Protective Thinking: Greater Nagaland or Mini Nagaland?
- Part-II -

Pakinrichapbo *

A proposed map of Nagalim covering other States in the North East region and part of Myanmar
A proposed map of Nagalim covering other States in the North East region and part of Myanmar :: Pix - TSE

Observing the impasse to Naga Peace Talk (21 years impasse) and the latest outburst of apprehension by Naga Hoho, the only way forward now is by having practical understanding of the political theory that, 'state can only be created by the people not given as a gift'. The same political theory applies to achieving Greater Nagaland and sooner the better; Nagas give up the full dependency on GoI to integrate its contiguous territories.

No doubt Naga Nationalist view themselves negotiating as equal entity between heads of two different Nations but it is really frustrating to see Naga leaders repeatedly committing past mistakes of fully depending on GoI and remaining helpless for 21 years. GoI still appears unwilling to take risk even after 21 years of peace talk so what more evidences do people need to authenticate that central government would not give consent to integration until Nagas successfully dealt with neighboring states, in fact central govt. has conveyed difficulties on their part being opposed by neighboring states yet Naga leaders still fail to deal with neighboring states.

Furthermore studying the Naga integration issues, it is ridiculous that till today, Naga leaders have not learnt any lesson from Mao Gate Episode 2010 where Manipur Government successfully banned Mr. Th. Muivah, NSCN IM General Secretary from visiting his native Somdal village in Ukhrul district Manipur. During the said crisis, GoI after giving clearance did not oppose Manipur govt. decisions stating that law and order is a state subject even when Nagas expected GoI on account of ceasefire and peace talk to intervene on Mr. Muivah's visit yet it never happen.

When Manipur government strongly opposes top Naga Nationalist leader visit to his native village how will Manipur and its loyal citizens react to any change in Manipur State territories is the urgent question Nagas need to seriously ponder upon and act upon it instead of helplessly accusing Manipur government including other states governments of not acknowledging Nagas legitimate right to integration on account of their distinct history, in such sensitive matter loyal citizens of Manipur and other states involved will never acknowledge in thousand years as they are fully determined their states interest while Nagas are still in disarray owing to power abuse by leaders and their failure in dealing efficiently with its multiple internal challenges.

Nagas ought to realize that sticking to Plan-A that is continuously giving free history lesson on Naga unique history to Non-Naga ethnic groups is not going to put Nagas on the path to integration unless they make necessary compromise in some sensitive issues like land territorial ownership to win support of some certain ethnic groups in neighboring states.

Nagas still owned huge area of unoccupied lands so giving up some area of lands and swapping of lands along with its populations in exchange for unflinching support of non Naga ethnic groups would not be a bad start moreover certain ethnic groups can never be in advantage position to achieve their political goals unless Nagas intervene, such arrangement can be a win-win situation for parties involved and steadily breaking the current impasse. Sticking to Plan-A for 21 years would not break the impasse; it's time to come with different plans and begin exploring options of Plan A-Z before Nagas end up with nothing by refusing to settle with something.

Apart from the recent declarations and activities of Manipur based CSOs and Manipur State Assembly resolution to protect state territorial integrity what really catches our eye is the latest statement of Manipur CM Mr. N. Biren Singh where he warn that the Government of Manipur would be compelled to take "extreme" steps if "Naga Deal" hurts Manipur's interests, though one cannot comprehend what will be his extreme steps it still leave a bad taste to a democratic society.

He also said in his interview with The Hindustan Times that while his government is in favour of a peaceful settlement of the Naga political issue, the central government must take the consent of the state assembly if the settlement involves any part of Manipur- be it cultural, administrative, economic or territorial.

While the latest outburst of warning of taking extreme steps from Manipur's CM does not matches to be the words coming from the head of one of democratic Indian states. Rather the Manipur's CM responded like a warlord. My point is that, the Manipur's CM warning of taking extreme steps is unconstitutional and is a blatant violation of the provisions of Article 3 of the Indian Constitutions. To his response no Naga leaders has so far issued warning of taking any extreme steps to those who oppose Naga integration only UNC has asked fellow Nagas to be ready for any form of agitation which I believed would be a lawful democratic agitation not burning govt. offices or intimidating Non-Nagas.

To prove my point that statement of Manipur CM is unconstitutional, learned people of Manipur and other states cannot deny the constitutional provisions of Article 3, which clearly states, that the Indian Constitution empowers the parliament to alter the territories or names, etc of the states without their consent or concurrence, which unambiguously means that state central government does not require consent from any Indian states of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh to grant Naga integration provided central government is bold enough to do it.( my emphasis) It can form new States, and can alter the area, boundaries or names of the existing States by a law passed by simple majority.

The conditions laid down for making of such law are- First, no Bill for the formation of new States or the alteration of the boundaries or the names of the existing State shall be introduced in either House of the Parliament except on the recommendation of the President.

Secondly, if the Bill affects the area, boundaries or names of the States, the President is required to refer the Bill to the Legislatures of the State, so affected for expressing its views within the period specified by the President. The President may extend the period so specified. If the State Legislature to which the Bill has been referred does not express its views within the period so specified or extended, the Bill may be introduced in the parliament even though the views of the State have not been obtained by the President.

If the State Legislature expresses its view within the time so specified or extended, the Parliament is not bound to accept or act upon the views of the State Legislature. Thus, it is clear that the very existence of a State depends on the sweet will of the Central Government. (Constitutional Law of India, J.N. Pandey, CLA, P-39).

From Constitution point of view; the statement of Manipur's CM, Manipur based CSOs warning of another riots like of 18 June Uprising including the statement of Former CM of Assam Tarun Gogoi, that no one should bypass the territorial rights of a state are all unconstitutional as it is the parliament who is the supreme authority to decide on state territorial rights not the states themselves. Citizens have legal rights to protest peacefully not to instigate riots; Central Government cannot give repeated excuses of law and order being a state subject to avoid dealing with riots at the same time make crucial decision to settle Naga Peace Talks

The above mentioned states did behave like India's neighboring independent nations states not under the Union of India which is a direct challenge to the basic structure of the Constitution and belittle the supremacy of the Parliament.

Having pointed out the unconstitutional stand taken by state governments of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh in opposing Naga integration, the huge setback for the Nagas is the lack of political consciousness among the mass of Naga populations unlike their fellow counterparts of other states who are very much participating in political arena under one umbrella in pursuing and protecting their political interest while among general Naga population certain sections exists who develop cold-feet to its own integration due to numerous factors involved, if remain unresolved will later cause unmanageable disaster.

The political drama of Naga integration appears not likely to find it end soon and the parties opposing Naga integration cannot override the provisions of the Constitution nor give twisted interpretation on any laws as they are doing right now.

In the end, fate of the divided Nagas shall be decided by their actions alone not entirely by their distinct history.

Along the way, Naga leaders ought to remember famous quote of Albert Einstein's, which says, "Madness Is Doing the Same Thing Over and Over Again and Expecting Different Results."

* Pakinrichapbo wrote this article for
The writer is an Advocate from Peren District, Nagaland and can be reached at pakinchawang(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was posted on August 06, 2018.

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Kayada Ningthijaba Lambino : Listen..
  • Billie's Book: A Children's Book : Review
  • Homage to an Apolitical Politician
  • Delhi, through the lense of a Manipuri
  • RPL Certificate of North Tripura
  • Alphabet of Silence :: Poem
  • Business Process Manager @ Globizs
  • Unsettled crisis
  • Now let the probe team do its job
  • Marangwon @Kangkhui #2 : Gallery
  • Cordillera in North Philippines : Gallery
  • Ithai Barrage and popular resistance
  • Moral education for a harmonious Society
  • Bad unity
  • Career in nutrition and dietetics
  • Locally made product- 'The Lois' launched
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • The want for more
  • Only catchy phrases & alluring documents
  • Expedite FA Rally #1 : Gallery
  • Merger & Manipur State Congress #1
  • Cry of a Dying River - 41 :: Poem
  • A recreation park for elderly
  • High-time NE recreate itself as brands
  • Natural skin detox
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • 72nd Independence Day by AR
  • Independence Day - for whom
  • Nongpok Thong Hangba
  • Khubak Eeshei @Kang festival : Gallery
  • Punsi Sangba, Mathiupuang :: eMing
  • Arresting decline of higher education
  • RPL-PMKVY Certificate at Tripura
  • Silence :: Poem
  • AFSPA took my father
  • Dark Net: Underbelly of the internet
  • Alternative Arrangement, Article 371A
  • Petition challenging dilution AFSPA
  • Rio for integration of Naga areas
  • Brought NE closer to Delhi: PM
  • Independence Day celebrated in NE
  • Tikendrajit : The Lion of Manipur #1
  • Compressed Earth Blocks: Housing
  • Support breastfeeding among adolescent
  • Ithai: Development Decision Gone Awry
  • Who made the sports university ours?
  • An Unoccupied Forehead :: Poem
  • 'NRC should not be a political issue'
  • Independence Day : Govt needs trust
  • Apprehensions before final pact
  • NNC stand to protect Naga sovereignty
  • 'Delay in solution irks people'
  • Patriots' Day- Floral Tribute : Gallery
  • A shot at survival
  • Demography and Population Studies
  • RPL-PMKVY Certificate at Baishalgarh
  • E-Commerce to help access new markets
  • Manipur Heart Foundation Anniversary
  • Artist lineup for NH7 Weekender
  • Kakching World War-II Memorial Run
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • AMPWA observed Patriots' Day
  • Real homage or just showmanship
  • Drama of political clout at MU
  • Patriots' Day @ Kolkata : Gallery
  • Historical War fought by Manipur
  • Where are the nurses in HIV response?
  • Understanding false smut of rice
  • The love song of autumn :: Poem
  • Help Underprivileged Sports Youngsters
  • Police : List of Awardees on I-Day
  • NSCN-IM word on Naga unity
  • Scribes demand colleague's release
  • Jadugi Mingsel :: Folk Tale
  • Patriotism Redefined [On 13th Aug]
  • Karate Winners felicitated at Kumbi
  • Of Citizenship & Manipur People's Bill
  • Seminar : Path & Pattern in Northeast
  • 42nd Indian Social Science Congress
  • Certificate Distribution at Tripura
  • Failure by WPS-IE to arrest rapist
  • Resolutions : People's Democratic Alliance
  • ..Will it burnt the state again
  • ..Now get the killers !
  • 'Homecoming', Painting Exhibition : Gallery
  • Legacy of Resistance in Cordillera Highland
  • Woke Up, But You're Nowhere :: Poem
  • Resurgence of Sanamahism
  • Nagas & Meiteis must live together
  • No change in 1951 as Base Year : JCILPS
  • B. Voc. at DM Community College
  • Young Scholars Conference 2018
  • ..legitimacy of remaining to power
  • The precursor of things to come
  • Khangkhui Cave , Ukhrul #4 : Gallery
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba #2 : Gallery
  • Reform Manipur's Education System
  • Friendship
  • Cry of a Dying River - 40
  • World's Indigenous Peoples Day
  • Chandigarh students' solidarity with MU
  • MU agitator should withdraw their agitation
  • Repercussion of a prejudice attitude
  • Regulate school vans/buses
  • Disputed Myanmar Border Pillar : Gallery
  • Seven Breaths of Dragon :: Book Rvw
  • Chronological framework of NRC
  • Buttering Najmaji in public
  • JRF Post at Mizoram University
  • Manipur Tourism : Festival Promotion Award
  • The uneasy shift
  • Well co-ordinated rallies across dists
  • Chalwa Village, Kangpokpi #1 : Gallery
  • General strike on article 371 (A) #2 : Gallery
  • Up against the saffron brigade
  • My unsailed ship :: Poem
  • Mathematics and Science Competition
  • General Strike by ATSUM on August 10
  • Drawing Competition at Wapokpi, Bishnupur
  • ADBU delivers course to Indian Railways
  • One man that put Manipur in frying pan
  • Relax MU shut down !
  • Khumang Pokpa Haraoba #2: Gallery
  • Robert Naorem @Blr Fashion Week : Gallery
  • Territorial integrity of Manipur
  • The string :: Poem
  • General Strike by KIM on August 8
  • Robert Naorem at Bangalore Fashion Week
  • Dr. Monisha Behal's work in North East
  • Registrations for IIT Techniche workshop
  • PDA on situation in Nagaland
  • The politics of divide: MU
  • Significance of August
  • Mukna Khong Kangjei #3 : Gallery
  • Greater Nagaland or Mini Nagaland? #2
  • Paint Your City : Campaign at Kakching
  • Pemberton line in Kabaw is our boundary
  • Awakening :: Poem
  • Coffee Plantation : In-lieu of Poppy
  • Recalling of AK Pandey by HRD Ministry
  • TSA's reply to KNO/KNA's allegations
  • 21st Manipur Integrity Day : Gallery
  • Konung Kang Chingba #3 : Gallery
  • Ecological, social impact of Ithai Barrage #3
  • Swindling Manipuris in solving Naga issue
  • The Last of the Romantics :: Poem
  • 'Thoughts on MU strategies'
  • Concerned about continued closure of MU
  • Fear factor
  • No takers for 1 month leave
  • View from Shirui Hills #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur as seen by Meiteis, Nagas, & Zo
  • Certificate Distribution at Nirjuli, ArP
  • Contract Jobs available at NIELIT HQs
  • Cry of a Dying River - 39 :: Poem
  • Banana flower vada
  • Entrance for Free Residential IAS Coaching
  • Resolution of NPF Consultative Meeting
  • Concerned about militants' interference
  • Issues : From ILP, MU to FA
  • Emergence Nongda Lairen Pakhangba #2
  • MU Rally at Canchipur : Gallery
  • News Analysis 0f Akashvani Imphal
  • ILP: A Genuine Idea Lost in Translation
  • Tryst with an Alzheimer's patient #2
  • Letter to Prime Minister of India
  • Female DTP faculty reqd at Protocol
  • In between :: Poem
  • Sowing the seeds of Greater Lim
  • General strike on article 371 (A) #1 : Gallery
  • Student is important or AP Pandey
  • Article 371A is sui generis
  • Protection on Land, Environment at TML
  • Press Conference on MU Crisis at Delhi
  • Oppose extension of Article 371(A)
  • DTP-Desktop Publishing course at Nambol
  • Certificate Distribution at Namsai, ArP
  • Rejoinder to KNO/KNA on Moreh attack
  • Issues which burn Manipur State Assembly
  • The brand of politics in MU crisis
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #3 : Gallery
  • August Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • Protest against MHRD @Delhi : Gallery
  • People's Strike greets this August
  • Slump in fight against #AIDS
  • What does moonlight want ? :: Poem
  • MU students protest against MHRD
  • An Unknown killer - "E-Waste"
  • Talking peace and threatening others
  • Singcha Wuya Won @Kamjong #1 : Gallery
  • Dismal Politics in Universities
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba #1 : Gallery
  • Engulfing Uncertainties
  • Ecological, social impact of Ithai Barrage #2
  • Certificate Distribution at Dibang, ArP
  • EEVFAM case: Report for 30 July
  • Pertaining to statement of T. R. Zeliang
  • Issues plaguing the state
  • What is the stand of BJP Govt ?
  • Monsoon Assembly Session : Gallery
  • Election 2019: end of road for Modi
  • The absurd baby talk :: Poem
  • Assam University BTech, MTech Admission
  • Saving the Rhinos - Campaign
  • Arrest perpetrators of Moreh attack
  • Training programmes of NCC
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #2 : Gallery
  • MU: Students clash with Police #2: Gallery
  • Prospects of coffee in Manipur
  • Why ILP should not be implemented
  • Hill students get alert on Trafficking
  • IBSD Meghalaya inaugurated
  • Conference on India-Vietnam
  • Govt's strategically pre planned conflict
  • Heart ruptured but life saved
  • Pseudo intellectuals should stop thinking
  • Mass sit-in protest : How about Nagaland?
  • Folklore genres of Meetei community
  • Kang Khichri chaba : Gallery
  • Binalakshmi Nepram at United Nations, NY
  • Out to clear her name
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #1 : Gallery
  • Our Common Crisis: What are We to Do #3
  • Pay Nareckpi : Funga Wari
  • Kayada Ningthijaba Lambino : Story telling
  • Yumkhaibam Nanao: Walking from Delhi..
  • Ningol Pali at Kang Festival : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba : Gallery
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #3: Gallery
  • Art Exhibit @Imphal Art College #1 : Gallery
  • Kang Khichri chaba @Kwakeithel : Gallery
  • Dzuko valley #4 :: 360 Panorama View
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • HSLC 208 Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Class XII Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Temples of Manipur : Gallery
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic