Recovering compensation from unruly CAA-NRC agitators legal, not 'badla'

Dhruva Saikia *

Is UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath breaking or upholding the law of the land by initiating an unprecedented exercise to make those 'identified' hooligans pay compensation for destroying public property worth crores of rupee during the anti CAA-NRC stir in several parts of the country, including UP?

This move by the resolute UP chief minister is a path breaking step in the world's largest democracy where outburst of public anger is not only free and frequent, but accompanied by violence and hooliganism that hurts at the core of democratic values and mechanism.

When democratic agitators jump over the fence and turn lawbreakers, it becomes somewhat equally tricky for their democratic rulers to maintain an expected decorum, and that explains for Yogi Adityanath's vow to take revenge on those CAA-NRC protesters who took to wanton destruction of public property to vent their anger over a bona fide piece of law.

Now that Yogi is doing what he said, certain sections are trying to ignore the legal obligations associated and instead picking up the Yogi's one word 'badla', which means revenge. Perhaps they expect us to believe that Yogi's action in this context can never be law-abiding because he wanted to take revenge, and exploiting the provisions of law to that end.

But that is not true; Yogi in fact is finding an answer to some legal loophole that renders even eminent jurists in the country unable to help. There is a law to prevent to destruction of public property, but when someone actually carries out the destruction, the court admits that there are limitations there that prevent the court from punishing the guilty.

A leading newspaper Indian Express, in order to examine the veracity of Yogi's attempt at pulling out compensation from lawbreaking CAA-NRC agitators in UP, has completed a survey of property destroying stirs during last four years in BJP ruled UP, Maharashtra, Punjab, Haryana, Haryana besides Delhi ruled by AAP.

Here is a summary of the survey that shows us that compelling the public property destroyers to pay for compensation, though not regular and widespread, is not without instances either. There are instances when the Court has asked the administration to arrange for due compensation to victims for loss of property, and that too not at the cost of the exchequer but drawing it from those responsible for destruction.

So, asking the agitators, who have been properly identified, to pay for compensation, hardly corresponds to revenge. This will be clear from the facts incorporated in the survey -

* December 2018- No notices for damage were sent to anyone by UP police for the killing of UP police inspector Subodh Kumar Singh, posted with Syana police station in Bulandshahr, burning police vehicle and ransacking the police station by a mob led by Bajrang Dal activists after recovery of some cow carcasses in the area.

* February 2016- Jat quota unrest in Haryana led to death of 30 people, 1,800 properties worth Rs 1,100 crore destroyed as per government estimate. No notice was sent and government paid Rs 65.38 crore compensation to people whose private property was damaged.

* August 2017- Following Court orders, Haryana state administration attached properties of Dera Sacha Sauda in Sirsa after Dera Sacha Sauda's Gurmeet Ram Rahim was convicted of rape and his followers, in protest, went on a rampage setting fire to vehicles, government buildings, petrol stations, media vans and railway stations. As many as 40 people were killed. The Punjab and Haryana High Court took cognisance of the violence and ordered recovery of damages from rioters.

* June 2017 and April 2019- No notice was sent for compensation in Madhya Pradesh after farmers' protest in Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh, turned violent with agitators damaging rail tracks and burning down 27 vehicles. As many as six farmers died in firing by police which suffered heavy stone pelting. The protests later spread across the state. In April 2019 a nationwide Dalit protest against Supreme Court order diluting the SC/ST Atrocities Act turned violent in Madhya Pradesh and there was no notice for compensation.

* In January 2018, No notice was sent by Pune administration to any protestor when Maharashtra witnessed large scale protests by Dalit groups over the Koregaon battle anniversary, in several parts of Pune, Pimpri-Chinchwad and Ahmednagar, stone pelting was reported and a 16-year-old boy, Yogesh Prahlad Jadhav was killed.

"In the past, in context of some political protests, police has sent reports on public property damage to civil administration which is supposed to issue notices. But rarely have any notices been issued or recoveries been made," a senior Maharashtra police officer said.

* Through 2017 and early 2018, parts of Rajasthan witnessed protests from Rajput group Karni Sena over the film Padmavati. Members of the group not only issued death threats to actors such as Deepika Padukone but also indulged in vandalism in Kota and Chittorgarh, where a mirror of the famed fort was broken. No notice was issued to any member of the Karni Sena by Rajasthan administration.

Said Lokendra Singh Kalvi, founder and patron of the Shri Rajput Karni Sena (SRKS): "No notices were issued to any Karni Sena activists in the state during the protests. Moreover, those who were arrested for vandalism in Kota were not Karni Sena activists. And in Chittorgarh, an FIR was indeed filed but it was against unknown persons."

A senior police official said, "After the FIR, we identified the culprits for the vandalism in Chittorgarh and filed a challan. That was the legal process as required in this case, we did not serve any notices."

* The National Capital too witnessed widespread violence and demonstrations in the wake of demolition of a Ravidas temple in Tughlaqabad in August this year. Protestors indulged in arson and vandalism in various parts of Delhi. Scores of cars, bikes and buses were set on fire. Delhi police sources said no action was initiated by the police to recover damages in this case.

These facts in the survey reveal at least three aspects of the so-called democratic, peaceful agitations in our country- they begin peacefully and turn violent, these agitations are exploited by criminals and our law prescribes punitive measures for lawbreakers among the democratic agitators.

It is this survey that also reveals that the states are not well equipped to follow Supreme Court orders which aim at containing violence and loss of public property during an agitation. The newspaper which arranged for this survey quotes a senior Madhya Pradesh police officer, "The MP administration has not sent notices to anyone with regard to any protest in the past few years. In fact, a mechanism to implement the SC order has not been set up fully here, " notwithstanding the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984 which punishes anyone "who commits mischief by doing any act in respect of any public property" with a jail term of up to five years and a fine or both. Provisions of this law can be coupled with those under the Indian Penal Code.

The survey also reflects on-

'In 2007, Supreme Court of Indian court took suo motu cognizance of "various instances where there was large scale destruction of public and private properties in the name of agitations, bandhs, hartals and the like", and set up two Committees headed by former apex court judge Justice K T Thomas and senior advocate Fali Nariman to suggest changes to the law.

In 2009, the Supreme Court issued guidelines based on the recommendations of the two expert Committees.

The Thomas Committee recommended reversing the burden of proof against protesters. Accepting the suggestion, the Court said that the prosecution should be required to prove that public property had been damaged in direct action called by an organisation, and that the accused also participated in such direct action.

"From that stage the burden can be shifted to the accused to prove his innocence," the Court said. It added that the law must be amended to give the Court the power to draw a presumption that the accused is guilty of destroying public property, and it would then be open to the accused to rebut such presumption.

Such a reversal of the burden of proof is applicable in cases of sexual violence, among others. Generally, the law presumes that the accused is innocent until the prosecution proves its case.

The Nariman Committee's recommendations dealt with extracting damages for destruction. Accepting the recommendations, the Court said the rioters would be made strictly liable for the damage, and compensation would be collected to "make good" the damage.

"Where persons, whether jointly or otherwise, are part of a protest which turns violent, results in damage to private or public property, the persons who have caused the damage, or were part of the protest or who have organized it will be deemed to be strictly liable for the damage so caused, which may be assessed by the ordinary courts or by any special procedure created to enforce the right," the Court said.

Apart from holding rioters liable and imposing costs, the Court also issued guidelines including directing High Courts to order suo motu action, and to set up a machinery to investigate the damage caused and award compensation wherever mass destruction to property takes place due to protests.'

* Dhruva Saikia wrote this article for
The writer can be contacted at dhroovajit(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on January 02, 2020 .

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Chingda Satpi Engellei #4 :: eRang
  • 28th Imphal Book Fair #2 : Gallery
  • Aseismic Building Design
  • Loving Death :: Poem
  • The benefits of CAA
  • Go natural with home made scrub
  • Looking at the journey from 1972
  • The Great Security Circus
  • Hentak - Indigenous Food Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Tribute Rock Concert for (L) Hegin #1 : Gallery
  • Markila, Shanghman, Charoibi : eMing
  • AMWJU amends code of conduct- Jan 22 2020
  • Lalkansung - Natl Child Award for Achievement
  • Where Vultures Dare :: Poem
  • 'BJP Nagaland President got his facts wrong'
  • Decide within four weeks message from SC
  • The Statehood Day
  • Landscape of Purul, Senapati #2 : Gallery
  • Naga Peace Process, Far from being close
  • Of bibliophile & Imphal Book Fair 2020
  • Constitutional protections to specific groups #2
  • Marketing & Sales at R-Square Design
  • Driver & Director's Assistant @ R-Square
  • Marketing & Research Officer @ Amethyst
  • Heart Camp at IGAR South, Mantripukhri
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Pragjyoti International Dance Festival
  • Mentality of those who man Khudengthabi
  • When you fail to control the L & O ..
  • Gaan-Ngai at Kakhulong #1 : Gallery
  • Children Adventure Sports Camp #2 : Gallery
  • Adventure Tourism in Manipur
  • Special Police Unit for NE in Delhi
  • Niagara Falls with Devaz
  • Project Coordinator @ MaolKeki Foundation
  • Reducing air pollution : Impact & prevention
  • Right time for Assam Rifles to Go Back
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand : Timeline
  • Interesting pact between KNO & NNPGs
  • Nation & Unintegrated part now bridged
  • Conservation initiatives of Hornbills #1
  • Day 3 : Sangai Fest #4 : Gallery
  • Reminiscence of legendary aerobiologist
  • A get-together to banish the boredom
  • Hear us oh God :: Poem
  • Resolutions on Naga Political Issue & CAA
  • Stop land allotment of Yaithibi Loukol
  • Wildfire at lower ridge of Shirui Kashong
  • Statehood Women's Polo : Gallery
  • Adversity of Diversity: Chow-Momo Indian
  • Harvard team with CM : Gallery
  • Workshop: Typesetting with Latex @ MU
  • The great cosmic discovery - VII
  • NPF opposed Citizenship Amendment Act
  • Of the highway brave hearts
  • 28th Imphal Book Fair #1 : Gallery
  • Winter Relief Program @Patsoi: Gallery
  • Who are Indigenous People of Manipur #7
  • 2019: Ministry of Development (DoNER)
  • Consultative meeting on Meetei ST demand
  • Beauty benefits of meditation
  • Environment conservation & mankind..
  • Of our Responsibility and our Rights
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni #2: Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chingkham Kabui Khul: Gallery
  • Condolence on demise of Mahima Khan
  • Coping with anxiety before laboratory test
  • The lonely Moon :: Poem
  • Natl Conference on chemicals sciences
  • Constitutional protections to specific groups #1
  • KASHISH, Indian LGBTQ short films
  • Drugs & manufacturing: Who are the kingpins?
  • Indigenous People must defend environment
  • Cultural @ Shirui Lily Fest #4 : Gallery
  • Children Adventure Sports Camp #1 : Gallery
  • Day 3 : Sangai Fest #3 : Gallery
  • The Killing Fields 2013-20 : News Timeline
  • Khangminashi VI, talk series : Food research
  • Can people of NE blame Centre alone for CAA
  • The City of Darkness :: Poem
  • Time for Nagas to build the future: Rio
  • Checking the statements of UG outfits
  • Restoring to the status of People's CM
  • Ibudhou Thangjing, Moirang :: 360 ø View
  • Phamsak collaboration in indigenous ambience
  • Why this relaxation of 12 yrs unless..
  • Being a chow-momo Indian; the fun side!
  • Monika Ingudam - Amb for India Volunteers
  • Petition to CM to dispose contract teachers
  • Call to curb favouritism and nepotism
  • For a better world - to our world leaders
  • Gaan-Ngai @ Ramji Kabui Khul : Gallery
  • Niti Aayog must stop plan to privatise health
  • For the future :: Poem
  • Career in Fashion Communication
  • Jobs at LMP Technology, Canchipur
  • Too many festivals in a year observation
  • What ails Chief Minister gi Haksel gi Tengbang
  • Thong Nambonbi broke apart: Gallery
  • Who are Indigenous People of Manipur #6
  • Fit India Khelo India
  • The Car Washed Shampoo :: Poem
  • Economic development : Special focus on hills
  • Climate change : Biggest challenge in 2020s
  • MAYA trainer at MAAC Imphal center
  • How about the Salt Lake Manipur Bhavan?
  • Fashion Show @ Sangai Fest #1: Gallery
  • Youth and Nation
  • Lyrics of Departing Year :: Poem
  • Forgotten elixir for youths of Manipur
  • Banknotes for sale
  • ADBU - 'Engaged University of the Year'
  • Traffic chaos - a serious problem
  • 'Nongju Ahing' :: eRang Classic Photos
  • Day 1 : Sangai Fest #5 : Gallery
  • City lights :: Poem
  • How China impacts security dynamics in NE
  • Rhythms & Aromas of NE at Ukhrul
  • Lipstick mistakes to avoid
  • Giving a fresh push to the Lim debate?
  • Thong Nambonbi is a part of our history
  • Shumang Leela Ningtham Kumhei: Gallery
  • Death Anniv- Maharaj Gambhir Singh : Gallery
  • Go develop the Hills : A live case study
  • A canal to augment Imphal City, a must !
  • The present health of Loktak Lake
  • Meiraba- 3rd in Badminton World Federation
  • After effects of CAA in North East
  • Film Policy - awaiting action
  • Arambai Langba @Kangjeibung : Gallery
  • JNIMS - Untold story #2
  • CAA is a threat to indigenous communities
  • Ukhrul auditions for Rhythms & Aromas of NE
  • A Wintry Number :: Poem
  • Career in fashion industry
  • Suspension Order issued by NPF to Kenye
  • Web Developer / Trainee at Lamjing IT
  • Cabinet approves NE Gas Pipeline Grid
  • Claiming hands in attack at JNU
  • The changing concept of patriotism
  • IM on integration, Pan Naga Hoho & others
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni #1: Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai :: e-Pao Flash Presentation
  • Gaan-Ngai :: Read all about it
  • Asylum for select migrants.. madness ?
  • Who are Indigenous People of Manipur #5
  • Irom Roshan to exhibit humanoid robot IVALA
  • NPF Statement on CAA 2019
  • Time to focus on examinations
  • The taste of Indian democracy
  • Culturals @ Mera Houchongba #3: Gallery
  • Press Club Foundation Day: Gallery
  • A Hymn for Goddess Emoinu
  • Post-mortem of New Year Celebration
  • Shillong audition for Rhythm & Aromas of NE
  • Army Arrived at Lunch
  • Cocktail of CAB, CAA, NRC & NPR
  • A treatise on mind #3
  • Menamparampil for Journalism Award
  • Govt committed to protect indigenous people
  • Cabinet increase pension for retired journalist
  • Hiyangthau :: Funga Wari
  • Official Release of AMAND Calendar 2020
  • Happening and good cheer as career
  • Voices of the Stars :: Poem
  • Yaikhomba: Selected National Bravery Award
  • War against the English language
  • BJP : In Delhi & Manipur: Twain does not meet
  • Licypriya- Top 100 Child Prodigy: Gallery
  • A Critique of the Manipur ILP Guidelines
  • Licypriya- 100 Child Prodigies : Report
  • Critique of ILP Guidelines (Meiteilon)
  • Architectural Designer at R-Square
  • AutoCad Drafsman at R-Square
  • Crops production & Award for Manipur !
  • New Year picnic @Singda Dam : Gallery
  • Kairembikhok Women opted carpentry
  • RIST Talk -42 @MU : Mimicking nature
  • Obsessive Compulsive Disorder
  • Project Engineer at R-Square
  • Site Manager at R-Square
  • Research Officer at Amethyst
  • Jobs @ Birla Emporiums, Khurai
  • Assam looking at bygone years
  • Krishi Karman Award for Manipur !
  • Khusbu Sorokhaibam : Glass Painting
  • Who are Indigenous People of Manipur #4
  • CC Meet 2019 : Fixture (Semis & Final)
  • JNIMS - Untold story #1
  • About Failed 'Real Madrid' & Climate Change!
  • Manipur : Krishi Karman Award for foodgrain
  • Year end review: Department of Atomic Energy
  • Disturbed area status & improved law & order
  • The choice is yours Mr. Chief Minister
  • Dec 30 : Sangai Fest #1 : Gallery
  • Marriage rituals of Tais #2
  • Recovering compensation from CAA agitators
  • In The Name of Democracy
  • A treatise on mind #2
  • Nightingales in Winter :: Poem
  • Social Service at Ibudhou Thangjing campus
  • Manipur start issue of ILP permits
  • 386 arrested in 282 drug related cases : 2019
  • NIA files chargesheet in AR ambush case
  • 'Marketing' on New Year 2020 eve: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2019 #6: Gallery
  • Meetei Today launches new website
  • Manipur : As I grew up in #3
  • Bye - Bye 2019 :: Poem
  • Stands in solidarity with the Workers
  • Peace or Pandora's Box in 2020 ?
  • X-Mas @Ukhrul, @Kpi #2 : Gallery
  • January Calendar for Year 2020 : Tools
  • Normal age forgetfulness vs Dementia
  • Who was afraid of NK Sanajaoba ?
  • Bidding farewell with a new hope
  • Hogenakkal - India's Niagara
  • Degrading environment vs activities
  • State of economy in the dark times
  • Understanding the lives of Trans community
  • New species: Trichodesma Kumareum
  • The Spear is born for the Zulu
  • Water Pollution: Causes & Effects
  • Year End Review 2019, Dept of Youth Affairs
  • Bridging disconnect & delving deeper
  • X-Mas @Ukhrul, @Kpi #1 : Gallery
  • Day 3 : Sangai Fest #2 : Gallery
  • State of our state
  • Culturals @ Mera Houchongba #2: Gallery
  • Destination NE @ Vanarasi #5: Gallery
  • Mister Manipur 2019 #3 : Gallery
  • Day 1 : Sangai Fest #4 : Gallery
  • Piulong Valley, Tamenglong #1: Gallery
  • Aerial- Imp to Tamenglong: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Nupi Lan Ningsing Lamjel #2: Gallery
  • Nupi Lan Day (State): Gallery
  • Brahmacharimayum Mahendra : Silpbhusan
  • Tolloi, Ukhrul :: 360 Panorama View