TODAY -

A cauldron of competing demands

Nehginpao Kipgen *

The proposed map of 'Kuki State' covering more than half of Manipur's territory spread over five hill districts
The proposed map of 'Kuki State' covering more than half of Manipur's territory spread over five hill districts :: pix - TSE



With Manipur's Kuki groups again in protest mode, it is time to ask why the Centre ignores their calls for a dialogue but talks to Nagas

Manipur, with a population of over 2.7 million, is home to three major groups: Kuki, Naga, and Meitei. While Meiteis, primarily settled in the four valley districts want territorial integrity of the State to be maintained, Kukis and Nagas are calling for separate administrative arrangements in the hill areas Kukis for a Kukiland and Nagas to join a greater Nagaland.

Identity is a major point of conflict between Kukis and Nagas. In the process of identity formation, a number of tribes, including Anal, Maring, Monsang and Moyon, have been assimilated into the Naga fold either by coercion or by other forms of persuasion. Another major point of conflict is land.

Ethnic violence from 1992 to 1997 between the two ethnic groups resulted in the death of over 1,000 people, destruction of thousands of homes, and the displacement of tens of thousands of people. While the physical violence has ceased, tensions still linger. The simmering tension has led to different forms of agitation, claims and counterclaims.

The conflict started between Thadou and Maring tribes, both recognised as Kuki during the British colonial administration. While the casualty on the Naga side is unclear, the Kuki Inpi Manipur (KIM), apex civil body of the Kuki people in Manipur, claims that over 961 Kukis were killed, 360 villages affected, and 100,000 people rendered homeless.

The biggest bone of contention is land. The Kuki National Front (KNF), later joined by the Kuki National Organisation (KNO), is demanding that a Kukiland be carved out of the five hill districts of Manipur: Churachandpur, Chandel, Senapati, Tamenglong and Ukhrul.

The demand for Kukiland is a direct challenge to the demand for greater or southern Nagaland by the National Socialist Council of Nagaland (NSCN-IM). The Naga militant outfit wants to form greater Nagaland by merging Chandel, Senapati, Tamenglong and Ukhrul with neighbouring Nagaland State.

The intention to drive out Kukis from these four hill districts led to "ethnic cleansing" by the NSCN-IM. Though the initial violence was triggered by militant outfits in Chandel district, it spread to other parts of the State, and to Nagaland and Myanmar as well.

Demands

To restore peace and normalcy, KIM has put forward two important demands to the Nagas and the Central government.

First, it wants the Nagas, especially the NSCN-IM, to formally apologise for the crimes committed in the 1990s and perform customary Kuki rites such as paying Luongman (corpse price) and Tol-theh (cleaning the house for shedding human blood).

Second, KIM wants the Central government to compensate the loss of life and property and rehabilitate the thousands of displaced.

Naga leaders, particularly the NSCN-IM, have not responded to the demands.

While Meiteis oppose the creation of either a Kuki homeland or a greater Nagaland, the Kukis and Nagas are unable to establish any kind of coordination or cooperation. This is partly due to the simmering tension in the aftermath of the 1992-1997 clashes. The wounds of past miseries are apparently yet to be healed.

The mutual distrust has reached such a point that it is difficult for civil society organisations to initiate any congenial dialogue between the two groups.

SIDELINED

It is pertinent to ask whether the government sees the conflict as an internal matter for the ethnic groups concerned to resolve among themselves or as too insignificant an issue to intervene.

While the tension lingers, the Central government is having a political dialogue with the NSCN-IM, ignoring calls by the Kuki armed groups for political dialogue despite their commitment to a Suspension of Operation agreement since 2005. It remains unclear whether this is an institutional problem on the part of the Kuki armed organisations, or another manifestation of bias toward the NSCN-IM.

The Naga demand has been alive for decades. Similarly, the Kuki National Assembly, a political body established in 1946, submitted a memorandum to Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru on March 24, 1960 demanding the immediate creation of a Kuki state comprising all the Kuki inhabited areas of Manipur.

When there are competing demands for the same geographical areas, talking with one group and sidelining the other could engender more problems.

That became apparent with the Kuki State Demand Committee (KSDC) announcing last month a series of protests including a "Quit Kukiland movement" and a call to boycott any official programme, including Republic Day.

The KSDC is demanding that the Central government begin a political dialogue with Kuki armed groups or withdraw its local authorities from Kuki inhabited areas.

The KSDC has announced a blockade of Manipur from midnight of February 24. It suspended an earlier phase of the blockade in January on an assurance from the Centre that it would begin a political dialogue with the group on their statehood demand. But such talks have not begun.

Though there seems no quick fix to the ongoing problems of the Kukis and the Nagas, it has become an issue that cannot be ignored any longer. However any attempt to achieve amicable political solution entails participation from both ethnic groups and other concerned parties, including the Central and State governments.


Nehginpao Kipgen
* Nehginpao Kipgen is general secretary of the U.S.-based Kuki International Forum. His research focuses on the politics of South and Southeast Asia. His academic article entitled "Politics of Ethnic Conflict in Manipur" focusing on the Kukis and Nagas is published in South Asia Research journal by Sage (London) in February 2013. This article was first published in The Hindu.
This article was posted on February 23 2013



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO!
  • Appeal about arbitrary arrest of Sharmila
  • Lesson to be learnt
  • Idea of Manipur as a geo-political reality
  • Exposition of Reservation Norms in MU
  • Impact of ILP movement on students
  • Pineapple Queen Contest #1: Gallery
  • Sharmila @Ima Keithel #2: Gallery
  • Birth Of Students' Force in Manipur
  • Significance of Martyrs' Day
  • An unimportant incident can make your day
  • Candle light vigil for Palestine
  • Pengba's Haircut
  • ILP: Checking Bakery : Gallery
  • Pursuing fake killers
  • Sino-Indian rivalry
  • Manipuri- a Classical Language ?
  • Human Rights Enforcement in Northeast
  • Inner Line Permit
  • My Girl Friend : Poem
  • Sadar Hills Movement & Its Impact #2
  • Meira Katpa #2 @13 August : Gallery
  • Can Modi have guts to remove AFSPA?
  • Interview with The Dirty Strikes
  • 3D visualisers @StudioCHANDI
  • BJP demands Cong to take call on AFSPA
  • Political vendetta
  • North East & systematic failures
  • Religious movement of Haipou Jadonang #1
  • Walking By Faith, Not By Emotions
  • Jeangam, Kalanbung, Gaikhuanlung : eMing
  • Imphal Flood @Cheirap : Gallery
  • ILP: Protest by Transgender : Gallery
  • Interview with 'ReCycle'
  • Towards a better Manipur
  • ST/SC student assistance schemes
  • Leiyisigee Wangmada - Premier at BOAT
  • India Cornering Nagas into submission?
  • Judges' reports reveal AFSPA scars
  • Thank you SMS's and split mandate
  • Dzuko Valley landscape #1: Gallery
  • Chayetpa Tomnao- Red Carpet : Gallery
  • Interview with Dr. George Haokip
  • Sharmila Re-arrest Fiasco
  • Tale of 2 State Bhawan & House
  • Takhelambam Sibaraj :Apartment Award
  • Flash floods @Imphal #2: Gallery
  • ILP : Ima @Raj Bhavan #2: Gallery
  • Jobs @KanglaSolutions
  • Travel and Tourism Fair, Ahmedabad
  • Netherlands Fellowship Programme
  • Naga peace talks to resume soon
  • Much ado about Sharmila
  • The Reason : Poem
  • Leiyisigee Wangmada #1 : eRang
  • Govt na meeyambu namthak toubani
  • Will illegal migrants outnumber NE people
  • Flash floods @GP College: Gallery
  • ILP : Ima @Raj Bhavan #1: Gallery
  • ILP : AutoRicksaw protest : Gallery
  • FC Khanglai Squad For Manipur League
  • ADB project: Thoubal to Kasom Khullen
  • Scheduled Castes Students Scholarship
  • SSSC condemns Sharmila's re-arrest
  • CSCHR distressed on Sharmila re-arrest
  • 'Sharmila's re-arrest a mockery'
  • Flash floods @Imphal #1: Gallery
  • State Level Quiz Competition
  • Signature campaign on ILP at Delhi
  • Manipur get separate IAS, IPS cadres
  • 7 from NE bag Sahitya Akademi award
  • NE for higher allocation of funds
  • UN body appeal for AFSPA repeal
  • The re-arrest
  • Cap on doctors' fee
  • Irom Sharmila re-arrested: Gallery
  • Indian Culture : Manipuri Music #3
  • First Christian Convert among Zeliangrong
  • Encountering With A Super Cop
  • ILPS in Manipur- Our birthright
  • ILP: Protest @Kakwa #1: Gallery
  • Natwar Singh And Mani Shankar Aiyar
  • he siHgrE ..? :: Seireng
  • Martyrs' Day at Mao Gate
  • Delhi tops in discrimination against NE
  • With or without Sharmila
  • Manipur in midst of divisive forces
  • Sharmila released from jail #2: Gallery
  • Sadar Hills Movement & Its Impact #1
  • Tamenglong #8: Wallpaper Download
  • I-Day @MR Ground #3: Gallery
  • Feeding Genre Of News-starved Children
  • Nirupan of Shri Madan Mohan, Anuprabhu
  • Beside the Statue of Martyr : Poem
  • Training for NE reps. in Delhi Police
  • RN Ravi as interlocutor- request for review
  • 'welcomes historic, far-sighted judgement'
  • Accountant @Technodata, Imphal
  • Siemens Scholarship for Engg students
  • Sharmila released from jail #1: Gallery
  • Proving the skeptics right
  • Landlocked Manipur & highway blockades
  • Rengdi Lem (Zeliangrong) #1 :: Ooba
  • Pukhrambam Dhanajit : Akademi Award
  • 13 August @BT Park : Gallery
  • 1st Manipuri Dance Tour of Australia, 1951
  • A Fantasy World.. : Poem
  • Manipulation of Thadou Certificate issuance
  • Manipur's political dissent into prominence
  • Prisoner of Conscience Irom Sharmila
  • Fragrances From North East: Film Fest
  • Medi-chopper service in NE
  • Interior designers @StudioCHANDI
  • Reqts @CloudZack Tech, Imphal
  • Reqts @Sky Hospital, Imphal
  • 13 August @Bengaluru : Gallery
  • Patriot's Day function at Bengaluru
  • Centre snubs Nagaland
  • Victory of Irom Sharmila
  • Freedom from AFSPA & nose feeding
  • NE women harassed by landlord in Delhi
  • NTC launches 'poster campaign'
  • NE CMs' meet to decide roadmap
  • ILP: Manipur BJP seeks white paper
  • Krishna Jarma @Mahabali : Gallery
  • For keeping 'Home' clean
  • Peace talk, surrender & rehabilitation
  • Meira Katpa at BT Park: Gallery
  • Role Of Family In Education
  • 13 August @Kangla: Gallery
  • I-Day @MR Ground #2: Gallery
  • The Dark Saga : Poem
  • The curious case of Maram assault
  • Zero tolerance, AFSPA & fake encounters
  • Longjam Tombi : Veteran Sportsperson
  • RIST Talk @MU
  • Healthcare Course at JCRE
  • Short Term Courses In Hotel Management
  • FC Khanglai Rope In I-League Players
  • Leiyisigi Wangmada: Credits :: eRang
  • Welcome To The North East : Video
  • "To Be Bboy" Vol. II - Video Release
  • Documentary film workshop @Tamei
  • Pebam Chittaranjan death anniv: Gallery
  • Sushila Likmabam : Judo - Profile
  • I-Day @CORCOM Strike : Gallery
  • I-Day @Raj Bhavan: Gallery
  • ILP: CC Hr. Sec Students : Gallery
  • Applicability Of UN Watercourse Treaty
  • NIT Manipur Foundation Day
  • Delhi students discover asteroids
  • CWG medalists @Airport: Gallery
  • Passengers stranded at Golaghat
  • Medical Transcription @DBN
  • Lal Dena talks on NE experiences
  • Conference: Sustainable urbanization
  • Loktak & Manipuri Lifeworld: Book
  • Aruba :: E-pao Radio
  • Govt & Manipur University Behaviour
  • 13 August @Pune : Gallery
  • Patriots' Day at Pune
  • Tech Support @Technodata, Imphal
  • Positions reqts at JNU
  • 13 August Drama : Gallery
  • ILP: Meira paibees @Paona: Gallery
  • Indian Culture : Manipuri Music #2
  • Manipuri's exemplary love of sports
  • ILP: Students rally @Kongpal #2 :Gallery
  • Patriots' Day Observation #1 :Gallery
  • Felicitation of CWG 2014 :Gallery
  • Jhulon Festival at Kwakeithel :Gallery
  • Chayetpaa Tomnao #3 :: eRang
  • Ethnic dances Leimatak :Gallery
  • Lush green field of Lamshang :Gallery
  • Leimatak bailey bridge :Gallery
  • Kang Shanaba Indigenous Game #2: Gallery
  • Nungsigi Ten :: Radio e-pao
  • Saphabi - Manipuri Movie :: eRang Classic
  • Sushila Nandeibam - Classics #1 : Radio
  • Ngangbam Shantikumar Interview
  • Thangal Folk song :: Ooba Video
  • Thokchom Bonium :: Profile by Daniel
  • Tamenglong #6: Wallpaper Download
  • MU Gate, Canchipur :: Panorama 360ø view
  • Pre-order Chingda Satpi for Mangka
  • SPONSORED ADS