TODAY -

Dry Manipur still Wet and 'High'
- Are we losing out on liquor prohibition ?

Ngangom Junior Luwang *



The latest report by the National Family Health Survey-5 (NFHS-5), 2019-21 on liquor is distressing in as much as the otherwise dry Manipur is found still high and infamously the fourth most "drunk" State (Andaman & Nicobar Island being a Union Territory )!

Instead of living with the duplicity of being "officially prohibited" but still with one of the highest figure of drinkers in India, it's high time to face the reality and lift prohibition in Manipur.

Unfortunately, we do have enough CSOs living with the illusion and moral high ground of 'prohibition', but still complaining about untimely Government salaries without bothering about the possible source of revenue for the State exchequer.

It is a matter of record that Manipur has complete prohibition since 1991 (though relaxed in 2002 in five hill districts), but the ground reality is best illustrated by naughty winks of many once evening sets in, mass availability of official "army", non-army and local liquor versions in increasingly mushrooming liquor vendors in every nook and corner, cases of death on account of spurious liquor including 5 fatalities in September, 2017 etc. Seemingly, the whole load of genuine liquor in Manipur is supplied by the army, which itself needs an investigation !

True but very sad for drinkers, there is no Fundamental Right to drink or carry on trade or commerce on alcoholic products under Part-III or any other part, Article, Clause, proviso, coma, semicolon of the Indian Constitution, as confirmed by a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court of India in Khoday Distilleries vs. State of Karnataka (1995) 1 SCC 574.

On the contrary, Article 47 of the Constitution casts a Part-IV (non-binding) obligation on Governments to "bring about prohibition of the consumption except for medicinal purposes".

Legal position notwithstanding, the following issues arise:

1. Has Liquor prohibition failed in Manipur ?

The latest report by the National Family Health Survey-5 (NFHS-5), 2019-21 is a clear indictment of unquestionable liquor prohibition failure in Manipur. The impracticability of total prohibition in Manipur is highlighted by the factum of the almost "cottage industry" status of liquor brewing, livelihood and cultural ethos of many communities in Manipur.

If liquor consumption is only getting worse despite more than 30 years of prohibition, the only inevitable conclusion is that prohibition has miserably failed. The best course forward will be to allow its sale through tax-paying and guarded licensed outlets, just as we used to see pre-1991. Just as the saying goes, if something cannot be prevented, regulate it and derive optimum benefits and fill the State coffers.

Prohibition as a policy has failed throughout human history – be it Xia Dynasty (ca. 2070 BC–ca. 1600 BC) in China, Hammurabi's (ca.1772 BCE) ban on sale of beer for money, Canada during 1907 to 1948 (Prince Edward Island), Russian Empire and Soviet Union during 1914 to 1925, Iceland during 1915 to 1933, Norway during 1916 to 1927, Finland during 1919 to 1932, Untied States during 1920 to 1933 etc.

The story is more or less the same in India. Haryana, Andhra Pradesh and Bihar had to junk prohibition. The Gujarat model of prohibition since 1960 is reportedly not a success as local brew continues to be available in abundance (not to discount other forms of liquor flowing in from other States). In Bombay, it gave rise to the Bombay underworld and eventually figures like Haji Mastan, Karim Lala, Dawood Ibrahim etc. Even in the USA, prohibition did not reduce alcohol consumption but gave birth, inter alia, to the Italian Mafia and bootlegging.

Though Manipur and Nagaland have been dry since 1991 and 1989 respectively, we do not see any step to curb local brew production, with good friend Assam standing like a rock for steady flow of other forms of liquor, just as UP and Bengal have stood by Bihar in "these very difficult times" for drinkers.

While we have read of brave police raids and seizure of alcoholic products from hotels, small shops, restaurants etc., we also know it equally well that some habitations are left scot free lest raiding such places is perceived as interference with local traditions and customs. Similarly, for the Koli population in the coastal districts of Gujarat, liquor is a staple and they brew it locally and there is nothing much the Government can do. Given this position, it could perhaps be in public interest to legalize local brew, allowing its production, subject, of course, to standard quality benchmarks and safety standards.

2. Would liquor consumption spike if prohibition is lifted ?

With so much abundance of army, non-army, local versions of liquor availability in every nook and corner of Manipur, we can safely infer that those who have to drink are drinking and teetotalers may not necessarily drink just because of official availability of regulated, branded bottles.

Our people to get more practical and help the Government with more revenue flows instead, while ensuring standardized drinks, without exposing many to urea- inflicted liquor brands and other unofficial versions of known brands.

3. Revenue Flow to the Government

The most important benefit of lifting prohibition will be substantial revenue flow to the State exchequer. Imagine the amount of revenue from sale of alcoholic products in different States for 2015-2016 (as per figures released by State Excise Departments).

For Tamil Nadu, it was Rs 29,672 crore, Haryana – Rs 19,703 crore, Maharashtra – Rs 18,000 crore, Karnataka – Rs 15,332 crore, Uttar Pradesh –Rs 14,083 crore, Andhra Pradesh – Rs 12,739 crore, Telengana – Rs 12,144 crore, Madhya Pradesh – Rs 7,926 crore, Rajasthan – Rs 5,585 crore, Punjab – Rs 5,000 crore etc. Excise duty on alcohol is the third-largest source of a State's own tax revenue (on an average), with an estimated contribution of 12.5 per cent in 2019-20.

States' budget data published by the RBI in its annual publication titled "State Finances: A Study of Budgets" show that the excise duty on sale of alcohol at the all India level for 2019-20 was estimated at Rs 1,75,501.42 crore (Rs 1.75 lakh crore), while estimating States' own tax revenues for the year at Rs. 14,09,325.33 crore (Rs 14.09 lakh crore).

Now, we know how much so-called dry States like Gujarat, Nagaland, Manipur etc. are losing out on such an important revenue stream ! When it comes to Gujarat, it will grow with or without prohibition because of its topographical and demographic reasons!

4. Public Health Hazard

Incidents of death on account of adulterated alcoholic drinks can be better controlled through regulated manufacture and sale of alcohol. With prohibition, what was once legally consumed still continued to be consumed but unlawfully, encouraging bootlegging, liquor mafias, spurious liquor consumption and a corrupt police.

It was in September, 2017 that 5 people died in Manipur after consuming spurious local brew. 2009 alone saw Gujarat with one of the worst hooch tragedies, which claimed 136 lives in Ahmedabad; hundreds of similar incidents have also been reported in other States.

Prohibition is arguably nothing but political posturing targeted at womenfolk as vote-banks and possibly at teetotalers for arguably giving them a false moral high. Prohibition has never worked as effectively as it is intended to; it only criminalizes sale and consumption of alcoholic products with serious consequences for State economy, public health and people's livelihood.

Now that, the present political dispensation is well placed and can afford to take drastic steps in the very beginning of its second term (just as the case of 2016 demonetization, howsoever controversial, in the middle of Modi's first term).

If at all lifting prohibition is unpopular in the beginning, the negative narrative, if any, would expectedly filter away when the next election comes ! Time to focus on war on drugs, not on liquor for both are incomparable in any sense of the term and on any benchmark whatsoever !


* Ngangom Junior Luwang wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer is an Advocate at Supreme Court and Corporate Lawyer
This article was webcasted on May 23 2022.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • ILP Check point at Jiri : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 27 June : Govt of Manipur
  • The untold story, lest it be forgotten
  • Assistance to victims of Assam Flood
  • A glimpse of 'Yangna Paikhredako Punshi'
  • Market innovations in developing country
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Anti-drug day expose state pathetic situation
  • The wedge amongst the Nagas
  • Coming of Manipur University in 1980
  • COVID-19 Status 26 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Laitonjam Lanchenba: Best Swimmer
  • Our capital Imphal - the city of sanity
  • Workshop : ND & PS Act, 1985
  • Mara Prabhu - Lord of the trees
  • Essence of international anti-drug day
  • July 1 : Taking the fight to plastic
  • Miss Shirui Lily 2022 #3 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 25 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Flesh Trade : Connection between Goa & NE
  • Importance of Soil Testing & Management
  • ST status Vs Classical language for Meetei
  • Life, faith and belief
  • MANISFA General Secretary appointed
  • Flood Watch : 23rd June #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 24 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Community led in ensuring HIV treatment
  • Approach to ideology & development
  • Solar Energy solution for healthcare facility
  • Yoga for health, beauty and immunity
  • Innovation Prize Launched for Designers
  • Knotty higher education sector
  • Classical language status and ST demand
  • Flood Watch : 23rd June #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 23 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Birds and Bees Talk launched 3rd phase
  • Luck matters, Rio's first entry into cabinet...
  • Need to deal with dumping of waste materials
  • Training on mushroom at Nagamapal
  • 1961 as base year: Take it or leave it
  • 10 years too late : JCILPS
  • Phamnaiba Jagoi @ Thangjing : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 22 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Women's cleanliness enjoys equal rights...
  • Life in some hill villages
  • The MCI Restoration II
  • 'BRO Cafes' on 75 border roads
  • Protest over boundary row headache for Govt
  • Issues on the indigenous question
  • Drug Menace In Manipur : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 21 June : Govt of Manipur
  • ST tag for Meiteis - A perspective!
  • Manipur State Welfare : Politics 1-0 Citizens
  • International Yoga Day at Assam Rifles
  • International Yoga Day at IBSD Imphal
  • International Yoga Day at NSU Imphal
  • Manipur Lokyukta: Fighting against corruption
  • Vision to distribute local rice under NFSA...
  • Taking the fight to the drug menace
  • Landslides - Imphal-Jiri [Jun 17] : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 20 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Thangjing in folklore of Koireng tribe
  • Health Workshop on Diabetes at Pune
  • Everyone is a thief :: Poem
  • E- barton for CM & Governor
  • Intensive cultivation of vegetables
  • High time to encourage e-vehicle operators
  • Scripting success story with Rs 500
  • Leima Jagoi by Transgender #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 19 June : Govt of Manipur
  • June 19 2022 : Father's Day message
  • Nine Hills One Valley : Ottawa Film Fest
  • Shirui Lily Festival or mud festival ?
  • Yoga for Women organised
  • Flight link to Mandalay dream come true
  • Action of Govt needs to be backed
  • 21st Great June Uprising #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 18 June : Govt of Manipur
  • The Great June 18 Uprising :: News Timeline
  • Revive environmentalism in Meetei ethos
  • COVID-19 Status 17 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Elephant army of Lord Guruvayurappan
  • Who will be next at Rashtrapati Bhawan
  • Hiyang Tannaba @ Loktak #1 : Gallery
  • Freedom movement against British #2
  • Inequity and health security
  • Donating blood is an act of solidarity
  • Unregulated deposit schemes & BUDS Act
  • Extension of entry age : Agnipath
  • Citizens feeding on adulterated food items
  • Of food safety and street vendors
  • Pooja Elangbam, IAS, 81st ranker in AICS
  • COVID-19 Status 16 June : Govt of Manipur
  • NE Model @Delhi Kids Fest : Gallery
  • Manipur Rajkunja
  • Effective Legal Aid to Women Prisoner
  • How to avoid cracked heel during hot summer
  • Aid to artisan must to promote local product
  • Education for whom ?
  • Kabui Dance @Nongshaba Haraoba : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 15 June : Govt of Manipur
  • 'Let's Talk About It' : music album
  • Significance of World Environment Day
  • The MCI Restoration
  • North East CSR Award 2022
  • Prolonged sitting or standing spoils your leg
  • State fast-tracking towards drug making hub
  • 'Progression' from smuggling to manufacturing
  • Bonny Elangbam : Longest distance covered
  • COVID-19 Status 14 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Interaction with Makakmayum Hosni Mubarak
  • India to become $5 trillion economy
  • Exploring traditional medicines of NE
  • Freefall of the kids after COVID-19
  • Honour the tax payers, expose defaulters
  • NE needs more than 'unprecedented'
  • Miss Shirui Lily 2022 #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 13 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Water management in paddy cultivation
  • PM Modi hails Nagaland Gaon Burahs
  • Blight of Nature :: Poem
  • Moreh as Las Vegas
  • NHIDCL's reputation at stake
  • Drugs, poppy & 'alternatives'
  • Thaopai Shithaine of Poumai #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 12 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Jadonang Park, Tamenglong :: Gallery
  • Freedom movement against British #1
  • Multi-Tasking Staff at Leima Traders
  • Toning down rhetoric that hurts religion
  • Shirui Lily fest brings to fore plastic menace
  • Conservation of pony & grazing fields
  • Kakwa Lairembi Haraoba #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 11 June : Govt of Manipur
  • The unheeded cry of children in labour
  • Why present distribution of urea fails?
  • World Day Against Child Labour 2022
  • Sunrise on the Civil Aviation Horizon
  • Arambam Samarendra Ningshingba :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 10 June : Govt of Manipur
  • NE Ex-Super Model at Delhi Kids Fest
  • What Diphu has, Dimapur & Kohima don't
  • Towards Manipur Budget 2022-23 ...
  • NE Social & Behaviour Change inaugurated
  • Fighting corruption remains an uphill task
  • Environment needs more than tree plantation
  • SN Chand: The father of Manipuri cinema #3
  • COVID-19 Status 09 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Degree Certificate for Survival #2
  • Value chain management of Umorok
  • Pulses for Nutrition Security in Manipur
  • Keeping your skin oil free during summer
  • Demand for impartial probe into IMC scam
  • Politics of isolating the NSCN (IM)
  • Raas @Manipur Rajbari, W Bengal :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 08 June : Govt of Manipur
  • A rare book on Birds of Manipur
  • Condemns bomb blast in Manipur
  • Market Innovations made America great #2
  • Jal Jeevan Mission : PHED Manipur
  • Disturbing data on lifestyle diseases in state
  • Tough talk against drug menace
  • Trekking to Shirui Peak, Ukhrul #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 07 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Take a leaf from sunderban if you're serious
  • Testimony of brother Ninghor Mahongnao
  • Local leaders unitedly push for One Health
  • Letters from the Republic of Dust #2
  • Soil testing for better crop production
  • Despicable threat to school
  • Outrage at Little Flower School
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Lam Thokpa #3 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 06 June : Govt of Manipur
  • India-Taiwan Global Bamboo Tech Forum
  • Condemns bomb attack at LFS
  • RSS chief sounds logical
  • Career options in Environmental Science
  • We reap what we sow
  • NRC in focus as keyboard warriors spar...
  • Coming together of COCOMI, UNC
  • HSE Result 2022 : Statistiscal Abstract
  • HSE Result 2022 : Subject Pass Percentage
  • HSE Result 2022 : District-Wise Pass %
  • HSE Result 2022 :Science Topper
  • HSE Result 2022 : Arts Topper
  • HSE Result 2022 : Commerce Topper
  • HSE Result 2022 : Science Stream Result
  • HSE Result 2022 : Arts Stream Result
  • HSE Result 2022 : Commerce Stream Result
  • COVID-19 Status 05 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Nagaland: Is it fair to blame Indrajit Gupta ?
  • 4th Plenary Session of WMC at Sugnu
  • World Environment Day at Tamenglong
  • World Environment Day at Lilong
  • World Environment Day at Haraorou
  • Musing :: Poem
  • Yet another World Environment Day observed
  • Mounting pressure for solution
  • Padmashree Award Moirangthem Muktamani
  • COVID-19 Status 04 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Congested road at Shirui Village :: Gallery
  • Degree Certificate for Survival #1
  • Admission for National Sports University
  • World Environment Day at Imphal
  • Include Meeteis in the ST list
  • Inhumane act of De-addiction centres
  • UK band Monuments @ShiRock #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 03 June : Govt of Manipur
  • 'Provocation' charges arrests on social media
  • Gerinda Loitongbam: Natl Women Award
  • Timeless Memories :: Poem
  • Ket Meth releases music video Trauma'
  • 8 years of Modi Govt: More hits than misses
  • Bad example commanders
  • Posers parents may raise within
  • Miss Shirui Lily 2022 #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 02 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Letters from the Republic of Dust #1
  • Workshop on Food Processing at Lilong
  • 1st June is the Global Day of Parents
  • 'Developing human resource in Manipur'
  • Swachh Bharat Mission (Grameen)
  • 'Yoga for personality development' orgd
  • Row over boundary fencing project
  • Brain storming session of the Congress
  • Lunghar (Imp-Kohima / Jessami) #3 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 01 June : Govt of Manipur
  • Delphi Oinam : Topper at Nagaland HSLC
  • Teaching at Churachandpur Govt College
  • Jadonang Park at Tamenglong renovated
  • Quality seed production of rice (HYV)
  • Audiobook for NEET aspirants launched
  • Naga issue: From bush war to shadow boxing
  • Tenants in Nagaland tag on the NSCN (IM)
  • Wakhom Leikai Lairembi Haraoba #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 31 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Pageant winners showcase Robert's collection
  • MIFF to pay homage to Irom Maipak
  • Awareness on Legal rights of women prisoner
  • Election petitions galore in Manipur
  • Training program on mushroom at Nagamapal
  • Must expedite process for border projects
  • Wanted : A far sighted leader
  • Naga Indigenous Wrestling :: Gallery
  • June Calendar for Year 2022 : Tools
  • UK band Monuments @ShiRock #1 :: Gallery
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Lam Thokpa #2 :: Gallery
  • SN Chand: The father of Manipuri cinema #2
  • Licypriya speech at East Timor :: Gallery
  • On 200th Anniversary of MK Binodini Devi
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2022 #2: Gallery
  • Harvesting Fest of Tarao #4 :: Gallery
  • Id-ul-Fitr @Hatta Golapati :: Gallery
  • Rules of English Pronunciation : Download
  • Sub-Syllables in English : Book Download