TODAY -

The Politics of Scheduled Tribe Status in Manipur

Dr. Thongkholal Haokip *

Chagah Festival : Annual festival of Liangmai community celebrated at Taphou Liangmai village, Senapati :: Oct 30, 2012
Chagah Festival of Liangmai community at Taphou Liangmai village, Senapati in Oct, 2012 :: Pix - Popcha Yambem



Since independence the Indian government has categorised certain historically-disadvantaged communities into Scheduled Tribe (ST), Scheduled Caste (SC) and Other Backward Class (OBC). These categorisations were intended to bring advancement of such socially and economically backward people through special provisions of affirmative discrimination and thereby reduce the gap of socio-economic disparity with the more affluent communities. It is through the constitutional protective arrangement, affirmative action and provision of resources and benefits that the government intends to lift up such groups of people.

India's tribal policy

The term "tribal" is used in administrative sense to denote STs in India. The categorisation of certain communities as 'tribal' or 'indigenous peoples' by the Indian government is primarily based on their lived experiences of marginality and vulnerability in relation to their historical dependence on land and forest resources. They are minority in most of the states they reside, even though some of them later become a dominant group in certain states due to their political demands and the subsequent creation of news states.

India has a clear tribal policy which was formulated by the first Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru in 1959. This is known as 'Panch Sheel' or five cardinal principles concerning the Government's attitude towards the tribals. This policy sought the protection of tribal rights in land and forests, non-interference of outsiders into tribal territory, their social and cultural institutions, and administration. It specifically denounced imposing of anything on them.

The Constitution specified 7.5 percent of vacancies in public sector and government-aided educational institutions as a quota reserved for the ST candidates. It was decided that this reservation system would be reviewed after a period of ten years, and the system has been extended every ten years for the past 60 years.

This percentage of reservation is still well below their population percentage of 8.1. In due course of time, apart from some groups who were newly given ST status, certain communities categorised as SCs were also later put into the ST category leading to a drastic increase in the number of ST population. However, the percentage of ST reservation has not been increased appropriately in proportion to the increase in ST population.

ST status for Meiteis

In the Northeastern state of Manipur the Scheduled Tribe Demand Committee of Manipur Valley (STDCMV) has been demanding ST status for the Meiteis since the latter part of 2012. Within a year the STDCMV was assured by the Indian Prime Minister, as reported in some Imphal dailies, for examining the demand provided the Manipur state cabinet takes a decision in favour of the committee's demand. There has never been such a hasty decision taken by the central government on any contentious demand made in the Northeastern region. This led to a series of protests by the hill tribes of Manipur in the form of press releases and threatening more intensive protests.

The STDCMV argued that the Meiteis Mongoloid physical features and the practice of animism (Sanamahi faith) by most of the population fulfill the criteria of being categorised as ST. It blamed the government of India for the present rift and misunderstanding between the hills and valley people, which is the result of the recognition of hills people as tribes by the Constitution of India in 1950, and the Meiteis as general category, emphasising the nonexistence of such atmosphere before Indian independence. They also emphasised the need to protect their endangered culture and identity by way of being recognised as ST.

The hills perspective

To the tribes of Manipur the main reason, as evident from their press releases, for the Meiteis seeking ST status is to avail the opportunity of reservation in jobs. However, when this apprehension is carefully examined, it can be found that the weaker sections of the Meiteis have already been given the SC and OBC statuses. If all sections of Meiteis need further reservations, they can either be club into SC or OBC. There is no logic when they enjoy the SC and OBC statuses which have more reservations for jobs in public sector and in educational institutions than ST, will seek for ST status. The Meiteis are dominant group controlling the state and its apparatuses. The state has been protecting their cultural, political, and economic rights, and they do not need ST status to protect their culture and identity.

When delved into this demand there are tacit objectives behind this. The hills-valley divide is so deep that it is almost disintegrating the state of Manipur. To the STDCMV, if ST status is given to the Meiteis the wedge between the hills and valley people could be reduced and the integrity of the state can be preserved.

For many decades the Meiteis, through the instrument of their dominated state legislative assembly, have been attempting to remove the restriction imposed on the Meiteis in purchasing lands in the hills without any success. The ST status to Meiteis will automatically remove this restriction and therefore be able to grab the lands in the hills with their sheer purchasing power. Through this they can expand their occupied territory beyond Imphal valley. This status will also exempt the whole valley from paying income tax.

To the hill tribal people of Manipur the demand for ST status by STDCMV is a ploy to attenuate the fervent political demands of the Kukis and Nagas, as well as a tacit strategy of the dominant valley dwellers to make inroads into the hill areas of the state.

The way out

Contemporary Manipur is filled with demands and counter-demands, protests and anti-protests, and bandhs and counter-bandhs. The three communities are intractably interwoven over different issues. What needs to be done is to pay attention into the apprehensions and misunderstanding among the state's people. Here arises the management of diversity. This key-issue has to be handled carefully by the state government. The best policy is to carefully and seriously manage this looming apprehension and misunderstanding among the people.


* Dr. Thongkholal Haokip wrote this article for Hueiyen Lanpao and for The Sangai Express
The writer is Assistant Professor of Political Science at the Presidency University, Kolkata
This article was posted on August 28, 2013.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Protesters & SF @Kwakta #2: Gallery
  • Violence in Manipur 2023 :: News Timeline
  • Marina by Night
  • Seminar at "Oriental Theological College"
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • Vote for me or my wife
  • Sohra International Half Marathon
  • State failure vis-a-vis ethnic cleansing
  • The blockade on the road to peace
  • World Bamboo Day @Patsoi #1: Gallery
  • The Meitei Nupi :: Poem
  • Traumatic experiences: Kuki-Meitei clash #1
  • Tifo unveiled during NE United game
  • Sign languages as Career
  • Torbung on May 3: Where it all started
  • The danger of Zalengam dream
  • The descent of Radha-Krishna #6: Download
  • Conflict in Manipur: Summary of issues
  • Chronological report on Manipur violence #5
  • Get to know more about Canine Distemper
  • The Power of Poppy - 3 :: Poem
  • Why Is Manipur Burning ?
  • Condemns Biased UN Side Event
  • Inpui Baptist Church celebrated Decadal
  • When the public relations fail #2
  • A decade for youth to make India #1
  • Tell the story to the outside world
  • Misleading the House of Commons
  • 'Laangban Chara Tamba' #2: Gallery
  • Village Volunteers: Protectors of the Nation
  • World Bamboo Day Painting Comp. results
  • Voluntary Blood Donation Camp
  • Improved potato varieties suited to Manipur
  • Autumn hair care: Tips for healthier hair
  • Manipur cannot go on like this
  • Shifting the theatre of war to Geneva
  • 1958: Kuki Chiefs' Memo to Union HM
  • Never too early never too late
  • Celebrities' approaches to Mental Health
  • International Day of Peace
  • Litter box training for cats
  • Trek leaders training programme
  • An indifferent Delhi
  • A good move with bad intention
  • Protesters & AR @Pallel #2: Gallery
  • Before the inflection point in our society !
  • Whither Naga Peace? Spl session of Parl
  • Lumpy Skin Disease
  • In total chaos since May 3 evening
  • Clutching at straws by drowning man
  • Winter Relief @ Mayang Imphal : Gallery
  • World Bamboo Day at Chandigarh
  • Will leaders walk the talk to end TB at UN
  • When the public relations fail #1
  • Chronological report on Manipur violence #4
  • Reimpose AFSPA call
