandhar
  • Ningol Chakouba at Pune :: Report
  • Hospitality at One Horn Nation
  • Henjunaha , masculinity redefined
  • World Diabetes Day 2019
  • Tension filled days for over 2 weeks
  • Subdued voice
  • Rani Hingchabi :: Funga Wari
  • Miss Kut @Imphal #3 : Gallery
  • Rejoinder to Lamcha Chongloi's piece
  • Salt brines : Source of Meitei Thum
  • Hibernating animals and climate variable
  • Combined Defence Services Exam (I) 2020
  • Rare good news : NMA reaching out
  • Forgotten pledge - a reminder
  • Children from Noney #1: Gallery
  • 7 NE entrepreneurs wins National Awards
  • Identity of Pangal in Manipur: Counter-points
  • Recharging the World with Li-ion Battery
  • Achoubi in Love, Bloody Phanek : Southasia
  • When the man is silent :: Poem
  • Chekshin Meepham at Kakching
  • Arrested, released, 'escorted' to Delhi
  • CM has every reason to believe..not public
  • Ema Keithel (Khwairamband) #2: Gallery
  • Argentina hosts Manipur Cup (Polo)
  • Cry of a Dying River - 100 :: Poem
  • Nazareth @ Shirock #2 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba : A beautiful tradition
  • Thanga Ningol to mapam #2 : Gallery
  • Lungpuiga Remei : Natyabhusan
  • World Tourism Day @Noney #5 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Korea : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Mysore #2 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakouba & Kut at Korea
  • Ningol Chakkouba by Journalists : Gallery
  • Ningol to her mapam lamdam : Gallery
  • Tolloi, Ukhrul :: 360 Panorama View
  • SPONSORED ADS