TODAY -

Puya - Meithaba: The Date Controversy

Chabungbam Amuba Singh *

Flag of Manipur flying high on Observance of  285 years of Puya Mei Thaba  at Hanjing Meekollok, Heingang
Flag of Manipur flying high on Observance of 285 years of Puya Mei Thaba at Hanjing Meekollok, Heingang :: Pix - Deepak Oinam



If God grants me the power to reverse a single event in the history of Manipur I would choose the event of burning of the Manipuri manuscripts during the reign of King Pamheiba in the second quarter of the eighteenth century. I have no evil feeling about King Pamheiba embracing Hinduism - because religion is always universal and anybody on earth can follow/adopt any religion of his choice. Faith is the essence of any religious practice. Campaigning against another religion is no religion. As conversion is morally acceptable and, in fact, is universally practiced Pamheiba's conversion into Hinduism with all its subsequent ramifications should be nobody's moral issue. But his act of burning up the Puyas is a unforgivable sin.

When I visited Tamil University, Thanjavur, as a member of a UGC team for evaluation of its XI Plan proposal what struck me most was not its sprawling wooded campus but the large collection of old palm-leaf manuscripts in its Tamil language department and also in the city library which has an imposing collection of palm-leaf manuscripts, each written on chemically treated dry palm leaves and stacked and bound (stringed) between two wooden strips as cover.

Moving in the large stack rooms filled with such manuscripts my mind was momentarily caught up with a yearning to have a glimpse of the lost puyas and wondered how those might have looked. When I read Saroj Nalini Arambam Parratt's lucid description of the process of making the Meetei paper on which the currently available Cheitharol Kumbaba (in Meitei script) copies are written I could not help wondering whether the old puyas were also written on similar material which can be called paper. This innocent musing assumes significance, as elaborated below, in the context of the currently popular belief of 'Tai-origin of the Manipuris', .

If we have any convincing evidence of the Meiteis having mastered the basic technique of paper making say in the first millennium A.D. that could be a significant evidence in support of the oriental origin of the Meiteis. For, It is generally known that paper was invented in China around the beginning of the 2nd century A.D. and that the art/technique reached Egypt in the 10th century and Europe only in the 12th century.

Not long ago there was a news item in a local daily which implied that R K Jhaljit Singh and H Bihari Singh had claimed that the episode of burning of Puyas did not at all occur in the history of Manipur. Coming from two prominent experts and eminent scholars - this comment, if at all they had made, should not be left un-debated.

Without prejudice to the debate-in-call, let me point out that there is no convergence of opinion on the date assigned to the tragic event of Puya-Meithaba. Before I proceed further I wish to make it explicitly clear that I am not contesting the truth of the occurrence of the event; I am simply dealing with the controversy about the date of occurrence.

Three different dates have been around:

1. A prominent group of Intellectuals (led by the Meitei National Front) has been observing the Puya-Meithaba day on the 23rd day of Wakching (since 1978!) maintaining that the sad event occurred on "Thursday, the 23rd day of Wakching in 1729 CE". The same date is maintained in a Wikipedia article on the History of Manipur with the further addition that the event occurred between 9 and 10 am.

2. In an Internet article entitled 'A Brief History(Puwari) of The Meiteis of Manipur' P. Lalit says, "On the full-moon day of Mera(October) 1732 AD he (Pamheiba) collected all the holy books(Puyas) and burned them". This date is identified as Friday the 3rd October 1732. [As the author has not cited the source of this information it may be taken as an educated conjecture.]

3. In the Cheitharol Kumbaba published by the Manipuri Sahitya Parishad (MSP), Imphal , in the Bengali script (second print, 1988),edited by L Ibungohal Singh and N Khelchandra Singh, the date of the event was recorded as Sunday the 17th day of Mera of Sakabda 1654 which, in the Common Era calendar, is the 5th October 1732. [This was, perhaps, a wilful editorial distortion of the original recording in the manuscript in Meitei script, as pointed out and positively criticised by Saroj Nalini Arambam Parratt in her book ,"The Court Chronicle of the Kings of Manipur The Cheitharol Kumpapa". In the latest print of the MSP's Cheitharol Kumbaba in Bengali script (2012) the original recording has been restored and there is no mention of burning of Meitei books(Puyas). However the editorial note on page 93 still persists implying that the event of burning of 'Meitei Lairik's occurred on Sunday the 5th October 1732]

[ Another prominent intellectual group (The Akom Lup, Kangleipak) supports this date,- according to a news item in the local daily The Poknapham of March 1, 2014,-by saying that there are so many books in support of this particular date].

A scrutiny of the first date with comments :

The first mentioned date, viz, "Thursday ,the 23rd Wakching 1729 CE", cannot be right per se. Because, the 23rd Wakching of 1729 CE was not a Thursday - it is, in fact, Saturday the 22 January 1729. This can be verified from the following facts: (i) there was a lunar eclipse on Sunday the 13th February 1729 (NASA Eclipse record, also recorded in the Cheitharon Kumbaba), and (ii) the first day of the month of Phairen of 1729 CE was also a Sunday (30 January 1729)(Cheitharol Kumbaba).

It is probable that a mistake was committed while translating the Sakabda year to the CE year. It is emphatically pointed out that the rote practice of converting a Sakabda year into the CE year just by adding 78 is not right for the months of January, February and March. For the first three months of a Gregorian year (also for a part of April) the correct procedure is to add 79 (not 78!). Digressing a little, let me point out that many historians of Manipur wrongly write that King Marjit ascended the throne in 1813 CE - a result of the simplistic practice of converting the Sakabda year 1735 into the CE year by adding 78. The truth is that Marjit ascended the throne on Wednesday the 17th day of Shajibu Saka 1735 which translates into the 6th April 1814 (not 1813!).

Suppose that such a mistake had crept in inadvertently and that the sad event occurred in the year of Sakabda 1651, then we could say that the event of Puya-Meithaba occurred on "Thursday, the 23rd day of Wakching of 1730 CE", because this day was indeed a Thursday.

This well-intended attempt to remove a lacunae meets the dead end of plausibility. KIng Pamheiba and his spiritual guru Shantidas were not at the palace(Kangla) on the 23rd Wakching Kum-Sok 1651 (Thursday, 12 January 1730 CE). They left the previous day for raiding/subduing the Kabui Nungshai tribes and returned to Kangla a week later, according to the Cheitharol Kumbaba.

A simple way out of the inconsistency is, of course, to suppress the lacunae by striking out the word 'Thursday' and simply say that the event took place on the 23rd day of Wakching 1729 CE without mentioning the week-day. This however amounts to making a significant departure from the hall-mark practice, adopted by the Manipuri Court scribes, of mentioning the week-day immediately after the lunar date of the day while recording an event.


* Chabungbam Amuba Singh wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is Former Vice-Chancellor, Manipur University and can be contacted at camuba(dot)singh(at)gmail(dot)com
This article was posted on March 03, 2014



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Padmashree Khangembam Mangi : Profile
  • Staff shortage remains bottleneck in hepatitis
  • The 7 statements of Jesus from the cross...
  • MKF Robert Memorial Internship Awarded
  • Yoga and Self realization #1
  • Apprenticeships for employment
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • FIFA ban will hit Manipuri players the hardest
  • Remembering August 15 'self immolation'
  • Pi Thadoi performed @JNMDA #2 :: Gallery
  • The case of illegal migrant, asylum for select
  • Patriotism & Iphone generation
  • Hazy History :: Poem
  • Corruption in NE: Can PM hold the bull...
  • Digital Transformation of Transport Sector
  • Naga flag & constitution demand ...
  • Naga sovereignty Vs 'integral part of India'
  • Tangmai Festival @ CCpur :: Gallery
  • Independence Day celebrated at IBSD Imphal
  • Towards zero waste Manipur
  • Top performing empanelled hospital in Imphal
  • Farm production of entomopathogenic fungi
  • Indo-Naga Talks (2012-) :: News Timeline
  • 13 August @HichamYaicham Pat #1 :: Gallery
  • 75th Manipur Independence Day observation
  • Goal of ensuring every child is born HIV-free
  • An Ode to Youth :: Poem
  • International Youth Day & my Environment
  • Moirang INA Martyrs Memorial campaign #2
  • Tricolour - Some significant facts
  • Indomitable spirit showcased by forefathers
  • Smuggling drugs via Manipur & drug cartels
  • 13 August observed by CSOs :: Gallery
  • 13 August observed @ Bengaluru :: Gallery
  • The good news in a bad world
  • 3rd National Lok Adalat for year, 2022
  • Organ Donation: Seven common questions
  • To Love You :: Poem
  • Jhulon Festival: Nupee Pala #1 :: Gallery
  • Read all about 13th August day significance
  • Report released : 'One District, One Crop'
  • Comment on ADC Bill
  • 'BHEEM' - Breastfeeding to Harness...
  • Moirang INA Martyrs Memorial campaign #1
  • 'Har Ghar Tiranga' with Ex-Serviceman
  • HAC members under Govt, public scrutiny
  • Tearing apart the idea of Manipur?
  • Houses @ Thalon, Tamenglong #1 :: Gallery
  • Cattle crossing Sekmai River :: Gallery
  • Resilient students: KEDO boys crack HSLC
  • Why people impacted by climate disasters...
  • 1000 Cr disbursed to farmers in Meghalaya
  • India Innovation Centre for Graphene
  • Employees doubling up as social media warrior
  • Only the unfortunate get caught?
  • 1st session: 12th Manipur Assembly
  • The beauty in random acts of kindness
  • Beauty :: Poem
  • 'Survival of Meetei Vs privilege of few'
  • Briefing on National Lok Adalat at Lamphel
  • Economic blockade is temporarily suspended
  • Fissures grow as indigenes stare at future
  • Raising the ST banner again
  • Leima Jagoi @Thangjing Haraoba :: Gallery
  • The ATSUM blockade
  • World's Indigenous Peoples Day at Leibi
  • World Indigenous Peoples' Day
  • 'Denounce agreement signed with State Govt'
  • Integrated crop management in Manipur
  • Fuel outlets, traders feasting on blockade
  • Omitting blockade: Clever play of words
  • Martial Art @Shirui Festival 2022 :: Gallery
  • Local coordinated action firewall HIV response
  • Mahua of MP on sale
  • Drug Awareness campaign at Ningthoukhong
  • The emptied :: Poem
  • The other younger version in you
  • Economic blockade, acts of arson tension
  • Busting drug manufacturing unit
  • Kangla Nongpok Torban #1 :: Gallery
  • Understanding Hill Areas Committee & ADC Bill
  • 'Release the arrested Tribal student leaders'
  • Unloved :: Poem
  • Eco-system & its economic evaluation #2
  • Neem for hair care during monsoon
  • Shutting down internet to quell protests
  • Suspending mobile data services
  • Pi Thadoi performed @JNMDA #1 :: Gallery
  • WABA | World Breastfeeding Week 2022
  • Figuring out real value of thing is key to living
  • "Tribe" in India: shrouded in uncertainty #3
  • We cannot #endAIDS if we depend on North
  • NDA to get its nominee into Upa Rashtrapati
  • Tarao Harvest Fest @ Chandel #5 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 05 August : Govt of Manipur
  • Conversion of Jhum fields for sedentary agri
  • National Aquifer Mapping Programme
  • NEP : Preparing for a knowledge economy
  • Govt move to put curb on new villages
  • HAC recommended ADC Bill, 2021
  • Media protest against NIA [4 Aug] :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 04 August : Govt of Manipur
  • The untold story of Koubru Mountain
  • UNAIDS data paint a grim picture of HIV
  • 'Nasha Mukt Bharat Abhiyan' at MU
  • Water approach to solving water scarcity
  • Environmental Activist Anish #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 02 August : Govt of Manipur
  • First rain :: Poem
  • Eco-system & its economic evaluation #1
  • My first colour film roll
  • House debates ADC Bill after protest threat
  • Ideas from the man from Ukhrul AC
  • Hiyang Tannaba @ Loktak #2 : Gallery
  • Online class : Interpretation
  • Acid test for Amit Shah & Neiphiu Rio
  • Nonage :: Poem
  • HIV care is essential, but not enough...
  • Fish based integrated farming system #2
  • The memories of my business school
  • Govt desperate to reopen IMFL sale outlets
  • Prohibition in force since 1991!
  • Kwatha (Indo-Myanmar border) #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 01 August : Govt of Manipur
  • Post for Project Associate at MU
  • "Tribe" in India: shrouded in uncertainty #2
  • Why is status of daughters not changing...
  • Animal Farm (In the Context of Imphal City)
  • ..with a pinch of salt & enjoy the humour
  • Sportspersons shine as state grapples ...
  • Call for ADC Bill, NRC: Studying the whys
  • Seasonal food items @ Ema Keithel : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 31 July : Govt of Manipur
  • How will children living with HIV grow up ...
  • Trafficking laws: to curb modern slavery
  • Pieces :: Poem
  • Drinkwell: Making safe water accessible
  • Tokyo to Birmingham: Hailing the Golden Girl
  • Infrastructure must to fuel Act East Policy
  • Aribam Syam Sharma :: Biography
  • Mirabai Chanu: gold @ Commonwealth Game
  • Petitions to Assembly for public grievances
  • Impact of science on society deliberated
  • 'Reinvent Northeast' initiative launched
  • Skin fasting for refreshed skin
  • NDPP-BJP Alliance for Nagaland Elections
  • Survey report of Tupul landslide
  • August Calendar for Year 2022 : Tools
  • COVID-19 Status 29 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Propose: Dada Saheb Phalka to Aribam Syam
  • Indigenous peoples lead to #endAIDS
  • World Hepatitis Day
  • 'Education abroad' by Stars of Northeast
  • Tigers, their survival is in our hands
  • Condition of road testifies cash-strapped state
  • Give more teeth to IMC call
  • Phuba Thapham, Senapati Dist. #2 : Gallery
  • Pu Neilienthang Telien : IAS MN-2013
  • Fish based integrated farming system #1
  • Lies :: Poem
  • Gaidinliu Vihar inaugurated at Tamenglong
  • Chatham Saw Mill - Asia's oldest & largest
  • Rosy surrender policy enticing armed outfit
  • Need to look beyond the academics
  • Pi- Thadoi :: A synopsis of the Play
  • COVID-19 Status 27 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Fixture for Durand Cup Trophies 2022
  • "Tribe" in India: shrouded in uncertainty #1
  • VUCA Plus in Manipur
  • Ukhrul observed Bijili Mahotsav & Ujala Diwas
  • CM unveils the Durand Cup Trophies
  • Performance of Government schools
  • Peaceful session in Assembly as tension...
  • Leima Jagoi by Transgender #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 26 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Marangching: could it be a wake-up call ?
  • AIDS: turning adversities into stepping stones
  • Fr. Joseph Kachiramattam: a Positive Aura
  • Dairy farming: A means of sustainable income
  • Spotlight back on Lhoukhosei Zou
  • Law makers must to curb drug scourge
  • Basanta Raas @ Govindajee Temple : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 25 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Naga American Foundation: 2023 Conference
  • Where fish are no longer forced to climb tree
  • Wholesale & retail price for 19 items revised
  • Tourism potentials of border pillars
  • The Fathomless Pain :: Poem
  • The poser: 'Kyam Pharaba Ngashidi'
  • Modern devices must to tackle drug menace
  • Pathetic Imphal-Jiribam Road #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 24 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Poppy/ganja plantation and Christianity
  • People living with HIV demand medicine
  • Apple benefit for skin
  • President Droupadi Murmu is the first tribal
  • Yearning for justice as encounters declines
  • The freebies put up for all to see
  • Meghachandra Kongbam & Manipuri Cinema
  • COVID-19 Status 23 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2022 #3: Gallery
  • The flesh profiteth nothing
  • 5 days Skill Training through Photography
  • Career through Skill Development
  • Don Bosco University adds new courses
  • Choidev Chongba @Kang Fest: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 22 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Legend of Lord Koubru & Liangmai princess
  • Pandemic talks resume amidst corporate ...
  • Nationwide hackathon for developers
  • The elasticity of love
  • Raj Bhavan to Rashtrapati Bhavan
  • Laying siege on highways to air grievances
  • Kabui Jagoi @Nongshaba #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 21 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Bhavamochani- Image of Manipuri dance form
  • Rooftop rainwater harvesting for water supply
  • Remains :: Poem
  • 'Let thy food be thy medicine'
  • What is the stand of Imphal ?
  • Used vehicles flooding into state inevitable
  • 13th Foundation Day EEVFAM #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 20 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Predicament of NH-202 construction in Ukhrul
  • Weeding out Congress Grass from Imphal
  • 'Out Of The Box' concludes in Agartala
  • National Lok Adalat at Lamphelpat
  • Making a beeline for private schools
  • ..State to justify double engine narrative
  • Environmental Activist Anish #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 19 July : Govt of Manipur
  • Overpopulation, an Asset or a Curse
  • NPF re-organization of Peren Division
  • Rev Joseph Mittathany Vision for Manipur
  • Chanakya IAS Academy launches at Jorhat
  • Announced on Jul 6, actualised on Jul 18
  • Loktak clean-up: Scapegoating soft targets
  • Tribute to Meira Paibis 2004 :: Gallery
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba @Konung :: Gallery
  • Shang-gi Chaminnaba @Andro #1 :: Gallery
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Lam Thokpa #5 :: Gallery
  • Late Most Rev. Joseph Mittathany
  • HSLC 2022 : List Of Top 25 Rank Holders
  • HSLC Result 2022 : Statistical Abstract
  • HSLC Result 2022 : Subject Topper
  • HSLC Result 2022 : Compartmental
  • HSLC Result 2022 : Full Listing
  • HSLC Result 2022 : pass % : Private
  • HSLC Result 2022 : pass %: Aided
  • HSLC Result 2022 : pass %: Govt
  • Environmental Activist Anish Ahmed
  • Landslide at Tupul [Jun 30] #2 : Gallery
  • Landslide at Tupul [Jun 30] #1 : Gallery
  • Padmashree Award Moirangthem Muktamani
  • Rules of English Pronunciation : Download
  • Sub-Syllables in English : Book Download