TODAY -

Experimenting with Supra State Body
- Separating Politics and Culture –

Yenning *



Students rally in Ukhrul demanding 'Alternative Arrangement' :: 25th November 2011
Students rally in Ukhrul demanding "Alternative Arrangement" :: 25th November 2011 - Pix :: Jimmy Leivon



The news story broken by the Guwahati based Seven Sisters Post about the Government of India's offer for a Supra State body to NSCN-IM for administering Naga people beyond the boundary of the present State of Nagaland in such areas as culture, custom and tradition has, as expected, generated mixed responses across the whole North East region.

Hopes and apprehensions evoked by the news story are more discernible in Manipur than in Assam and Arunachal Pradesh, the other two States broadly encompassed by the proposed Supra State body. Much before the Government of India's offer for Supra State body was made public by the Seven Sisters Post, Naga frontal organisations under the captaincy of the United Naga Council (UNC) have imposed economic blockade on the national highways connecting Imphal with other cities of India and it is still going on.

Initially, the highway blockade was launched to counter the indefinite blockade imposed by the Sardar Hills Districthood Demand Committee (SHDDC) against the latter's pursuit of a separate Sadar Hills district. However, the UNC, till date, has not displayed any intention to lift the counter blockade even though the blockade which they intended to counter was lifted 26 days back.

It is no longer a counter blockade but purely a blockade. The moment SHDDC lifted their blockade, the UNC's justification for the counter blockade vanished in thin air. Yet, the counter blockade continues, and now the UNC's vindication is New Delhi's failure to take forward the process for alternative arrangement (for the Nagas of Manipur).

Here we cannot overlook the fact that UNC's renewed demand for alternative arrangement came at a time when New Delhi's offer for Supra State body was already made public. The UNC, as per news reports published by The Sangai Express on November 22, 2011, maintained that the ongoing economic blockade would be called off once the Government of India sends its feedback over the alternative arrangement demand. Again, the same report quoted the UNC as stating that "the matter (Supra State body) is at a high-level Indo-Naga talk process".

In view of the re-invigorated campaign for alternative arrangement and the report about the offer for Supra State body, which of course was rejected by the Home Minister of India, Shri. P. Chidambaram as "baseless and mischievous", only to be rebuffed by the Seven Sisters Post boldly calling the Home Minister untruthful, it would be rather interesting and meaningful to explore possible ramifications as well as the underlying concept of the proposed Supra State body.

Supra State Body

According to the report published by the Seven Sisters Post about the negotiation between New Delhi and NSCN-IM, the pan-Naga Supra State body was drawn up by New Delhi in response to NSCN-IM's persistent demand for integration of Naga inhabited areas under a single political entity to be called Nagalim (greater Nagaland). NSCN-IM leadership put their demand in this way.

It is the position of the NSCN that the present so-called state of Nagaland comprises only portion of Nagaland and that more realistic boundaries should be agreed upon that enable the Naga areas to be integrated within one administrative entity. The portions of Nagaland which are situated in present day Myanmar will not form part of the present negotiations.

Response of the Indian negotiators: Under law boundaries of State can be altered only after taking into consideration the views of the concerned State Legislators. The views of the Government of Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh and Assam are very clear in this regard. Therefore, it would not be possible to concede to the demand in the absence of political consensus from all concerned.

Therefore, NSCN (IM) may think of 'second best' if the 'best' in their view is not possible. Possible autonomy of Naga areas without altering the boundaries of the State's concerned so that in many matters, the representatives of the hill areas may administer the subjects in their charge along with a supra State body for the Nagas for their cultural, social and customary practices may be discussed. This pan-Naga Supra State body will be in the recognition of the distinct identity of the Nagas.

It is clear that NSCN-IM leadership have been demanding physical integration of the Nagas against which New Delhi is offering some sort of cultural unification of the Nagas through the proposed Supra State body.

NSCN-IM leadership have not made any official comment on the proposed Supra State body. At the same time, New Delhi has not yet disclosed any details about the functions and operational mode of the pan-Naga (cultural) body. As of now, what we understand is that the proposed Supra State body would administer the Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh in their cultural, social and customary practices. The Supra State body will not have the power to oversee the security aspect of the Naga inhabited areas (beyond the present State of Nagaland). The report published by the Seven Sisters Post states "Law and order and police will entirely be the call of the concerned State Governments but the Supra State body will advise the concerned State agencies on the implementation of different projects in the Naga areas".

The obvious implication of this arrangement, if it is true, is that Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh would have political affiliation to the respective State Governments while at the same time their cultural, social and customary practices would be governed by the Supra State body based outside the States. This would create not only a dicey situation but also breed a serious dilemma among the Nagas of Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh.

And we are not sure if this arrangement would be welcomed by the Nagas living outside Nagaland. Instead of the present single authority of which they are subjects, Nagas would be made subjects of two separate authorities—the concerned State Governments and a pervasive Supra State body. In fact, the Supra State body is a bold initiative of the Government of India to arrive at an honourable solution after 13 years of peace talk with NSCN-IM but we cannot help asking if politics, culture and social practices can ever be separated as intended by the Supra State body.

First, let's appreciate the positive aspect of the proposed body. It is true that granting rights to ethnic groups, such as the Nagas, can ensure their domination. The present proposal goes beyond the form of federalism and consociationalism prevalent in India for the establishment of multiethnic States. The earlier approach supports ethnic pluralism, while the final position, integration, foresees its decline with the gradual building of social and cultural cohesion.

The present proposal or position in the form of a supra body is strongly advocated in the United Kingdom, where multiculturalism was officially abandoned in 2004 due to its perceived effect as ethnically divisive, in favour of policies concerned with community cohesion ad integration. In other words, the United Kingdom was already experimen-ting with the idea of supra body. Here, integration is seen as encompassing the goals of ethnic equality and ethnic interaction, with strong concern over ethnic groups that lead parallel and separated lives.

However, the problem is, India is not United Kingdom. The latter is a unitary State, meaning to say that the Government of United Kingdom directly deals with the ethnic minorities, formulates and implements the policies directly. In the case of India, as much as New Delhi or the Nagas desires, the State Governments can never be bypassed. This has been clearly admitted by New Delhi. Moreover, the case of United Kingdom relates more with immigrant population, not the natives. Finally, one is yet to assess the achievements of such a policy even in the case of UK.

In the context of the proposed supra body, one is reminded of the dual administration of Manipur during British colonialism after the Anglo-Manipur War of 1891, which was characterised by separation between political-economy and culture and religion. The former was an absolute realm of the British (including the administration of the hill areas) wherein the King of Manipur did not have any say.

The latter, that is, culture and religion, was a domain of the native ruler. We are familiar with the chaotic situation that ensued, which in fact planted the seeds of separation between the valley people and the hills. Thus, one can even go to the extent that the proposed supra body is not a new one but a revisit of colonial policies.

Coming to the present understanding of "the political", political theories ranging from the varied liberal tradition to the Marxist including critical theory as well the subaltern, denies the separation between politics and culture. In either way, culture has to form a part of the politics or politics has to take into account the cultural stratum.

Any political or administrative policy, which calls for a dichotomy between the two is likely to result in collision of authority (State Government versus the Supra State body) without bringing any benefits to the stakeholders. The idea of the supra body instead of bringing desired results, say ending the vexed Naga issue, is bound to generate rounds of conflict in the North East.


* Yenning wrote this article for The Sangai Express in a regular column "Hoi Polloi & Mundanity"
The writer can be reached at yenning05(at)rocketmail(dot)com or visit hoipolloiandmundanity.blogspot.com
This article was posted on November 29, 2011.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Art Exhibit @Imphal Art College #1 : Gallery
  • HSLC students @ Chalwa, KPI : Gallery
  • Arambam Modhu Kalabhusan-Lairik Haiba
  • Interferences in private school affairs
  • Diagnostic Testing Phases -complexities
  • The Kite Runner :: Poem
  • Call for joint mass protest at New Delhi
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Manipur CM warns of extreme steps
  • Naga civil society playing key role
  • This will be an Acid test for N. Biren
  • Best option : A graceful exit ..for Pandey
  • Kang Khichri chaba @Kwakeithel : Gallery
  • Plastic Surgery Day @RIMS : Gallery
  • Kang Chingba @Keishampat : Gallery
  • Human rights of women in our society
  • AFSPA Gesture and Better Alternative
  • Leisure :: Poem
  • Restore Life After Burns : Plastic Surgery
  • IM accuses AR of 'cold-blooded murder'
  • Konung Kang Chingba #1 : Gallery
  • Dont waste searching for word/phrases
  • Hill People & Merger of Manipur
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #5
  • U-Mangra for biofuel for economic devpt
  • Painting competition on environment
  • Condemn Moreh terror attack
  • Climbing Shirui Hills, Ukhrul #3 : Gallery
  • Ichangthoubi, Thotmungchan :: eMing
  • Kang Chingba - Rath Yatra : Book
  • Why the impasse at Manipur University
  • Condolence Message for Tamenglong
  • Maharaj parleys Bizando
  • Opt for fruit/vegetable beauty product
  • DG Assam Rifles meets Governor
  • Recreation - a Serious Business
  • Tuilha Kolt waterfall @Kpi #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Lamjing Meira Ningsing Numit #2 : Gallery
  • Who Created the Border Pillar Conflict ?
  • EEVFAM amidst Numbness and Noise
  • Special Olympics Unified Cup 2018
  • Path for youth's bright future
  • Addressing core issues
  • Students Vs Centre's man : MU
  • Thangjam Manorama Anniversary: Gallery
  • A reflection on POCSO Act, 2012
  • Fear :: Poem
  • War veterans laboured to clean compound
  • Free Career Counselling Program
  • NEFIS writes to University bodies
  • Sit-in-Protest Against House Search
  • 50th World Population Day celebrated
  • Something worrying
  • Congress : 2 days session too short
  • Jadugi Chei :: Funga Wari
  • Tribal protest for MU normalcy : Gallery
  • Framework Agreement: What is it ?
  • Some cairns from the way: Artist's retake #2
  • Cry of a Dying River # 36 :: Poem
  • Overview on Manipur University imbroglio
  • Tribal Students memo to HRD on MU
  • India-Vietnam Film Show 2018 at Delhi
  • Why the CM is helpless ?
  • No end in sight to MU crisis
  • Indo-Myanmar Pillar 81 @Kwatha #1: Gallery
  • Global Bamboo Congress @Beijing : Gallery
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #4
  • Kamesh Salam : Speaker at BARC, Beijing
  • Career in Cooperatives
  • Nagaland CM's speech at NEC
  • NPF Rejoinder to JD (U) of July 9
  • The Killing Fields - 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Unfair Game
  • Expecting documentary proof from villagers
  • Lamjing Meira Ningsing Numit #1 : Gallery
  • Woken Youth Clubs in season of World Cup
  • Converting tourism potential into reality
  • Let me live in your heart :: Poem
  • D-Jent.... Djentleman... Anyone ?
  • Socialism or destruction of humanity ?
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Demand action against KSO activists
  • 3 Manipur girls in BCCI U-19 squad
  • Rights meet on bill outcome
  • Naga integration will be democratic..
  • Ichangi Laidhi #3 :: eRang
  • Modernizing Manipur University Library
  • In the grip of nothingness :: Poem
  • Password protection - I
  • Congenital Heart Defect operated
  • Hill area bandh relaxed temporarily
  • State & central govt must stop conflict
  • Cohesion is sports
  • Explain 'devious purpose'
  • Willong Khullen, Maram #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur merger agreement 1947
  • Wari Jalsa at New Delhi
  • Congress grass menace in North-East
  • M A Thomas National Human Rights Award
  • What does worry do to us ?
  • Is Manipur a part of India ?
  • Rumours of child lifters : Dangerous
  • List of MLA (Jan 2018) #3 : Gallery
  • Forest Rights Act 2006 -context of Manipur
  • Supreme Court Hearing on EEVFAM case
  • Cry of a Dying River - 35 :: Poem
  • Terirama Th. met South Korea's first lady
  • Securing security cameras: invisible eye
  • Rejoinder to Nagaland CM's statement
  • Meitei Mayek - are the scales tipped now
  • Patronising non-locals : Nail the insiders
  • UNC oppose indefinite Manipur bandh
  • Tribal University @ Senapati : Gallery
  • Rally to remove MU VC #2 : Gallery
  • Some cairns from the way: Artist's retake #1
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #3
  • UN experts on 'fake encounter' killings
  • Nagaland CM Rio statement on July 4
  • Condemns inhuman eviction by Govt
  • Trainees Certificate of RPL at Kamrup
  • Minor reunited with mother after 26 days
  • Non-Operative Closure of "hole in the heart"
  • We are for the people, for the society
  • Over 30 days : Centre sleeps, MU 'burns'
  • Thokchom Brindashabi Devi :: Profile
  • Kshetri-bengoon Eviction Protest : Gallery
  • Successive pay commissions: It's impact
  • Research Support @ R-Square Design
  • leingakki thouwong - state terrorism
  • Rebuttal: Interview of Ranju Singh
  • Different forces pulling Manipur : Lim
  • Pakhangba Cheng Hongba #3 : Gallery
  • Some ideas for prevention of flood
  • Satisfaction :: Poem
  • Supreme Court hearing on EEVFAM - 2 July
  • Dark lips .. causes and care
  • Training on Handloom Weaver at Hojai
  • CME on 'Congenital Heart Diseases'
  • Nagaland CM should make his stand clear
  • 2019 LS polls : BJP on the offensive
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #4 : Gallery
  • Naga American conference in California
  • Life of an army officer's daughter
  • The Winter Blues :: Poem
  • 16th Mega Miss North East
  • NDPP on Naga integration
  • Allegations against VC holds no ground
  • Rally to remove MU VC #1 : Gallery
  • July Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • A Washed-Out Summer Vacation in MU
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #2
  • My short interaction with Penna Donna
  • 9th Men Mega Mister North East
  • Memo submitted to Kiren Rijiju
  • India- no interest to protect its boundary
  • Idea of who is a citizen of the land
  • Poumai Purul Hiimai Paoki #3 : Gallery
  • Dr Thingnam Kishan Memorial : Gallery
  • Black sheep in movement for ILPS #3
  • Our Common Crisis: What are We to Do #2
  • Jackichand Singh signs for FC Goa
  • No co-operation to MU VC
  • Nagaland CM contradicting himself : NPF
  • Career Guidance Workshop at Ukhrul
  • The tales of a forgotten University
  • Pulling at idea of Manipur : Lim, ATC
  • Climbing Shirui Hills, Ukhrul #2 : Gallery
  • Moirangthem Arup: 90 Km Marathon, Africa
  • Pitfalls on land acquisition for Mapithel Dam
  • Chinese dominance in 21st century
  • Caring for the elderly
  • IIT-G's Technothlon prelims at UAE
  • Mass Rally from Manipur University
  • Nagaland CM releases book by teenager
  • Why trying to dictate media time & again
  • MU, border pillar, Citizenship Bill
  • Oinam Dilip's Painting Exhibition
  • Intl Day Against Drug Abuse : Gallery
  • The Manipur Merger Agreement 1949
  • A road to Mandalay
  • Keeping up: medical diagnostics tech
  • The mother of all preventive strategies
  • Relief camps for Flood affected families
  • The dark side of Indian democracy
  • From three time CM to Oppn leader
  • Khumang Pokpa Haraoba #1 : Gallery
  • Enduring Theatre of Guerrilla War
  • Intl Day in Support of Victims of Torture
  • Impact of trade & floods on economy
  • Imparting training as profession #2
  • Najmaji's flood fixing formula
  • History of Yoga
  • Intl Day against Drug Abuse
  • Politicising MU issue: by whom ?
  • Effective ban on plastics needed
  • Thaunaphaba Marup :: Funga Wari
  • Naga Nationalism & Naga Integration
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #1
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #3 : Gallery
  • Mova Cave, Hungpung, Ukhrul #1 : Gallery
  • Tribal Cultural Festival #2 : Gallery
  • General Thangal Eco Park : Gallery
  • Garlic Festival @Ukhrul #4 :: Gallery
  • Dzuko valley #4 :: 360 Panorama View
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Laitonjam Rajnikanta : Profile
  • Kang Tournament @ Yaiskul : Gallery
  • HSLC 208 Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Aerial view from Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #2: Gallery
  • Class XII Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Temples of Manipur : Gallery
  • Recipients of Akademi Awards for 2014
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS