TODAY -

Win-win solution to the 3- controversial bills

Dr. Vareso Ningshen *

ILP : Protest rally at Imphal on May 17 2016
ILP : Protest rally at Imphal on May 17 2016 :: Pix - Shankar Khangembam



The making of a new Manipur as a just, equitable, open, pluralist, vibrant and prosperous state in the new millennium will remain a day dream if the standard of judgment over the 3- Controversial (ILP) Bills by the stake holders including that of the experts and intellectuals of the state are of any indication. In the past, most of the issues in Manipur either socio-economic or political remained unresolved due to the colonial-like attitude of the government or lack of sound judgment over the issues by many stake holders. Yes, it is a knowledge era, no doubt.

Manipur although a small state is known for its best intelligence and knowledge in science, technology, medicine, arts, and sports. But what is the use of our best knowledge and intelligence if it is not guided by wisdom and character when it comes to application? Knowledge alone can destroy rather than build our society and our world. This is what M.K. Gandhiji meant when he once said ‘Knowledge without character is a powerful evil’. It can bring injustice, chaos, division and destruction in our society if not prudently used.

The 3-controversial bills: The Protection of Manipur People Bills, 2015 (PMP Bill), The Manipur Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Seventh Amendment) Bill, 2015 and the Manipur Shops And Establishment (Second Amendment) Bill, 2015 are all said to have been passed with the primary objective to protect the indigenous peoples of Manipur.

The first bill is learnt to have been withheld whereas the other two bills are to be returned for reconsideration by the House. Indebt discussion, consultation and debate on the substance of a bill is not only a fine democratic culture but an inalienable structural ingredient of a constitutional democracy like ours. Any legislative process bereft of this requirement will not produce a good law for want of credible and composite ideas, opinions, information and consensus on the subject matter.

However good and productive laws can be passed by optimizing all available legislative credentials and adhering to the constitutional jurisprudence relevant to our context. Frankly speaking, the prevailing crisis is a self made crisis of the Government of Manipur and the Hon’ble Legislative Assembly. The dubious attempt of the Government to extend the new provisions of MLR & LR in the entire state without inserting an exceptional clause negates the very constitutional objective to protect and safeguard the tribals and their land.

It stands in direct contravention of the Principal Act of MLR and LR which exempts the Hill Areas from its operation. It will above all breach the customary laws of the tribals which govern and safeguard their land from time immemorial. This reality and the sentiment attached therein needs to be respected by the state and all concerned. Transfer of tribal land, however, is legitimately done either to the Centre or State Governments for any developmental purpose by lease, donation, sale or acquisition process purely on the basis of the agreed terms and conditions arrived between the tribal land owners and the government or any other such similar entity.

The agreed terms must include reversionary right of ownership to the original land owners in the event of expiry of the project span of the government and/ or winding up of such developmental projects/ programs.

The contentious new amendment bill in Section 14 A (1) of the MLR and LR provides that “Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, Non-Manipur persons, firm, institutions or any other similar entities who intend to purchase any land in the state of Manipur shall submit an application to the Deputy Commissioner of the district concerned where the land to be purchased is situated for obtaining the prior approval of the State Government before such purchase is made by him”. Honestly, this section does not require logical interpretation to get its clear-cut construction of the content.

Grammatical interpretation itself conveys its clear literal and technical meaning. It express that discarding or regardless of all existing laws including exemption provision for Hill Areas contained in Section 2 (2) of the Principal Act, this new amendment bill if enacted into law will allow Non-Manipur persons, firms, institutions (all outsiders) to purchase land in Manipur including Hill Areas by obtaining prior approval of the State Government.

Meaning, the new amendment bill will extend and cover the Hill Areas currently outside the MLR and LR jurisdiction in order to enable the Non-Manipur persons to purchase land in the Hill Areas even while non-tribal brethren of the state are still prohibited therefrom. This is the crux of the problem. The comment of various experts and government officials either spoken or written that the bill does not extend to Hill Areas and, hence, not affecting the rights and interest of the tribals seems to be duping and misleading the people of both hill and valley.

