TODAY -

Riding the tribal horse: Why ILP should not be implemented in Manipur

Thangbiaklian Hangzo *



In order to understand Inner Line Permit (ILP) one has to view in the right perspective and that is the view of the erstwhile British rulers. The much hyped ILP in Manipur or The Manipur Peoples Bill, 2018 also is an offshoot of Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873 also known as Regulation 5 of 1873 by the British for British Subjects.

The main intention was to isolate various backward areas under British India in order to protect those British subjects who came in areas where there was danger. According to Alexander Mackenzie (History of the Relations of Government with the Hill Tribes of the Frontier of Bengal, 1884), “There was a pressing necessity of bringing under more stringent control the commercial relations of our own subjects with the frontier tribes living on the borders of our jurisdiction.”

It purportedly also was to protect the Crown’s commercial interest on tea, oil and ivory trade from other British Subjects. The act had given the Crown Government the control to draw a line beyond which no British subjects of certain classes or foreign residents can pass and lay down rules regarding trade and possession of land beyond “that line” without a license. Whatever the intention might be, it is a regulation that pertains to certain scheduled areas occupied by backward people – tribal.

The ILP regulation, framed during Colonial India, per se is an ultra vires of the Constitution of India. It contravenes with the Preamble to the Constitution of India which accords “equality of status” to all citizens of India. Moreover, it is a violation of Article 19 (4) & (5) on the fundamental right which grants each and every citizen of India “the freedom to migrate and settle in any parts of India”. On top of that, “Inter-state migration; inter-state quarantine” exclusively falls under the Union List at Entry No. 81 of the Seventh Schedule.

Nevertheless, in continuation of the British legislative legacy, after their withdrawal, the Indian adaptation of the regulation continued to be applied in Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh and Mizoram states where exclusive tribal communities inhabit and different schedule of land and law applies. But Nagaland’s commercial town and port head Dimapur has been excluded under its regulation.

Meghalaya, a tribal state, passed a bill called Meghalaya Residential Permit Bill in 1973 which was rejected by the President of India. And an attempt was made again in 1979 to introduce a bill to address the influx of migrants in the form of ILP, but the same could not be considered by its assembly since the subject falls under the Union List.

In Manipur, the bulk of its demography comprises of plain dwelling Meitei/Meetei people, who are categorised as general population and followed a caste Hindu religion. Boasted millennial of written history and touted a constitutional monarchy prior to that of even India’s very own constitution. If one is to go by precedence or original intent of ILP, it will be prudent to comprehend that Manipur in its entirety has no legislative sanction for such blanket protection or inner line permit system.

However, one caveat that could potentially help increase the chance in Manipur is the constitutional status of the Scheduled Tribes who inhabit the Hill Areas and their interest. In other words, ILP should ideally be implemented in the Hill Areas for the Scheduled Tribes leaving out the Imphal Valley as in the pattern of Nagaland’s Dimapur.

Interestingly, the main proponents and advocates are not the Scheduled Tribes, but the valley dwelling caste Hindu Meitei/Meetei community. And the first ILP bill “The Protection of Manipur Peoples Bill, 2015” was introduced as, “A bill to provide protection, maintenance of socio-economic and cultural balance of the Manipur People…” without any mention of Scheduled Tribes , nor was there an intent to address their interest, and was withheld by the President of India.

Whereas the resurgence of the same bill “The Manipur Peoples Bill, 2018” states, “A bill to protect the people of Manipur and for maintenance of peace and public order and to regulate entry into and exit from Manipur for Non-Manipur People in public interest and for the protection of the interest of Scheduled Tribes…” giving special mention of the interest of Scheduled Tribes in its preamble.

What is astonishing in this melodrama is that JCILPS and Manipur government, arm twisted the Hill Areas Committee, and suddenly develop a conscience and the heart to protect the interest of the Scheduled Tribes, in the ILP bill, even after the conglomerate of tribal CSO leaders unequivocally plead them not to do so by deleting the clause “for the protection of the interest of Scheduled Tribes” from the preamble of the revised bill, to say the least.

And we all know whose interest the bill is going to serve if it receives gubernatorial and presidential assent

If Manipur is genuinely interested in “protecting the interest of the Scheduled Tribes”, it could have worked on to repeal the section in MLR & LR Act that empowers the Manipur Gazette to arbitrarily extend the act in the Hill Areas of Manipur. Or ensure that correct reservation policies for Scheduled Tribes are followed in job recruitment or the enrolment of students in the Manipur University.

If Manipur government sincerely desires the protection of the interest of the Scheduled Tribes, they should have installed an infrastructure for at least a marble game, if that exist, in each of the Hill districts during the 30th National Games in 1999, or built a campus or two of the Manipur University in the Hill Areas long time ago rather than whining about the congestion in the valley.

If the protection of the interest of the Scheduled Tribes have been genuine, successive Manipur governments could have responded to the query of the Ministry of Home Affairs when it asked to clarify what it meant by “with certain local adjustments and amendments” in the matter of extending Sixth Schedule in the Hill Areas of Manipur. Or Manipur could have respected tribal heritage and embraced plurality in its historical narrative and withdraw its decision over Chandrakirti Memorial Park at Chivu near Behiang village or Kailam Wildlife Sanctuary which insults its history, heritage and encroaches tribal ancestral land without their prior consent. If, only if.

The endeavour to protect the interest of the Schedule Tribes by the Manipur government or JCILPS came a tad misplaced and little late by a couple score of years or so. The Scheduled Tribes of Manipur are very much privy of what their interest entail, and does not require such autocratic imposition by the Manipur government or JCILPS. Dictating one’s communal agenda and coercing another community to accept it as their own only reveals the hegemonic attitude and narrow bigotry against the Scheduled Tribe community.

The whole ILP episode turns out to be a ploy by JCILPS and Manipur government to ride on the privileges and rights of the Scheduled Tribes in the pretext of protecting their interests, while the real intent is to serve the communal interest of dominant Meitei/Meetei community. There are legal and other alternative recourse to ensure that the bill doesn’t see daylight even if assembly sanction and gubernatorial assent is bulldozed in Manipur. It is, therefore, judicious and fair for the Manipur government if the pending and overdue “interests” of the Scheduled Tribes are addressed as the ILP tarry a while.

A song by the title “Strong Enough to Bend” sung by Shania Twain had these interesting lyrics:
There’s a tree out in the backyard
That never has been broken by the wind
And the reason its still standing
It was strong enough to bend.

Bending, yes! It may hurt a little, but who knows, it may well be the only way to keep the idea of Manipur alive. The pain of bending will surely be more bearable than the pain of breaking.

Or suggest better options, if you have one.


* Thangbiaklian Hangzo wrote this article for e-pao.net
The author may be reached at hangzo(DOT)biak(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on July 28 , 2018.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Nongpok Thong Hangba
  • Khubak Eeshei @Kang festival : Gallery
  • Punsi Sangba, Mathiupuang :: eMing
  • Arresting decline of higher education
  • RPL-PMKVY Certificate at Tripura
  • Silence :: Poem
  • AFSPA took my father
  • Dark Net: Underbelly of the internet
  • Alternative Arrangement, Article 371A
  • Petition challenging dilution AFSPA
  • Rio for integration of Naga areas
  • Brought NE closer to Delhi: PM
  • Independence Day celebrated in NE
  • Tikendrajit : The Lion of Manipur #1
  • Compressed Earth Blocks: Housing
  • Support breastfeeding among adolescent
  • Ithai: Development Decision Gone Awry
  • Who made the sports university ours?
  • An Unoccupied Forehead :: Poem
  • 'NRC should not be a political issue'
  • Independence Day : Govt needs trust
  • Apprehensions before final pact
  • NNC stand to protect Naga sovereignty
  • 'Delay in solution irks people'
  • Patriots' Day- Floral Tribute : Gallery
  • A shot at survival
  • Demography and Population Studies
  • RPL-PMKVY Certificate at Baishalgarh
  • E-Commerce to help access new markets
  • Manipur Heart Foundation Anniversary
  • Artist lineup for NH7 Weekender
  • Kakching World War-II Memorial Run
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • AMPWA observed Patriots' Day
  • Real homage or just showmanship
  • Drama of political clout at MU
  • Patriots' Day @ Kolkata : Gallery
  • Historical War fought by Manipur
  • Where are the nurses in HIV response?
  • Understanding false smut of rice
  • The love song of autumn :: Poem
  • Help Underprivileged Sports Youngsters
  • Police : List of Awardees on I-Day
  • NSCN-IM word on Naga unity
  • Scribes demand colleague's release
  • Jadugi Mingsel :: Folk Tale
  • Patriotism Redefined [On 13th Aug]
  • Karate Winners felicitated at Kumbi
  • Of Citizenship & Manipur People's Bill
  • Seminar : Path & Pattern in Northeast
  • 42nd Indian Social Science Congress
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Certificate Distribution at Tripura
  • Failure by WPS-IE to arrest rapist
  • Resolutions : People's Democratic Alliance
  • ..Will it burnt the state again
  • ..Now get the killers !
  • 'Homecoming', Painting Exhibition : Gallery
  • Legacy of Resistance in Cordillera Highland
  • Woke Up, But You're Nowhere :: Poem
  • Resurgence of Sanamahism
  • Nagas & Meiteis must live together
  • No change in 1951 as Base Year : JCILPS
  • B. Voc. at DM Community College
  • Young Scholars Conference 2018
  • ..legitimacy of remaining to power
  • The precursor of things to come
  • Khangkhui Cave , Ukhrul #4 : Gallery
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba #2 : Gallery
  • Reform Manipur's Education System
  • Friendship
  • Cry of a Dying River - 40
  • World's Indigenous Peoples Day
  • Chandigarh students' solidarity with MU
  • MU agitator should withdraw their agitation
  • Repercussion of a prejudice attitude
  • Regulate school vans/buses
  • Disputed Myanmar Border Pillar : Gallery
  • Seven Breaths of Dragon :: Book Rvw
  • Chronological framework of NRC
  • Buttering Najmaji in public
  • JRF Post at Mizoram University
  • Manipur Tourism : Festival Promotion Award
  • The uneasy shift
  • Well co-ordinated rallies across dists
  • Chalwa Village, Kangpokpi #1 : Gallery
  • General strike on article 371 (A) #2 : Gallery
  • Up against the saffron brigade
  • My unsailed ship :: Poem
  • Mathematics and Science Competition
  • General Strike by ATSUM on August 10
  • Drawing Competition at Wapokpi, Bishnupur
  • ADBU delivers course to Indian Railways
  • One man that put Manipur in frying pan
  • Relax MU shut down !
  • Khumang Pokpa Haraoba #2: Gallery
  • Robert Naorem @Blr Fashion Week : Gallery
  • Territorial integrity of Manipur
  • The string :: Poem
  • General Strike by KIM on August 8
  • Robert Naorem at Bangalore Fashion Week
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Dr. Monisha Behal's work in North East
  • Registrations for IIT Techniche workshop
  • PDA on situation in Nagaland
  • The politics of divide: MU
  • Significance of August
  • Mukna Khong Kangjei #3 : Gallery
  • Greater Nagaland or Mini Nagaland? #2
  • Paint Your City : Campaign at Kakching
  • Pemberton line in Kabaw is our boundary
  • Awakening :: Poem
  • Coffee Plantation : In-lieu of Poppy
  • Recalling of AK Pandey by HRD Ministry
  • TSA's reply to KNO/KNA's allegations
  • 21st Manipur Integrity Day : Gallery
  • Konung Kang Chingba #3 : Gallery
  • Ecological, social impact of Ithai Barrage #3
  • Swindling Manipuris in solving Naga issue
  • The Last of the Romantics :: Poem
  • 'Thoughts on MU strategies'
  • Concerned about continued closure of MU
  • Fear factor
  • No takers for 1 month leave
  • View from Shirui Hills #1 : Gallery
  • Manipur as seen by Meiteis, Nagas, & Zo
  • Certificate Distribution at Nirjuli, ArP
  • Contract Jobs available at NIELIT HQs
  • Cry of a Dying River - 39 :: Poem
  • Banana flower vada
  • Entrance for Free Residential IAS Coaching
  • Resolution of NPF Consultative Meeting
  • Concerned about militants' interference
  • Issues : From ILP, MU to FA
  • Emergence Nongda Lairen Pakhangba #2
  • MU Rally at Canchipur : Gallery
  • News Analysis 0f Akashvani Imphal
  • ILP: A Genuine Idea Lost in Translation
  • Tryst with an Alzheimer's patient #2
  • Letter to Prime Minister of India
  • Female DTP faculty reqd at Protocol
  • In between :: Poem
  • Sowing the seeds of Greater Lim
  • General strike on article 371 (A) #1 : Gallery
  • Student is important or AP Pandey
  • Article 371A is sui generis
  • Protection on Land, Environment at TML
  • Press Conference on MU Crisis at Delhi
  • Oppose extension of Article 371(A)
  • DTP-Desktop Publishing course at Nambol
  • Certificate Distribution at Namsai, ArP
  • Rejoinder to KNO/KNA on Moreh attack
  • Issues which burn Manipur State Assembly
  • The brand of politics in MU crisis
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #3 : Gallery
  • August Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • Protest against MHRD @Delhi : Gallery
  • People's Strike greets this August
  • Slump in fight against #AIDS
  • What does moonlight want ? :: Poem
  • MU students protest against MHRD
  • An Unknown killer - "E-Waste"
  • Talking peace and threatening others
  • Singcha Wuya Won @Kamjong #1 : Gallery
  • Dismal Politics in Universities
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba #1 : Gallery
  • Engulfing Uncertainties
  • Ecological, social impact of Ithai Barrage #2
  • Certificate Distribution at Dibang, ArP
  • EEVFAM case: Report for 30 July
  • Pertaining to statement of T. R. Zeliang
  • Issues plaguing the state
  • What is the stand of BJP Govt ?
  • Monsoon Assembly Session : Gallery
  • Election 2019: end of road for Modi
  • The absurd baby talk :: Poem
  • Assam University BTech, MTech Admission
  • Saving the Rhinos - Campaign
  • Arrest perpetrators of Moreh attack
  • Training programmes of NCC
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #2 : Gallery
  • MU: Students clash with Police #2: Gallery
  • Prospects of coffee in Manipur
  • Why ILP should not be implemented
  • Hill students get alert on Trafficking
  • IBSD Meghalaya inaugurated
  • Conference on India-Vietnam
  • Govt's strategically pre planned conflict
  • Heart ruptured but life saved
  • Pseudo intellectuals should stop thinking
  • Mass sit-in protest : How about Nagaland?
  • Folklore genres of Meetei community
  • Kang Khichri chaba : Gallery
  • Binalakshmi Nepram at United Nations, NY
  • Certificate Distribution at Changlang, ArP
  • Out to clear her name
  • CBI failed to comply to SC orders
  • Condemned as a cry in wilderness
  • Security meeting conducted
  • Ripe opportunity for awareness & action
  • Is the NRC of 1951 available ?
  • Central team @ BP 81 , Kwatha #1 : Gallery
  • Our Common Crisis: What are We to Do #3
  • ..Take a break from the common road
  • Skin problems that arise during monsoon
  • Cry of a Dying River - 38 : Poem
  • Meghalaya edition of NH7 Weekender
  • 'Special status' under which provisions ?
  • Issues which need minute deliberations
  • Pay Nareckpi : Funga Wari
  • Kayada Ningthijaba Lambino : Story telling
  • Yumkhaibam Nanao: Walking from Delhi..
  • Ningol Pali at Kang Festival : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Naga American conference at California
  • MU: Students clash with Police #1: Gallery
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba : Gallery
  • ISKCON Kang Chingba festival : Gallery
  • Meira Rally protest of MU VC : Gallery
  • Bandh demanding VC removal #2 : Gallery
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #3: Gallery
  • Art Exhibit @Imphal Art College #1 : Gallery
  • Kang Khichri chaba @Kwakeithel : Gallery
  • Dzuko valley #4 :: 360 Panorama View
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • HSLC 208 Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Class XII Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Temples of Manipur : Gallery
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS