TODAY -

14th Finance Commission and green bonus

Akham Bonbirdhwaja Singh *

The 14th Finance Commission on Oct 7 at Imphal
The 14th Finance Commission on Oct 7 at Imphal :: Pix - TSE



We have been talking about green, many things with green and the Green Bonus is one of them. Green Bonus is a new term in the environmental parlance denoting the money which is to be given for the effort made by a country, state or community for preservation of green cover. It is a compensation to be given to the people for the sacrifices they have made in preserving the green cover, which not only benefits them, but also benefits others nearby and humanity as a whole. So, in the 14th Finance Commission Awards, green bonus need to be given adequate consideration.

We know that the Uttarakhand is likely to get a green bonus for ecosystem services of its forests. The Environment Minister has given a green signal a few months back, might have been a bit influenced by the recent disaster the state had during June last. In fact, many states are clamouring for a green bonus from the centre.

The states of Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh have been pioneers. They have substantial areas under forest cover. Of late, Maharashtra also joined the party. Other states likely to get benefit of Green Bonus are Kerala, Karnataka, Arunachal Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Orissa and Madhya Pradesh. There was an interim order of the Supreme Court passed in course of interlocutory applications (IA 424) of W.P (C) 202/1995 that the forest deficit states should pay the forest surplus states.

It was technically and logically sound idea because the forest surplus states live with a lot of handicaps due to the overbearing existence of forests, its benefit of ecosystem services and environmental amelioration shared by forest deficit states. But due to pressure from the large forest deficit states, the burden has been taken over by the centre.

The awards under 13th FC was meant to be in the form of green bonus with forest as the main parameter. But is not the case. It has been worked out on the mechanism of EPI (Environmental performance index) with only 2% weightage, in which not only the forest cover, growing stock and afforestation, there are other factors such as sewage treatment, air quality, climate change preparedness etc.

There is a need to have a separate recognition for protection of forest cover, carbon stock and biodiversity, a bonus for that under the 14th Finance Commission. It need not be diluted with the fallouts of modern development like green house gases, sewage treatment and water pollution.

The forests of Manipur play an important role in the life of the people through the ecosystem services. The ecosystem services rendered by forests of Manipur can be valued to at least 1-1.5 lakhs crores of rupees for the different types of services such as Supporting services (nutrient dispersal and cycling), Provisioning services (food, energy, timber, medicines), Regulating services (carbon stocking, pest & disease control, purification of water and air) and cultural services (recreational, scientific, spiritual) etc.

As per NPV(net present value) method, it has been valued at 1.34 lakhs crore rupees (Bisht & Singsit). In terms of total carbon stocks, Manipur stands at 16th position (Source: Carbon Stocks in India’s Forests by FSI). . The total carbon stock of the state is 138 million tonnes (208 million cum) including below ground biomass (BGB) and Soil Organic Matter (SOM). This could be of monetary equivalence of 25,000 crores of rupees. The Forest of Manipur is very important from the present and potential level of sequestration to mitigate the impacts of global warming.

Does Manipur deserve a green bonus? We have to have a close look and analyse the relevant data to draw a comparison without any bias so that the interests of the state are not ignored. Though the abovementioned states have substantial areas under forests, their percentage forest cover is quite low in comparison with their geographical area. In case of Manipur, we have a large extent of forest cover.

According to the India’s State of Forest Report (ISFR), 2011, the state stands at 16th position in extent of Forest Cover. In terms of percentage of Forest Cover vis-ŕ-vis geographical area, Manipur stands at 7th position. The extent is much above the requirements as per the National Forest Policy (NFP), 1988 (in spite of the loss of 190 sqkm in 2011 report). The excess over the NFP level is our contribution to the national cause.

In most parts of the country, more forest cover means poverty, and backwardness. Due to restrictions under conservation laws, new industries and roads cannot come up, railway lines cannot be laid. New commercial places cannot be set up. The opportunities for development are lost due to forest cover and the society suffers.

Unless, there is a new approach backed up by green bonus for the opportunity lost by the people of Manipur, there will be more difficulty in saving the forests, because whatever forests are left, they are precariously balanced and vulnerable. This bonus shall act as green security, to check further loss of forests.

Manipur is among the poorest states having third lowest GDP in the country, having only about half of the national GDP and far below Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Tripura and Nagaland. Its poverty being related to the extent of forest cover and lack of industry needs a bonus to boost its economy to reduce people’s dependence on forests.

There are a lot many things the forest rich states have to say. At national level, the people who cleared their forests get schemes and projects easily and whereas, if people preserve forest, they get nothing. If this situation is not reversed, and people are rewarded, protection of forests may be extremely difficult.

That is why the Chief Ministers of Himalayan States like Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh have been making persistent demand for green bonus in addition to 13th Finance Commission Awards in lieu of the opportunity cost they are foregoing. The green bonus has to act as green security against further depletion. There can be a reasonable bonus, for about ten years.

The demand of Himachal Pradesh has been supported even by the Union Ministers. The commitment of the centre that the Himalayan States should be given green bonus has been in the news for quite some time. The Himachal and Uttarakhand have been expecting green bonus for some time.

Considering the need to improve the growing stock of forests, the provide food security to jhuming families and considering the ecosystem services that the forests of Manipur is rendering to the people of the state and adjoining states, it will be good if Manipur also can get a green bonus. It can be used to reward the people in the villages who have been instrumental in protecting the forests.

Now that the 14th Finance Commission is in the offing it is time that we understand our position.


* Akham Bonbirdhwaja Singh wrote this article for The Sangai Express
This article was posted on October 08, 2013.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Linda Thangjam - Singer Profile :: eRang
  • Lamngaanbi, Ngangbiton :: eMing
  • Sharmila in court- Aug 23 : Gallery
  • Retrospective on Aribam Syam deferred
  • Letter to Manipur Govt reg. Draft Bill
  • Can then Model Schools be the answer
  • Sharmila .... continue your struggle
  • Meet on Human Trafficking Issue at Moreh
  • Sirarakhong Hathei Phanit at Ukhrul
  • From Mary to Sarita: Dronacharya Dayal
  • Deep divide over proposed Bill
  • World will laugh, When India...
  • Sharmila agitation (From 2006) :: Timeline
  • Khongjom :: 360° Panorama
  • Jhulon Festival @Imphal : Gallery
  • MPS Alumni Meet @Koirengei : Gallery
  • Give Sharmila a breathing space #1
  • Public Interest Litigation (PIL) ....
  • After Assam, BJP sets its eyes on Manipur
  • MoU for upgradation of waste management
  • Post Mortem :: Poem
  • Felicitation for Anthony Shimray at Delhi
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) :: Timeline
  • 1st Alumni Meet of Manipur Public School
  • Involve women in talks: Forum
  • Solution should be inclusive: NTC to PM
  • Militant actions hit four NE States
  • Uncultured question on culture
  • On mission to make Imphal 'a smart city'
  • Dzuko Lily, Dzuko valley #5 : Gallery
  • Patriot's Day observation #4: Gallery
  • From Iron Lady to honey
  • Sanamahism and Seven #1
  • Train Whizzing Down the Track : Poem
  • Para 9 of draft ILP 2016 bill
  • 12 Films on NE @Woodpecker Festival
  • Irom's breakfast chronicles
  • SHRI : Scripting history
  • Imphal-Jiri Highway Condition: Gallery
  • K Bobin Music Video release: Gallery
  • Patriot's Day observation #3: Gallery
  • Missing focus in proposed Non-Local Act
  • Seven Billion Dreams, One Planet...
  • Letter to Shanmuganathan on Culture #4
  • 1st kidney transplant @ Shija
  • 18th IIT Techniche at Guwahati
  • Army denies raids inside Myanmar
  • Manipur woman leads by example
  • 5 days after 70th Independence Day
  • Bir Tikendrajit - The Hero of Manipur
  • ILP: Kh Ratan remanded: Gallery
  • Independence Day @Jiri : Gallery
  • Letter to Shanmuganathan on Culture #3
  • Nirmala Chongtham @World Bamboo, DC
  • UFO sighting: Kolkota flight? Aug 17
  • Rice for National Food Security Act
  • From LPG to traffic and NFSA
  • The greed factor
  • ILP : Kh Ratan @Keishampat: Gallery
  • Khunung Eeshei #2: Goshe :: e-pao Radio
  • Pebam Chittaranjan death anniv: Gallery
  • Did you know AFSPA before Sharmila ?
  • Yoga Center at Jiribam: Application Form
  • To be a transgender living with HIV in India
  • Buddhism differs from other religions #9
  • Stakeholders meet on NE Himalayan Region
  • Northeast India Fest enthralls Bengaluru
  • 5-member gang attacks evangelist
  • IM adamant on integration of Naga areas
  • Testing time for Govt, people: stormy days
  • Problem of 1949 Annexation of Manipur #3
  • Patriot's Day observation #2: Gallery
  • Independence Day #2: Gallery
  • Letter to Shanmuganathan on Culture #2
  • World Indigenous Peoples Day
  • Condition of Sora Junior High School
  • Seminar @Sikkim: Development in India
  • Bharti Infratel Scholarship Program for NE
  • Robita gives in to family, ends fast
  • New Manipur governor - Najma Heptulla
  • Workshop on Naga 'Framework Agreement'
  • Traffic Circus : Lack of civic sense
  • The lawless Law
  • Bishenpur Keithel #1: Gallery
  • Pakhang - Tairen : e-pao Radio
  • An open letter to Governor of Manipur
  • Independence day at Jiribam
  • Family bars Robita from taking up fast
  • 2014 Edition Of The Sangai Festival II
  • Blooming Sendra Lambi #2: Gallery
  • Positive / negative developments in Manipur
  • Walk in Interview at C-DAC Silchar
  • Independence day at Loktak Power Station
  • Manipur's 'wanted' breaks silence
  • Centre's move on illegal Hindu migrants
  • India's pathetic show at the Olympics
  • Insignificant Independence Day
  • Manipuri Atheletes at Olympic 2016 Rio
  • Independence Day @MR Ground : Gallery
  • Letter to Shanmuganathan on Culture #1
  • I-Day: Bombs exploded @Tera : Gallery
  • 13 August observed @Pune : Gallery
  • The Amazing Thailand, Tourists' Haven
  • Tata Trusts: Enabling youngsters achieve
  • India market boom louder in smaller states
  • "Don't need lessons on culture.."
  • Manipur embodies concerns of minorities
  • Patriots Day observed at Pune
  • 13 August : Heikat Leikat : Gallery
  • Robita- AFSPA hunger strike : Gallery
  • Run Raise Respond North East - 7 Sisters
  • Sharmila ends fast - what next?
  • Youth Day focuses on poverty eradication
  • Moreh and Yongchak #2
  • Ananda Purna School student wins prize
  • Patriots Day observed by ESACO
  • Independence Day celebration at ARPS
  • Framework Agreement to joint statement
  • Patriot's Day observation #1: Gallery
  • Proposed Bill on Regulation Of Non-local
  • Nagas Will Rejoice
  • Patriots' Day at Delta Tutorials
  • Patriots' Day at Loyola School
  • United Nations' International Youth Day
  • Urge India Govt to repeal AFSPA
  • JAC against 'anti-tribal' Bills : 13 Aug
  • Preserving & promoting culture
  • The historic day of 13th August
  • Ha Long Bay, Vietnam #3: Gallery
  • Manipur Technical Univ & diaspora
  • The Living Legend :: Poem
  • Chief Minister's Police Medal for Gallantry
  • Khuthang Chara Henba Numit 6
  • NH7 Weekender to start from Shillong
  • Colour Of Water #1 : eRang
  • Tejpal, Shoma in Court: Gallery
  • Imphal Turel - Tairen : e-pao Radio
  • Historical War fought by Manipur : 13 Aug
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Will Sharmila take on Modi on AFSPA
  • Prospect of MBA in Rural Management
  • Research Scientist at NE-SAC, Umiam
  • Independence Day at Sana Konung
  • Director General Assam Rifles visit Manipur
  • Manipur Regulation of Non-Local Bill 2016
  • AFSPA rally @Ukhrul : Gallery
  • Chirom Indira: Handloom National Award
  • Drafting of new ILPS Bill in Manipur
  • People movement in absence of Think Tank
  • I wonder :: Poem
  • Untitled Poem :: Poem
  • Solidarity Action for Sharmila in Delhi
  • World's Indigenous Peoples Day
  • Irom Sharmila released [Aug 9] : Gallery
  • Star Kamei play Khangnegong : eRang
  • Changing Trend: Are We Heading Forward
  • GST - A game-changer for India
  • Employment at Oorei Teahouse, Sagolband
  • Free admission course under PMKVY
  • Calls for mass movement against AFSPA
  • International day: World Indigenous Day
  • End of Irom Sharmila's hunger strike
  • Nambol Keithel #1 : Gallery
  • CJM's order on Sharmila - 9 August
  • Blooming Sendra Lambi #1: Gallery
  • Transforming Quality Of Education #2
  • Sharmila, Sabotage and Us
  • Playing first Olympic hockey match in 36 yrs
  • Manipur women vow to continue fight
  • Gardening for blooming Sendra Lambi
  • Protest: commissioning of Mapithel dam
  • Program on Implementation of POCSO Act
  • Khuthang Chara Henba Numit Nini...
  • Community Gardening at Moirang Sendra
  • The Killing Fields 2016 :: News Timeline
  • Looking eastward
  • 9 August 2016: A Day of Reflection
  • Ahongbam Bemthoi: cracked APSC Exam
  • Manipur Technical University: Gallery
  • To Irom Sharmila with hope
  • Employment opportunity for Naga youth
  • Manipur Cultural Integration Conference
  • Medical Concession for NE at Delhi
  • Wasmir Epham @ Mr Junior Asia 2016
  • 19th Manipur Integrity Day: Gallery
  • Bomb exploded near BT Park: Gallery
  • Indigenous People Protection Bill impasse
  • Journey of Oinam Indira: Book Release
  • Saikhom Mirabai :: Manipur Rio Dreams
  • Robert Naorem : Unity of Community
  • AMMA FC returns from Denmark: Gallery
  • RIST Popular Talk -21 @Manipur Univ
  • Thokchom Anuradha :: Manipur Rio Dream
  • ILP: Students/Police [Jul 27] #2 : Gallery
  • Hiroaki Yokoyama- came searching for Pena
  • Alford Manor campaign- Maharaja's Clothes
  • Indo-Naga Talks : News Timeline
  • Kothajit Khadangbam : Manipur Rio Dream
  • ILP Demand - Photos from 2012 :: Gallery
  • Landscape of Dzukou Valley #4 : Gallery
  • JE vaccination @CCpur : Gallery
  • Tangkhul War Dance :: Ooba Video
  • Phiyowon blooms @Ukhrul #2: Gallery
  • ILP : TG students protest #2 : Gallery
  • Kabow Valley : Gallery
  • Yangnu Golmei : Kala Akademi Award
  • Archived News Photo #3 :: May - July 2016
  • Manipur Phone Directory :: e-pao Tools
  • SPONSORED ADS