TODAY -

Experimenting with Supra State Body
- Separating Politics and Culture –

Yenning *



Students rally in Ukhrul demanding 'Alternative Arrangement' :: 25th November 2011
Students rally in Ukhrul demanding "Alternative Arrangement" :: 25th November 2011 - Pix :: Jimmy Leivon



The news story broken by the Guwahati based Seven Sisters Post about the Government of India's offer for a Supra State body to NSCN-IM for administering Naga people beyond the boundary of the present State of Nagaland in such areas as culture, custom and tradition has, as expected, generated mixed responses across the whole North East region.

Hopes and apprehensions evoked by the news story are more discernible in Manipur than in Assam and Arunachal Pradesh, the other two States broadly encompassed by the proposed Supra State body. Much before the Government of India's offer for Supra State body was made public by the Seven Sisters Post, Naga frontal organisations under the captaincy of the United Naga Council (UNC) have imposed economic blockade on the national highways connecting Imphal with other cities of India and it is still going on.

Initially, the highway blockade was launched to counter the indefinite blockade imposed by the Sardar Hills Districthood Demand Committee (SHDDC) against the latter's pursuit of a separate Sadar Hills district. However, the UNC, till date, has not displayed any intention to lift the counter blockade even though the blockade which they intended to counter was lifted 26 days back.

It is no longer a counter blockade but purely a blockade. The moment SHDDC lifted their blockade, the UNC's justification for the counter blockade vanished in thin air. Yet, the counter blockade continues, and now the UNC's vindication is New Delhi's failure to take forward the process for alternative arrangement (for the Nagas of Manipur).

Here we cannot overlook the fact that UNC's renewed demand for alternative arrangement came at a time when New Delhi's offer for Supra State body was already made public. The UNC, as per news reports published by The Sangai Express on November 22, 2011, maintained that the ongoing economic blockade would be called off once the Government of India sends its feedback over the alternative arrangement demand. Again, the same report quoted the UNC as stating that "the matter (Supra State body) is at a high-level Indo-Naga talk process".

In view of the re-invigorated campaign for alternative arrangement and the report about the offer for Supra State body, which of course was rejected by the Home Minister of India, Shri. P. Chidambaram as "baseless and mischievous", only to be rebuffed by the Seven Sisters Post boldly calling the Home Minister untruthful, it would be rather interesting and meaningful to explore possible ramifications as well as the underlying concept of the proposed Supra State body.

Supra State Body

According to the report published by the Seven Sisters Post about the negotiation between New Delhi and NSCN-IM, the pan-Naga Supra State body was drawn up by New Delhi in response to NSCN-IM's persistent demand for integration of Naga inhabited areas under a single political entity to be called Nagalim (greater Nagaland). NSCN-IM leadership put their demand in this way.

It is the position of the NSCN that the present so-called state of Nagaland comprises only portion of Nagaland and that more realistic boundaries should be agreed upon that enable the Naga areas to be integrated within one administrative entity. The portions of Nagaland which are situated in present day Myanmar will not form part of the present negotiations.

Response of the Indian negotiators: Under law boundaries of State can be altered only after taking into consideration the views of the concerned State Legislators. The views of the Government of Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh and Assam are very clear in this regard. Therefore, it would not be possible to concede to the demand in the absence of political consensus from all concerned.

Therefore, NSCN (IM) may think of 'second best' if the 'best' in their view is not possible. Possible autonomy of Naga areas without altering the boundaries of the State's concerned so that in many matters, the representatives of the hill areas may administer the subjects in their charge along with a supra State body for the Nagas for their cultural, social and customary practices may be discussed. This pan-Naga Supra State body will be in the recognition of the distinct identity of the Nagas.

It is clear that NSCN-IM leadership have been demanding physical integration of the Nagas against which New Delhi is offering some sort of cultural unification of the Nagas through the proposed Supra State body.

NSCN-IM leadership have not made any official comment on the proposed Supra State body. At the same time, New Delhi has not yet disclosed any details about the functions and operational mode of the pan-Naga (cultural) body. As of now, what we understand is that the proposed Supra State body would administer the Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh in their cultural, social and customary practices. The Supra State body will not have the power to oversee the security aspect of the Naga inhabited areas (beyond the present State of Nagaland). The report published by the Seven Sisters Post states "Law and order and police will entirely be the call of the concerned State Governments but the Supra State body will advise the concerned State agencies on the implementation of different projects in the Naga areas".

The obvious implication of this arrangement, if it is true, is that Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh would have political affiliation to the respective State Governments while at the same time their cultural, social and customary practices would be governed by the Supra State body based outside the States. This would create not only a dicey situation but also breed a serious dilemma among the Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh.

And we are not sure if this arrangement would be welcomed by the Nagas living outside Nagaland. Instead of the present single authority of which they are subjects, Nagas would be made subjects of two separate authorities—the concerned State Governments and a pervasive Supra State body. In fact, the Supra State body is a bold initiative of the Government of India to arrive at an honourable solution after 13 years of peace talk with NSCN-IM but we cannot help asking if politics, culture and social practices can ever be separated as intended by the Supra State body.

First, let's appreciate the positive aspect of the proposed body. It is true that granting rights to ethnic groups, such as the Nagas, can ensure their domination. The present proposal goes beyond the form of federalism and consociationalism prevalent in India for the establishment of multiethnic States. The earlier approach supports ethnic pluralism, while the final position, integration, foresees its decline with the gradual building of social and cultural cohesion.

The present proposal or position in the form of a supra body is strongly advocated in the United Kingdom, where multiculturalism was officially abandoned in 2004 due to its perceived effect as ethnically divisive, in favour of policies concerned with community cohesion ad integration. In other words, the United Kingdom was already experimen-ting with the idea of supra body. Here, integration is seen as encompassing the goals of ethnic equality and ethnic interaction, with strong concern over ethnic groups that lead parallel and separated lives.

However, the problem is, India is not United Kingdom. The latter is a unitary State, meaning to say that the Government of United Kingdom directly deals with the ethnic minorities, formulates and implements the policies directly. In the case of India, as much as New Delhi or the Nagas desires, the State Governments can never be bypassed. This has been clearly admitted by New Delhi. Moreover, the case of United Kingdom relates more with immigrant population, not the natives. Finally, one is yet to assess the achievements of such a policy even in the case of UK.

In the context of the proposed supra body, one is reminded of the dual administration of Manipur during British colonialism after the Anglo-Manipur War of 1891, which was characterised by separation between political-economy and culture and religion. The former was an absolute realm of the British (including the administration of the hill areas) wherein the King of Manipur did not have any say.

The latter, that is, culture and religion, was a domain of the native ruler. We are familiar with the chaotic situation that ensued, which in fact planted the seeds of separation between the valley people and the hills. Thus, one can even go to the extent that the proposed supra body is not a new one but a revisit of colonial policies.

Coming to the present understanding of "the political", political theories ranging from the varied liberal tradition to the Marxist including critical theory as well the subaltern, denies the separation between politics and culture. In either way, culture has to form a part of the politics or politics has to take into account the cultural stratum.

Any political or administrative policy, which calls for a dichotomy between the two is likely to result in collision of authority (State Government versus the Supra State body) without bringing any benefits to the stakeholders. The idea of the supra body instead of bringing desired results, say ending the vexed Naga issue, is bound to generate rounds of conflict in the North East.


