TODAY -

ST status demands in India : A brief overview
- Part 2 -

Sanjoy Akoijam *

 Sit-in protest for inclusion of Meitei in ST list at Kongba Keithel :: 03rd September 2022
Sit-in protest for inclusion of Meitei in ST list at Kongba Keithel on 03 September 2022 :: Pix - Shanker Khangembam



The six communities seeking ST status are currently enjoying either Other Backward Classes (OBC) or More Other Backward Classes (MOBC) status in Assam. Though, historically, most of them were ruling communities, they have been cornered in many ways in post-independence India and have remained backward.

For the Adivasis, some scholars have argued that a certain segment of population has remained at the very bottom of the social ladder, due to the constraints of the tea plantation economy and the inability of those outside tea gardens to take advantage of a development process that takes no account of their social and cultural 'backwardness'.

The issue of ST inclusion in Assam according to many scholars is a matter of 'political, not anthropological interest.' The biggest roadblock on the road towards ST status for the six communities seems to be a lack of consensus with the existing Scheduled Tribes of the State.

In Sikkim, eleven Nepali speaking communities have been seeking tribal status Gurung, Mangar, Rai, Sunwar, Mukhia, Majhi, Jogi, Thami, Yakha, Bahun, Chettri and Newar. The Gorkhas of the neighbouring Darjeeling hills in West Bengal, too, have been demanding ST status for eleven communities living in the area.

However, unlike in the Darjeeling Hills, the Sikkimese are demanding the tribal status on the basis Article 371F of the Constitution, which provides special status to the Himalayan State that merged with India in 1975.

The previous Sikkim Democratic Front Government and the present Sikkim Krantikari Morcha led Government in Sikkim have submitted a number of representations to the Centre on the issue, but there have been no concrete steps from the Central Government so far.

In January 2021, the Sikkim Government unanimously adopted a resolution to include the communities in the State's Scheduled Tribes list. The ruling BJP led Government at the Centre has also repeatedly assured that the ST demands by the communities in the Darjeeling Hills would be fulfilled.

In Maharashtra, the Dhangar is a community which practices shepherding as their traditional occupation, due to which most of the population lives a socially isolated life, wandering mainly in forests, hills and mountains.

Dhangar community is classified as a 'Vimukta Jati'-Nomadic Tribe (NT) in Maharashtra, and it comes under the OBC category of the Central level. However, the community is demanding the reservation under ST category. Since NT category is not recognised at the Central level, the community members feel that they have been deprived of reservation in Central Government services.

The ST category list includes "Dhangad" community at the Central level, while Dhangars with an 'r'- have been excluded. The community claims that the difference in spelling is a clerical mistake since there is no application from any community in Maharashtra claiming to belong to the Dhangad category. So, the community demands that the Government should amend the mistake by changing Dhangad to Dhangar.

They complain that "due to this typographic error, tribal Dhangar community is not getting any benefits since 1976". In the caste census of 1931, the British Government included Dhangar as a similar caste with Oran. In 1968, the Central Government published the biography of SC, ST and marginal tribes and it mentioned Dhangar (Dhangad) as a Scheduled Tribe.

The Mandal Commission also noted that Dhangar and Dhangad were the same. During the tenure of former Prime Minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, the Government included the Dhangar community in the Scheduled Tribe in Bihar, Jharkhand, and Odisha. The Maharashtra Government recommended to include the Dhangar community in the Scheduled Tribe in 1966 and 1979, but the Government for some reason took back the recommendation in 1981.

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) led by former Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis which came to power in 2014 promised to materialise their demands. At the end of 2015, the State asked the Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai (TISS) to establish whether the Dhangars met the criteria to be identified as ST.

In effect, this meant establishing whether 'Dhangars' were the same as 'Dhangads' to guard against any future legal challenge to Dhangars being moved from VJNT to ST. Over the past few years, almost all major political parties in the State have supported the inclusion of Dhangars in the ST category. Every political party, however, has found itself facing the prospect of dealing with people from Scheduled Tribes who are unwilling to allow the dilution of their quota by the inclusion of a big community like the Dhangar.

Maharashtra's most recent Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray had assured that his Government would take positive steps towards the economic development of the Dhangar community and consult legal experts and various stakeholders over the reservation demand. The Dhangars in the neighbouring State of Goa are also demanding ST status.

Moving to Tamil Nadu, the Narrikurovar is a semi-nomadic tribe who originated in Northern India before migrating south to the area about half a millennia ago. Traditionally hunters (Narrikurovar means "jackal" or "fox hunters"), their origin stories tell of their tribe being associated with upper castes, mostly providing security for kings.

However, once invaders took over the territories they inhabited, they became nomadic and retreated into forests. It has been seen that the community struggles with high levels of illiteracy, multiple health challenges, and unemployment. The Tamil Nadu Government classifies them as a Most Backward Class (MBC) community. This leads to erroneous assumptions about this population.

For example, in 2005, the percentage of STs below the poverty line in rural Tamil Nadu was 32.1 percent (below the national ST average of 47.3 percent), but that of rural Other Backward Classes (OBC) and others was only 19 percent.

Classifying the Narrikurovars as OBCs leads to the assumption that they have a higher chance of being above the poverty line than communities recognized as STs. Furthermore, by being classified as MBCs, the Narrikurovars have been competing for access to government benefits with nineteen other larger communities with higher socio-economic status and greater political clout.

Over the last three decades, the Narrikurovars have viewed themselves as "Adivasi" and have been attempting to gain ST status. Their precarious position is further complicated by their nomadic lifestyle across rural and urban areas which runs against the criteria of "geographical isolation" required for ST status.

Additionally, as the Narrikurovar sell their products to the community at large, they might not display "shyness of connect," which is another criteria. But since these criteria are not explicit, it becomes quite difficult for the community to formulate clear political demands.

The Narrikurovars have found it difficult to navigate this uncertain legal terrain and have been appealing to the principal Dravidian political parties, the DMK and AIADMK. Since 2013, the Narrikurovars have focused their efforts on grassroots political mobilization and have been organizing several sit-ins and hunger strikes.

This increased awareness of the precarious state of the community led to efforts by the central government to amend the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order of 1950 to include the Narrikurovar, Kurivikarran, and Malayelee Gounder among the STs. The bills were introduced in the Lok Sabha in December 2016, but till date there has been little progress in this regard. In March 2022, the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu MK Stalin appealed to the Prime Minister of India to grant the community's demand.

Then, there are the Kudmi-Mahato people of Central and eastern India. The tale of the Kudmi-Mahatos is one of paradox. The Kudmi-Mahatos were enlisted as a tribal community in census related documents in India before 1931. But back then, the community strived to attain a Hindu Kshatriya status.

There were several movements and attempts to cement their Kshatriya status, the establishment of the All India Kurmi Kshatriya Mahasabha (AIKKM) in 1894 being an example. The Kudmi-Mahatos also began using the spelling 'Kurmi' instead of 'Kudmi'. After the 1930s, the community was successful in de-scheduling themselves from the list of STs and getting themselves the Kshatriya Hindu status administratively.

It is believed that the community wanted to shed the tribal tag as the higher caste Hindus controlled a majority of natural resources back then. They performed ceremonies and rituals like higher caste Hindus and their agricultural activities were also performed according to the Hindu calendar and they also worshipped Hindu Gods and Goddesses. In short, one scholar remarked that they strived hard to "Kshtriyanise" into the upper categories of the Hindu caste hierarchy.

But now in the 21st century, the community is seeking a return to the ST list. The younger generations of this community are pointing out to a paradoxical issue of identity crisis. They want to be rescheduled in the ST list from which once their forefathers had de-scheduled themselves in order to become Kshatriya Hindus. With the passage of time and changing power relations, a large section of the community feel that they would be better off being STs. Movements for the same have been going on in the past few years in Jharkhand, Odisha and West Bengal.

The case of the Kudmi-Mahatos seems quite similar to that of the Meiteis. The Meiteis/Meeteis too were listed as a 'tribe' (under the name 'Manipuri') in several colonial era documents. Mention may be made of the Census of India 1891, Census of India 1901 and the Census of India 1931.

The 1931 Census mentions that the "Manipuris (Meiteis) are a wholly Hindu tribe, but retain their distinct language and culture." Many proponents of the Meitei ST Demand movement have stated that they are simply asking for a 'return' to the list of tribes in India, and not something brand new.

Recently, there have been news reports of demands for ST status by some communities in Jammu (in the UT of J&K) and Himachal Pradesh as well, coupled with opposition to the same by the existing ST communities in the area. Interestingly, Assembly elections are due in Himachal Pradesh later this year, and political activities have also picked up in Jammu.

A common observation in a majority of ST status demand movements is opposition from other communities who already 'enjoy' ST status, and the varying situations and ways of life of the communities demanding ST status. This puts the spotlight on the concept of 'tribe' in modern day India, a concept which is still ill-defined and ambiguous in nature.


* Sanjoy Akoijam wrote this article for The Sangai Express
This article was posted on September 28, 2022.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • 60th Mr Manipur Bodybuilding #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Poumai Dance :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Khulang Eshei :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 05 Dec : Govt of Manipur
  • Medicines that save us from STI
  • Taj Mahal - The white wonder
  • World Soil Day
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Oting killing: Protracted probe imminent
  • How many tourists visited during Sangai Fest
  • Sangai Day 1: Laihui Folk Music #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 04 Dec : Govt of Manipur
  • Aeromycology over Kachai lemon plantation #2
  • Fostering NE-Bangladesh ties through Assam
  • Medical camp at Khongsang
  • Brighten your winter face with pumpkin
  • Stray cattle menace & food self-sufficiency
  • Accusing fingers raised by PAPPM
  • Sangai Fest: Sayol Sangai Chatkoi :: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2022 #5: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 03 Dec : Govt of Manipur
  • International Day of Persons with Disabilities
  • The unseen masks men put on
  • Organic seed production- Issue & strategy #4
  • Christmas Carol Competition at Leimakhong
  • Sangai Fest: Thang Ta :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Chiru Dance :: Gallery
  • Sports sees no gender, Sports has no gender
  • COVID-19 Status 02 Dec : Govt of Manipur
  • RFYC Naupang League in Mizoram
  • MPSC is going ahead of UPSC
  • Session on Meditation & Mental Health
  • Challenges stacked up for Manipuri women
  • Antagonists of ST demand for Meiteis
  • Sangai Day 10: Closing #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 10: Crowd scene :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 01 Dec : Govt of Manipur
  • Will Thailand lead in antimicrobial resistance
  • Webninar @NEHU : India-Japan Relations
  • Keeping up with time :: Poem
  • World AIDS Day 2022 at Tamenglong
  • Doctor-Govt stalemate, public in peril
  • Progress of the Naga peace talk
  • Sangai Day 9: Dancing Drummers :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2: Aimol Dance :: Gallery
  • December Calendar for Year 2022 : Tools
  • COVID-19 Status 30 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • A flight of the Hornbill
  • Working with children as career
  • Stable situation essential for attracting tourist
  • Selling Manipur to outside world
  • Sangai Day 8: Shumang Leela :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2: Kom Dance :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 29 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Innocence :: Poem
  • Foreign Secy's Myanmar visit ... Naga peace
  • Cancellation of residential proof certs
  • Derelict teachers threat to govt schools
  • Many questions, but no answers
  • Sangai Day 8: Food Stall #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 7: Vaiphei Dance :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 28 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • 1st & 2nd session of 12th Manipur Assembly
  • Organic seed production- Issue & strategy #3
  • IFFI means to upscale to Manipuri Cinema
  • Continuous bid to save endangered ponies
  • Arguments over ST : Meiteis are indigenes
  • Sangai Day 6: Elowe: Dzuko Valley :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 5: Khunung Eshei :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 27 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Alligator weed: Indigenous fodder resource
  • Two lives :: Poem
  • People don't actually care !!
  • The beauty in tea
  • Healthy response to Sangai Fest
  • Lessons from Japanese fans at WC
  • Sangai Day 5: Fashion parade :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 3: Thangal Dance :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 26 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Masterclasses add value to 53rd IFFI at Goa
  • 7th Charuangc 2022 : Rongmei of Delhi-NCR
  • Miss India from Manipur
  • Startup Innovation Conclave 1.0
  • National Constitution Day at Lilong
  • Sangai Day 4: 3 Types Of Drums :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 3: Chothe Dance :: Gallery
  • Involuntary Displacement in Manipur
  • Forgotten feature Film comes alive at IFFI
  • Will we protect medicines that protect us
  • God gives us our daily bread...
  • NPF consultative meeting at Zunheboto
  • Lapses in education laid bare by student
  • Adding a new flavour to War on Drugs
  • Sangai Day 3: Polo International :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2: Tangkhul Dance :: Gallery
  • 1st L. Keivom Memorial Day
  • Eina Khankhiba Natte : Movie Review
  • COVID-19 Status 24 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Eight Meet of Astronomers concluded at MU
  • 'Manipuri films projecting Manipuri culture'
  • Condemn govts of Assam & Meghalaya
  • Corruption-free Manipur resolve under scrutiny
  • Asia at the World Cup
  • Sangai Day 2: Khutpak Chatkoi #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2: Tarao Dance :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 23 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Screening of Manipuri films at IFFI
  • Nagaland Govt has no economic policy: NPF
  • Organic seed production- Issue & strategy #2
  • Reinvent Northeast - Dimapur launched
  • Uneasy calm in northeast as border rows rage
  • FIFAWC and Sangai Festival : Splendid recipe
  • Ningol Chakkouba @ Pune :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 22 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Ningol Chakouba organized at Pune
  • Free mega health camp at Nagamapal
  • Outlaw glyphosate and its derivatives
  • Creators Meet of Tripura at Agartala
  • No respite from drug and tobacco threats
  • Manipur: Fountainhead of drugs ?
  • Sangai Day 1: Laihui Folk Music #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 1: Opening ceremony :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 21 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Copa Manipur at Buenos Aires, Argentina
  • South Asia's film market features Manipur
  • ST Demand: Decided by merits; not by poll
  • Ecotoxicology- needed to save living beings
  • 'Look East policy into Act East Policy'
  • Tourism promotional fest litmus test for state
  • Sangai & Pony, the twin face of Manipur
  • Tarpon Chaklen Katpa #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Festival 2022 :: Activities List
  • The Dream Kangleipak :: Book Review
  • COVID-19 Status 20 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • 53rd IFFI featuring Manipuri Cinema kicks off
  • World Toilet Day 2022
  • Pulicat Lagoon, Flamingos' haven
  • Amid substance abuse, thrust on open gym
  • FIFA World Cup 2022
  • 1st CM's Sagol Kangjei C'ship :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 19 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Sangai Fest as a way to Look East Policy
  • 1st Chief Minister's Sagol Kangjei C'ship
  • Organic seed production- Issue & strategy #1
  • For PM Modi, G20 has come at the right time
  • Rock band Arogya releases latest single
  • Community Ningol Chakouba #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 18 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Out of the heart comes the issues of life
  • NE Startup Showcase @ Manipur Tech Hub
  • Immortal Gallows :: Poem
  • Workshop on Amrita Meditation at RGU ArP
  • Skin Pigmentation in Winter
  • Influx issue headache for all indigenes
  • Wanted: Visionary leaders :: Follies of past
  • The changing idioms of Manipuri theatre
  • COVID-19 Status 17 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • DFC Shillong launched with Model workshop
  • Antimicrobial resistance... to reverse progress
  • 2nd North East Olympic Games closes
  • Unending quota system & National excellence
  • Solar energy can help India achieve net-zero
  • Sangai Festival as launch pad for tourism
  • All eyes on Qatar
  • Manipur Journalist Awards #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 16 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • Delegates for IFFI, Goa
  • Intellectual Class- First Line of Defense
  • Who are ST in true spirit of Constitution
  • Journalism is a public good ...
  • Vaccine transported through Drones in ArP
  • Mass tree felling depreciates existence...
  • ST demand : Let Delhi have the say
  • 5th Kwatha Festival #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 15 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • This Eleventh Edition of Sangai Festival
  • The garden of Kew #2
  • NE International Fashion Week 2022
  • Housing system for sow & piglets
  • Doctors grieving relentlessly, Govt silent
  • Law catching up after 21 years
  • Leima Jagoi @ Nongshaba #1 :: Gallery
  • Manipur Technology innovation Hub
  • North East BJP Karyakartas Sammelan
  • Supreme Court call for revisit of reservation
  • Rural Immersion Camp at West Kameng
  • World Diabetes Day 2022
  • Undeserving PDS rice beneficiaries
  • Leaving the doors wide open
  • On author, research & publication #3
  • COVID-19 Status 13 Nov : Govt of Manipur
  • MSAD : newly elected executives for 2022-23
  • 'Trust deficit' in Naga talks
  • Professor Bimola : A Life Fully Lived
  • Love's Twist :: Poem
  • Rani Gaidinliu Training Camp concluded
  • Job for all promise as unemployed rises
  • Presenting Manipur to the world
  • Manipur Fashion Extravaganza #3 :: Gallery
  • Seminar on Role of Women in Sports : Report
  • The great Asian Highway : Tokyo to Istanbul
  • Seminar : Reconstruction of Education
  • 4th National Lok Adalat for the year, 2022
  • Rishi Sunak .. is a pucca English Burra sahib
  • Ningol Chakkouba : Gift presents :: Gallery
  • Conference on Metallomics @ Manipur Univ
  • An awakening sprout in darkness :: Poem
  • Narration from a man who chase mountains
  • Jobs @ JCRE skill solutions, Thangmeiband
  • Masterclass on Social Photography kicks off
  • Training on mushroom cultivation
  • Probe into PMGSY project blot on graft-free
  • Opinion poll & quest for ST status
  • MANITEX @ Nilakuthi #1 :: Gallery
  • Downloadable Manipuri Calendar for 2023
  • Camping @Shirui Lily Fest #2 :: Gallery
  • Aku Zeliang : Young Talent of the Year Award
  • Manipur in UN's drug cartel map...
  • Hiyang Tannaba @ Loktak #3 :: Gallery
  • Application: AgriEntrepreneur across Manipur
  • Sangai Festival 2022 :: Program & Venues
  • Ningol Chakouba at Bengaluru
  • Linthoi Chanambam- Judo Player :: Gallery
  • Indo-Naga Talks (2012-) :: News Timeline
  • Hari-Uthang Kang Chingba :: Gallery
  • Ningol on way to her mapam #2 :: Gallery
  • Kut Festival @ Churachandpur : Gallery
  • AMAND Pune: Cultural Program #2 : Gallery
  • Ningol on way to her mapam #1 :: Gallery
  • Okram Kumar : Archaeological researcher
  • Mera Houchongba @ Kangla #2 :: Gallery
  • Olympians & National awardees of Manipur
  • Rules of English Pronunciation : Download
  • Sub-Syllables in English : Book Download