  • Lesson to be learnt from SAFF boys
  • Breaches of International Humanitarian Law
  • Do we have a Government!
  • 'Birthday boy' glows, critics wonder...
  • Two Murals from Two Corners
  • Sir, a birthday treat for us
  • 'Laangban Chara Tamba' #1: Gallery
  • Student Council: Pillars of Governance
  • World Ozone Day observed at Imphal
  • Col N Hemachandra: Brigadier in Army
  • The Power of Poppy - 2 :: Poem
  • Manipur Crisis: You can bring Delhi to Imphal
  • Manipuri Kokyet finds space in Parliament
  • Relief materials at Moirang, Thoubal
  • Armed Forces' role in Manipur under scrutiny
  • India elevated G20 as 'premier forum'
  • 'Solution first, peace later' slogan
  • Hoping against hope
  • Candle light vigil @ Kangla #2: Gallery
  • DMCC met Defence Minister Rajnath Singh
  • The existential crisis - The Reality
  • Seriousness of legal proceedings
  • Role of Governor in summoning Assembly #2
  • One-sided reports vis-a-vis Manipur crisis
  • Death of a Sub-inspector
  • Raja Dumbragi Jeevan Charitra : Download
  • Dr Marjit: Academic Award at Malaysia
  • Interreligious Appeal to end violence
  • Gurkha War & diaspora in Manipur #3
  • Manipur Special Youth Assembly Session
  • From new districts to separate State
  • Looking for ally, desperately
  • Protesters & SF @Kwakta #1: Gallery
  • An Open Letter to President Joe Biden
  • Elephants in a Seed
  • Switzerland of India become a love lost State
  • Restoration of mining affected areas
  • Why did Army invite EGI : CJI
  • EGI invited by Army for objective assessment!
  • Note on Kuki-Hmar Trouble [1960]
  • Sober Thoughts
  • Weaving Looms presented at Relief Camp
  • A compassionate relief & cash payment
  • Sisters and brothers :: Poem
  • Coming to the negotiating table
  • The way forward
  • Protesters & AR @Pallel #1: Gallery
  • Romi Meitei : Best director @Kazan film fest
  • Success of Rahmani30 in Manipur NEET-UG
  • Modi, Biren, Shah exposes tragic series
  • Bharat is older than India
  • Mega Health Camp & Skill Development
  • Demand for ST tag by Meiteis
  • Internationalising the Kuki-Meitei conflict
  • The descent of Radha-Krishna #5: Download
  • Creating Hope Through Action
  • Ningthoujam Binoy: National Teachers' Award
  • The Power of Poppy - 1 :: Poem
  • Role of Governor in summoning Assembly #1
  • Gurkha War & diaspora in Manipur #2
  • Darkest Era of Meiteis
  • Robert Memorial Internship Awarded
  • Churachandpur Meiteis at the crossroads
  • Chronological report on Manipur violence #3
  • Meeting of Meitei Club, Burari
  • G20 call to action in agriculture
  • Silent on the remains at CCpur
  • The resolution to unite all CSOs
  • Rebuttal: EGI Fact-finding Mission Report
  • S Tiken (Thang-Ta) Fellowhsip Award
  • Manipuri or Meitei ?
  • Relief Distribution at Wakhong Pukao
  • Human-centric globalisation : Taking G20
  • Cancer Screening at SP Office, Imphal
  • Doing a disservice to Kuki-Chin cause
  • Epidemic threat at relief centres
  • The Chothes of Manipur
  • Communalism; A Dangerous Ism
  • Condemns the incident at Chalwa
  • Unity - need of the hour
  • International Day of Police Cooperation
  • 5,000 Scholarships for 1st year undergrad
  • Classic case of victimising the victims
  • 11 years in service and raring to go
  • Relief Work - August 2023 : Gallery
  • Krishna Leela
  • Gurkha War & diaspora in Manipur #1
  • Cancer Awareness at Imphal East
  • Training on cultivation of mushroom
  • Illegal immigrants & Manipur violence
  • Missing fact in EGI's fact-finding report
  • Is govt inviting a 3rd Nupi Lal ?
  • The Chieftaindom of Kukis
  • The role of teachers in society
  • Condolence Message
  • Framework for the future of work
  • Understanding Manipur crisis in four days!
  • The case of 'Meitei media'
  • List of Kings of Manipur: 33 - 1984 AD
  • Chronological report on Manipur violence #2
  • Winter Relief Services commenced
  • Special Session of Parliament
  • Advantage of simultaneous election in India
  • Fake Finding Committee ?
  • Poisoning the mind of Kuki-Chin people
  • Raja Dumbragi Jeevan Charitra #4 : Book
  • Organic links between C3C & Manipur conflict
  • Entrepreneur set to introduce first Tea Wine
  • Remedies to reduce hair growth on upper lip
  • Rally against Narco-Terrorism #3 : Gallery
  • On ethnic Nationalism & exclusive domains
  • Stay vigilant on Employment Offers
  • Waterways development in NE India
  • Condemn accusations on Pangal
  • Violence doesn't bring lasting solution #2
  • Feeding lies and more lies
  • Blame it on CSOs
  • Climate Change & flawed solution in Manipur
  • 92th Martyrdom Day of Haipou Jadonang
  • Change the minds, Peace is possible anytime
  • Who is running Nagaland Govt ?
  • Chronological report on Manipur violence #1
  • Manipur Distress Relief Work : August
  • Playing heroes on social media
  • Yes, it's time for a public assembly
  • Haipou Jadonang Martyrdom Day
  • September Calendar for Year 2023 : Tools
  • Statement of Thadou Students' Assn
  • Land of jewel trapped under conspiracies #4
  • Health Awareness Programme at MU
  • Manipur- 13 medals at Junior National Judo
  • Where have the guns come from ?
  • The curious case of 10 Kuki MLAs
  • Candle light vigil @ Kangla #1: Gallery
  • Restoring peace - The talk of the town
  • National Sports Day 2023
  • Rethinking caste-based reservations in India
  • Why computer studies is gaining popularity
  • Cold bucket of water after a hot shower
  • Committing a crime to avoid a crisis
  • Raja Dumbragi Jeevan Charitra #3 : Book
  • 19th Asian Games: 43 Manipuri athletes
  • Relationship of Manipur & Tai kingdom #3
  • Violence doesn't bring lasting solution #1
  • Bangladesh's aid to Myanmar
  • Does 'separate State' agenda drive violence?
  • Is the Chief Minister lying?
  • Hunger Marchers' Day
  • Sudden strike & the knotty quagmire
  • Moon, Bharatnaut and ShivShakti
  • Even Rocket Science is doable
  • Tales from relief camps
  • All in a day's session
  • Manipur in History: Reflection...
  • Langonjam Birmangal: Manipuri literature #2
  • Onam Fever (Festival of Kerala)
  • Cancer Awareness Program at Khongman
  • Manipuri film @ National Film Award
  • Huidrom Oliviya: bronze at World Cadet Judo
  • Patriots' Day @ Kangla: Gallery
  • Congratulations to Dr Raghu Ningthoujam
  • Scientist Raghu Ningthoujam leads team
  • Intractable Framework Agreement of IM
  • Protesters with Army [Aug 03] #3 : Gallery
  • Indigenous Wrestling @ Purul : Gallery
  • Patriots' Day @ Thangal Temple: Gallery
  • Maram folklore & Meitei connection
  • >
  • 'Remove Assam Rifles' [Aug 07] #2 : Gallery
  • Raja Dumbragi Jeevan Charitra #1 : Book
  • Patriots' Day @ Hicham Yaicham : Gallery
  • Model of Spelling-bee Competition
  • Patriots' Day @ New Delhi : Gallery
  • Protest against AR [9 Aug] : Gallery
  • Taionaba Taibang Gi Akanba Nongju
  • Protesters with Army [Aug 03] #2 : Gallery
  • Nang-eigi Pangal Sonbi Emado
  • 'Remove Assam Rifles' [Aug 07] #1 : Gallery
  • Rally against Narco-Terrorism #1 : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2023 #3: Gallery
  • HSLC 2023 :: Top 25 Rank Holders
  • HSLC 2023 :: Subject Topper
  • HSLC 2023 :: Full Result
  • HSLC 2023 :: Compartmental Result
  • HSLC 2023 :: Pass % : Govt Schools
  • HSLC 2023 :: Pass % : Private Schools
  • HSLC 2023 :: Pass % : Aided Schools
  • HSE 2023 Toppers :: Science
  • HSE 2023 Toppers :: Arts
  • HSE 2023 Toppers :: Commerce
  • From May 3, 1993 to the present
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar for 2023