TODAY -

Can Manipur break out of its self-perpetuating cycle of economic stagnation and ethnic tension?
Yes but it needs a new political paradigm

Sophia Rajkumari *

Mass Peace Rally appealing to stop Economic Blockade by UNC :: 23rd December 2016
Mass Peace Rally appealing to stop Economic Blockade by UNC on 23rd December 2016 :: Pix - Daniel Chabungbam



The recent events in Manipur the State Government's announcements regarding the formation of new districts in predominantly tribal populated hill areas and the retaliation by the so-called United Naga Council through the imposition of an economic blockade targeted at the denizens of the predominantly Meitei community populated Imphal Valley have hardly attracted significant attention in the mainstream Indian and international press. The responses of the Government of India and its nodal ministries have also been lethargic, to say the least.

Think about it if goons in Haryana and U.P. were to suddenly block all road and rail traffic to Delhi bringing the flow of food, fuel, medicines, goods and people to a complete halt and if the citizens of Delhi had to cope with the consequent shortage of essential commodities and pay Rs. 300 per liter of petrol after waiting in line for a day, would the media be so unconcerned? And would the Government of India nonchalantly wait for 50 days to pass before sending a junior minister to make an assessment if the situation?

And this is precisely what has happened in the case of Manipur. And not for the first time this has become an almost yearly occurrence. India clearly doesn't care about Manipur's fate or the suffering of its people. Whether it is the media, common people, or governmental institutions, this recurring situation exposes the very loose ties that bind Manipur to the Indian Union, and the weakness of Manipur's own institutional mechanisms a process that began with the controversial accession of the princely state of Manipur to the Indian Union in 1949.

Prior to the accession, which some allege occurred under duress placed on the then Maharaja during his visit to Shillong, Manipur had been evolving into a constitutional monarchy. While it already had an elected assembly, no attempt was made to seek the assembly's consent, hold a plebiscite or otherwise gain popular approval for the move.

With the relegation of Manipur to Union Territory status, and no statehood until 1972, when various separatist insurgencies were already gathering steam, the incipient institutions of the State had no opportunity to take root. The balance that had prevailed for centuries between different communities assorted Naga, Kuki and other hill people and the Meitei people in the valley was upset, with no means to correct it.

The problem was compounded by New Delhi's colonial mindset the North-Eastern States, racially and ethnically different from the rest of India, are seen more as an extension of India's strategic and territorial outreach, rather than as an integral part of India in a cultural and civilizational sense. Thus, with the onset of separatist insurgencies, New Delhi began to cultivate a model where Manipur was treated as a sort of client state in a zero sum game the idea being to install a puppet regime beholden to New Delhi's patronage and to practice a strategy of containing and co-opting the insurgency by spreading corruption and inhibiting development. Whatever was left of Manipur's institutions completely withered away as corruption became entrenched at all levels. Development infrastructure, economic and social took a back seat and Manipur's transformation to a client state addicted to New Delhi's handouts was complete.

Some of the other smaller North Eastern States also faced similar challenges but were able to gradually turn the tide. Mizoram was fortunate to be relatively ethnically homogenous, which helped restore normalcy relatively quickly once the Mizo peace accord was signed. Nagaland, Tripura and Meghalya were geographically better placed, with good connectivity to Assam, and state governments that could deliver on a measure of social development if not infrastructure.

Manipur, with it's remoteness and ethnic diversity, faced challenges of a greater order, compounded by India's moves to isolate it from Myanmar, which has been it's traditional trading partner and market for centuries. Thus, with it's institutions weakened and corrupted, and it's key trade routes cut off, Manipur has faced continued deterioration in its social and economic indices and has found it difficult to cope with increased ethic tensions, often stoked by the divide and rule colonial style policies practiced by New Delhi's mandarins.

Consider this Manipur, a state with a population of less than 3 Million, is now the poorest state in the India Union, save for Uttar Pradesh (population 200 Million+) and Bihar (Population 100 Million+). With a GDP per capita of around US$ 900, Manipur is quite comparable to sub-Saharan Africa in terms of its development and income indices. While China is now building a second railway to Tibet, the roof of the world, much more easily accessible Manipur is yet to have any meaningful rail connectivity nearly 70 years after India became independent.

Turning to the present crisis, it almost seems to be playing out to a predictable script. First, the State Government, led by Chief Minister Ibobi Singh, who has developed a reputation for thorough corruption, incompetence and maliciousness in his 15 years at the helm, realizes that elections are around the corner and something needs to be done to shore up his dwindling political base. Dusting off his old playbook from 2010-11, Ibobi seems to decide that a communal polarization that enables him to be seen as a protector of the Meiteis and guardian of Manipur's territorial integrity is his best bet at garnering enough votes for a fourth term.

So, after several years of doing nothing to improve administrative efficiency, Ibobi determines it is best now, at the eve of his third term, to suddenly announce the creation of seven new districts to be carved out of predominantly tribal dominated hill areas thus sharpening the divide amongst the various Kuki and Naga ethnic communities (gathering some votes there in the process) while shoring up Meitei support in the face of the anticipated opposition from certain Naga groups to this move. Of course, Ibobi, the epitome of wholesome administrative failure if there ever was one, claims this is being done to enhance administrative efficiency.

Act two enter the United Naga Council (UNC). A front organization for the NSCN-IM terror outfit, the UNC then spots an opportunity to make itself more relevant amongst the various Naga communities and override the reality that it only essentially represents a faction of one tribal group. And it does this by resorting to economic terrorism of the worst kind by seeking to impose an economic blockage of Manipur by force. Of course, this creates communal polarization exactly what both Ibobi and UNC want, albeit for differing reasons.

Ibobi does nothing to have the economic blockade lifted despite having the State's forces and added Central armed forces at his command. He let's things slide for several weeks as the common people of all communities suffer. And then he allows a situation to develop where innocent Naga civilians residing in Imphal and it's vicinity are terrorized by unruly mobs and prevented from leaving for home to celebrate Christmas, even as property and churches are vandalized. Of course, no protection is forthcoming from the State's forces.

And naturally, New Delhi snoozes away while the weeks go by. Finally, when the Union Home Minister awakes from his 50 day slumber, he realizes that the State is slipping away. A BJP MLA from the Meitei community has just defected and joined the Congress to be seen as siding with Ibobi. And the BJP, which had been coasting along expecting to be victorious in the 2017 assembly elections, reckons that it has been outwitted by Ibobi.

Time to attempt some belated damage control not because the people of Manipur have no food, fuel, medicines, or security but only since it is getting closer to election time. So a junior Minister of State for Home Affairs is dispatched to Manipur to make some suitable noises, demonstrate concern, and blame the State Government. He claims that the Home Ministry was unaware of the situation on the ground, conjuring images of the messenger pigeon era.

Of course, New Delhi's unsavory relations with the NSCN-IM are also a factor New Delhi has been merrily signing secret accords with the NSCN-IM without taking any state governments or Parliament into confidence even as the NSCN-IM goes about killing and extorting Indian citizens with impunity. The UNC has no constitutional locus so the claim in some quarters that it should have been consulted before the formation of new districts was announced by the State Government doesn't have any legal or moral basis.

Furthermore, those with genuine grievances against the move do have various avenues of peacefully opposing the State Government's decision these include filing a judicial challenge and having their representatives in the State Assembly voice their opposition. Petitions and peaceful assemblies are all legitimate choices but an economic blockade is clearly illegal and only intended to terrorize and provoke a communal backlash.

What then might the long-term solutions be? The people of Manipur Meitei, Naga, Kuki and others need to realize that they stand alone and have to resolve their problems and develop their state themselves. India will not help and doesn't care. We have to do this ourselves and chart our own destiny.

The world respects strength and that is gained from wealth and economic power. As long as Manipur stays beholden to Indian hand-outs, it will remain a polarized client state, subject to India's divisive policies, apathy and puppet regimes. Thus, the first priority for Manipur is to become developed and wealthy. This will only happen if different communities can create a peaceful environment conducive to development and avoid falling prey to attempts to communally polarize them.

This requires the likes of Ibobi and the UNC to be rendered politically irrelevant, and replaced by entities that represent the genuine development aspirations of all sections of Manipur's population in a responsible and mature manner. Neither the Indian national political parties such as the Congress and the BJP and their local acolytes, and nor purely communal organizations affiliated to terror outfits such as the UNC and it's other Naga, Meitei or Kuki equivalents can offer this.

Thus, what is needed is a pan-Manipur local political movement that seeks to represent all communities on a platform of rapid economic growth and development. While this does seem far-fetched, it is not impossible the building blocks in the form of educated youth with strong aspirations are already present, and social media can provide the impetus from a communications and outreach standpoint in a relatively inexpensive way.

The contours of such a political entity can be flexible it need not be a traditional, unitary command and control political party, but perhaps more an agglomeration of strong local movements sharing a development ideology with a democratic, central core. If the people of Manipur recognize this a difficult ask in an era where the main goal seems to be to bribe one's way to an irrelevant government job Manipur perhaps has a chance of breaking out of its' cycle of stagnation. It is a bit like a de-addiction program weaning the addict away from the drug and restoring his or her dignity and sense of self is a difficult process with many pitfalls and the chances of failure are greater than those of success. And it cannot work if the addict doesn't have the will to kick the habit.

While Manipur must remain within the Indian Union for the foreseeable future for practical considerations, it does still have leeway to be a more cohesive and economically independent society within this set-up, with strong relations and trading links with its neighboring states as well as Myanmar, Thailand and Western China. Critical to realizing this vision is social harmony, human capital in the form of a well-educated and productive workforce and rapid infrastructure development. Geography allows Manipur to be a trade hub, and with some investments and peace, it can vastly grow its services and tourism sectors, while focusing on higher value agricultural domains such as horticulture and floriculture. Diversity can yet be Manipur's strength instead of being a weakness.


* Sophia Rajkumari wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is a Bangalore based social entrepreneur and can be contacted at sophirajkumari0408(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was posted on December 27, 2016.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Khoupum Valley Expedition #5:: Gallery
  • 36th World TB day Rally :: Gallery
  • Veteran Cricket Tournament :: Gallery
  • And thus she became a fast learner
  • Coalition Government & its periphery
  • Know your test: Uric acid
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • No compromise on territorial integrity
  • Ten meritorious students sponsored
  • Anti Corruption Cell to be set up
  • Centre, State: Put RIMS back on track
  • Minister promise on Imphal Jiribam road
  • Students for HSLC Exam :: Gallery
  • Governor Cup Polo tournament #1:: Gallery
  • Blast of Md Kora & his shadows
  • A Drunken Dream :: Poem
  • Downfall of Congress party in Manipur
  • Corruption a part and parcel in our society
  • Hangkhanlian, Radheshyam, Nemcha ...
  • Indo-Naga Talks 2017 :: News Timeline
  • Lecture on TS. Eliot's contribution
  • Naga integration via FA: Game of word play
  • Almost perfect team...missing "Lok Ayukta"
  • Miss Manipur Queen 2017 #2 : Gallery
  • Yangkholet, Somatai, Mangaleima :: eMing
  • N Biren sworn-in CM #3 :: Gallery
  • Lanmei Thanbi Re-imagining the Light Spirit
  • Did we glorify the UNC highway blockade?
  • Career penchant in Anthropology
  • The formation of new BJP-led Government
  • The Killing Fields :: News Timeline
  • Nagas safe under Framework : NSCN-IM
  • New fish species discovered in Assam
  • Making Manipur bandh & blockade free: Guv
  • Politicking the politics
  • Photo : Governor with all Elected MLAs
  • Day 3: @ Bamon Leikai #3 : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Day 3 activities #2 : Gallery
  • Kanchan Soibam in Femina Miss India 2017
  • RIST talk 28-Transition in amorphous solid
  • Formation of Gender Champions @RGU
  • Free spectacle distribution at Loktak Station
  • Naga history of transition stands unique
  • Delhi warn NE against shady land deals
  • Screen kids' films in NE languages
  • Looking at the pre-poll promises of BJP
  • State govt- perceptions & premonitions
  • MLAs took oath of office : Gallery
  • SundarGopal Condolence @Ghy : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Thabal at Pune #2 :: Gallery
  • Yaoshang: Journalist Sports #2 :: Gallery
  • What Term of Negotiation btn GoM & UNC?
  • Class 12 marks may decide your college..
  • N. Biren led Govt won the floor test
  • Sadar Hills Demand 2011-2017 : Timeline
  • Job @ VK NRL Hospital at Numaligarh
  • Cycling from Jessami to Mantripukhri
  • Lifting the longest ever blockade
  • Hope amid the hesitations
  • Tenwa Chandrasakhi :: Funga wari
  • Yaoshang Day 5: Sports #2: Gallery
  • Day 3: Yaoshang activities #1 : Gallery
  • Day 3: @ Bamon Leikai #2 : Gallery
  • Drinking bottled mineral water culture
  • Condolence meeting for friend of Assam
  • Food Outlet at DM Community College
  • APFEJ urges Delhi to be respectful to media
  • TSA Ceremonial Rite to its Former SG
  • Statistics not telling the whole story
  • Kangleipak Kang Trophy #1 : Gallery
  • Day 5: Yaoshang Activities #4: Gallery
  • N Biren sworn-in CM #2 :: Gallery
  • Insurgency as reflected in Chagi Khuji
  • Yaoshang Meithaba @Uripok: Gallery
  • Women Empowerment
  • Construction as career choice
  • Condolence meeting for Sundar Gopal
  • Manipuri group to stall trains
  • Manipur State Archery Championship
  • Miss Manipur Queen 2017 #1 : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Halankar celebration : Gallery
  • 2nd phase Polling @Nungba #2 :: Gallery
  • Art of Lamangdong's stone bowls & Toupokpi
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Loukhatpa #2: Gallery
  • Pabung Sunder Gopal funeral at Mandalay
  • Emotional integration of all communities
  • Training on Traditional Snacks
  • How to take along disparate parties
  • Yaoshang Day 5: Sports #1: Gallery
  • Meetei Pokpi :: Radio e-pao
  • Day 3: @ Bamon Leikai #1 : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Thaba #4: Gallery
  • Letter: Manipur Public Service Commission
  • Career as Chef
  • HQ IGAR celebrates 14th Raising Day [upd]
  • N Biren sworn-in CM #1 :: Gallery
  • Yaoshang Thabal at Pune #1 :: Gallery
  • Mix Media Art exhibition #2 :: Gallery
  • Yaoshang: Journalist Sports #1 :: Gallery
  • Nongthombam Biren sworn-in CM, Mar 15
  • Glaucoma Week : March 12 - 18, 2017
  • Annual Yaoshang Thabal 2017 at Pune
  • Course in Butterfly Studies at BNHS
  • Yaoshang- with DJ @Sekmai :: Gallery
  • Kangleipak Football Trophy 2017 :: Gallery
  • Thabal chongbagi Peisa khaiba #2:: Gallery
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Thaba #3: Gallery
  • Cue card for the new Chief Minister
  • International Rivers Day at Tamenglong
  • What kind of Nagaland are we moving..
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Loukhatpa #1: Gallery
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Thaba #2: Gallery
  • Election: Counting & Winnners #2:: Gallery
  • Ending TB is going to be hard...
  • Holi Pala performance at Raj Bhavan
  • Archery Championship at Keithalmanbi
  • NPF to support non-Congress coalition
  • Workshop on filmmaking at MSFDS
  • Yaoshang Day 1: Mei Thaba #1: Gallery
  • Yaoshang Day 1: AMWJU Sports : Gallery
  • 2nd phase Polling @Chandel :: Gallery
  • Testing patience of Manipuris, Cong-UNC
  • Bangladesh Meetei leisabi at Sylhet
  • A Hindi tract with feminist ideals
  • Condemns decision on Sajibu Nongma
  • Churchill Brothers vs Shillong Lajong
  • Election: Counting & Winnners #1:: Gallery
  • Mamliba maikeise :: Radio e-pao
  • Saroi Khangba #3 : Gallery
  • Yaoshang :: A flash presntation
  • UNC in Manipur Electoral Politics #3
  • The Election Trap :: Poem
  • Mix Media Art exhibition #1 :: Gallery
  • Mountain Division Polo #2 : Gallery
  • MCA T20 Luwangpokpa Trophy :: Gallery
  • Possibility of hung House
  • BJP will form government in Manipur
  • Trade connection with Southeast Asia #2
  • Breast Cancer Conference :: Gallery
  • Saroi Khangba #2 : Gallery
  • 2nd phase Polling @Sora :: Gallery
  • Judgement regarding MCSCCE - 2016
  • 2nd phase Polling @Nungba #1 :: Gallery
  • Thabal chongbagi Peisa khaiba #1:: Gallery
  • Featured Photo for 2017 #1 :: Gallery
  • Exam Centers for HSE 2017 : Download
  • 'Thammoi Tahoure' : Muslims' musical
  • International Women's Day at Delhi
  • International Women's day
  • Thoubal Keithel #1 : Gallery
  • Gita-Govinda- Dance Drama #2: Gallery
  • Women's Day: Women Safety in Train
  • All eyes on 2nd phase polls
  • Not so hard verdict, but perhaps..
  • Kabui Keioiba & Lai Khutsangbi ...
  • Rahul Gandhi @Imphal #2: Gallery
  • Mountain Division Polo #1 : Gallery
  • People's Convention on FA : Gallery
  • Manipur hills as tourist destination
  • Armed Violence & Nationalism : Report
  • Saroi Khangba #1 : Gallery
  • Polling for Assembly election #2 : Gallery
  • PM Narendra Modi #3: Gallery
  • Maphou Dam :: 360 View Panorama
  • Manipur Sangai Festival 2016 #2 : Ooba
  • Laisram Birendra Kumar: PadmaShri Award
  • Trekking to Dzukou Valley #2: Gallery
  • Biju Ningombam (Photos) #3 :: eRang
  • Laihui @Tanglei Music Festival :: Gallery
  • Landscape of Manipur #5: Wallpaper
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Wareppa Naba :: Profile of Theatre Actor
  • Meiteilon Folk & Tangkhul duet : Ooba
  • Khunung Eeshei/ Ema Emoinu #3 : Radio
  • SPONSORED ADS