TODAY -

A brief note on Manipur and the Lushai Expedition, 1871-72
- Part 3 -

Prof N Lokendra Singh *

 The inscription on stones at Chibu
Original Inscription on Chebu stone :: Pix - TSE



We like to bring these official narratives in brief here for the readers.

1. Account of Mr. J.W. Edgar, the Political Officer, Cachar Column

[Source: NAI, FP, August 1872, No. 95: Edgar to Bourchier, 21 March 1872].

Mr. J.W. Edgar, the Political Officer, Cachar Column of the Lushai Expeditionary Force, informed that the bone of contention between Lushais and Suktes at this time was the "detention" of several villagers of "Sotes or Pytes" by the former in Vonolel's country and that these Suktes now "took advantage of the presence of our force and the disorganization of the Looshai villages to escape to their own country".

Hence, on the 3 March 1872 "about one hundred armed men from Kamhow's villages" had come to the Looshai villages "for the purpose of protecting the Sotes who wished to leave". On the 5 March 1873, Edgar was informed by Durpong that "nearly one thousand Sotes had gone off to Kamhow under the protection of the armed party sent by the latter, and that they had taken with them all their property".

Edgar said that "these were the people who appeared two days later at the Munnipoorie camp". He went on reporting that "Kamhow has acted as the ally of Munnipoor all through the campaign, and that the Munnipoories have never expressed the slightest doubt of his fidelity".

He described the incident at Chibu as:
"The armed men of Kokatung's party were outnumbered by the Munnipoories in the proportion of at least three to one, probably much more. They evidently went into the midst of the camp in perfect reliance on the friendliness of the Munnipoories, for, as the result showed, they put within reach of the latter the women and children as well as the property of the refugees.

Their suspicions were not even aroused when the Munnipoories officer fired off the muskets of the Chiefs and when each armed man was surrounded by a group of three sepoys. I do not believe that the Sotes had the slightest intention of attacking the Munnipoorie camp. The charge was, in all probability, afterwards invented by the Majors to excuse their own conduct".

2. Account of Alexander Mackenzie

[Source: The North East Frontier of India, 1894, pp. 165-71].

Mackenzie in his book brought together all facts into account and concluded: "The question whether, up to this time, the Sooties [Kamhows] were really friendly or hostile to Manipur, was therefore a disputed one".

He said this because he found that there were 7 Kamhow raids between 1857 and 1871 and two during the Lushai Expeditions which the latter had repudiated the later raids before 1872 was done without his authority.

On the other hand, he found that at the beginning of 1871 the Kamhows sent 4 heads to Manipur after their successful raid on the Lushai country which Mackenzie said as an evidence that "they were not then openly hostile to Manipur". When Kamhows were asked to assist the expedition at the end of 1871 by the Maharaja of Manipur, the Chief sent a deputation to Manipur and informed him that he cannot leave his country due to fear of attack from the Lushais but given his "friendly assurances."

Mackenzie went on saying: "When the Manipur troops were returning after the conclusion of the expedition they fell in with a party of Kamhows under the Chief named Kokatung, who were carrying away 957 captives from two Lushai villages.

The Kamhows came into the camp of the Manipur Contingent apparently not expecting to be treated as enemies, but were all made prisoners by the Contingent and taken to Manipur and placed in irons in the jail. The 957 captives were also taken to Manipur, but not as prisoners; they were settled in the valley.

General Bourchier stigmatized this as an act of "treachery" on the part of the Contingent, though it had been admitted that Kokatung had committed a raid on a Manipur village in 1871".

He went on saying that Kamhows were anxious for the release of prisoners and sent embassy to Manipur in April which was denied. It was after the return of this embassy that Kokatung died in the prison. In August 1872, the Political Agent heard that Manipur was intending to attack the Kamhows and the latter on the other hand "had given out that they would require 100 human heads to perform the funeral obsequies of the late Chief".

The British government was averse to any war. In October 1872, the Kamhows sent another embassy who came with four captives and elephant tusks. The officiating Political Agent, Col. Mowbray Thomson "endeavoured to effect a reconciliation between the Manipur and Sooties". He was eventually successful, for in December 1872, the deputation returned with 26 captives, which was exchanged with similar numbers of prisoners.

The following month another 14 captives were brought where further exchange was affected.

Mackenzie went on saying:
On this occasion, Colonel Thomson proposed that the tribe should swear allegiance and fealty to Manipur, to which Kikoul agreed, and said they wanted peace with Manipur, but stipulated that the son of their late Chief, Kokatung, should be released, and the skull and bones of his dead father made over to them.

This request was complied with by the Manipur authorities, and March 1873 peace was sworn between Kokatung's son and Manipur, and the whole of the Kamhows released then their departure for their Native hills.
(p. 168)

Mackenzie went on saying that "the peace thus brought about did not last long". In October 1874, the Kamhows attacked two villages of Kumsol and Mukoong to the south of the valley. In February 1875, Manipur sent an expedition against the Kamhows but it was "not much felt by them". So from 1876 "they seemed to be becoming more aggressive and arrogant than before". So, he went on narrating a series of raids thereafter.

3. Account of B.S. Carey and H.N. Tuck

(Source: The Chin Hills, Vol. 1, 1895, p. 19, fn. 1)

Carey and Tuck discuss the case of Kokatung arrest at Chibu and provided the version of the Chins on the subject.

"The following is the Chin version, which we have received from Kokatung's sons and the man named Kikoul (who recovered Kokatung's bones) and from persons who were arrested at the Chibu Camp by the Manipuris". "Kokatung's correct name was Nokatung; he was a Nwite and not Kanhow, and he lived at Mwelpi… During the Lushai expedition Nokatung, who had gone north, fearing for the safety of his relations, crossed into Lushai and persuaded the emigrants to return with him to settle down in his village. On their way to Mwelpi they saw the Manipur encampment, and, considering the Manipuris as friends, they entered the camp and were treacherously seized and carried off to Manipur, where Nokatung died in jail in 1872".

Conclusion

We have seen the different accounts of Manipur's column in the Lushai Expedition and the events that follow. It is evident from those accounts that the Manipur's column was encamped at the Chibu salt-spring and from here took control of its frontier as had been expected. It was here that memorial stones were erected and inscription endowed in the name of the Maharaja as was the usual practice during that time.

The recent public discourse had questioned the lines written on the stones as false and exaggeration. It should be remembered that judging the past events and writings from today's point of view would be a mistake we had often done than not. It is felt that the past should be understood from its own context so is the inscription they laid down.

Here, we have had a precolonial state system which had their own way of doing things and an understanding of the kingdom, territory and population which differed much from what we know of the same today. Erection of memorial stone was one such state activity to mark an important event. It could be done only with the permission of the king and can only be done in his name.

Such stones were erected in a certain courtly fashion that naturally praised the king and his achievements in a highly stylized fashion. The language has to be panegyric in character. The terms like loichanbaa or loichalakpa (translated as, "subjection", "subdue", "submit", etc.,) are the usual courtly language that needs to be understood from that context only, not otherwise.

Given all circumstances into perspective, one may look into the whole episodes at Chibu in the context of the Manipur-Lushai Treaty of 1872 that centre on "mutual friendship". We suggest that this aspect needs to be emphasized by all rather than banking on the controversy and egoism that corrupted the colonial officers.

In the spirit of "mutual friendship" which had concluded the expedition, the present government, which is now creating a Park in the name of the king, may also take steps to heal the hurt feeling meted to Kokatung's clan/tribe. Such a healing touch may work a long way in ensuring peace and prosperity in the state.

Concluded.....


* Prof N Lokendra Singh wrote this article for The Sangai Express
Prof N Lokendra Singh is the Head of Department of History, Manipur University
This article was webcasted on July 22 2020.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @ Kangla #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 02 Oct : Govt of Manipur
  • Chingangbam Ranju: Gold in Skateboarding
  • Clean India Campaign 2022 at MU
  • Prof without a PhD
  • Bio-security to prevent diseases in livestock
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Befitting response from 'unwanted' parents
  • Stand of STDCM & WMC : ST demand
  • Lamyanba Irawat Birth Anniv #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 01 Oct : Govt of Manipur
  • North East cheers for now
  • Loving Her :: Poem
  • Revoke Show Cause Notice to Dr Sanatomba
  • This Gujarat Model is worth replicating
  • The age-old art of Chola bronze statues
  • Laklaroi Amuk Hanna Yeningtha #2 : Gallery
  • October Calendar for Year 2022 : Tools
  • Old Lambulane, was a trend setting locality
  • Agniveer recruitment rally at Mizoram
  • Prevention of parasitism in livestock #3
  • The ground zero of gratitude
  • Eye makeup products every girl should have
  • Another statewide observance of Irabot Day
  • Saluting the Lamyanba : Respecting dissent
  • How does the full moon make waves...
  • COVID-19 Status 29 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Legalising production & sale of liquor
  • RKCS Children's Painting Competition
  • Online Essay Competition
  • Significance of World Heart Day 2022
  • A kind of feeling :: Poem
  • Free rice and plight of state's farmers
  • Lifting prohibition after 3 decades
  • Linthoi Chanambam : First Judo Gold Medalist
  • COVID-19 Status 28 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2022 #4: Gallery
  • Sore Admiration :: Poem
  • Accountant Assistant @ Amber & Arthur
  • World Heart Day 2022
  • Indo-Naga Talks (2012-) :: News Timeline
  • Plastic menace: Time over for warning
  • Promoting cycling in Imphal
  • Mera Chaorel Houba @ Kangla #1 :: Gallery
  • Tripura Fashion Week @ Agartala :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 27 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • ST status demands in India #2
  • Socio-cultural tourism in NE India
  • Investigation against CRPF Personal
  • Backache in diabetics: Never ignore it
  • 'Poison' liquor still favourite for commoners
  • What has happened to the ban on SUP ?
  • Maibi Jagoi @ Thangjing Haraoba :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 26 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Lamyanba Irabot Ningsing Tha : Plantation
  • World Pharmacists Day 2022
  • Workshop of Wildlife Crime Prevention
  • Genius is knowing when to stop !
  • Naga final pact as Nagaland polls near
  • Lifting prohibition : Talk of the day
  • Tarpon Chaklen Katpa @ Andro #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 25 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Lamyanba Irabot Ningsing Tha : Fingerlings
  • Tripura Fashion Week in Agartala
  • World River Day & our environment
  • Nubank : banking industry in Brazil
  • Opposition parties struggling to dent BJP
  • From High Court to Supreme Court ?
  • Lokchao Bridge @ NH 102 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 24 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • What were Phizo's last words to Khodao?
  • Priyadarshini, Priyanka: Everest Taekwondo
  • I swear :: Poem
  • Incomplete lifting of prohibition
  • Prevention of parasitism in livestock #2
  • Wakhal Eronba- Sumang Leela #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 23 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Arbin Tonjam: best designer - Miss Manipur
  • Lamyanba Irabot Ningsing Tha at Ithing
  • Ferry to Ganges :: Poem
  • Making public health messaging entertaining
  • Student schooling order exposes fault...
  • Discipline : The common thread
  • Camping @ Shirui Lily Fest #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 22 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Youth : An idea can change the world
  • Perceived class conflict triggers friction ...
  • The tale of a forgotten diary
  • Face Redness- How to get rid of it
  • CADA - Govt on collision course
  • Inching towards a final pact ?
  • Border Pillar Inspection @Kamjong :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 21 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Strange bed fellows attempting to cohabit
  • Training for entrepreneur in Food Processing
  • Recalling Alzheimer once again !
  • New Education Policy : The CUET rigmarole
  • Liquor for better health! Indigestible
  • Now focus on ST demand
  • Byron Aihara - A True Lover of Manipur
  • International Day of Peace 2022
  • Human Capital Formation, need of the hour
  • Prevention is better than cure !!
  • Prevention of parasitism in livestock #1
  • Security Conference at Tamenglong
  • Concrete action must follow 'CM Da Haisi'
  • Tag of a dry State for the last 30 years
  • Pungyam Yeiba Fest @Singjamei :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 19 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • National Bamboo Innovation Challenge
  • International Day of Peace & environment
  • Lamyanba Irabot Ningsing Tha: Social Service
  • World Bamboo Day celebrated
  • Domestic capitalists unwilling to trust & invest
  • Street food vogue boon for youth
  • Sit-ins demanding inclusion in ST list
  • Down Memory Lane: My Years with MSAD #3
  • COVID-19 Status 18 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Licypriya to attend UN General Assembly
  • Screenwriters invited to 6-month screenlab
  • An ideal civil servant
  • Tripura Fashion Week in Agartala
  • Opposition parties struggling to dent BJP
  • Taking the customer for granted
  • Miss Manipur 2022 #2 :: Gallery
  • Irabot Ningsing Tha : Jagoi Competition
  • Bringing drug users to mainstream society
  • Namo Birthday special: India matters globally
  • Criticizes village occupation in Ukhrul
  • Use of local agri wastes as substrate
  • Jiribam Keithel [15 June] #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 16 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Boeing University Innovation Leadership
  • ST status demands in India #1
  • Literacy enhancement as a career choice
  • Agniveer recruitment rally at Assam
  • Ignoring the perfect solution to everything
  • Eyeing to end insurgency in next 5 years
  • Laklaroi Amuk Hanna Yeningtha #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 15 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Manipuri Muslim (Pangal) Historical Society
  • 7th election: NE Student Org, Jalandhar
  • Macnivil releases new song: Price they'll pay
  • Youth advocating for sexual health & rights
  • Engineers : The backbone of any Nation
  • IBSD celebrated Hindi Diwas
  • Who is at fault for shrinking roads?
  • After 25 years of negotiations
  • Heikru Hidongba @Bijoy Govinda #2: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 14 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Joint Accordant by NSCN/GPRN & NNPGs
  • In search of Khubak Ishei
  • Lamyanba Irabot Ningsing Tha at Bishnupur
  • Beauty benefits of Amla
  • STDCM sets sight on bandh to draw Govt
  • The unplanned city of Imphal Concrete jungle
  • Down Memory Lane: My Years with MSAD #2
  • COVID-19 Status 13 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Constitution & flag still dogs settlement
  • Churachandpur - The chaos and mess !
  • Rice Afrika is using tech to increase rice
  • Voluntary Blood Donation: An act of solidarity
  • Nagaland desperate for solution to Naga issue
  • Final solution likely very soon: Note key word
  • Miss Manipur 2022 #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 12 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Is there a need for another Nupi Lan ?
  • Consultation: Development at Lairouching
  • Bullying : Losing of children's dignity
  • Social Entrepreneur, social currency they earn
  • AMSU in dire need of support of CSOs
  • Mum on the points of JCILPS, STDCM
  • 57th Hunger Marchers' Day #3 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 11 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • 1st Anniv: The Keithel Store Pune :: Gallery
  • Beyond Teachers' Day
  • On farm production of Mycorrhizae
  • Onam and the legend behind it
  • COVID-19 Status 10 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Fake voters testify official nepotism
  • From 1999 to 2022 : TSE is now 23
  • Yaoshang Thabal Competition #3 :: Gallery
  • Kholao Deben went with the Queen
  • Imaginary grudge severs human relations
  • A Phenomenally Him :: Poem
  • Bharat Jodo Yatra: Last ditch effort...
  • Special Lok Adalat for Imphal & Bishnupur
  • Pineapple Fest @Bunglon, CCpur :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 09 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Tarpon: Annual offerings to the dead by living
  • Book review: Aeromycology over Kachai lemon
  • On saying Hello
  • Himalayan Day celebrated at IBSD, Imphal
  • Get rid of strawberry legs at home
  • Manipuri driver primary source of 'Loyalty tax'
  • The 'tax-extortion' argument
  • Down Memory Lane: My Years with MSAD #1
  • COVID-19 Status 08 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • [Jobs] Biotechnology ignition grant for NE
  • 1st Anniversary of The Keithel Store Pune
  • International Literacy Day & our Environment
  • 1 Lakh Hand Sanitizer Bottles handed over
  • Pinning hope on Sangai fest to draw tourists
  • Points to study from Mizoram
  • Heikru Hidongba @Bijoy Govinda #1: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 07 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Schedule Tribe Demand, Recent cries
  • Intricacies of core issue in Naga insurgency
  • On Poiroukhongjin High School issue
  • Celebrating International Literacy Day, 2022
  • Condemn physical assault on women vendor
  • Scoundrel official undermining essence of ILP
  • Is the ban on SUP effective ?
  • Ayekpam Shyamsunder's life & works
  • Book release: 'Osman Thambal' at Imphal
  • World Sexual Health Day celebrated in NE
  • Manipur Tech Univ: top at India Hackathon
  • Insomnia :: Poem
  • Change - Inside Out!
  • Biological control in agriculture #2
  • Nearest-to-home posting of teachers policy
  • Addressing shortage of teachers
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #6 :: Gallery
  • Ancient Manipur kingdom and Brahmanism
  • Teachers' role in multicultural North East
  • Regarding closing 34 Assam govt schools
  • mPharma is revolutioning access to medicine
  • Asking to believe as we receive
  • 10 years of TPC: Success collectively shared
  • Significance of observing Teachers' Day
  • Krishna Janma @ ISKCON :: Gallery
  • Growing support globally to end HIV medicine
  • Teachers' Day & My Rumbling Thoughts
  • Soibam Bindeshori : Indian Prime Icon Award
  • Can't public figures drink & dance
  • Climate emergency
  • Jumping ship trademark of state's politicians
  • Switching side from JD (U) to BJP
  • Sit-in for Meetei ST @ Kongba :: Gallery
  • Meira Rally against Drug Traffic #2 :: Gallery
  • 57th Hunger Marchers' Day #2 :: Gallery
  • Reception of Linthoi Chanambam :: Gallery
  • Jiribam Train station [15 Jun] :: Gallery
  • Haipou Jadonang - Martyr Day :: Gallery
  • 13 August observed by CSOs :: Gallery
  • Mirabai Chanu: gold @ Commonwealth Game
  • Rules of English Pronunciation : Download
  • Sub-Syllables in English : Book Download