Memorandum submitted to Inquiry Commission of Supreme Court

Imphal Press Club, 21 February 2013


In a Memorandum submitted on 18 February 2013 to the independent Commission of Inquiry appointed by a directive of the Supreme Court of India on 4 January 2013, with a copy to the Chief Justice of India, Mr Altamas Kabir, the Civil Society Coalition on Human Rights in Manipur and the UN (CSCHR) raised critical concerns relating to the modus operandi of the Inquiry Commission. The Inquiry Commission is reportedly coming to Imphal on 1 March 2013.

1. The undated Public Notice published in one local vernacular daily newspaper and one English language daily newspaper only on 9 February 2013 inviting sworn affidavits in English, with three extra copies, to be submitted to its office established at the Manipur Bhavan in New Delhi within 10 days of its publication is deficient and objectionable, and having no precedence in the history of Inquiry Commissions in Manipur.

2. The undated Public Notice gives no contact details of this office except a postal address. No office is set up in Manipur where the terms of this Commission are to be met, its business conducted and where the alleged extra-judicial executions took place. With no office established yet in Manipur, what are the plans and schedules of the Commission in this State and where will the aggrieved families, witnesses and other interested parties meet the Commission when it visits Imphal on 1 March 2013 as reported?

3. Despite the Supreme Court directive, the Central and Manipur governments have not extended diligent necessary manpower and secretarial assistance to the Inquiry Commission after more than a month of its establishment.

4. The full Terms of Reference of this Inquiry Commission has not been made known to the public.

5. There are no mechanisms established for witness protection or safety. No confidentiality procedures have been established.

As the findings and conclusions of this Inquiry Commission will have direct implications in the ongoing petitions before the Hon’ble Supreme Court finally to bring justice and reparation within the grasp of the long aggrieved surviving families of the deceased, the Memorandum drew the attention of the members of the independent Inquiry Commission to the following:

I. Considering that the undated Public Notice of 9 February 2013 does not give satisfactory contact details thereby nullifying a feasible mechanism of communications by telephone, fax or email (Internet based channels) or otherwise, to make available contacts where the original statements, affidavits and evidence may be presented at Imphal before the Inquiry Commission.

II. An informed Public Notification to be re-published or broadcasted in both State and privately run information dissemination mediums like the radio, television, daily newspapers, etc., at least three times in English, Manipuri and other languages in the State.

III. The public to be informed of the full Terms of Reference of the Inquiry Commission through such a re-notification.

IV. The Inquiry Commission must immediately have an office established at Imphal, Manipur with the full cooperation and essential support including secretarial and financial assistance extended by the Central and Manipur governments. This office should be empowered to receive any material evidence or statements or affidavits to the Inquiry Commission, as such facilitation would greatly ease the hardships being faced by the interested parties in the cases being examined.

V. Last date for receipt of information by the Inquiry Commission regarding the facts and circumstances relating to the killing of the aforesaid seven persons to be extended till 28th February 2013 to lend more accountability and inclusivity to the process.

VI. The Inquiry Commission must establish due processes and effective mechanisms to protect the witnesses, surviving family members of the deceased and other interested parties who wish to submit information, depose or appear before it.

VII. The Inquiry Commission must also institute a confidential mechanism as established by similar communications procedures worldwide and in the United Nations Human Rights Council. This will further contribute to the personal security of witnesses and confidentiality for those who wish to appear and depose before the Inquiry Commission.

VIII. Reduce the number of copies of documents required to be submitted to one copy. The burden of making necessary copies must lie with the office of the Inquiry Commission, and not be imposed on the aggrieved families of the deceased.

IX. Apart from printed/written documents, the Inquiry Commission should allow the submission and inclusion of audio, video, photographs, object/material evidences including fact-finding visits to the alleged encounter sites in order to establish the true facts and circumstances of the killing of the seven persons in Manipur during 2009 for effective and speedy delivery of justice to the aggrieved parties.

The Commission was established under a directive of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India on 4 January 2013 (WP [Crl] No.1/2009 and WP [C] No. 445 of 2012) following a recent petition filed by Extrajudicial Execution Victims’ Families’ Association Manipur (EEVFAM), which pleaded for an independent probe into more than 1500 cases of extra-judicial killings in Manipur.

The three member Inquiry Commission, comprising of retired Supreme Court Justice N. Santosh Hegde, former Chief Election Commissioner J.M. Lyngdoh and retired DGP of Karnataka Police, Mr. Ajay Kumar Singh, is to conduct an independent probe into 6 different cases of extra-judicial killings, involving 7 (seven) victims including a child in the State of Manipur.

(Dr Laifungbam Debabrata Roy)
Email: cschrmanipur(at)gmail(dot)com
Blog site:

* This info was sent by CSCHR Manipur who can be contacted at cschrmanipur(at)gmail(dot)com
This Press Release was posted on February 21, 2013.

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #2: Gallery
  • Buddhist Temple in Bangkok #2 : Gallery
  • An incident..India is still a racist country
  • Can BJP translate into reality of opinion poll
  • Chicken centre culture (live/dressed)
  • Another Facet of Beauty :: Poem
  • North East Zone Sports Climbing
  • CMO Nagaland reacts to Ibobi's statement
  • Thoughts on quality of good leader
  • Loktak Folklore Museum #1 : Gallery
  • Chonthingla, Medun :: eMing
  • 125th Police raising day : Gallery
  • Elections, integrity and rhetoric
  • Library movement in Manipur #3
  • ATSUM rebuts Dr Rajesh on MU imbroglio
  • Taming addiction
  • Objection to Kuki Tribal Dialect recognition
  • Jobs at Unitrans Solutions, Imphal
  • Indo-Myanmar Border Committee Meet
  • National Christian Leaders Meeting
  • Protests against Delhi University's decision
  • CFSI's film bonanza for NE kids
  • TR Zeliang: Sowing the seeds of divide
  • Tunnel-vision monologues
  • Naga Village Conference #1: Gallery
  • Shamu Khongyetpa : What Am I?
  • Heisnam Kanhailal: Exit of a theatre icon
  • Movements In Manipur, 1891-1947 #3
  • Observance of World Mental Health Month
  • Trafficking and illegal trading of pangolin
  • Annual Newsletter from MSAD released
  • Hottest chilli burns a hole in American man
  • Mary Kom To Join BJP ?
  • Jobs @ Prism D Solutions [upd]
  • Price of thumping: chest pain
  • India, Myanmar to jointly fight militancy
  • Now Delhi an ally, Imphal an adversary
  • 'PRJA', can it become another AAP
  • Savaang Rotha Ekur- Monsang: Gallery
  • Meitei Chanu Beauty Peagent #2: Gallery
  • MU fiasco: Tracing the root cause
  • Human Rights & Tangkhul Women #5
  • Let us speak about breast cancer
  • Career option in Geology
  • Indo-Naga Talks 2016 :: News Timeline
  • People's Campaign for Resurgent Manipur
  • TSA-GHQ endorses total shut-down
  • Rural Camp/Village Adoption at Tirap
  • NTC reaction on Rongmei tribe recognition
  • Reading everything along community divide
  • Clash of classes
  • Meitei Women in Collectives #3
  • Floating Restaurant at Riha, Ukhrul: Gallery
  • Where Is Manipur Today?
  • Just a day with Heisnam Kanhailal
  • What reservation should be followed in MU
  • Palliative care in Manipur
  • Climate Change : Food & Nutrition Security
  • Jobs @ Eastern Entrepreneurs
  • News Reporting Training Course Conclude
  • Sharmila in electoral politics
  • Laymen views on Electoral Politics
  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #1: Gallery
  • Kwak Tanba @Sana Konung #2: Gallery
  • Claims & Refutations: ILP : Book (corrected)
  • Wildlife conservation in Manipur #2
  • Point-of-care HIV testing: end AIDS by 2030
  • Thadou-Kuki subject at secondary school
  • Bitten by circus bug, artists fight all odds
  • Water scarcity looms large in Manipur
  • Cannot accept bill, says Ibobi
  • 40 seats : BJP obviously on a high
  • Dolaithabi Dam , Senapati : Gallery
  • Phoomdi - Compost: Prospect & Implication
  • Mera Houchongba festival
  • Education in the Valley & the Hills Areas #2
  • Sleep still my sweet, sweet Shilki : Poem
  • Becoming a Green Rebel- need of hour
  • Online Short Story Competition
  • Chavang Kut by Kuki of Karbi Anglong
  • 'Framework agreement' is hope of Nagas
  • Sharmila, don't go for election, lead people..
  • Kakching Garden @Uyok Ching #2: Gallery
  • Bor khoiramnaba @Hiyangthang #2: Gallery
  • The great Mera Haochongba festival
  • Attending King Bhumibol's B'day 2006
  • Manipur needs a Game-changer
  • An ode to India Post
  • Oct gi manungda GOI da recommendation
  • Guru Kirtana Seva observed
  • Journalism trainees in senapati
  • CNTC's fact-sheet on Rongmei recognition
  • Worrying times for the Congress
  • October 15: a journey with wrong starts
  • Priyanka Rajkumari - Singer Profile :: eRang
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Rally against MU Academic Council: Gallery
  • Hygienic maintenance of State Museum
  • Psychological & Mental Health
  • Clue to a mystery :: Poem
  • ILP System Demand- Photos from 2012
  • Delhi: Bureaucrat from Manipur attacked
  • Boithang Haokip: in Mumbai FC
  • Climate change led to surge in JE cases ?
  • Discussion on Democratisation of Myanmar
  • Ignoring the route that feeds the people
  • Terror foresees even before election
  • Kwak Tanba @Sana Konung #1: Gallery
  • Kakching Keithel : Gallery
  • Irawat the Legend #3
  • How can CM intervene in a central varsity?
  • Reform Resistant & Patience Fatigue
  • Library movement in Manipur #1
  • Manipur boys show intent in NE's show
  • Manipuri festival celebrated at Moodbidri
  • Twitter thread alleges CRPF harassment
  • The Moreh effect on policy
  • Hiyanggei Gee thabal in Delhi
  • Ratan urges Union Minister on MU crisis
  • Casting the shadow of the Lim demand
  • Will Ibobi returns back as Chief Minister?
  • Meitei Chanu Beauty Peagent #1: Gallery
  • Khunung Eeshei by Goshe #3 :: e-pao Radio
  • Home Stay @Mapao Zingsho: Gallery
  • Inner Line Permit Bill: Submitted by APSCS
  • Education in the Valley & the Hills Areas #1
  • In conversation with Monish Karam
  • Manipur cheer as Amur falcons arrive
  • Saving the next generation from HIV
  • Blood donation drive in Delhi
  • NESCH seeks clarification from Gurgaon
  • Heavy rains trigger flash floods in Moreh
  • Zeliang to attend meet on accord in Manipur
  • Battle line is drawn : BJP versus Congress
  • Imphal-Jiri road: a tool for political gimmick
  • Heisnam Kanhailal :: Profile
  • Bor khoiramnaba @Hiyangthang #1: Gallery
  • Mng ama :: Poem
  • Movements In Manipur, 1891-1947 #1
  • Zeliangrongs: Law on murder cases #4
  • Course in News Reporting at Senapati
  • HSLC Exam-2017 Mock Test at Kwakeithel
  • Sahitya Parishad Meghalaya Awardees 2016
  • Manipur set to reel under blockades
  • All eyes on Manipur University
  • Stop politicizing the Sports' University
  • epao feeds & updates : Android Apps
  • Lamyanba Irabot Birth Anniv #3: Gallery
  • History of Inner Line Permit System
  • Far from the madding crowd : Poem
  • NE Fest @Pondicherry Univ: Gallery
  • FATHOM 16: NE Fest in Pondicherry
  • Petition to Govt of Manipur on welfare
  • Against natural justice
  • Phiyowon @ Kachui (Ukhrul) #3 : Gallery
  • Mass rally against bandh #2 : Gallery
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) :: Timeline
  • Raseshori Pala troupe @Bheigyachandra
  • Meeyamgi Luchingba :: Poem
  • Rice Harvesting at Purul, Senapati: Gallery
  • Soft Target @Sign Film Festival
  • Meitei Women in Collectives #2
  • World Tourism Day #2 : Gallery
  • Lamlong Keithel #2 : Gallery
  • What is Buddhism ?
  • Potential of Space Technology
  • Job Requirement at JCRE Skill Solutions
  • Legal Awareness Program at CCpur
  • Tenders invited from CEO, Manipur
  • Jobs @ Directorate of Treasuries, Manipur
  • Kakching Garden @Uyok Ching #1: Gallery
  • 218 Bheigyachandra Death Anniv: Gallery
  • Changing the Fortunes of NE : Jobsenz
  • Goondaism on the campus
  • Joseph Ki Macha selected for Film Bazaar
  • Ngamok :: Poem
  • Farm mechanization for employment #3
  • Courses in Cinematography, Screen Play..
  • Nurse-turned-actress Anamika : eRang
  • Lamyanba Irabot Birth Anniv #2: Gallery
  • Kakching Lamkhai : Gallery
  • Ukhrul in cherry blooming season : Gallery
  • Mass rally against bandh #1 : Gallery
  • Irawat the Legend #1
  • Irom Sharmila agitation :: News Timeline
  • Cleanliness Drive- Police/AMWJU : Gallery
  • Ningel safeguarding traditional Salt
  • Jananeta :: Poem
  • Book published on Irabot Day : Download
  • Irabot Day Observance @Delhi: Gallery
  • Psyche of dreams- own your dream!
  • Lamyanba Irabot Birth Anniv #1: Gallery
  • Mapao : One of oldest villages in Manipur
  • Fashion Show @IITF, Delhi : Gallery
  • More Families Should Come Out :EEVFAM
  • Make Heritage Fun! Imphal : Gallery
  • Non-Local Peoples Bill : Draft [Sep 27]
  • Houdong Lamboiba & Pebet :: Funga Wari
  • The Cajon Diaries : Gallery
  • Thokchom Anuradha (Hockey) : Gallery
  • Featured Photo for year 2016 #4 :: Gallery
  • Khuga Dam, Churachandpur : Gallery
  • Chilli Festival @Ukhrul #3: Gallery
  • Sahnit Ni (Black Day) #3 :: Gallery
  • Linda Thangjam (Singer) Gallery : eRang
  • At a cave in Dzukou Valley : Gallery
  • Loktak lake #6 : Gallery
  • Meetei ST demand Rally : Gallery
  • Heikru Hidongba #2 : Gallery
  • Rail Construction @Noney : Gallery
  • Anal Cultural Dance :: Ooba Video
  • Manipur Phone Directory :: e-pao Tools