TODAY -

E-Pao! Essay - Independence - what more can it offer

Independence - what more can it offer?
- Part I -

By: Geetchandra Chandam *



Part 1 of the Theoritical, Practicability and Methodical Considerations

In the last half a century, various naharol groups have sprung up in Manipur with an aim to free Manipur from India, resulting in the continued violence. All of us here in Manipur, in one way or the other, are affected to a significant extent by this conflict. We have lost some of our dear brothers, friends to this conflict and most importantly, we are being denied the right to live a normal life for the last so many years. There seems no chance of ending the conflict in the near future. Most of us actually are neither strong supporters nor opponents of the idea of an independent Manipur. As the outcome will affect not only our lives but also of our children, each of us has a stake in it and we should have a say in shaping the outcome of the conflict. To an ordinary Manipuri like me, lots of doubts arise on the question of an independent Manipur. I think it is the duty of those groups and their supporters to address these issues and convince us about the same.
The idea of living in an independent Manipur is very tempting indeed. Many of us especially the youngsters are very excited about such a possibility. Let us forget about the feasibility of such an idea for a while and consider what this alternative can offer to ordinary people like you and me.

THEORITICAL CONSIDERATION

Concept of a ‘nation state’: The idea of a nation state in my opinion, can be considered as a ‘state of mind,’ an illusion created by its proponents. The proponents of ‘nation state’ may emphasize on shared history, common territory, language, race, shared interest etc of its people as the basis of the nation. However, any of these factors cannot be the sole basis for the idea of a ‘nation state’. Territorial boundary, language, religion, name and even its people can be changed from time to time in a single country. I feel, the most important factor has to be ‘shared interest’ of its people. Now, the question arises of whether it is in the best interest of an ordinary Manipuri to be a part of India or that of an independent Manipur.

What are the basic roles of a state? We expect a state to provide its citizens equality, justice and security and maintain peace. Freedoms to expression, practice of religion, right to life, right to protest are fundamental rights which are valued universally and expected from a modern nation state. Are these rights provided to the people of Manipur under the Indian constitution? Definitely, there is no doubt about it. So, what more can an independent Manipur offer?
However, many questions arise of the actual treatment by the government of India (GOI) to people in Manipur? The answer will depend largely to different perceptions. One of the important grievances by people living in this part of the world (in India’s remote NE states) is that Delhi treats us as second-class citizens and our rights are violated. How much truth is there in such a perceptions?

Human rights: Most of us in Manipur and significant number of mayangs in other parts of India will agree that GOI through its security agencies intentionally or un-intentionally has committed human rights violation in Manipur. We have protested vehemently against this. The ongoing movement to repeal AFSPA led by Sharmila Chanu and various NGOs is one such example. We cannot deny the fact that insurgent groups active in Manipur also has committed gross human rights violation to its own people. However, there was no significant protest by civil organizations against such rights violation by a insurgent group.

Different Perceptions: When we think of India and Manipur at the same time, most of us automatically think of the exploitation of us by the other Indians and GOI. However, you may be surprised to know that significant number of Indians think that we, in northeast India has been given undue attention in terms of central funding, different privileges (sixth schedule, reservations etc.) disproportionate to its size and population. So, who are being victimized? Another major grievance is the outlook of the ‘Indians’ towards us, calling us Nepalis, chinkies etc. but what about our treatment of Biharis and other Indians in Manipur or Meitei’s treatment of tribals in Manipur?

Aspiration and Grievances: We need to distinguish between the aspiration of the people and its grievances. AFSPA, RAP, etc are clearly peoples’ grievances which can be addressed by the GOI. If GOI decides to repeal all such acts, will the naharols then be ready to join Indian mainstream?
On the other hand an independent Manipur may be an aspiration of its people. As long as it remains the aspiration of the majority of the people of Manipur, the GOI and the world community cannot ignore it for long. However, there is not much direct or indirect evidence to assume that a majority of Manipur’s inhabitants want separation from India. There is more evidence to show the contrary. Look at the elections held under the Indian constitution. As far as I know (correct me if I am wrong), no election held in Manipur after merger had voter turnout below 50%. There is no reason to believe it will be different this time (Feb 2007 elections). There is no significant demand for independence from civil society groups unlike those in Kashmir. So, how can we assume that it is a peoples’ movement? Is it fair for a minority of people to try to impose their ideas on the majority? If they are strongly convinced about their cause then they should first try to convince the people, ordinary people like you and me.

Identity and self pride: Some people may argue that independence is necessary to preserve our identity and for our own self pride. However, remaining in India does not necessarily mean loss of our identity. We can be a proud Manipuri and also an Indian at the same time. Now let us consider the issue of Manipur’s right to exist as an independent nation state based on history, different ethnic profile and cultural differences from other Indians. I am not denying the existence of such differences but at the same time we have to acknowledge the similarities also. India is a country of different races, languages and cultures. So, whose country is India? Is it for the Biharis or Punjabis? Even Biharis and Punjabis are not homogenous entities; they consist of different groups with different castes, languages, religions and subcultures. They also have the same complain of step motherly treatment of their states by the central government.

Who shares this dream of an independent Manipur? One of the weakest links in the theoretical as well as practical consideration of an independent Manipur is the reluctance of the non-meitei groups to be a part of such a dream. Nagas want to be part of a separate Nagalim whereas Kukis are demanding their homeland. Even the Manipuri Muslims, it seems do not want to be a part of it. How many Tribals or Muslims have joined the valley based’s so called ‘Manipuri’ naharol groups fighting for an independent Manipur? Do we know any number and percentage? There are also many conflicts among the Meiteis, Nagas, Kukis and Muslims. So where is the question of a united independent Manipur state? These are issues that cannot be resolved later after getting independence. The naharol groups and their supporters need to convince us that Manipur will not become another Darfur where warlords have their own fiefdoms.

Read Part I | Part II

Read Comments by Somchandra Nahakpam


* Geetachandra Chandam, a professional working in a private company in Delhi contributes for the first time to e-pao.net with this 2 part articulation of what he feels about Manipur as a nation state vis-a-vis as part of multi ethnic nation called India . The writer can be reached at geetchandra_chandam AT yahoo DOT co DOT in.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Protest against CAB [Jan 15] #1: Gallery
  • CChongkhong, Apanthou :: eMing
  • Crop diseases & organic way of managing
  • War and Poetry :: Poem
  • Landeng-Pena yakaiduna Poster Campaign
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Condemns communal nature of CAB 2016
  • PCC, Arunachal Pradesh on CAB, 2016
  • CAB and other issues before LS polls
  • Sit-In against CAB [Jan 14] : Gallery
  • CAB : Our Identity & Culture is at stake
  • Re-Imagining the Naga Peace Process
  • Demand for ILP :: Articles/Photos...
  • Northeast Startup Summit 2019
  • Ponder them to live like human beings
  • No Shield for Manipur against CAB
  • Missing link: NE, CAB & obscure assurance
  • JCILPS Protest against CAB : Gallery
  • AMUCO Rally against CAB : Gallery
  • Poetic Justice - II :: Poem
  • Makar Sankranti Musing
  • Biren should release Kishorchandra
  • New archaeological site in Senapati
  • A Christian perspective on solidarity #1
  • New craft gallery to promote NE products
  • Rights body warns Nagas on Article 371 (A)
  • NE Black Day against CAB : Gallery
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #2 : Gallery
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #2: Gallery
  • Myanmar-India Business Summit, Sagaing
  • Cry of a Dying River - 61 :: Poem
  • Preventing the Dengue threat
  • NPF on Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016
  • Nagaland Chief Minister On CAB 2016
  • Hijacking by pseudoscience
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Mr. CM, you can't fool people on CAB
  • CAB 2016: Adoption of foreign citizens
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #1 : Gallery
  • CAB & question of India's North East
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #1
  • Local actions for #GlobalGoals
  • Know your HIV status
  • Pope Francis - the last Pope!
  • CAB is unsecular discriminatory bill
  • When Govt. disregard Constitutions...
  • Citizenship Bill: An exceptional exception
  • The Walking Lady : A Short Story
  • 4th Convocation Ceremony of CAU
  • The Voice of Silence :: Poem
  • Against CAB 2016 : 6 Student Bodies
  • Need for a separate time zone
  • BOOM MMA : 'Manipur Top Team' members
  • Against Citizenship Bill Act 2016
  • Lt Gen Rajeev Sirohi at Spear Corps
  • Is the middle man responsible
  • Economically weak at Rs 8 lakh per annum ?
  • Umanglai Haraoba: Traditional Institution
  • Strike against CAB : Gallery
  • People - animal conflict
  • Fine on relieving in public
  • Flawed/divisive Citizenship Bill dangerous
  • Broken :: Poem
  • Meetei gi mayokta leiba Political party..
  • NE uniting under shutdown call : CAB
  • Trains in NE to get 'glass-top' coaches
  • Yubi Lakpi #2 : Gallery
  • Freedom's fault lines
  • Traditional Manipuri Curries
  • Governance in Multi-Ethnic States
  • Understanding animal welfare
  • Unite against corruption for development
  • Manipurgi Maraibk Kari Oihougani
  • On restoring of director of CBI
  • Citizenship Bill : scourge for NE
  • Feel good factor from UNC
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #2: Gallery
  • A tale of two falcons
  • Artificial Insemination in livestock
  • The Naked Truth :: Poem
  • My itinerary visit to Veeranapalya
  • Test for Free Coaching for IIT/AIIMS
  • Critique of Transgender Persons Bill
  • Press Rejoinder from NPF [7 Jan]
  • Nagaland Cabinet on Citizenship Bill
  • Can we expect something from govt
  • Mova Cave, Ukhrul #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Sumo Wrestling #2 :: Gallery
  • Maipaksana RK: Entrepreneurship Award
  • Poetic Justice - I
  • IIT-G Technology Incubation Centre
  • Sana Chahi Ahum & 1857 revolt #2
  • Economics of climate change & growth
  • Singhat Students tour to Delhi & Agra
  • Congress against Modi on Rafale Deal
  • Press Club celebrates foundation day
  • NSF to impose 11-hr bandh on Jan 8
  • 518 drug traffickers arrested in 2018
  • Gangmumei Kamei Memorial lecture
  • Taking the Street Vendor seriously #1
  • WWII museums in Japan: Gallery
  • Schedule : HSLC Examination 2019
  • Schedule : Class XI Examination 2019
  • Schedule : HSE Examination 2019
  • Caste System in Contemporary India: Book
  • Save energy and save your skin
  • Benefits of henna for beauty
  • Coronary In-stent obstruction treated
  • A take on PM visit to Imphal
  • No over the top promises, assurances
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #1: Gallery
  • Management of commercial broiler farming
  • 61st CC Meet Football Tournament 2019
  • Noise Ruins & Blights Lives
  • Social media & freedom of speech
  • Cry of a Dying River - 60 :: Poem
  • Declare war against air pollution
  • Winter relief at Thanga
  • Of monologues and conveniences
  • Raising posers before PM's arrival: Cong
  • Irengbam Bedamani :: eRang Photos
  • Poireiton Chakhao at Loktak Lake
  • Hojang :: Poem
  • New Year: Challenges & opportunities
  • One Rank One Pension Paper (OROP)
  • Fasting before diagnostic tests
  • Open Mic. event at Agartala
  • Happy New Year '2019' :: NPF
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Respecting life & the trust deficit
  • Need to look beyond New Year-2019
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #1: Gallery
  • May the Year 2019 bring integrity of Manipur
  • Sangai Fest: Evening Prog #2: Gallery
  • What I learned from Kishorchandra detention
  • Charlie, the angel :: Story
  • Against NSA to Kishorchandra Wangkhem
  • Quality New Year
  • Reminder to PM on Pravish Chanam death
  • What is there to be happy on New Year
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #4: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Village Authority in Hill Areas of Manipur #2
  • Sana Chahi Ahum & 1857 revolt #1
  • Local leaders commit to #endTobacco
  • Transformation of China in last 40 years
  • Boys Hostel for Pangal Students
  • From the diary of an insomniac - II
  • From nomenclature conflict of oral tradition
  • Gearing up for Parliamentary polls
  • Dimapur Meetei Council donates
  • Bye Bye 2018 !!! : Gallery
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2019 : Download
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2018 #6: Gallery
  • Unforgettable Revolutionary NK Sanajaoba
  • Life's pain :: Poem
  • New Year resolution of our honorables
  • Certificate distribution at Namsai, ArP
  • Indo-Myanmar Relations : Talk @ MU
  • Butchering a Pony for meat! Shameful
  • Top 5 Indie/Alternative Picks of 2018
  • Sangaithel Park @Sangai: Gallery
  • Things that change educational settings
  • Good Times around the Corner :: Poem
  • Mann Ki Baat - A Chicken Hide
  • Indira Gandhi - An ephemeral encounter
  • A view of Ukhrul Town #1: Gallery
  • January Calendar for Year 2019 :: Tools
  • National Mathematics Day & Ramanujan
  • Thougal Jagoi @Sangai: Gallery
  • Training Program at DM Community College
  • Ode to Radio Telegraphy
  • To the Muse :: Poem
  • Respecting the Freedom of Speech
  • Attending to homeless lady : Humane
  • Wildlife return after 50 years
  • Snowfall @Tamei, Tamenglong : Gallery
  • China spreads across Indochina Peninsula
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping a#2: Gallery
  • Cry of a Dying River - 59 :: Poem
  • Match words with actions to #endTB
  • Hacking : Base of all cyber crimes
  • Illegal adoptions in hospitals
  • Controlling the school transporters
  • Detention under NSA : Stand of MUSU
  • Xmas: Churches @Lamphel : Gallery
  • 27th Imphal Book Fair #2 : Gallery
  • The Crying Call of Motherland :: Poem
  • Jobs at C-DAC: International centre posting
  • Bye-Bye Congress Grass: Biological Mgmt
  • How to prevent your kajal / eye make up
  • Jobs at Manitech Consultancy, Imphal
  • Of politicians & their electoral politics
  • AFSPA: Politico-legal sanction for impunity?
  • Kwatha Festival #3 : Gallery
  • 12th Manipur Polo Intl #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur Statehood Day Women's Polo
  • Of Rafale deal: Beyond politics
  • Career options in painting
  • Gun Culture must be put to an End
  • Until Kishorechandra is released
  • Condemns arrest of Manipur journalist
  • Assam Rifles celebrates Christmas
  • Why the uproar against Manipur media ?
  • Tattooed With Taboos #3 : Review
  • Oinam Dilip : Rising Star Award 2018, Delhi
  • Human Resource Management :: Book
  • Christmas @Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Harvard Leadership Program at Don Bosco
  • Manipur Fest 2019 in Bengaluru
  • Best Christmas Wishes :: Poem
  • Christmas @Churachandpur : Gallery
  • UN Rapporteur briefed on Kishorechand
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #3: Gallery
  • Irengbam Bedamani - Actress :: eRang
  • Communities @ Barak Festival #1 : Gallery
  • Khumanthem Prakash : Akademi Award
  • Ningol Chakouba @ MBC #4 : Gallery
  • List of Restricted Holidays for 2019
  • List of Public Holidays for 2019
  • List of General Holidays for 2019
  • Ningol - mapam lamdam : Gallery
  • Fabrics of Bangladeshi Manipuri: Download
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS