TODAY -

Kishorechand Wangkhem's case: A threat to national security or an anguished cry for the recognition of Manipur's history?

Sophia Rajkumari *



The recent arrest and detention of the Imphal based journalist Mr. Kishorechand Wangkhem for calling the Chief Minister of Manipur, N. Biren Singh, a puppet of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has again raised questions about freedom of speech in the world's largest democracy.

While Article 19(1) of India's constitution guarantees freedom of speech, it also imposes some restrictions through Article 19(2) - including those related to security of the state, public order and incitement of offences, among others.

According to press reports, Mr. Wangkhem uploaded a video on his Facebook page on November 19, 2018 criticizing the BJP-RSS and the Manipur state government. In the video he is alleged to have described Mr. Singh as a puppet of Mr. Modi and Hindutva, and expressed annoyance with the state government for organizing a function to mark the birth anniversary of Rani Lakshmi Bai of Jhansi, who fought the British during the 1857 rebellion.

He also apparently stated that Rani Lakshmi Bai had nothing to do with Manipur's freedom. Thereafter he was dismissed from his job by the local TV channel ISTV and arrested by the police. After being released on bail, he was rearrested and has since been detained under the National Security Act for sedition - and will potentially remain under detention without trial for up to a year. The reports further mentioned that the police alleged the journalist had used foul language to condemn the Chief Minister and his government.

Based on the above facts, it is quite clear that while Mr. Wangkem's outburst may perhaps be intemperate, it certainly does not seem to qualify as sedition and he can hardly be deemed a threat to national security.

Numerous judgements of the Supreme Court of India make it amply clear that mere criticism of the government does not necessarily disturb public order, and further, that ordinary breaches of public order which don't involve any danger to the state cannot be deemed to fall within the purview of the restrictions under Article 19(2).

The matter raises some important questions, which ought be answered by the Central and State Governments, as well as the management of ISTV and civil society in Manipur, namely:

1. Does seeking recognition of one's existence and history even if this is done in an inelegant or abusive manner or contrary to political etiquette - amount to sedition?

2. Does the liberty of Mr. Wangkhem pose a clear and present danger to the security of the state and nation? Are the state and nation so weak that they cannot withstand the criticism ill tempered or otherwise of an individual who arguably has hardly any influence?

3. What is the objective basis for charging Mr. Wangkem under the provisions of the NSA that demonstrate the danger posed by him and can the State Government file an affidavit on oath to affirm that they have sought sound legal opinion before depriving him of his liberty?

4. Is this case being used to create a deterrent effect, and if so why? Will all critics of the government now meet a similar fate?

5. Did ISTV issue a show cause notice and follow due process before terminating the services of Mr. Wangkhem? Was ISTV management pressurized in this regard by the Manipur authorities?

6. Why was Mr. Wangkem re-arrested under the NSA after being granted bail in the initial case filed against him under the Indian Penal Code (IPC)? Why wasn't the IPC proceeding sufficient?

7. Why is there no mass protest from the civil society? Does this not impact the public?

For several decades since India became an independent nation, the Manipuri language was officially taught in the Bengali script in Manipur's schools it is only in the last couple of decades that the shift was made to Manipur's native Meitei Mayek script. This meant that multiple generations of Manipuris, including myself, were deprived of the ability to understand and decipher our traditional texts and scriptures in their original form.

History as prescribed in our school textbooks hardly alluded to Manipur or its rich legacy dating back nearly two millenia where Manipur subsisted as an independent kingdom. Instead, it focused more on the Indian freedom struggle, mentioning Manipur as a footnote in the context of Subash Chandra Bose's Indian National Army which fought alongside the Japanese forces against the British and Indian Armies in the Battle of Imphal during the Second World War.

To this day, most educated Indians that I meet are profoundly unaware of Manipur's history or even it's geographical location, capital or culture and how these are distinct from other parts of North Eastern India and South East Asia. Racial stereotypes continue to abound compounding the problem and leading to anguish, which is sometimes directed at the Central Government and its political leadership.

Given this context, it is understandable that many Manipuris do seek a more detailed recognition of Manipur's own history, and seek to distinguish it from events in other parts of India in the era before 1947 when Manipur was a separate political entity.

Accordingly, a view may be taken that the State Government should prioritize the commemoration of local historical figures such as General Thangal, Tikendrajit, Lingthoigambi and Paona Brajbasi rather than those from other parts of India such as Rani Lakshmibai, who while being deserving of honor, didn't significantly influence Manipur. This is no different from other Indian states for example Chatrapati Shivaji being commemorated in Maharashtra or Tipu Sultan in Karnataka.

People react and express themselves in varied ways. Mr. Wangkhem reacted aggressively on social media, but the basis for his view is quite fundamental. At the same time, it is patently ridiculous to argue that his outburst or abusive style threatened national security.

One is free to agree or disagree with him and to condemn his unsavory language but there is no basis to persecute him. Only a weak or deeply insecure state needs to do that. In any durable society, one would simply like or dislike his Facebook post and move on. Accordingly, it is sad that Mr. Wangkhem - a husband and father of 2 little girls is being subjected to this apparent abuse of state power.

In the interests of honoring India's constitution and showing some understanding of Manipur's unique heritage, it would be best if Mr. Wangkem is released at the earliest and the charges against him dropped. Politically too, his detention is likely to backfire and it is best that damage control measures be undertaken at the earliest.


* Sophia Rajkumari wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer can be contacted at sophirajkumari0408(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on February 12, 2019.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • 46th AMWJU Foundation Day : Gallery
  • Machengluang cleared Tamei road
  • Scrapping of Constitution Article, 35 & 370
  • Her Kitchen :: Poem
  • Career in journalism
  • BMSA Freshers' Meet : Thanks Giving
  • Mass Awareness for PMJAY & CMHT
  • Oscar Winning Film - Hugo screening
  • Need for JAC & school to act reasonably
  • Traffic Challans & other challenges
  • Hinduism in Manipur #3
  • Atomacha, Adibo, Leikoiba :: eMing
  • An interaction with Dr. O.K. Singh #2
  • Loneliness :: Poem
  • Let Road Users have their say ..
  • RIST Talk: Binary Recurrence Sequences
  • Racial profiling & criminalization of people
  • ZPO rejects its dissolution
  • 10 houses torched in inter-village dispute
  • Heikru Hidongba #2 : Gallery
  • Attitude to life and family
  • Breaking the glass ceiling
  • 28th NAMA Convention at Chicago
  • Inpui Naga Karing Ngei 2018 : Book
  • Dr. Md. Hamidur Rahaman : AMP Award
  • World Patient Safety Day
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Peace talk reportedly at final stage
  • Chayom Thupki (Meetei Philosophy) #11
  • 48th Foundation Day of RIMS : Gallery
  • Tarpon: Annual offerings to the dead
  • Licypriya : Climate change in Angola
  • World Ozone Day 2019
  • iKON 4th anniversary : Indian iKONIC
  • Gratitude to Dk. Korungthang
  • Xavier Board Higher Education Conference
  • Confusing announcement: ban on plastics
  • Nongpok Sanjenbam village #1: Gallery
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #4: Gallery
  • Ways of seeing Atiyagi Maya
  • National Lok Adalat at Lamphel Court
  • Take Me Home :: Poem
  • Money Lending business in Nagaland
  • Ambeshori : Gold at Jr Women Natl Boxing
  • Crime against nature deserve punishment
  • Khamba Thoibi Museum #1 : Gallery
  • Time- Is it an illusion? Certainly not
  • Can there really be peace without justice
  • Enrollment Program for PMJAY & CMHT
  • Heavy traffic fines, Harekrishna krishna
  • Jenil Khuman : Heroes of India award
  • Cracking the whip on driving by minors
  • ST demand: Is this a consensus decision..
  • Mukna - indigenous game : Gallery
  • An interaction with Dr. O.K. Singh #1
  • Cry of a Dying River - 92 :: Poem
  • Missing person : Dongminlian at Tirupati
  • Google Earth for ground & aerial survey
  • Mary Kom 1st woman athlete for Vibhushan
  • Delivering a point maturely
  • There should be a toll free grievance cell
  • Hiyang Tanaba @Lamlai #1: Gallery
  • Shrinking safe spaces
  • Child sexual abuse (CSA)
  • Demands: Flag for Naga & ST for Meitei
  • Proud of our scientists & ISRO
  • Daanveer Dutta Karna : 2nd best play
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Significance of Sept 11 to TSE
  • Climate Crisis, People, and the State
  • Ibudhou Marongkhong Haraoba #3: Gallery
  • Conundrum for Manipur govt over CAB
  • Violence against medical fraternity
  • Thongkhatabam Ankita : Governor's Award
  • The Enchantress :: Poem
  • Sunyata & Kenosis: Search of Ultimate Truth
  • Lim divide continues to run deep
  • Of nationalism, patriotism & against nature
  • Heikru Hidongba #1 : Gallery
  • Komrem Students Day @B'lore : Gallery
  • Protective Thinking: Village Nationalist #1
  • Haipou Jadonang: A Social reformer #3
  • Ungracious :: Poem
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • IAS Officer: Hero- Whipping boy- Villain
  • Petition CM to revoke breach order in Edn-S
  • Stand against illegal immigrants
  • September and Hijam Irabot
  • Impact of Christianity among Vaiphei #3
  • Kakching WW II Memorial Run : Gallery
  • Framework Agreement: Divide the state
  • Training Program for Remand Advocates
  • Hunt for North East designers & models
  • Kakching World War II Memorial Run: Report
  • Common Admission Test for IIMs
  • No school bags day for young students
  • GoI backtracking on Framework Agreement
  • Trekking to Dzukou #3 : Gallery
  • English as a Lingua Franca for NE
  • A Good Place to Spend the Night : Poem
  • The idea of Manipur
  • Vacancies at Hadron Techs, Imphal
  • 8th Convocation of Assam Don Bosco held
  • Yogurt based DIY packs to try
  • Big Bang Edge Test
  • Bhabananda was right; it was not only him ..
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #3: Gallery
  • Judicial administration under Bhagyachandra
  • Reena Bhavsar(Pebam ningon): Mrs India
  • Sick Education System should be blamed ...
  • Foundation Day of Physics Dept, MU
  • 26th World Congress of Political Science
  • DBC, Maram bags SBSI National award
  • Regulate pay of Pvt school teachers
  • Chingda Satpi Engellei #1 : eRang
  • The Endurers : a growing tribe
  • Swachh in Manipur
  • Khongoinaba & Kanglei Chanura Kanba
  • The ten in between :: Poem
  • Happy for no reason
  • Convocation: Assam Don Bosco University
  • Sounding the alert at the entry points:
  • Victims of greed
  • Folk Dance @Retreat ceremony #2: Gallery
  • Call for Papers : NACETER 2019 at Aizawl
  • Celebrating Teachers' Day 2019
  • Draft Bill on violence against healthcare
  • From the heart - Transcending fears
  • Her Richness :: Poem
  • Beauty benefits of mint
  • Return of the power struggle
  • 'We Dont, So Shouldnt You' of Mayangs
  • Licypriya: Peace Prize : Gallery
  • Haipou Jadonang: A Social reformer #2
  • Licypriya : World Children Peace Prize
  • Champions at 5th Intl Thang-Ta C'ship
  • International Geological Congress 2020
  • Manipur Tourism: Best cultural Award at TTF
  • 46th AMWJU Foundation Day
  • NDPP leaders called on Nagaland Governor
  • Condemns UP Govt for case against Journo
  • Looking to CBI to deliver: The trust deficit
  • Mockery of the legislation
  • Hinduism in Manipur # 2
  • No mee should disturb peace in Kuki Hills
  • Cry of a Dying River - 91 :: Poem
  • Human service demands need to save river
  • Aromatherapy as career option
  • Khelen Thokchom Media Fellowship
  • Rejoinder to Yanthungo Patton
  • New traffic rules and regulations
  • Myopic leaders and misplaced priorities
  • Over 19 lakhs excluded in Assam NRC
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #2: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Maibi Jagoi : Gallery
  • FMGE -Foreign Medical Graduates Exam
  • Referendum in Catalonia
  • Allergen-specific blood test for allergies
  • Better investment climate: Challenge of Govt
  • AMWJU Identity Card
  • Chayom Thupki (Meetei Philosophy) #10
  • September Calendar for Year 2019 : Tools
  • Freshers Meet/Musical Night at Bangalore
  • Surgery over Healthcare
  • Discussion: Identity at India-Myanmar Border
  • A Euphoric Day Of Freedom :: Poem
  • Remembering the past famine...
  • Stalls- Hathei Phanit, Ukhrul #1: Gallery
  • AMSU & Naga Peace Talk
  • Hypocrisy of 'The Federation Of Haomee'
  • Introspecting renewed Hydropower push #2
  • Enrolment Program for PMJAY & CMHT
  • Martyrdom of Haipou Jadonang: Gallery
  • The traffic maze
  • Haipou Jadonang: A Social reformer #1
  • Chinglensana Kangujam : Arjuna Award
  • A Rainy Morning in Summer :: Poem
  • Apple Farmer Mayengbam Shyamchandra
  • The idea of a book club Imphal
  • Condemns act of locals in ICFAI Univ
  • Free medical camp at Ithai Barrage
  • Attacker on Childline must be arrested
  • Computer Courses at IP Infotech
  • Dead men or dead girls tell no tale
  • Going beyond people's expectations
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #1: Gallery
  • Wainu Chara : An indigenous rice breed
  • The sugarcane crisis
  • Positive Teachers-Students relation
  • NDPP & BJP met with Bishop of Nagaland
  • Zero budget natural farming
  • Helmet drive with sweets at CCpur
  • Responsibility matters
  • Manipur Independence Day : Gallery
  • Manipur Heli Service : Gallery
  • Kariang nuna sip eh :: Poem
  • River Rights as legal person
  • Athokpam Right: Kalams Book of Record
  • Be Educated; Be Empowered 0.02 Edition
  • Separate flag and separate Constitution
  • Manipur on a high: Drug menace
  • Impact of Christianity among Vaiphei #2
  • Introspecting renewed Hydropower push #1
  • Jhulon @ Imphal #2 : Gallery
  • Climate variability in Phalee khul, Ukhrul
  • What vows does a catholic priest take ?
  • Leg Pain : What to do ?
  • Convention: Defense of Democratic Rights
  • Transit route to manufacturing unit
  • Khangkhui Cave, Ukhrul #5 : Gallery
  • Meeting on Road project at Phalong
  • The road that halted us by earthfall
  • National Entrepreneurship Awards 2019
  • Strategies to adopt for IAS Exam
  • Discussion: Issues of Legal Services
  • Irregularities of Non-NET Fellowship in MU
  • Threatened democracy
  • Nagas await historic day: NSCN (I-M)
  • Hathei Phanit @Ukhrul #1 : Gallery
  • Dr Ak Priyokumar : Golden Achiever Award
  • Lai-Harouba @JNMDA #2 : Gallery
  • Sangai fest: Dance Drama : Gallery
  • N'Jang-Ngi Thangal fest : Gallery
  • Jhulon @ Nabadwip, WB : Gallery
  • School Fagathanshi Mission : Gallery
  • Healthy & active lifestyle: A healthy Manipur
  • Heikat-Leikat [13 Aug] #2 : Gallery
  • Babysana: Student - Aug 10 #2: Gallery
  • Jhulon @ Imphal #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Chayom Thupki (Meetei Philosophy) #9
  • Patriots' Day @ Pune : Gallery
  • Babysana: State bandh - Aug 9 #2: Gallery
  • Folklore of Hao communities #3
  • Aliyah #2 (Film Scenes) :: eRang
  • Babysana's last rites performed: Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2019 #3: Gallery
  • Tolloi, Ukhrul :: 360 Panorama View
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2019 : Download
  • SPONSORED ADS