* Yenning wrote this article for The Sangai Express in a regular column "Hoi Polloi & Mundanity"
The writer can be reached at yenning05(at)rocketmail(dot)com or visit hoipolloiandmundanity.blogspot.com
This article was posted on November 29, 2011.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • RIMS areas disinfected - [March 26] : Gallery
  • Makanmi, Namthujin, Sayoni: eMing
  • Status Update 27 March: Medical Directorate
  • Covid-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Manipur Govt Orders/Directives : 27 March
  • FEGOCTA donate 1 Day Salary to CM's Fund
  • Cure for COVID
  • What a respect to the caregivers !
  • Charity Mission Committee on COVID-19
  • NH7 Weekender : Online music festival
  • Lockdown amid curfew
  • PDS rice to CMHT excluded Keishamthong?
  • Curfew in Imphal - [March 24] : Gallery
  • COVID-19 helpline numbers in Manipur
  • Screening at Mao [Mar 20] : Gallery
  • COVID 19 & Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897
  • Decoding Tax Jargon through March Ending
  • NPF urged Nagaland Govt on COVID-19
  • Food items to Child Care Institutes
  • Hand rub bottles manufactured & distributed
  • Studying the total shutdown in Manipur
  • Cheiraoba Chak Katpa #1 : Gallery
  • Social Distancing observed [Mar 25] : Gallery
  • An appeal to all on COVID19
  • What is love ? :: Poem
  • Career option in Geomagnetism
  • Kohima gets a brand new song
  • Communique on Covid-19 : Nagaland Oppn
  • CM Covid-19 Relief Fund created
  • 12 on board flight with patient quarantined
  • Quiet celebration of Cheiraoba
  • Quarantine started- Mao -Mar 24 : Gallery
  • Leikai Public curfew -Mar 24 : Gallery
  • Stop stigma of Covid 19 +Positive Friends
  • Media : Essential services during lockdown
  • Acts of Kindness, Unity among Communities
  • Racist attacks on people from North-east
  • A friend in need is a friend indeed
  • Enforce total lockdown in Nagaland :: NPCC
  • Ugly response to positive case of COVID-19
  • First Case in Manipur
  • Lamphel Nawa Kombirei at Cheiraoba
  • Woman returned from UK has Coronavirus
  • Screening at Mao - Mar 22 : Gallery
  • Why PM want Leishemba to be RS MP #1
  • Janata Curfew - 'Go corona' festival
  • Panacea for Economic Collapse: COVID-19
  • Total Lockdown till March 31st
  • Sajibu Cheiraoba - Meitei New Year Day
  • Giving racial twist to coronavirus
  • Need action to those mocking PM
  • COVID: Janata Curfew -Mar 22 #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur Govt Orders - Mar 22 : Gallery
  • Status Update 22 March: Medical Dir Lamphel
  • We will get by. We will survive.
  • Covid-19: Impact in Manipur :: Photos/News..
  • War against Corona
  • What ails Indian Railways
  • Appeal to Govt during COVID 19 crisis
  • Hats off to the men in white
  • COVID-19: Ima Keithel -March 21 : Gallery
  • Bandh on March 21 : Gallery
  • Social Justice & Democracy in Northeast
  • Sociology of Coronavirus
  • COCOMI extended help to victims of Chassad
  • The Omnipresent Fear :: Poem
  • MU Chemistry Dept makes hand sanitisers
  • COVID-19 : A blessing for Khwairamband
  • Wakching Thagi Sanarei #2 :: eRang
  • Who will rebuild Chahsat village ?
  • The untameable :: Poem
  • Importance of Fish & Fishery in Manipur
  • Challenges for female entrepreneur in India
  • The Killing Fields 2013-20 : News Timeline
  • How well prepared is Manipur?
  • More seriousness needed to fight COVID-19
  • Khongu NangGi Baasi :: Shumang Leela
  • Yaoshang Fancy Dress #1 : Gallery
  • Journalistic Challenges in Reporting Chassad
  • Paneer Our Daughter's Delight
  • Civil Site Engineer / Site Manager
  • Architectural Designer at R-Square
  • Research Officer - Financial at Amethyst
  • Chinky to Coronavirus: Racial profiling chain
  • Promises, prosperity, Rights & Responsibility
  • Wars, Devastation & events in Kakching #1
  • When Chassad Blazed Our Hearts Burnt
  • Nagas entering final phase of power struggle
  • Climate change & predator : Any link?
  • Restore Chassad village to normal condition
  • The other side of Covid-19
  • Is Manipur taking adequate steps?
  • Silencing the voice of dissent
  • Dzukou Valley, Senapati #3 : Gallery
  • Condemns the burning at Chassad Village
  • Conduct fact finding mission at Kamjong
  • Lost at the edge of uncertainty!
  • Global Youth Peace Conclave postponed
  • Entrance exams after 10 + 2
  • Workshop organized on Einstein's birthday
  • Titular King in the race for RS
  • Coronavirus, H1N1 & garbage in Imphal
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand : Timeline
  • Yaoshang Sports Meet #2 : Gallery
  • Restoring Chassad- the village with no house
  • Manipur Maharaj & House of Lords
  • COVID-19 : Hand sanitizers at Bangalore
  • Appeal to install Covid-19 test in Nagaland
  • Communal violence & over-lap ethnic aspiration
  • Understanding Ponzi scheme
  • Yaoshang Halankar #1 : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Sports Meet #1 : Gallery
  • Nano Technology in Bio Organic Fertilizer
  • Joydev Thongam: Story behind the muscles
  • COVID-19: Agent to end Economic Globalisation
  • Cannabis in HIV and AIDS
  • Is society gender-sensitive enough ?
  • Day light Thabal Chongba #1 : Gallery
  • Intl Women's Day @ Imphal : Gallery
  • International Rivers Day at Kangoi Area
  • Getting workplace ready for COVID-19
  • A Tale on Yaoshang :: Poem
  • India's improving journo-murder index
  • But Leishemba should also act politically
  • Yaoshang Marathon @ Singjamei : Gallery
  • Wangkhem Rezia : Success Stories NE
  • Guwahati Music Festival #2 : Gallery
  • A Beautiful Mind :: Poem
  • Of Purity and Arrival of Spring
  • Fr Biju Michael - Salesian South Asia
  • Yaoshang Cheng Khaiba : Gallery
  • Saroi Khangba @ Khwairamband : Gallery
  • Intl Women's Day @ Bangalore : Gallery
  • Women's health & nutirition - A glance
  • Manipur band wins at Guwahati Intl Music Fest
  • Human Beings as a bait in battle of Vice
  • 2019 Year review : Ministry of AYUSH #2
  • Journalist Sports Meet: Winner announced
  • Manipur schools to close till March 31
  • Shah's Manipur visit postponed
  • Family of late Shaiza clarifies
  • Yaoshang Rock @Sagolband :: Gallery
  • MOU - Guest House at Mandalay :: Gallery
  • #VOLUNTEER4HEALTH launched at Delhi
  • Summer breeze and Autumn leaves :: Poem
  • Why afraid of corona ?
  • Yaoshang Thabal at Bangalore postponed
  • 2nd year of PDA..lots of controversy
  • Yaoshang Mei Thaba :: Gallery
  • Until the right time, I had let you go :: Poem
  • Festival of Holi- Brahma Kumaris concept
  • Women studies as career choice
  • Consultative meeting with NPF Manipur
  • Condemns killing, calls for action against AR
  • Yaoshang Mei Loukhatpa @ Kangla :: Gallery
  • Health Camp at Pune :: Gallery
  • International Women's Day at Bangalore
  • Universal access to sexual health services
  • Health Camp on Women's Day at Pune
  • More employment for our politicians
  • Gender Resource Centre in Agriculture
  • Entry points at Indo-Myanmar border sealed
  • Peace rallies urge PM for early Naga solution
  • Reversing masculinization of India's workforce
  • Torch Rally: Journalist Sports: Gallery
  • CAA - An Act of isolation & destruction
  • Economic growth or grimmer ..Coronavirus
  • Tribal Youth Fest Marks Women's Day
  • Holi skin and hair care tips
  • Politics of South China Sea Disputes : Book
  • CM's appeal : Scale down Yaoshang revelry
  • 1st Barak Festival @Senapati: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2020 #1: Gallery
  • Yaoshang (Holi) Festival :: Book
  • Churup Ki Mahao : Short story
  • Gender equality still a distant dream
  • Remove Chairperson, Women Commission
  • Celebrating Women's day
  • Phisakol - Film Scenes #2 :: eRang
  • yeniHTa :: Seireng
  • N Romeo promoted to Brigadier at Army
  • Cry of a Dying River
  • Never closer & this is only beginning
  • Vacancy at Info Trade, Lamphelpat
  • Ugly development at exam centre
  • Govt should think before dealing Salai case
  • Yaoshang Thabal Peisa donation: Gallery
  • Sangai Festival [Nov 28] #2 : Gallery
  • Message from a breast cancer thriver
  • Leishangthem Bala : NE Success Stories
  • A Bhakta: Treasurer- Indian Journalist Union
  • The unique 63 Saints Festival
  • Restrictions on Thabal Chongba
  • Essence of celebrating Yaoshang
  • World Meetei Convention @Cachar : Gallery
  • Women Empowerment :: Poem
  • Licypriya Kangujam to address at Washington
  • Bringing Into Disrepute ?
  • 10th Journalist Sports Meet, 2020
  • Women in Armed Forces
  • The virtues of virtual marketing
  • Negligence by child institution of Imphal East
  • From Wuhan to over 70 countries
  • Killer virus reaches neighbouring Myanmar
  • Lui-ngai-ni, Naga festival @Ukhrul #3 : Gallery
  • 13th Mega Marathon Manipur #3 : Gallery
  • A fish in the jar :: Poem
  • Empowerment of rural women: reference to NE
  • Jobs at Lalon.in , Keishamthong
  • We can't lose more Boa SR
  • Mock Exercise on Disaster Management
  • Krishnam Classical Festival at Guwahati
  • Politics behind war of words
  • Empowering women- Manipur's perspectives
  • Importance of basic science research
  • Women are the foundation of a healthy nation
  • Rice Distributed in Bengaluru
  • Civil Services Examination 2020
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Guwahati Music Festival : Last Day Report
  • Expulsion Order : Chizami Area Unit NPF
  • Irom Sanju : Judo coach, Grand Prix, Morocco
  • No cure, highly contagious: Prevention only way
  • Stop bullying young talents
  • Lining up for delimitation, ADC polls
  • Belief in Goddess Imoinu
  • Guwahati Intl Music Festival : Gallery
  • Maniacal Negative Viral(ism) in Manipur
  • The Friday Evening Blues :: Poem
  • Men-Tsee-Khang Imphal branch clinic open
  • Guwahati Music Festival : Day 1 Report
  • Saroi Khangba @ Imphal #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • March Calendar for Year 2020 : Tools
  • Manipur Budget, 2020 & 12 challenges
  • The Nymph of Kangleipak :: Poem
  • How smoking & alcohol affect beauty
  • Sporting spirit & Yaosang Festival
  • Shopping List - Shivaratri #2 : Gallery
  • Wakching Thana Lakpada #2 :: eRang
  • 13th Mega Marathon Manipur #2 : Gallery
  • Folk Dance Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Students @ Class XII Exam #2 : Gallery
  • Lui-ngai-ni, Naga festival @Ukhrul #2 : Gallery
  • Mukna Kangjei -Indigenous game : Gallery
  • Bangladeshki Sana Tampha #1 :: eRang
  • Manipur Legislative Assembly Building : Gallery
  • Eepan Thaba -birth ceremony : Gallery
  • Dzukou Valley Landscape #2 : Gallery
  • Apple Farm @ Kumbi : Gallery
  • Coronavirus prevention @ Moreh : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai at Kakhulong #2 : Gallery
  • SPONSORED ADS