Such comments appear to be lopsided and lack universal standard-quality required in building a vibrant and pluralist society in Manipur. The tribals will fully support the amendment bill which provides adequate procedural safeguard in the purchase of land by outsiders in the MLR and LR extended valley districts but not to the Hill Areas where the Principal Act itself is not extended and where sale of land to non-tribals is prohibited leave alone the Non-Manipuri persons (not even defined in this Act), firms, etc. as envisaged in the proposed bill. I see no credible justification for such a move in asmuch as it violates their standing customary laws and the Constitution of India which sanction prohibition of absolute transfer of land belonging to Scheduled Tribes to non-tribals. Thus, the bill will certainly affect the tribals if not rectified.

The 2nd and in fact the most important issue is the ambiguous nature of the PMP Bill, 2015 which is now being withheld by the President of India. The reason for such rejection could obviously be not on the constitutionality of the bill but its defectiveness in substance and in procedure. PMP Bill was virtually an ordinary bill and not a Money Bill as such. The substance of the draft-bill wholly relates to restriction and regulation on the movement, works and residence of Non-Manipur persons (migrants and immigrants) entering the state of Manipur.

The question of Money Bill will arise only in the subsidiary bill evolving fiscal and other financial structure for implementing PMP bill only after being enacted into law. This has deprived the democratic space and privilege in the legislative process of the House and more particularly that of the Hill Areas Committee. Comprehensive consultation would have avoided or at least minimized the gravity of the present crisis.

Another general defect is the non-feasibility of the execution of the PMP law by sheer reliance of the 3- Registers of 1951 (a basis for determining Non-Manipur persons). This is due to the non-availability of the relevant registers and other records in the valley district and more specifically in the obscure Hill Areas where there was extremely poor communication and administrative system in those days. The bill is also vague and uncertain as the term, “Native people of Manipur” in section 8 (A) who are to be exempted from the application of the bill remains undefined. The principal of legislation opposes any vague and uncertain legislation.

Let us not forget to always remember that it is not sweet words alone that we often utter but our good attitudes and actions that will ultimately count in making a harmonious, equitable and progressive society. In that perspective, a win-win approach can be had with these options of workable solution:

1. As regards to MLR & LR (7th Amendment) Bill 2015, maintain status quo by inserting an exemption clause for the Hill Areas concurrent to the Principal Act.

2. Manipur Shops And Establishment (2nd Amendment) Bill 2015 may be thoroughly reviewed by consulting the stake holders of the tribal society and the Hill Areas Committee.

3. A new PMP legislation be initiated to protect and safeguard the demographic interest of the indigenous peoples (‘Yelhoumi’ in Meiteilon and ‘Haomi’ in Tangkhul dialect) of Manipur. It appears that there is no immediate threat to the demographic interest of the tribals in Hill Areas as they have the constitutional protection in this regard.

However, if the Government desires to enforce PMP law in Manipur including Hill Areas all stake holders including tribal Village Chiefs/ Headmen, ADC members and Civil Societies must be thoroughly consulted prior to such legislation. Over and above this, mandatory procedural requirements including House debate and reference to Hill Areas Committee must be fully exhausted for consensus and better result.

Any repeated legislative attempt without addressing the genuine concern of the tribals of Manipur may further alienate them to the extent of resorting to peaceful non-cooperation and non-participation of the ensuing Manipur Legislative Assembly Election 2017. May the good office of the Government of Manipur be guided by the will and wisdom of God, and may we all be given the wisdom & ability to have sound judgment over the crisis so as to peacefully resolve it in the interest of all.

(Note: This write up is purely an academic exercise for public discourse without ill will or prejudice to anyone.)


* Dr. Vareso Ningshen wrote this article for Imphal Times
This article was posted on June 17 , 2016.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Zeliangrong orphaned by Nationalism #2
  • General Thangal Eco Park : Gallery
  • Letter to President on Crisis at MU
  • Precision medicine & life sciences
  • Black topping-can ground leveling be behind
  • Condemns security force intrusion in MU
  • Developer wanted at LMP, Konjeng Leikai
  • AR gears up for International Yoga Day
  • NPF rejoinder to NDPP : 20 June
  • Rejoinder by Dr. Shurhozelie : 20 June
  • For a little bit more
  • Deadline of 5 days time set : MU crisis
  • Garlic Festival @Ukhrul #4 :: Gallery
  • Flood in Imphal [14 June] #3 : Gallery
  • Inungshi, Gaichanglungliu :: eMing
  • Taking 'Hau' Music to Rest of World
  • Kakching bags cleanest city in NE Award
  • JRF (Junior Research Fellow) at IBSD
  • Oxfam India launches emergency response
  • VC, MU - Resign immediately :: MUTA
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Translation of ancient Manipur texts begin
  • Pre Yoga Capsule organized
  • NDPP Rejoinder on 19 June
  • NPF Youth Wing Rejoinder on 19 June
  • Favouring digital govt : still a Virtual dream
  • June 18 Anniv : Consult all stakeholders
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #1 : Gallery
  • Binota Thokchom at BRICS Young Scientist
  • The Merger of Manipur
  • Improving school management in Manipur
  • Pros & cons of screening tests
  • NPF Rejoinder on 18th June
  • Nagaland CM statement on Aboi ambush
  • June 18 significance: Still living on prayer
  • Need to identify one's strength
  • 18 Immortal Souls Remembered : Flash
  • The Great June Uprising : Read all about it
  • The Pitfalls of Identity Politics
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • All his sons :: Poem
  • Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2016
  • Eid bring cheer in flood hit areas
  • Willong Khullen, Maram #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Defending the environmental defenders
  • Delusion in self - cause of worry
  • Road to Russia: FIFA World Cup
  • It must be love :: Poem
  • 'Future of Naga people is bleak'
  • Give a miss call to Amnesty
  • 'Naga area' bandh on June 18
  • Dzuko valley #4 :: 360 Panorama View
  • Flood in Imphal [14 June] #2 : Gallery
  • Id-Ul-Fitr Festival
  • Letter to PM Modi on Naga Talks
  • Greetings on Eid-Ul-Fitr
  • Rejoinder to NPF statement
  • Rejoinder to Nagaland Chief Minister
  • Flood relief continue on 3rd day
  • India-Vietnam Youth Dialogue 2018
  • MU debacle: Why would it be left unnoticed
  • Spirit of World Cup : Brazil to Russia
  • NEC to come under Home Ministry
  • Manipur NGO hosts summit on LGBTQ
  • Flood in Imphal [14 June] #1 : Gallery
  • Women Struggle in Self-Determination
  • 14 June- World Blood Donor Day
  • Naga Integration not possible- NPF react
  • Naga Integration is not possible- CM Rio
  • Relief work in flood affected areas
  • A day which keeps our spirit alive
  • Ranked 320 in the country : MU
  • Flood in Imphal [13 June] #2 : Gallery
  • Sovereignty Struggles in Northeast #5
  • Be alert: It's admission time
  • Yin and Yang
  • Watermelon beauty benefits
  • Temp accommodation for Aligarh students
  • Wrath of Mother Nature: Why challenge..
  • 60 pc is no longer first class : 95 pc
  • Flood in Imphal [13 June] #1 : Gallery
  • Sanamahi Laihui & Sanamahi Laining
  • Kuhi- Essential plant for Nungbi pottery
  • Climate justice is integral to development
  • The bridge :: Poem
  • Lt S Vijaya Devi felicitated
  • Then : Indifferent :: Now : Hyper sensitive
  • Phumdigi Tantha : Dance Drama : Gallery
  • Grief at Xavier Rutsa's demise
  • Modi's India: A descend into Ochlocracy
  • The Philippine Experience
  • Cry of a Dying River #33 :: Poem
  • Community Iftar at Moijing, Cachar
  • Candle Light at DU over Assam lynching
  • Demand replacement of Manipur Univ VC
  • The Tragedy of Higher education
  • Unacceptable points spelt out
  • Teinem Luira Phanit @Ukhrul #3: Gallery
  • RPL-PMKVY trainees @Hojai : Gallery
  • Manipur Sports University in UP ?
  • Coloniality of the Postcolonial
  • Yellow leaves in the autumn :: Poem
  • Prof N Irabanta-distinguished academician
  • Leadership matters
  • Artificial turf for budding talents
  • 2 municipal bodies in NE awarded
  • Who is Arambam Somorendra ?
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Shirock 2018 - Shirui Lily Fest #3 : Gallery
  • Linthoi's "The Tales of Kanglei Throne" #2
  • Grass root challenge- Education in hills
  • Earth does not belong to us...
  • Sita Mata as test-tube baby
  • What happen to VIP Culture Mr. CM
  • Merchants of education
  • Laitonjam Rajnikanta : Profile
  • A blessing to see :: Poem
  • Sovereignty Struggles in Northeast #4
  • Difference between Hinduism & Hindutva
  • How to choose the perfect fragrance
  • Iftaar party at Lilong
  • Bitter truth of Manipuri society
  • MU, NSU, IGNTU : Students at the centre
  • Amuktang-Ga Haikho #1 : eRang
  • Sangai Veterans' Football #2 : Gallery
  • Pony : A Cavalry Horse Par Excellence #2
  • Issues that keep Manipur burning
  • Cry of a Dying River - 32 :: Poem
  • CM & AR interaction with villagers
  • Certification of PMKVY trainees of Hojai
  • Christian appeals for Peace in Shillong
  • How safe are our women?
  • Riders put up by JAC for talk
  • Khangkhui Cave in Ukhrul #3 : Gallery
  • Pluralism, Democracy & Ethnic Relation #2
  • Irom Sharmila meets with Mehbooba Mufti
  • JRF @ Mizoram University (Biotechnology)
  • Tobacco and heart disease
  • Understanding SOWA - RIGPA #2
  • Campaign "to End Child Sexual Abuse"
  • Implementation of 7th Pay
  • Indigenous street vendor sing gi wafam
  • The crumbling Manipur University
  • Kang Tournament @ Yaiskul : Gallery
  • Zeliangrong orphaned by Nationalism #1
  • A rainy night :: Poem
  • HSLC Exam is the start! What next?
  • 1528 cases of fake encounter
  • Linthoi's "The Tales of Kanglei Throne" #1
  • Handloom Weaver @Bishnupur : Gallery
  • Shirock 2018 - Shirui Lily Fest #2 : Gallery
  • Hinduism in Manipur : Political Perspective
  • All the World and his Wife :: Poem
  • Tribal Cultural Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Women in CCpur turn to self-help groups
  • Purul Paoki Wrestling : Gallery
  • Sangai Veterans' Football #1 : Gallery
  • Khangminashi IV (Lecture) : Report
  • Seminar at MU - Hinduism in Manipur'
  • Evolution of The Meetei State
  • Heartbreak at Ukhrul: Unfolding Shirock
  • State Level Khurpui-Lam Festival: Gallery
  • June Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • School Girls Basketball #2 : Gallery
  • Where is Manipur....???
  • 'Manipur' in Google maps : Gallery
  • The Killing Fields - 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Mama Poktabi :: Funga Wari
  • Veterans Football Tournament #2 : Gallery
  • Shirock 2018 - Shirui Lily Fest #1 : Gallery
  • Sougrakpam Vijaya makes history sailing...
  • Arunachali unfurled Salai Taret at Mt Everest
  • Panthoiba: 2nd Rank- class XII, Uttarkhand
  • Ras Leela @JNMDA Day : Gallery
  • HSLC 208 Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • HSLC 2018 :: Toppers Listing
  • HSLC 2018 :: Check Result
  • HSLC :: Statistical/Subject Topper
  • HSLC 2018 :: External
  • Poumai Purul Hiimai Paoki #2 : Gallery
  • Kakching Garden :: 360 Panorama View
  • Folk Dance Festival #5 : Gallery
  • Aerial view from Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Curtain Raising- Sangai Fest 2017: Gallery
  • Lainingthou Lai Lam thopka #2 : Gallery
  • Re-visiting Khangkhui caves in Ukhrul
  • Gardening @Ema Keithel #2: Gallery
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #2: Gallery
  • Pakhangba Cheng Hongba #2 : Gallery
  • Steelheart @ Shirock , Ukhrul #3 : Gallery
  • A. Halim Chowdhury: A Profile
  • Class XII Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Class XII Result : Science Toppers
  • Class XII Result : Arts Toppers
  • Class XII Result : Commerce Toppers
  • HSE Result 2018 : District Wise
  • HSE Result 2018 : Highest Marks
  • HSE Result 2018 : Science Stream
  • HSE Result 2018 : Arts Stream
  • HSE Result 2018 : Commerce Stream
  • Temples of Manipur : Gallery
  • Recipients of Akademi Awards for 2014
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS