TODAY -

E-Pao! Essay - Independence - what more can it offer

Independence - what more can it offer?
- Part I -

By: Geetchandra Chandam *



Part 1 of the Theoritical, Practicability and Methodical Considerations

In the last half a century, various naharol groups have sprung up in Manipur with an aim to free Manipur from India, resulting in the continued violence. All of us here in Manipur, in one way or the other, are affected to a significant extent by this conflict. We have lost some of our dear brothers, friends to this conflict and most importantly, we are being denied the right to live a normal life for the last so many years. There seems no chance of ending the conflict in the near future. Most of us actually are neither strong supporters nor opponents of the idea of an independent Manipur. As the outcome will affect not only our lives but also of our children, each of us has a stake in it and we should have a say in shaping the outcome of the conflict. To an ordinary Manipuri like me, lots of doubts arise on the question of an independent Manipur. I think it is the duty of those groups and their supporters to address these issues and convince us about the same.
The idea of living in an independent Manipur is very tempting indeed. Many of us especially the youngsters are very excited about such a possibility. Let us forget about the feasibility of such an idea for a while and consider what this alternative can offer to ordinary people like you and me.

THEORITICAL CONSIDERATION

Concept of a ‘nation state’: The idea of a nation state in my opinion, can be considered as a ‘state of mind,’ an illusion created by its proponents. The proponents of ‘nation state’ may emphasize on shared history, common territory, language, race, shared interest etc of its people as the basis of the nation. However, any of these factors cannot be the sole basis for the idea of a ‘nation state’. Territorial boundary, language, religion, name and even its people can be changed from time to time in a single country. I feel, the most important factor has to be ‘shared interest’ of its people. Now, the question arises of whether it is in the best interest of an ordinary Manipuri to be a part of India or that of an independent Manipur.

What are the basic roles of a state? We expect a state to provide its citizens equality, justice and security and maintain peace. Freedoms to expression, practice of religion, right to life, right to protest are fundamental rights which are valued universally and expected from a modern nation state. Are these rights provided to the people of Manipur under the Indian constitution? Definitely, there is no doubt about it. So, what more can an independent Manipur offer?
However, many questions arise of the actual treatment by the government of India (GOI) to people in Manipur? The answer will depend largely to different perceptions. One of the important grievances by people living in this part of the world (in India’s remote NE states) is that Delhi treats us as second-class citizens and our rights are violated. How much truth is there in such a perceptions?

Human rights: Most of us in Manipur and significant number of mayangs in other parts of India will agree that GOI through its security agencies intentionally or un-intentionally has committed human rights violation in Manipur. We have protested vehemently against this. The ongoing movement to repeal AFSPA led by Sharmila Chanu and various NGOs is one such example. We cannot deny the fact that insurgent groups active in Manipur also has committed gross human rights violation to its own people. However, there was no significant protest by civil organizations against such rights violation by a insurgent group.

Different Perceptions: When we think of India and Manipur at the same time, most of us automatically think of the exploitation of us by the other Indians and GOI. However, you may be surprised to know that significant number of Indians think that we, in northeast India has been given undue attention in terms of central funding, different privileges (sixth schedule, reservations etc.) disproportionate to its size and population. So, who are being victimized? Another major grievance is the outlook of the ‘Indians’ towards us, calling us Nepalis, chinkies etc. but what about our treatment of Biharis and other Indians in Manipur or Meitei’s treatment of tribals in Manipur?

Aspiration and Grievances: We need to distinguish between the aspiration of the people and its grievances. AFSPA, RAP, etc are clearly peoples’ grievances which can be addressed by the GOI. If GOI decides to repeal all such acts, will the naharols then be ready to join Indian mainstream?
On the other hand an independent Manipur may be an aspiration of its people. As long as it remains the aspiration of the majority of the people of Manipur, the GOI and the world community cannot ignore it for long. However, there is not much direct or indirect evidence to assume that a majority of Manipur’s inhabitants want separation from India. There is more evidence to show the contrary. Look at the elections held under the Indian constitution. As far as I know (correct me if I am wrong), no election held in Manipur after merger had voter turnout below 50%. There is no reason to believe it will be different this time (Feb 2007 elections). There is no significant demand for independence from civil society groups unlike those in Kashmir. So, how can we assume that it is a peoples’ movement? Is it fair for a minority of people to try to impose their ideas on the majority? If they are strongly convinced about their cause then they should first try to convince the people, ordinary people like you and me.

Identity and self pride: Some people may argue that independence is necessary to preserve our identity and for our own self pride. However, remaining in India does not necessarily mean loss of our identity. We can be a proud Manipuri and also an Indian at the same time. Now let us consider the issue of Manipur’s right to exist as an independent nation state based on history, different ethnic profile and cultural differences from other Indians. I am not denying the existence of such differences but at the same time we have to acknowledge the similarities also. India is a country of different races, languages and cultures. So, whose country is India? Is it for the Biharis or Punjabis? Even Biharis and Punjabis are not homogenous entities; they consist of different groups with different castes, languages, religions and subcultures. They also have the same complain of step motherly treatment of their states by the central government.

Who shares this dream of an independent Manipur? One of the weakest links in the theoretical as well as practical consideration of an independent Manipur is the reluctance of the non-meitei groups to be a part of such a dream. Nagas want to be part of a separate Nagalim whereas Kukis are demanding their homeland. Even the Manipuri Muslims, it seems do not want to be a part of it. How many Tribals or Muslims have joined the valley based’s so called ‘Manipuri’ naharol groups fighting for an independent Manipur? Do we know any number and percentage? There are also many conflicts among the Meiteis, Nagas, Kukis and Muslims. So where is the question of a united independent Manipur state? These are issues that cannot be resolved later after getting independence. The naharol groups and their supporters need to convince us that Manipur will not become another Darfur where warlords have their own fiefdoms.

Read Part I | Part II

Read Comments by Somchandra Nahakpam


* Geetachandra Chandam, a professional working in a private company in Delhi contributes for the first time to e-pao.net with this 2 part articulation of what he feels about Manipur as a nation state vis-a-vis as part of multi ethnic nation called India . The writer can be reached at geetchandra_chandam AT yahoo DOT co DOT in.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Sangai Day 2 : Pung & Dhol Chollom :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2 : Maibi Jagoi :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 2 : MMTA Adventure :: Gallery
  • Hazari/Tombi Polo [7 Nov] :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 1 : Culturals #3 :: Gallery
  • She left us but who'll forget her ?
  • My New Song :: Poem
  • Indo-Naga Talks 2017 :: News Timeline
  • Thanks Dr. Sinha for highlighting Manipur
  • SN seek clarification from NSCN (I-M)
  • House panel summons Ravi to clarify on FA
  • Sangai Day 1 : Culturals #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Day 1 : Culturals #1 :: Gallery
  • Miss Kut #5 :: Gallery
  • Best ever Bond film for children
  • Media Challenge: Glance from hills #2
  • Hard on the hexagon of beehives, Meiteilon..
  • NPF Resolutions of Nov 22, 2017
  • Inaugural Day Sangai Festival :: Gallery
  • Featured Photo for 2017 #5 :: Gallery
  • Kokkhum Festival #2 :: Gallery
  • Seitinmang, Laljangam, Parihal: eMing
  • Khamba Thoibi & Poems on Manipur : Rvw
  • Significance of learning Chinese language
  • JFA condemns Tripura scribe's murder
  • Zeliang calls for NE Tourist Circuit creation
  • Shillong Lajong I-League Squad 2017/18
  • Tourism Potential of Manipur
  • Sangai Run-Marathon @Sendra #1 :: Gallery
  • On Peace Deal & Framework Agreement #1
  • 22nd Winners' Cup (Football) #1 :: Gallery
  • The charge of sisters :: Poem
  • Reorganisation of North Eastern Council #2
  • DAMMS Freshers / Literary Meet 2017
  • (Blank Editorial)
  • Culturals @Mera Houchongba #2 :: Gallery
  • Kang Chingba @ Wangkhei :: Gallery
  • North East Fashion Week #2 :: Gallery
  • Know The Meetei
  • Indo-Naga Peace Process :: Articles
  • Not just the Gateway
  • Use milk for silky smooth skin
  • Mobile Application for Sangai Festival
  • Manipuri Mega Photo Contest Finalist
  • 5 point resolution on Naga Political Issue
  • NE is least favoured tourist destination
  • Final: Hazari/Tombi Polo #1 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Festival 2017- Events Schedule
  • #TB hotspot cannot be on blindspot
  • United Metal 3.0 @Imphal
  • My name is Kom, Mary Kom
  • Swachch Bharath Swasth Bharath
  • Sangai Festival 2017- Online booking site
  • The Killing Fields (2013-17) :: Timeline
  • Mary set on Olympic gold
  • For every causes, there is a reason
  • Moibung Khunou -near khurkhul :: Gallery
  • Miss Kut #4 :: Gallery
  • On the Naga Framework Agreement
  • Media Challenge: Glance from hills #1
  • GIS day at NIT Manipur
  • Pangal Leader Mohammed Hanif Shah
  • NPF questions Speaker convening meet
  • Painting Exhibition by Babli Das (Tripura)
  • Looking out for possible measures
  • Manipur Sangai Festival 2016 #7 : Ooba
  • Cultural Program @ MCA :: Gallery
  • Ningol ChakKouba @MBC #3 :: Gallery
  • Oh dear Daddy, see I a Native Proud: Poem
  • Buddha's metta and karuna #3
  • Narendra Modi will never play Nehru
  • Photo Caption Contest by Whakal.com
  • General Call to All Former NPF Leaders
  • Penguin Readathon & Book Gifting
  • ENNG opposes inclusion of TCL..
  • Report alarm for Arunachal
  • Loktak witness drastic fall in migratory birds
  • Lecture on 'Rohingya Resettlement'
  • 'Weaves of Ching-tam' @London :: Gallery
  • Opening: Jadonang Football #1 :: Gallery
  • Robert's Weaves of valley & hills at London
  • Remembering boy..felled by fake encounter
  • Sangai Photo Awards 2017 : Contest
  • Meeyam meekup nahum singna leibiyu
  • HighWays : Govt. needs seriousness
  • Singcha Wuya Won @Kamjong #4 :: Gallery
  • SDG Consultation: NE :: Gallery
  • North East Fashion Week #1 :: Gallery
  • Distribution Patterns of the Asian Eye
  • Sustainable Development Goal Consultation
  • Wrangle in Mapithel dam: Legal perspective
  • In the Slums of Heaven :: Poem
  • Wreath Laying Ceremony for AR Martyrs
  • Time to take a bow, Robert
  • Create jobs for NE to stop trafficking
  • March: Mera Houchongba #4:: Gallery
  • Sin-Lang Fest @DM College #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Festival: Ideas for a change
  • A shadowy dreamer :: Poem
  • Winter - A blessing in disguise for us ...
  • Course in Nanotechnology at NEHU
  • Pamel : Serene Natural Hub, near Lamlai
  • Vacancy at YVU Financial Services, Thoubal
  • System Operators @PR Enterprise, Khurai
  • Just by showing concern will not change..
  • Food Stall @Phayeng #2 :: Gallery
  • The moment :: Poem
  • Board exams decoded
  • 3rd NE Fashion at Itanagar: Day 2
  • Conference : North East in Globalized Era
  • NE-IAS launched to support Startup India
  • Painting Competition on Conservation
  • Ramkung Pamei is new MHJU Chief
  • Priyogopal (Senior Artist)- Photo :: eRang
  • Kabui Dance @Jadonang Football:: Gallery
  • Fashion @NE Festival, Delhi :: Gallery
  • Deviance and Corruption in Kangleipak
  • Applied health research is vital to #endTB
  • 3rd NE Fashion at Itanagar: Day 1
  • Tri-nation Motorcycle Rally reach Imphal
  • Traffic woes continues
  • Kwatha festival #1 :: Gallery
  • Kokkhum Festival #1 :: Gallery
  • Special Rapporteur on Human Rights
  • The threat to balkanize Manipur
  • Cry of a Dying River - 6 :: Poem
  • Biological based integrated Congress grass
  • 3rd Audition of Fagi Unplugged
  • Sadar Hills District Demand: News Timeline
  • Of clean environment
  • Paonam Lily (Archery) Reception :: Gallery
  • North East Fest @ Delhi :: Gallery
  • Girls Football- Nov 4 #2 :: Gallery
  • IBSD, India & VITO, Belgium signed MOU
  • First angioplasty for in-stent restenosis
  • RIST Popular Talk-33: Quantum Hall states
  • Commonwealth alumni event of NE
  • Lecture on The Rohingya Conundrum
  • Tri-National Motorcycle Rally
  • 3rd North East Fashion Week at Itanagar
  • ILP Nov 30 deadline: Why not only for valley
  • Expected changes, do we see ?
  • Festival of Raas Leela #2 :: Gallery
  • Sin-Lang Fest @DM College #1 :: Gallery
  • Hari Uthan- Kang Chingba #2 :: Gallery
  • Code of silence: Concealing gender justice
  • God Rules Over All :: Poem
  • Five day 'Flower Show' at Ukhrul
  • Go birding to honour Bird Man of India
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Uphul Waiphul and Leikhom Leinang
  • A reminder to Central Govt.
  • Ningol Chak-Kouba @Pune :: Gallery
  • Miss Kut #2 :: Gallery
  • Meitei Pictographic Writings :: Book Review
  • Careers related to mental health
  • Beauty & Money for a purpose
  • Human rights infractions in Mapithel Dam
  • AMAND Ningol Chakouba at Pune : Report
  • Chef Required at Kakching
  • NHPC Raising day at Loktak Power Station
  • Of ST demand, ILP, peace talk
  • For elderly people
  • Prof. Nongmaithem Tombi Singh : A Profile
  • Hazari/ Tombi Polo Tournament #2:: Gallery
  • U-17 Footballer honored by Guv :: Gallery
  • Just in favour of nocturnal life
  • Dance of Fire Flies at Autumn :: Poem
  • North East Festival bids farewell
  • Agenda of Govt spelt out at DBC, Maram
  • Nurturing the future
  • Ningol Chak-Kouba @Delhi #2:: Gallery
  • NE Fashion Weekend @Delhi #1 :: Gallery
  • History will not forgive us
  • A girl :: Poem
  • Pre-merger political party struggle
  • JRF wanted at NIT Silchar
  • March: Mera Houchongba #3:: Gallery
  • Girls Football- Nov 4 #1:: Gallery
  • Taxi- raising Air Pollution in Ukhrul
  • Skill development training with MUDA
  • Pui Thangamliu -Photos #1 :: eRang
  • NH7 Weekender [28 October] :: Gallery
  • Surjalal: Fellow of American Physical Society
  • Salesian College Grabs UK Project
  • Prime focus
  • Miss Kut #1 :: Gallery
  • Hari Uthan- Kang Chingba #1 :: Gallery
  • Kangujam Chinglensana (Hockey) feted
  • Chavang Kut @Tengnoupal :: Gallery
  • Sub-Junior Girls Football #2:: Gallery
  • Namsai gets Buddha relic from Thailand
  • Ningol Chak-Kouba @Delhi #1:: Gallery
  • 3rd Ningol Chakouba, Delhi : A Report
  • Dr. Rahejuddin Sheikh : Best Director Award
  • Chothe: Shabu Hong Rein :: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Candle light for Belinda Morse :: Gallery
  • Exhibition of Pottery Crafts #2 :: Gallery
  • Phayeng Cultural programme :: Gallery
  • Khongjom War Memorial #3 :: 360 ° View
  • Ichangi Laidhi #1 :: eRang
  • Ningol Chakkouba by Paomee:: Gallery
  • Ningol Chakkouba @Kolkata :: Gallery
  • Ningol to her mapam lamdam :: Gallery
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2018 : Download it
  • Mera Men Tongba :: Gallery
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • Landscape of Manipur #7: Wallpaper
  • SPONSORED ADS