TODAY -

Open Letter to V Shanmuganathan (Governor of Manipur) on the Definition of Culture
- Part 2 -

Kshetri Prem *

V. Shanmuganathan : Governor of Manipur
V. Shanmuganathan : Governor of Manipur :: Pix - DIPR



We the people of the Northeast are known by the Sanskrit term kirata [6] meaning roughly means 'uncivilised', meaning non-Aryan. We (Meiteis non-Aryan) were Hinduiased through the process of Hinduaisation/Hindu method of tribal absorption/Aryanisation. The concept is very much like the European 'enlightenment' theory which the cultural imperialists believed in (and bow down before) and by convincing themselves and rest of the world that they were actually on a 'civilising mission' to sanctify a savage land inhabited by 'untamed dangerous people' [7] . This pretext called 'civilising mission' was carried out by Vashnavite missionaries and Brahmins who came to Manipur with their 'scrolls and sanctities' [8].

Your Excellency, as you understand, the notion of culture is fluid, dynamic, and ever evolving. Trying to define culture is like trying to hit a moving target. As a small time teacher who discusses high and popular/mass/low culture, production and propagation, insemination and dissemination, associated terms, origin of the concept and its reception in various fields, etc. of culture both with Post-Graduate as well as PhD students, I must confess that I do not try to define culture or give a pre-existing definition of culture in a classroom scenario. I don't do it because the term 'culture' has become very political in today's world. The domain of culture has become a fertile ground for expression and assertion of ascendancy of a dominant class over a subordinate class.

Therefore, we have the concept of 'hegemony' which is the process of making, maintaining, and reproducing authoritative set of meanings, ideologies, and practices. The dominant class tries to push down their ideals and ideologies through the throat of the subordinate class. This process is what Italian Marxist Antonio Gramsci called 'incorporation'. The dominant class believes that they can incorporate the subordinate class by claiming the existence of a 'dominant centre' but, in a country like India, there is no 'dominant centre'. There is no such thing as common culture either. Let's all remember that culture is heterogeneous both in terms expression and the ways in which we (people from different cultures) find meaning within that expression.

Your Excellency surely knows that Canada has 'multiculturalism' in their constitution (Section 27 of 'Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom' to be precise). But, interestingly, an extremely diverse country (racially, culturally, and linguistically) such as India has not made 'multicultural' as part of its constitution. But, we believe in the concept of 'unity in diversity'. Do not Your Excellency think that 'unity in diversity' is just a popular excuse for grouping impossibly diverse entities together under one overarching all-inclusive theme (a line borrowed from a concept note of a seminar)?

For your kind information, the Northeast alone is a conglomeration of around 475 ethnic groups and sub-groups, speaking over 400 languages/dialects. Manipur alone has some 35 different tribes speaking as many languages and practicing and propagating as many cultures. Would it be wrong to conclude that each tribe would have its own notion and understanding of culture? Do we even practice 'unity in diversity'? Instead of promoting multiculturalism do we not always talk in terms of my culture versus your culture?

Yours Excellency's 'hundred word essay on culture challenge' to the people of Manipur reminds me of the immigration officer at the Indira Gandhi International Airport, New Delhi who bullied a young Manipuri lady by questioning her 'Indianess' for which Smt. Sushma Swarji, Honourable Union Minister, External Affairs, Govt. of India had to apologise. If we look at these two incidents structurally, I do not see and find any difference. Such unfortunate statements are the direct results of cultural arrogance and false superiority complex. Your Excellency must be having the same notions about us as the rest of India does.

This is what the rest of India thinks and perceives the people of the Northeast. 'You' have a static 'jingalala hurr syndrome' about 'me'. My 'self' evokes an image of a half naked spear-wielding tribal, wearing buffalo horns and jumping hysterically to the sound of tom-toms and shouting 'jingalala hurr' feverishly in some corner of the earth. I also seem to eat everything that creeps and crawls (except for cars) and everything that flies (except airplanes). The region is marketed as Paradise Unexplored a paradise 'yet to be found'.

It is believed to be a land of exotic orchids, inaccessible yet beautiful jungles, enchanting half clad tribal girls dancing everywhere at any given point of time (as shown in the Northeast Brochure published by Ministry of Tourism, Government of India), wild animals and wilder food habits, strange languages and stranger customs, primitives whose history and literature are yet to be written ... Simply put, we are waiting to be explored. A 'case study' of sorts for researchers, anthropologists, NGOs, and the people who hold 'I Love N-E' placards at Jantar Mantar.

The Northeast is perceived, at the turn of the twenty first century, by many of the 'mainstream Indians' (a term which has mainstreamed by itself in the centre-margin discourse) as mysterious, exotic, bizarre, and the actual location for 'hunger games'. The race-culture issue of the Northeast still mars the socio-political discourse of India. Racist attacks on the people of the Northeast in all parts of the country are becoming a 21st century Indian reality. However much we deny that racism exists in India, discrimination issuing from racial and cultural differences permeate everywhere. We are called 'chinky' (whatever that word means). That's not all. There are food epithets in this racial 'slur'ping. I am not just a 'chinky', I am a Momo Chinky Chow man.

Please allow me to take Your Excellency down the memory land and discuss with you the process of Hinduasation that happened in successive periods. During the reign of Meidingu Kiyamba (1467-1508) Hindu conversion efforts accelerated in Manipur. Waves of Shaivism and Vaishnavism sects entered Manipur. Chief among them are the Nimbarka Sect, Vishnuswami Sect, Madhavcharya Sect, Ramandi cult, Madhu Guru Sect, etc. Vaishnavism was adopted as a state religion during the reign of Maharaj Garibniwaz (1709-1748) but not one sect could hold the ground for long.

Finally in about 1777 Rajarshi Bhagyachandra (1748-1799) adopted Gouranga (Narotam) Paribar of the Bengal branch of the Madhu Guru Sect. The madhur bhava of Radha and Krishna enticed the valley of Manipur for more than two centuries. However, Manipuris never gave up their indigenous faith. Something had to be done to consolidate Vaishnavism in Manipur. That consolidation effort included rewriting Manipuri history and superimposing Hindu gods on Meitei lais (deities). An ambivalent syncretism ensued between the two faiths. The configuration of Manipuri cocktail identity began thus.

One cannot help but notice Ngugi's sarcasm when he says that, "It is the final triumph of domination [neo/colonialism] when the dominated [colonised] started singing its [coloniser's] virtues." [9] We had many in the 1930s who through carefully selected Vedic texts made us see and feel Aryan blood in Mongoloid veins. I have nothing against any religion. I am a proud atheist who still considers Hinduism as one of the best ways of life. I still am a son of a pious Vaishnavite mother and Christian minded Vaishnavite father. But, what followed after the Meiteis got converted to Vaishnavism is something we need to introspect.

The Hindu religion brought to the land (Manipur) Hindu culture, the notion of amang/aseng (impure-pure/touchable-untouchable), Sanskrit and Bengali languages and script, and above all, the propagation of a false racial superiority (elevated self) of the Meiteis among the rest of the ethnic communities. Suddenly, there was a divide between the hill tribes and the valley tribes who had co-existed for centuries.

This divide (religious) continues to persist (in political avatars) as the hill tribes have adopted Christianity (around the time of British occupation of Manipur in 1891) and the valley tribes have made themselves stranded in a unique situation of racial, religious, and cultural wilderness [10]. Manipuri language and literature was being sidelined to promote a hegemonic language and culture. There is a sense of pride in the following observation made in 1890 CE in an article called "Manipur" in Janmabhumi published by Shri Kebalram Chattopadhyay.

My prosaic translation from Bangla is:
Previously in Manipur, the Sanskrit language was highly coveted, and the nagarakshar/devanagri script was used. But, after Goswamis of Nabadvip became their mantra gurus, the Bengali language and the script began to be preferred by the people there. However, this has not resulted in the complete disappearance of devanagri. Manipuris who are well versed in Hindu dharmahastra have great respect for Srimadbhagavat and other Veishnav texts. [11]

To be continued.....


* Kshetri Prem wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is Assistant Professor, Dept. of English, Tripura University and can be reached at kshprem(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was posted on August 18, 2016.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai - festival of Kabui #1
  • Protest against CAB [Jan 15] #2: Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai, Festival of Zeliangrong
  • Understanding Mao Tse-Tung
  • Of Vernacular & my Enlightenment..
  • Teacher wanted at Tekcham High School
  • Demanding release of Kishorechandra
  • BJP's Agenda : Curtain raised
  • Topping in enrolment in pvt schools
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni #1 : Gallery
  • Gaan Ngai :: Flash Presentation
  • CAB Protest [16 Jan] : Gallery
  • Dr Thokchom Asha: Teacher Award
  • Cry of a Dying River - 62 :: Poem
  • Occasion & festivity as career choice
  • Rejoinder to NDPP on CAB by NPF
  • Saving tomorrow for our children
  • Open invitation to Mission schools
  • Women's Intl Polo [Jan 17] : Gallery
  • A Hymn for Goddess Emoinu
  • Manipur tops enrolment in private schools
  • Variance of laboratory results
  • A Christian perspective on solidarity #2
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Naga International Trade Fair at Dimapur
  • Has Loktak mortgaged to Company
  • CAB: Lining up public convention on Jan 20
  • Purnima Ngangom (Printmaker) :: Profile
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #3 : Gallery
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #2
  • CAB & scoring 21 out of 25 ?
  • Complications :: Poem
  • North East Business Summit at Delhi
  • Almond oil is the ultimate skin care
  • The Bill that haunt the government
  • Over 50 police personnel chargesheeted
  • Insurgency related incidents in NE states
  • Myanmar border fence going nowhere
  • Protest against CAB [Jan 15] #1: Gallery
  • CChongkhong, Apanthou :: eMing
  • Crop diseases & organic way of managing
  • War and Poetry :: Poem
  • Landeng-Pena yakaiduna Poster Campaign
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Condemns communal nature of CAB 2016
  • PCC, Arunachal Pradesh on CAB, 2016
  • CAB and other issues before LS polls
  • Sit-In against CAB [Jan 14] : Gallery
  • CAB : Our Identity & Culture is at stake
  • Re-Imagining the Naga Peace Process
  • Demand for ILP :: Articles/Photos...
  • Northeast Startup Summit 2019
  • Ponder them to live like human beings
  • No Shield for Manipur against CAB
  • Missing link: NE, CAB & obscure assurance
  • JCILPS Protest against CAB : Gallery
  • AMUCO Rally against CAB : Gallery
  • Poetic Justice - II :: Poem
  • Makar Sankranti Musing
  • Biren should release Kishorchandra
  • New archaeological site in Senapati
  • A Christian perspective on solidarity #1
  • New craft gallery to promote NE products
  • Rights body warns Nagas on Article 371 (A)
  • NE Black Day against CAB : Gallery
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #2 : Gallery
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #2: Gallery
  • Myanmar-India Business Summit, Sagaing
  • Cry of a Dying River - 61 :: Poem
  • Preventing the Dengue threat
  • NPF on Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016
  • Nagaland Chief Minister On CAB 2016
  • Hijacking by pseudoscience
  • Mr. CM, you can't fool people on CAB
  • CAB 2016: Adoption of foreign citizens
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #1 : Gallery
  • CAB & question of India's North East
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #1
  • Local actions for #GlobalGoals
  • Know your HIV status
  • Pope Francis - the last Pope!
  • CAB is unsecular discriminatory bill
  • When Govt. disregard Constitutions...
  • Citizenship Bill: An exceptional exception
  • The Walking Lady : A Short Story
  • 4th Convocation Ceremony of CAU
  • The Voice of Silence :: Poem
  • Against CAB 2016 : 6 Student Bodies
  • Need for a separate time zone
  • BOOM MMA : 'Manipur Top Team' members
  • Against Citizenship Bill Act 2016
  • Lt Gen Rajeev Sirohi at Spear Corps
  • Is the middle man responsible
  • Economically weak at Rs 8 lakh per annum ?
  • Umanglai Haraoba: Traditional Institution
  • Strike against CAB : Gallery
  • People - animal conflict
  • Fine on relieving in public
  • Flawed/divisive Citizenship Bill dangerous
  • Broken :: Poem
  • Meetei gi mayokta leiba Political party..
  • NE uniting under shutdown call : CAB
  • Trains in NE to get 'glass-top' coaches
  • Yubi Lakpi #2 : Gallery
  • Freedom's fault lines
  • Traditional Manipuri Curries
  • Governance in Multi-Ethnic States
  • Understanding animal welfare
  • Unite against corruption for development
  • Manipurgi Maraibk Kari Oihougani
  • On restoring of director of CBI
  • Citizenship Bill : scourge for NE
  • Feel good factor from UNC
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #2: Gallery
  • A tale of two falcons
  • Artificial Insemination in livestock
  • The Naked Truth :: Poem
  • My itinerary visit to Veeranapalya
  • Test for Free Coaching for IIT/AIIMS
  • Critique of Transgender Persons Bill
  • Press Rejoinder from NPF [7 Jan]
  • Nagaland Cabinet on Citizenship Bill
  • Can we expect something from govt
  • Mova Cave, Ukhrul #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Sumo Wrestling #2 :: Gallery
  • Maipaksana RK: Entrepreneurship Award
  • Poetic Justice - I
  • IIT-G Technology Incubation Centre
  • Sana Chahi Ahum & 1857 revolt #2
  • Economics of climate change & growth
  • Singhat Students tour to Delhi & Agra
  • Congress against Modi on Rafale Deal
  • Press Club celebrates foundation day
  • NSF to impose 11-hr bandh on Jan 8
  • 518 drug traffickers arrested in 2018
  • Gangmumei Kamei Memorial lecture
  • Taking the Street Vendor seriously #1
  • WWII museums in Japan: Gallery
  • Schedule : HSLC Examination 2019
  • Schedule : Class XI Examination 2019
  • Schedule : HSE Examination 2019
  • Caste System in Contemporary India: Book
  • Save energy and save your skin
  • Benefits of henna for beauty
  • Coronary In-stent obstruction treated
  • A take on PM visit to Imphal
  • No over the top promises, assurances
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #1: Gallery
  • Management of commercial broiler farming
  • 61st CC Meet Football Tournament 2019
  • Noise Ruins & Blights Lives
  • Social media & freedom of speech
  • Cry of a Dying River - 60 :: Poem
  • Declare war against air pollution
  • Winter relief at Thanga
  • Of monologues and conveniences
  • Raising posers before PM's arrival: Cong
  • Irengbam Bedamani :: eRang Photos
  • Poireiton Chakhao at Loktak Lake
  • Hojang :: Poem
  • New Year: Challenges & opportunities
  • One Rank One Pension Paper (OROP)
  • Fasting before diagnostic tests
  • Open Mic. event at Agartala
  • Happy New Year '2019' :: NPF
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Respecting life & the trust deficit
  • Need to look beyond New Year-2019
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #1: Gallery
  • May the Year 2019 bring integrity of Manipur
  • Sangai Fest: Evening Prog #2: Gallery
  • What I learned from Kishorchandra detention
  • Charlie, the angel :: Story
  • Against NSA to Kishorchandra Wangkhem
  • Quality New Year
  • Reminder to PM on Pravish Chanam death
  • What is there to be happy on New Year
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #4: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Village Authority in Hill Areas of Manipur #2
  • Sana Chahi Ahum & 1857 revolt #1
  • Local leaders commit to #endTobacco
  • Transformation of China in last 40 years
  • Boys Hostel for Pangal Students
  • From the diary of an insomniac - II
  • From nomenclature conflict of oral tradition
  • Gearing up for Parliamentary polls
  • Dimapur Meetei Council donates
  • Bye Bye 2018 !!! : Gallery
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2019 : Download
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2018 #6: Gallery
  • Unforgettable Revolutionary NK Sanajaoba
  • Life's pain :: Poem
  • New Year resolution of our honorables
  • Certificate distribution at Namsai, ArP
  • Indo-Myanmar Relations : Talk @ MU
  • Butchering a Pony for meat! Shameful
  • Top 5 Indie/Alternative Picks of 2018
  • Sangaithel Park @Sangai: Gallery
  • A view of Ukhrul Town #1: Gallery
  • January Calendar for Year 2019 :: Tools
  • National Mathematics Day & Ramanujan
  • Thougal Jagoi @Sangai: Gallery
  • Snowfall @Tamei, Tamenglong : Gallery
  • China spreads across Indochina Peninsula
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping a#2: Gallery
  • Cry of a Dying River - 59 :: Poem
  • Match words with actions to #endTB
  • Hacking : Base of all cyber crimes
  • Illegal adoptions in hospitals
  • Controlling the school transporters
  • Detention under NSA : Stand of MUSU
  • Xmas: Churches @Lamphel : Gallery
  • 27th Imphal Book Fair #2 : Gallery
  • The Crying Call of Motherland :: Poem
  • Kwatha Festival #3 : Gallery
  • 12th Manipur Polo Intl #2 : Gallery
  • Oinam Dilip : Rising Star Award 2018, Delhi
  • Harvard Leadership Program at Don Bosco
  • Christmas @Churachandpur : Gallery
  • UN Rapporteur briefed on Kishorechand
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #3: Gallery
  • Irengbam Bedamani - Actress :: eRang
  • List of Restricted Holidays for 2019
  • List of Public Holidays for 2019
  • List of General Holidays for 2019
  • Ningol - mapam lamdam : Gallery
  • Fabrics of Bangladeshi Manipuri: Download
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS