TODAY -

Women Reservation versus Naga Customary Law: Dialectical Approach

Sira Kharay *



Nagaland for the first time is debating on the subject of Article 371A of the Constitution since the history of its formation on 1st December, 1963. The debate is crucial. Not because "33% women reservation" in the Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) transgresses Naga customary law, but because it evokes a serious constitutional question as to the sanctity of Naga customary law vis-a-vis inviolability of Article 371A.

The apprehension of the tribal hohos cannot be faulted as totally misplaced. Not because the concept of "urban municipal law" per se threatens Naga customary law for all purposes, but because Part IXA threatens to take away the partial right to internal self-determination protected under Article 371A. More so because Naga customary law and identity do not exist outside the special autonomy guaranteed under Article 371A.

However, the apropos issue has been bastardized as mere instance of "traditional men" resisting "women empowerment" on a slipshod analysis. Name-shaming of Nagaland continues. Whereas, the collective gender consciousness inherent in the Naga society which constantly invalidates the assumption that all is well with the status of women in the Naga society has been completely sidelined.

Polarising Factors

Politicking over the issue has resulted in deep social polarisation on institutional lines. Flip-flop mishandling of the situation thereafter by the State Government coupled with its incompetence led to the avoidable impasse. Thanks to the State Government for finally giving way to people's voice. Bordering on the absurd, however, NATC-JCC-ACAUT are now serving folk-martial diktats on the Government and Nagaland for all the wrong reasons continues to be in the headlines.

The stance of the tribal hohos unfortunately has been thus so divergent and rife with confusion. The constant inability to articulate the moot point of contention without reference to "33% women reservation" in particular makes the issue even more problematic. To make it worst, rhetoric often relapses into a banal form of "women-bashing" ending up in gender-shaming and intimidating of women. Naga Mothers Association (NMA) became a natural scapegoat. Consequently, a false dichotomy has been projected as though the narrative of women rights is in collision course with the practice of Naga customary law.

Ironically, some tribal women units have even withdrawn their membership from NMA. NMA has been thus pushed to a defensive corner for the fault of their own husbands. But this writer has not come across any valid argument for limiting the proposed affirmative action to ULBs alone. Call me a feminist if you like NMA must carry the legitimate voice down to the grass-root village traditional authorities up till the State Legislative Assembly.

Reservation Not Dehors Article 371A

To label the fallout, however, as a case of gender contestation between men and women is to misread the whole issue. Naga Hoho has categorically declared that "no Naga man is against participation of womenfolk" and men are "open to any percentage, be it 33% or even more". NMA has equally made it clear that Naga women are not challenging the sanctity of Article 371A. In other words, in as much as Naga Hoho is interested in empowering women, NMA is equally interested in protecting Article 371A.

There is thus no actual conflict between Article 371A and Article 243T as misconceived. More so because to contend that "33% women reservation" infringes Naga customary law is to argue that "human rights" are antithetical to Naga customary law. Even assuming that Article 243T offends Naga customary law, "No custom or tradition, no cultural values or religious beliefs, can justify depriving a human being of his or her human rights" (United Nations).

Threat to Article 371A

Every incidence of municipal taxation or mode of ownership of property cannot also be denounced as inimical to Naga customary law. However, to contend that "urban municipal law" is altogether a different regime of law not relatable to custom is conceptually fallacious. "Urban municipal law" is not merely a "civic law" depart from social reality, but it constitutes a regime of local self-governance which necessarily originates from a social and cultural context. Therefore, Naga municipal law must also necessarily emanate from its local customary practice and not from the general Indian municipal code.

It is thus not Article 243T or the term "Nagaland Municipal Act" per se that actually threatens Article 371A, but Part IXA and the fact that Nagaland Municipal Act, 2001 originates from Part IXA and not from the plenary legislative power of the Nagaland Legislative Assembly under Article 371A. Hence, the present stalemate Because the fate of Article 371A cannot also be compromised in the name of extending "33% women reservation" unless the same originates without reference to Part IXA.

Applicability of Part IXA

Problem, however, arises with the above construction in the event Part IXA is held to be applicable to the State of Nagaland. To draw a conclusion, it may be seen that Part IXA deals with "Municipalities" and Article 243ZC therein exempts the hill areas of Darjeeling Gorkha Hill Council and the Scheduled Areas and tribal areas under the Fifth Schedule and Sixth Schedule from the applicability of the Part.

Reference may also be made to the preceding Part IX which deals with "Panchayats". It must be seen that in the case of Part IX, Article 243M therein specifically exempts not only Nagaland, but also Meghalaya, Mizoram and the hill areas of Manipur from the applicability of the Part. From a comparative perusal of Part IX and Part IXA, it appears that Nagaland is not exempted from the applicability of Part IXA.

Part IXA Conflicts Article 371A

But municipal law being a regime of local self-governance, applicability of Part IXA to Nagaland is not in accordance with the spirit of Article 371A. Part IXA effectively takes away the customary law autonomy protected under Article 371A as local self-governance conceptually cannot exist outside customary law regime.

Even otherwise, Part IXA is in inherent conflict with Article 371A. Part IXA makes the members of the Panchayats a composite part of the structure of the Committee for District Planning and Committee for Metropolitan Planning as contemplated therein. However, applicability of Part IX being exempted, there is no Panchayat system in the State of Nagaland. Thus, the Committee for District Planning and Committee for Metropolitan Planning as contemplated under Part IXA are at odds with the State of Nagaland.

Conclusion

To resolve the conflict, however, the latin legal maxim "generalia specialibus non derogant" must be brought into full play and Part IXA being a general law and Article 371A a special law, the special law under Article 371A must be presumed to prevail over the general law under Part IXA. Accordingly, the safest political recourse for the State Government for now may be to invoke its plenary legislative power under Article 371A and to revisit and extricate the existing Nagaland Municipal Act, 2001 from Part IXA with a specific reservation clause for women without reference to Article 243T.


* Sira Kharay wrote this article for e-pao.net
The author is an Advocate based at New Delhi and can be reached at sirakharaypeh(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was posted on February 17, 2017.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Chingarel Biodiversity Park #1 :: Gallery
  • Junior Girls District Football #2 :: Gallery
  • Aesthetics & Culture (Performing Arts)
  • A Song of Hopes :: Poem
  • ..roads in NE may drive small tribes away..
  • 'NPF is natural ally of BJP'
  • Sadar Hills District Demand: News Timeline
  • AMAND Education Aid
  • Challenges before MST bus service
  • Public transport system in Manipur
  • Great June Uprising #3 :: Gallery
  • Kang Chingba @Singjamei :: Gallery
  • Nengvah, Krehe, Achoubi :: eMing
  • On Probable Origin of Letter Atiya
  • 181, Cyber Crime ; How about Zero FIR?
  • Shree Shree Govindajee Temple :: 360 °
  • Manipur U-19 Teams victorious at 'Oorja'
  • Remove Army Camp from MU Campus
  • The Killing Fields :: News Timeline
  • MU VC neglecting academics : MUSU
  • 100 days of BJP led Govt
  • AFSPA - a push to arms?
  • Id-ul-Fitr @Imphal #1 :: Gallery
  • 15th Mega Miss North East :: Gallery
  • Cyclist have Rights on the roads
  • International Day Against Drug Abuse
  • Mary Khyriem is Mega Miss North East
  • Felicitation of Thangjam Guneshwar
  • Corruption of lairik-laisu
  • Approaches towards NE development
  • Jobs at Thangjam Agro (Likla)
  • Militarising a place of learning : AR in MU
  • ..Liangmais to withdraw from Zeliangrong
  • Scientist Thangjam felicitated
  • Idd-ul-Fitre celebrated in NE
  • Konung Kang Chingba #1 :: Gallery
  • Suman Ningthoujam is Mega Mister NE
  • Kang Chingba (Rath-yatra)
  • Baptism of pugilist Sarita Devi..
  • President of India from Manipur, when?
  • Conditions leading to birth of Marxism
  • Meeting on oil Exploration at Tupul
  • Condoles death of Palal Haokip
  • Diabetes Detection - Medical Camp
  • Dzukuo: SAYO refutes Mao CSO allegation
  • Cong to Delhi: Lift lid on Naga pact
  • Manipur man to contest presidential poll
  • Three Mothers Art Gallery :: Gallery
  • U 14 Subroto Football :: Gallery
  • Environment Day: Loktak Ema Laments
  • Khangchiu/Liuchiu: Liangmai institution #2
  • Value based education in schools
  • Yoga and dress
  • Bengal Govt repressing Gorkha people
  • Media appeals management to obey..
  • Recreation- a Serious Business
  • Reintroducing MST bus service
  • Subhadra chhuri huranba :: Funga Wari
  • Kanglei Haraoba Festival #3 :: Gallery
  • Angkor Wat - Cambodia #6 :: Gallery
  • Traffic Jam gigs on home ground
  • Cheiraoba Ching Kaba #6 :: 360 ° View
  • Preserving Macha Ebemma Khudithibi area
  • Life in some hill villages
  • Paramedical Courses Admissions
  • NPF responds to Congress diatribe
  • Surrogate teachers
  • Great June Uprising #2 :: Gallery
  • Road Condition @Senapati :: Gallery
  • School on Phum: Innovative Learning Place
  • Sketches of the Countryside :: Poem
  • Why MBA in Business Analytics ?
  • Grand finale of Mega Miss North East
  • Rehabilitation of Villagers affected by Mora
  • Making NFSA meaningful: Life into MSFC
  • Expecting some appreciable act
  • Earth crack at Kangpokpi #2 :: Gallery
  • Yoga Day @Khuman Lampak :: Gallery
  • Finance Capitalism & the Naga Question
  • Alumni 1998 Batch Ki Ningai
  • Manipur Univ's CMS awarded 4.5 out of 5
  • Legal Training for Justice Workers
  • Career Counselling for Bishnupur students
  • International Yoga Day
  • Indo-Naga Talks 2017 :: News Timeline
  • Noting the SOS from the DC of Kpi
  • For that little bit more
  • Lai Khong Chingba @Thangjing #4
  • Landscape of Kangpokpi :: Gallery
  • Yeningthagi Wari Kumhei :: Gallery
  • Beyond beef eating
  • World Father's Day :: Poem
  • Bereavement of Khaplang & can of worms
  • Union HRD Prakash Javadekar at Imphal
  • Jobs at basicP, Singjamei
  • Job at Escent Diagnostics, Imphal
  • Treating patients with a human touch
  • Deliberate mistakes
  • Yu Thongba by Loi of Awang Sekmai #2
  • Dialysis Programme @JNIMS :: Gallery
  • Pukhri Macha at Kangla :: 360 ° View
  • Khangchiu/Liuchiu: Liangmai institution #1
  • Mass awareness on congress grass
  • Shut down in hills, Unity Day in valley
  • Sever pol ties: Where does this leave NPF ?
  • June in Manipur
  • June 18 effect
  • Great June Uprising #1 :: Gallery
  • The Great June Uprising 2001 :: Photos
  • Stalls @Barak (spring) Fest #2 :: Gallery
  • Farmers: Occupation or a Game?
  • Food, nay tobacco, for thought
  • Paris climate agreement & India's role
  • The day to pay tribute to our own father
  • Annual Iftar Gathering at Konthagram Masjid
  • Compositeness of settlers of Manipur #3
  • The Great June 18 Uprising :: Tribute
  • Flooding at Kangpokpi :: Gallery
  • Robert Naorem collections at Milan Walk
  • Peace in post-Khaplang North-East
  • My Manipur: A tryst with ground reality
  • Ignoring the parallel Government
  • Call to IM leadership to wake up
  • Talk offer from Naga outfit: Delhi should..
  • Regulating private schools
  • Arbind Soibam (Singer) :: Erang Photos
  • Tha, Tha Thabungton: Reviewing a Lullaby
  • No More WW2 Bridge at Heingang
  • Women in Khasi & Jaintia society
  • My Song :: Poem
  • Mind boggling job interviews
  • Researchers from Kerala & Maharashtra..
  • Ripe opportunity for awareness & action
  • Flood in Imphal- June 14 :: Gallery
  • Dr. Asha Sougaijam, short stories winner
  • 6th Thang-Ta Federation Cup at Agra
  • Yu Thongba by Loi of Awang Sekmai #1
  • Yaipan, wild flower @Ukhrul :: Gallery
  • NEROCA Vs Southern Samity #5:: Gallery
  • Buddhism in Manipur
  • PDS : Proven Deceitful System
  • Love thy neighbour as thyself
  • B.Tech admission in NIT Manipur by JoSAA
  • Resolution adopted by Naga People Front
  • Iftar with locals at Lilong
  • Doubtful sincerity
  • Film Personalities #3 :: eRang Classic
  • U17 District Subroto Football :: Gallery
  • India's troubled region evades scribe-killing
  • Agenda of the BJP led Government #7
  • Sendra Park & Resort #3 :: 360 ° View
  • Career options in Education #2
  • Feverous Earth :: Poem
  • Create the right ambience for the kids
  • Reposing the trust
  • Compositeness of settlers of Manipur #2
  • Moirangthem Arup at Marathon, Africa
  • For the love of football
  • .... Moirang Sendra is for Moirang
  • Counselling for DU admission
  • Congratulate candidates from Thadou
  • North East - Delhi Consultancy
  • Jobs at PR Enterprises, Keisampat
  • Discussion on Oil Exploration at Chandel
  • Crucial period for parents/guardians
  • Manipur Sangai Festival 2016 #5 : Ooba
  • RKFD Sangai Trophy Veteran #2 :: Gallery
  • Achingliu Kamei at Half Marathon, St Albans
  • Sleepless night :: Poem
  • Arambam Boby Singh felicitated at Guwahati
  • Vice-free campus beckons Manipur student
  • Meeting on Stop Oil Exploration at Maklang
  • Shillong Lajong Signs Players For U-15
  • Need for a strong Congress ..Opposition
  • Lai Khong Chingba @Thangjing #3
  • 2nd Hill People's Day by CM :: Gallery
  • Barak Festival at Senapati #2 :: Gallery
  • Phynyx coming up with new original songs
  • Goods & Service Tax & its role in Manipur
  • Oil Exploration Consultation at Khangabok
  • Condolence for Khaplang :: Nagaland CM
  • To each his own
  • Earth crack @ Kangpokpi #1 :: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Major David Manlun :: Gallery
  • Pottery by Thongjao, Kakching :: Gallery
  • Gurumayum Robert (Archer) :: Profile
  • Lai Khong Chingba @Thangjing #2
  • Nampanliu Riamei : Ningtingale Award
  • Flood in Imphal [May 31] #2 :: Gallery
  • HSLC 2017 : Result
  • HSLC 2017 : Stats/Subject Toppers
  • HSLC 2017 : Result (External)
  • HSLC 2017 : Top 25
  • Shirui Lily Festival, Ukhrul #4 :: Gallery
  • Art exhibition at Ukhrul :: Gallery
  • President presents Award to Prof Subadani
  • Camping @ Phangrei, Ukhrul #1 :: Gallery
  • Kanchan Soibam :: eRang Photos
  • HSE 2017 : Toppers in Science :: Gallery
  • Class XII result announced :: Gallery
  • Nungbi Chaphu - Ukhrul Pottery :: Gallery
  • Ksh Bhaktakumar- Mr India 2017:: Gallery
  • Featured Photo for 2017 #2 :: Gallery
  • Landscape of Manipur #6: Wallpaper
  • 'Nura Pakhang'(Video) @Portugal:: Gallery
  • Purul, Senapati :: 360 View Panorama
  • SPONSORED ADS