TODAY -

Puya - Meithaba: The Date Controversy

Chabungbam Amuba Singh *

Flag of Manipur flying high on Observance of  285 years of Puya Mei Thaba  at Hanjing Meekollok, Heingang
Flag of Manipur flying high on Observance of 285 years of Puya Mei Thaba at Hanjing Meekollok, Heingang :: Pix - Deepak Oinam



If God grants me the power to reverse a single event in the history of Manipur I would choose the event of burning of the Manipuri manuscripts during the reign of King Pamheiba in the second quarter of the eighteenth century. I have no evil feeling about King Pamheiba embracing Hinduism - because religion is always universal and anybody on earth can follow/adopt any religion of his choice. Faith is the essence of any religious practice. Campaigning against another religion is no religion. As conversion is morally acceptable and, in fact, is universally practiced Pamheiba's conversion into Hinduism with all its subsequent ramifications should be nobody's moral issue. But his act of burning up the Puyas is a unforgivable sin.

When I visited Tamil University, Thanjavur, as a member of a UGC team for evaluation of its XI Plan proposal what struck me most was not its sprawling wooded campus but the large collection of old palm-leaf manuscripts in its Tamil language department and also in the city library which has an imposing collection of palm-leaf manuscripts, each written on chemically treated dry palm leaves and stacked and bound (stringed) between two wooden strips as cover.

Moving in the large stack rooms filled with such manuscripts my mind was momentarily caught up with a yearning to have a glimpse of the lost puyas and wondered how those might have looked. When I read Saroj Nalini Arambam Parratt's lucid description of the process of making the Meetei paper on which the currently available Cheitharol Kumbaba (in Meitei script) copies are written I could not help wondering whether the old puyas were also written on similar material which can be called paper. This innocent musing assumes significance, as elaborated below, in the context of the currently popular belief of 'Tai-origin of the Manipuris', .

If we have any convincing evidence of the Meiteis having mastered the basic technique of paper making say in the first millennium A.D. that could be a significant evidence in support of the oriental origin of the Meiteis. For, It is generally known that paper was invented in China around the beginning of the 2nd century A.D. and that the art/technique reached Egypt in the 10th century and Europe only in the 12th century.

Not long ago there was a news item in a local daily which implied that R K Jhaljit Singh and H Bihari Singh had claimed that the episode of burning of Puyas did not at all occur in the history of Manipur. Coming from two prominent experts and eminent scholars - this comment, if at all they had made, should not be left un-debated.

Without prejudice to the debate-in-call, let me point out that there is no convergence of opinion on the date assigned to the tragic event of Puya-Meithaba. Before I proceed further I wish to make it explicitly clear that I am not contesting the truth of the occurrence of the event; I am simply dealing with the controversy about the date of occurrence.

Three different dates have been around:

1. A prominent group of Intellectuals (led by the Meitei National Front) has been observing the Puya-Meithaba day on the 23rd day of Wakching (since 1978!) maintaining that the sad event occurred on "Thursday, the 23rd day of Wakching in 1729 CE". The same date is maintained in a Wikipedia article on the History of Manipur with the further addition that the event occurred between 9 and 10 am.

2. In an Internet article entitled 'A Brief History(Puwari) of The Meiteis of Manipur' P. Lalit says, "On the full-moon day of Mera(October) 1732 AD he (Pamheiba) collected all the holy books(Puyas) and burned them". This date is identified as Friday the 3rd October 1732. [As the author has not cited the source of this information it may be taken as an educated conjecture.]

3. In the Cheitharol Kumbaba published by the Manipuri Sahitya Parishad (MSP), Imphal , in the Bengali script (second print, 1988),edited by L Ibungohal Singh and N Khelchandra Singh, the date of the event was recorded as Sunday the 17th day of Mera of Sakabda 1654 which, in the Common Era calendar, is the 5th October 1732. [This was, perhaps, a wilful editorial distortion of the original recording in the manuscript in Meitei script, as pointed out and positively criticised by Saroj Nalini Arambam Parratt in her book ,"The Court Chronicle of the Kings of Manipur The Cheitharol Kumpapa". In the latest print of the MSP's Cheitharol Kumbaba in Bengali script (2012) the original recording has been restored and there is no mention of burning of Meitei books(Puyas). However the editorial note on page 93 still persists implying that the event of burning of 'Meitei Lairik's occurred on Sunday the 5th October 1732]

[ Another prominent intellectual group (The Akom Lup, Kangleipak) supports this date,- according to a news item in the local daily The Poknapham of March 1, 2014,-by saying that there are so many books in support of this particular date].

A scrutiny of the first date with comments :

The first mentioned date, viz, "Thursday ,the 23rd Wakching 1729 CE", cannot be right per se. Because, the 23rd Wakching of 1729 CE was not a Thursday - it is, in fact, Saturday the 22 January 1729. This can be verified from the following facts: (i) there was a lunar eclipse on Sunday the 13th February 1729 (NASA Eclipse record, also recorded in the Cheitharon Kumbaba), and (ii) the first day of the month of Phairen of 1729 CE was also a Sunday (30 January 1729)(Cheitharol Kumbaba).

It is probable that a mistake was committed while translating the Sakabda year to the CE year. It is emphatically pointed out that the rote practice of converting a Sakabda year into the CE year just by adding 78 is not right for the months of January, February and March. For the first three months of a Gregorian year (also for a part of April) the correct procedure is to add 79 (not 78!). Digressing a little, let me point out that many historians of Manipur wrongly write that King Marjit ascended the throne in 1813 CE - a result of the simplistic practice of converting the Sakabda year 1735 into the CE year by adding 78. The truth is that Marjit ascended the throne on Wednesday the 17th day of Shajibu Saka 1735 which translates into the 6th April 1814 (not 1813!).

Suppose that such a mistake had crept in inadvertently and that the sad event occurred in the year of Sakabda 1651, then we could say that the event of Puya-Meithaba occurred on "Thursday, the 23rd day of Wakching of 1730 CE", because this day was indeed a Thursday.

This well-intended attempt to remove a lacunae meets the dead end of plausibility. KIng Pamheiba and his spiritual guru Shantidas were not at the palace(Kangla) on the 23rd Wakching Kum-Sok 1651 (Thursday, 12 January 1730 CE). They left the previous day for raiding/subduing the Kabui Nungshai tribes and returned to Kangla a week later, according to the Cheitharol Kumbaba.

A simple way out of the inconsistency is, of course, to suppress the lacunae by striking out the word 'Thursday' and simply say that the event took place on the 23rd day of Wakching 1729 CE without mentioning the week-day. This however amounts to making a significant departure from the hall-mark practice, adopted by the Manipuri Court scribes, of mentioning the week-day immediately after the lunar date of the day while recording an event.


* Chabungbam Amuba Singh wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is Former Vice-Chancellor, Manipur University and can be contacted at camuba(dot)singh(at)gmail(dot)com
This article was posted on March 03, 2014



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Lamklai Kummoi Maring Fest #2: Gallery
  • National School Games- Fencing: Gallery
  • We want the ring...
  • The Queen's Heart :: Poem
  • Education of heart: Heart of Education
  • Mao - The Revolutionary
  • Discussion on India-Vietnam Relation
  • Sangai of the Sangai festival
  • Jarnail in his element
  • Tough road awaits Sarita in World Boxing
  • ACAUT says NNPGs unable to rein..
  • State has no say in ILP - Conrad
  • Ningol Chakouba @ MBC #2 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakouba Nga Mela #2 : Gallery
  • Rajkumar Jhaljit : Sahityaratna 2017
  • Gaudiya Vaishnavism in Meitei Nation #2
  • Ningol Chakouba :: Poem
  • World Diabetes Day 2018
  • Bartending as a career option
  • The unintended windfall
  • Issues before the Parliamentary polls
  • Mera Kongchat Mass Rally #3: Gallery
  • Rock Show at X-Jam 2018 : Gallery
  • Bloody Phanek wins at Signs Festival
  • Gender Equality & Development :: Book
  • I am friend of India for life- Japanese PM
  • 2019 Commonwealth Scholarship in UK
  • 55th Nagas' Meet at New Delhi
  • Black money and the dream-merchants
  • What steps to address traffic chaos ?
  • Govt extends ban on seven Meitei groups
  • It won't be easy for Mary Kom - Nieva
  • Ningol Chakouba @ Mysore #1 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakouba @ Dubai #1 : Gallery
  • Cry of a Dying River - 54 :: Poem
  • Religious education- Part of our life
  • Free Heart Camp at Kakching Bazar
  • Jobs at Gyan Jyoti Foundation
  • Nothing seems change; everything remains
  • Predatory instinct of man: Targeting 'Manipur'
  • Lihaaz- Classical Music at IIT Guwahati
  • Mera Wayungba #1 : Gallery
  • L Modhuchandra : Young Scientist Award
  • Chavang Kut celebrated in Delhi
  • Temple runs for a pilgrim's journey
  • First day of All India Young Writers' Festival
  • Ningol Chakkouba in era of materials
  • Constitutional breakdown in governance
  • Attacked on Environment Defenders
  • Kut festival @ Chandel : Gallery
  • Mega Marathon Manipur #2 : Gallery
  • Karen people's pursuit for survival..
  • Glamorous Maniac & their new single
  • City bus for high end of society- Why not?
  • Youth Leadership Camp at Yairipok
  • Course in Political Science at NEHU
  • Of Indian Constitution
  • Ningol Chakouba @ MBC #1 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakouba Nga Mela #1 : Gallery
  • NH7 Weekender @Meghalaya #2 : Gallery
  • Gaudiya Vaishnavism in Meitei Nation #1
  • Old Man in the Winter :: Poem
  • Drawing inspiration from Dave Mustaine
  • Condemns attack on Agnes Kharshiing
  • NEUFC Fan Park celebrates
  • Achievement lists of PDA is 'Boring'
  • MPP : Down but not out
  • Ningol - mapam lamdam : Gallery
  • Kwatha Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba: Biggest fest of Manipuri
  • Mizoram Under the British Rule :: Book
  • Dr. Udit Raj: a Crusader
  • Undisclosed #MeToo campaign in Manipur?
  • Drought :: Poem
  • When Money matters, sincerity is out..
  • Detaining two more at Jiribam
  • Ningol Chakkouba : Flash Presentation
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping #1: Gallery
  • Chingjaroi, Atengba, Ahongbi :: eMing
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Those Sparks and Sounds
  • Manipur from Independence to Merger #2
  • Understanding RSS :: Book Review
  • Cry of a Dying River - 53 :: Poem
  • A take on Freedom of Media
  • Pay of private school teachers
  • Mera Kongchat Mass Rally #2: Gallery
  • Art Festival @ Imphal : Gallery
  • 26 month left to meet AIDS 90-90-90 target
  • Tengnoumanbi- Essential food item ..
  • Dr Abdul Kalam vision of transforming India
  • A Wintry Landscape :: Poem
  • 'Say no to Lead Paints'
  • Completing bigger task
  • Biomedical wastes: Health, ecology at stake
  • NIA files chargesheet against 5 NSCN (K)
  • Ningol Chakouba @ Kolkata : Gallery
  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #3: Gallery
  • Irony of idea of communal harmony
  • Blood Donation at RGU, Arunachal Pradesh
  • Career opportunities in Ecology #2
  • Down the Country Road :: Poem
  • Change of season: Prepare for winter
  • Govt forgotten promises to improve traffic
  • ATC demand: Setback to pluralistic Manipur
  • Mega Marathon Manipur #1 : Gallery
  • Descent & inheritance among Zeliangrong
  • Constituent Assembly Of India & NEFA #3
  • Seminar : Reforming Teaching-Learning
  • Attitude :: Poem
  • Tourism: A key sector in the world
  • NH7 Weekender Meghalaya : Day 2 Report
  • Early solution in Manipur difficult : Army
  • Fabrics of Bangladeshi Manipuri: Download
  • NH7 Weekender @Meghalaya #1 : Gallery
  • Pukning Pothasang: Suicide prevention
  • Where have all the flowers gone? Khurkhul
  • Engaging Failed State :: Book Review
  • eNorth East Award 2018
  • Song of a Tree :: Poem
  • NH7 Weekender 2018 Kicks Off
  • Unsolved case of Pravish Chanam
  • Imphal Jamboree : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Manipur from Independence to Merger #1
  • A beacon of hope
  • Mishing tribe of Assam
  • Ransomware that made the world cry
  • State Level Painting Competition
  • A suggestion for a strong democracy
  • Issues before Parliamentary polls
  • Kut Festival @ Kangpokpi : Gallery
  • HIV : Gap between research & impact
  • My Tryst With Manipur : A Memoir :: Review
  • Cultural heritage (Kut fete)
  • Bleeding inside Brain treated at SKY
  • Indo-Myanmar Regional Border Meet
  • In Her Arms Of Death :: Poem
  • Pravish Chanam : No Action by CBI
  • Assam Don Bosco : University of the Year
  • NH7 Weekender 2018 in Meghalaya
  • Media that criticize are not your enemy, CM
  • MU limping back to normalcy
  • Mera Kongchat Mass Rally #1: Gallery
  • Happy Kut Wishes :: Flash Presentation
  • November Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • Weavers training for Mamit , Mizoram
  • Diwali Lagao : Mapugidi Munda
  • Career opportunities in Ecology
  • Jobs at Trueblue, Taxi Service, Imphal
  • CM should not let this opportunity out..
  • Where will Oct 31, 2018 stand ?
  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #2: Gallery
  • Kut Festival :: Series of Articles
  • Comedian Huirem Manglem passed away
  • Constituent Assembly Of India & NEFA #2
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Overview of Buddha's teachings on Karmma
  • Technological Globalisation and Manipur
  • Initiate disciplinary action against Police
  • 13th Indo-Myanmar Border Committee Meet
  • .....but traffic is still in mess
  • Obstinately silly or immense clout
  • 'Ethnic Conflicts in Manipur: Issues'
  • Mapithel Dam Irrigation Canals #2
  • Kangla is like Ayodhya for Meiteis..Sacred
  • Health Care & Status in North East :: Book
  • Speaker List: Imphal Jamboree- Youth Fest
  • Roars of #MeToo to douse the flame of lust
  • A Welcome Change :: Poem
  • Liangmai community performed at NE fest
  • Immature press statement from NDPP: NPF
  • Our expectation from the government
  • October 31 : Rally and bandh
  • Chalwa Village in Kangpokpi #3 : Gallery
  • NEROCA Vs East Bengal : Gallery
  • Lullaby by This Chord :: Critical Analysis
  • Imphal Jamboree - Youth festival
  • Getting ready for Act East Policy
  • Hey! You're a role model :: Poem
  • Training on Cultivation of Mushroom
  • Yitachu is propagating misguiding facts
  • Naga Talk: Wary yet committed & hopeful
  • Fashion Show: Lamklai Kummoi: Gallery
  • Pukning Pothasang : Bereavement
  • Khong: significance in Zeliangrong culture-2
  • RIST Talk -37 : The Physics of Lunar Dust
  • Cry of a Dying River #51 :: Poem
  • WhatsApp cheating : Unexplained loss
  • Cat :: Poem
  • TSA cautions EMRS School
  • Non-issue turns issue
  • Cong gunning for Governor
  • Mera Houchongba @Konung #1: Gallery
  • Sanjenbam Bhanumati Devi : Kavyabhusan
  • Church and climate change
  • Environmental human rights: Its evolution
  • Developing a database on bio-resource #2
  • Incomplete Love :: Poem
  • Beauty benefits of potato
  • The toddler calls
  • UNC : Acceptable to the Zeliangrongs?
  • Trekking to Dzukou Valley #2: Gallery
  • Constituent Assembly Of India & NEFA #1
  • Can we end tobacco pandemic ?
  • Experiencing Senapati town
  • City Bazaar :: Poem
  • Eepan Thaba #1: Gallery
  • Mapithel Dam Irrigation Canals #1
  • Chumthang Crafts at European Congress
  • A Road Trip to Myanmar #3
  • Narmada Sougaijam - Natl Konkan Award
  • Bor khoiramba @Hiyangthang #2 : Gallery
  • Mera Houchongba : Unity - hill & valley
  • Khong: significance in Zeliangrong culture-1
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2018 : Download
  • Lamyanba Irabot- Floral Tribute #2: Gallery
  • Mera Chaorel Houba #2 : Gallery
  • Anglo-Kuki War 1917-19 : Gallery
  • Pari Imom (Film Scenes) #1 :: eRang
  • Death Anniv - Bhagyachandra #3 : Gallery
  • Jarnail Singh @ MU : Gallery
  • Heikru Hidongba #3 : Gallery
  • AMAND Pune: Cultural evening : Gallery
  • Sizo Festival @Saikot : Gallery
  • Tarpon Sonba : Gallery
  • mtM :: Seireng
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #4: Gallery
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS