TODAY -

Which first - Peace or Development ? Justice First !

By Jinine Laishramcha *



Which first, "Peace" or "Development"?—has been a very purposeful and fundamental question in the conflict and violence ridden Manipur. The argument goes... When peace is in its best position, development will flourish, or in the absence of development, peace has no chance.

The contextual understanding of development in the question though mainly concerned with the constructional activities of the Government, it will be about constructing a situation where people can pursue their full potential and lead productive, creative lives in accordance with their needs and interests, thus bringing the focus back onto people.

The general simple meaning of peace will be of a situation where people can live free from violence, conflicts, sufferings, fears and tensions of any kinds. From the viewpoint of the conflict, the peace is durable, involves high level reciprocity and cooperation, and virtual absence of self-defense measure among parties, although it may include their military alliances against a common threat. A "positive peace" prevails based on shared values, goals, and institutions (eg democratic political systems and rule of law), economic interdependence, and a sense of international community.

Most of the common people are in favour of this proposition that there is no peace where there is no development. So is development first. But Government and most of their agents would prefer to appeal "here is no chance of development in case here is no peace." Hence, peace should be imposed first. Again many of us comment a simultaneous existence of both; there is no question of first or later. The argument may be correct to some extent. However, according to my experience and analysis a gigantic principal building block called "Justice" is missing in the debate.

Many among the people believe that the armed movement of the political conflict and its associate violent activities in Manipur are prompted by the issue of development—the development that Government turns off for a quite long time. Important portion of truth perhaps may be in here. On the other hand without fair acknowledgment of the root causes of the existing conflict and issue, the Government insist on, "peace must be enforced first, in fact with the militarisation at the cost of human rights usually".

The peace from the State perspective may be of the implicit notion of controlling and contending the armed opposition organisations and their activities particularly those who oppose and obstruct Government policies and undertakings. They even ignore the universal interpretation of peace that involves human rights. The peace in Manipur has been of negative implication, as the active militarisation, factional violence, ethnic enmity, and "the lasting talk not the lasting peace" are on the scene. I do not rule out the partial correctness in the above debate. What I am attempting to suggest is, "Justice is the foundation of Peace and Development; in the absence of Justice there is no chance of valid and viable Peace and Development".

Justice as I would like to define is the correct and rightful treatment guaranteed to the peoples and exercised for the well-being of the peoples, society and environment respecting human rights ie life, liberty, equality and dignity. The bottom line is the political conflict and its byproduct issues of human rights violations and other related problems that have come up due to so many injustices done to the people. Thus, the concern for violence and consequent issue of peace has come along.

Apart from the general violence, a violence referring to as a structural violence is one key contribution to the debate. This structural violence is marked by the controversial merger, subsequent downgrading of the princely State and the imposition of anti peoples' legislations. It has emerged out of the creation of social and political structures that deprives the rights of (indigenous) peoples of Manipur in terms of safety, respect, participation, economy, identity and culture. It is considered to be the fundamental root cause for the existing Political Conflict and its byproduct Human Rights Violations.

How far justice has been done to the prolonged survival of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA), and the imposition of other anti-people legislations, National Security Act, Activities of National Investigation Agency, Protected Area Permission (a brief lift recently on experimental basis), the protected impunity that encouraging the recurrent crimes by Government security forces and other criminals who enjoy Government favour.

The months long deception drama of secret detention of Sanayaima, Chairman of the UNLF and India's charade that AFSPA never violates human rights at the 1st session of Universal Periodic Review of the Human Rights Council, at Geneva, claiming the AFSPA has constitutionality; Constitution upheld the act. So, is the Indian Constitution is draconian? India lied about fact that actual happening on the ground.

What justice has been done to the world phenomenon hunger strike of Irom Chanu Sharmila. Only the Government demonstrate a racial discriminatory response to Sharmila's decade long hunger strike against AFSPA, whereas Delhi reacts so promptly to the Anna Hazare's Anti-Corruption Bill and Medha Patkar's Narmada Bachao Andolan demands.

In such isolated Manipur, peoples have been protesting whatever they can; from sit in protest to general strike, from rally to mothers' nude agitation, from effigy burning to self immolation. Notwithstanding, rights violations continue, in the year 2008-9 about 603 cases of extrajudicial executions by Indian Armed Forces and Manipur Police Commandos and about 400 of the killed by unidentified persons and non-state actors were documented.

In addition to this, the tension and the suspicion among the ethnic peoples of Manipur are rising ever since the Government of India initiated peace process with some armed opposition groups. Also here is an increasing number of killings by the unidentified gunmen and organised crimes by splinter armed groups nexus with security forces indulging in killing, bombing and shooting, kidnapping and extortion.

Justice concern is demanded so much in the following matters:

  • Destruction of evidence of the extrajudicial executions due to improper deposition of the dead bodies in the Regional Institute of Medical Sciences (RIMS) mortuary, the autopsy procedure that is noncompliance with the custodial killings, quick disposed off the body, non conduction of forensic examination, etc. have been a usual practice. The discouraging response of the Government towards the Human Rights Institution and media community is very much explicit.
  • The lasting peace talk or suspension of operation that Government let some armed groups free in continuation of violent activities towards the other ethnic groups. Besides, usually people have dismay towards the forces for their active involvement in destabilising communal harmony in the region.
  • Is the expansion of job creation for local indigenous youths of Manipur in armed sector of Manipur Police Commandos, the Indian Reserved Battalions Village Defense Force, and Special Police Officers truly productive? Is the fear of fraternal bloodshed among son of soil in the name counter insurgency a peaceful vision?
  • People have not seen Government's productive policy and undertaking to meet the economic means of the peoples so there comes up the widening gap between the economic means and desire at the backdrop of the global consumerism trend which consequently causing the breed of organised crimes.
  • For whom the Loktak Hydro Electric Project was built, how far has this Electric Project provided benefit to Manipuris? Why will the Tipaimuk Dam be undertaken by destroying such a rich biodiversity hot spot? Why is the Government blind to such environment friendly bio resources that can earn billions of dollars? In whose interest is the Look East Policy mapped out? The fact is the development projects and policies are laid out with either hidden agenda or without Free, Prior and Informed Consent of the people.
  • Allow to remain the free float evil of the drug abuse and alcoholism unchecked and to continue the cycle of rampant corruption creating an environment of easy grow money to allure the fellow Manipuris to trap into haywire net of corruption and violence are not addressed so far.
As long as the Government continue their attempt to build peace and to undertake developments without acknowledging the injustices involved, and the public remain insensitive to the sensitive issues, we merely witness a proven negative peace and an invalid development that prolong the suicidal action for the society.




* Jinine Laishramcha wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer is a human rights defender; MA Human Rights, IIHR, New Delhi; Certificate Course in Conflict Analysis, USIP, Washington DC and International Humanitarian Law Training, ICRC, Geneva and can be reached at lcjinine(at)gmail(dot)com
This article was webcasted on April 21 2011.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Product @Langbal Keithel #1:: Gallery
  • Death Anniv- Bhagyachandra #3 :: Gallery
  • Written Exam for CDPO postphoned
  • Lamyanba Hijam Irabot :: Read all him..
  • Manipur Assembly Elections 2017 #1
  • Ekai Thabi- Aquatic vegetable cash crop
  • Message to the Meiteis living abroad
  • A Cloud of Dust :: Poem
  • Jobs in IT Cell at C-DAC Silchar
  • Making change to education scenario
  • 107 illegal migrants pushed back
  • Deficit monsoon rains in most of NE
  • Nangna Helli Nungshiba #1 :eRang
  • AIM, Khabam Vs NEROCA FC :: Gallery
  • Yumnam Yaima : Manipuri Sahitya Parishad
  • Langol Watch Tower #5 :: 360 ° View
  • FIR against fmr CM Ibobi in MDS scam
  • Protest demanding justice for Pravish
  • Killing Of Tripura Journalist
  • The Killing Fields :: News Timeline
  • Idiotic stand of making Hindi compulsory
  • September and Hijam Irabot
  • Death Anniv- Bhagyachandra #2 :: Gallery
  • National Repentance Day :: Gallery
  • Chasing Tidal Waves by Lo! Peninsula
  • Volleyball tournament at Chingai, Ukhrul
  • Condemns murder of Shantanu Bhowmik
  • Condemns scribe's murder in Tripura
  • Deep grief over another assassination
  • Suspicious death of missing youth in Noida
  • Protest outside UP Bhawan in Delhi
  • Bigger threat from Bangla immigrants
  • Of war, wine and women
  • A trip to Moreh #1 :: Gallery
  • Death Anniv- Bhagyachandra #1 :: Gallery
  • Breach of Privilege & Contempt of the House
  • Career option in History
  • Cry of a Dying River - 1 :: Poem
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand : Timeline
  • Condemn provocation against Pangal
  • Meetei Demand Of Scheduled Tribe @ Delhi
  • Resolutions adopted by NPF Central HQs
  • TSA-GHQ calls off agitation
  • Diverting filled cylinders from hills
  • Manipur Sangai Festival 2016 #6 : Ooba
  • History of Printing in Manipur
  • Hydro Electric Power: A must for Manipur #1
  • Why Total Knee Replacement is necessary
  • Self-styled godmen and mental darkness
  • The Dawn of Knowledge :: Poem
  • Consideration for Govt on UTLA camp attack
  • Bloody Phanek premiere in South Korea
  • Memo to Satywati College against Hindi
  • NE militant in Myanmar may face problem
  • Putting the limelight on O Ibobi
  • Bamboo - our green treasure
  • Jadonang: Indomitable faith of martyrdom
  • 12th Manipur State League #3:: Gallery
  • Cyberbullying
  • British rule in India: blessing or curse?
  • Candle light for Pravish Chanam at Delhi
  • Concern over Cambodia media crackdown
  • Present crisis a blessing for NPF: MLA
  • Medical Camp at Tokpaching, Chandel
  • High promises, high expectations : BJP Govt
  • Traffic regulation still yet be improved
  • Traditional Ritual @Khurkhul #4 :: Gallery
  • Athokpam Tomchou :: Sahityabhusan
  • Kanglasha & Kangla Fort :: 360 ° View
  • Mapithel Dam: Tumukhong village's sorrow
  • Earthen Pots of Thongjao :: Poem
  • Protest Rally at Uchiwa on Pravish's death
  • Three former insurgents killed in Manipur
  • Frisking exercise intensifies along borders
  • Manipur await to deport Rohingya prisoner
  • Culturals @ Pineapple Fest #2 :: Gallery
  • Boisang, Yaronsho, Thangmeiso :: eMing
  • MSL: NISA Vs FC Zalen :: Gallery
  • Fund the Athlete: Support Sumanta Naorem
  • Carbon Sequestration Vs Agroforestry tree
  • PHYNYX changes name & going global
  • NEFIS reaches HM on Pravish death
  • Expecting the expectation
  • Priyogopal : Senior Film Artist :: eRang
  • Ningtham Charei fashion catwalk :: Gallery
  • My Japanlan memoir after 4 score yrs- D
  • Candle light: Justice for Pravish Chanam
  • Science as a Christian vocation
  • Yesterday Today and Tomorrow :: Poem
  • Early Childhood Education Impact Study
  • Condemn the attitude of Noida Police
  • Protest at Noida SSP's office
  • A Child Cannot Decide Its Parent
  • Notification from COHSEM for Class XI
  • Threat to ban movement of non-local
  • Re-defining Mr. Clean perspectives
  • Hathei Phanit @Sirarakhong :: Gallery
  • Education in Manipur- reform & vision
  • Career option in Political Science
  • A Robe of Love :: Poem
  • Memo to CM regarding dead in Noida
  • Meghalaya edition of NH7 Weekender
  • Away from Imphal centric: Govt-Hills Bhai!
  • Panchayat election matters...
  • Reception for CM at CCPur :: Gallery
  • 239th Heikru Hidongba #2 :: Gallery
  • Buddha Said: The More The Govt... #2
  • R & R anomaly in Mapithel dam
  • Letting go :: Poem
  • Bedtime beauty hacks to look young
  • Warepnaba Meefam Saruk Yabiyu
  • Indo-Naga Talks 2017 :: News Timeline
  • Civil Sectt crawling at snail pace
  • Perplexity trends
  • Heitha Leithaba @Kekrupat #2:: Gallery
  • Ningtham Charei :: Fashion Show
  • ISKCON Temple, Imphal #2 :: 360 ° View
  • Remote Villages conditions remain same
  • General Meeting & Social Gathering of EMA
  • Leadership management
  • Karo Sambhav School Program at Tripura
  • Blood Donation Camp at RIMS
  • Another spell of cooking gas shortage
  • Parking paralysis
  • Manipur Univ of Culture #3 :: Gallery
  • Sub Junior Boys Basketball #2 :: Gallery
  • Binalakshmi Nepram: NE Excellence Award
  • Manipuri in Proto-Sino-Tibetan Family
  • Lamka: Urban character with rural admin
  • MUTA Colloquium : 3 decades of teaching
  • IIHEd Seminar : The Rohingya Conundrum
  • Inter Village Volley Ball at Chandel
  • Trafficking story from CCpur
  • Local body election matters
  • Pottery Crafts of Manipur #1 :: Gallery
  • Techniche, IIT Guwahati :: Gallery
  • Anger begets hope & constructive action
  • World's oldest Parliamentarian
  • Convocation of Assam Don Bosco Univ.
  • Times I Live In :: Poem
  • Sadar Hills District Demand: News Timeline
  • Date with Sep 11 : Setting new benchmarks
  • Angaoba Film Scenes #2 :: eRang
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • My Japanlan memoir after 4 score years- C
  • Flood & Ithai Barrage: A brief reflection
  • Indigenous people must be consulted...
  • When a Star Finally Dies :: Poem
  • Job openings at The Rice Company
  • Lesson need to learn from Gouri Lankesh
  • Sumi Hoho calls on Nagaland CM
  • #NeverStop Guwahati: fitness enthusiasts
  • Protests against Myanmar govt
  • Culturals @ Pineapple Fest #1 :: Gallery
  • 12th Manipur State League #1:: Gallery
  • Tete a tete with the Education Minister
  • Freak and frank job interview
  • Buddha Said: The More The Govt... #1
  • Dichtung und Wahrheit :: Poem
  • Protest: Myanmar for persecuting Rohingya
  • Subroto Football under 14 yrs at Delhi
  • Performance anxiety: and its election again
  • Heitha Leithaba @Kekrupat #1:: Gallery
  • Heikru Hidongba Definition: Bijoy Govinda
  • Shri Shri Govindaji Temple #2 :: 360 ° View
  • Era gone with Rishang Keishing demise
  • International Literacy Day, 2017
  • De-notify Disturbed Area tag & repeal AFSPA
  • Waiting for a Good Morrow:: Poem
  • Annual Fresher's Meet, MSAD
  • Clogged waterways: Plastics, plastics...
  • Life is to be lived, not to merely survive
  • State level Teacher's Day :: Gallery
  • MU Inter-College Basketball :: Gallery
  • Half Step Rock signs up PHYNYX, now 'LEN'
  • RIST Talk 31 : metal cholate hydrogels
  • Day 3 at Techniche IIT Guwahati
  • Response to "need male empowerment"
  • Condemns murder of Gauri Lankesh
  • Condemns murder of Bengaluru journalist
  • NPF on impersonation of its President
  • Pre-recruitment Training for Chandel Youth
  • Where are the Ojas in teachers ?
  • Another stunt, but things remain the same
  • Bhoot Ki Thoujal :: Funga Wari
  • 52nd Hunger Marchers' Day #3 :: Gallery
  • Global development agenda & local realities
  • Sita :: Poem
  • Career in Audio/Sound Engineering
  • Education for conflict
  • Bikram's Blog :: 10 Year on Web
  • 7th Pay & the fiscal reality of the State
  • Of Patriot and patriotism
  • 2nd Conclave of NEDA
  • Kang Tournament #2 :: Gallery
  • NE Fashion Week #2 :: Gallery
  • Beauvoir's Second Sex & Maam's teaching
  • Face to Face with Rishang Keishing
  • ...real fact nobody wants to tell naked truth
  • to whom it may concern :: Poem
  • Importance of yoga
  • 'Court Arrest Prog' on Teachers' Day
  • Recruitment drive at Globizs, Imphal
  • JCILPS back after a brief lull
  • Culture of respect
  • 239th Heikru Hidongba #1 :: Gallery
  • Oinam Doren wins award in Italy (Lessinia)
  • For Chester : Tribute Concert :: Gallery
  • Id-ul-Zuha @ Hatta, Minuthong :: Gallery
  • Tribute to Rishang Keishing #3 :: Gallery
  • Heikru Hidongba
  • Result: 3rd Imphal National Photo contest
  • Haipou Jadonang day :: Gallery
  • Sub-Junior Football for NE :: Gallery
  • Xth Pineapple Fest @CCpur :: Gallery
  • L Devendro : O Bembem :: Arjuna Awards
  • Ige KNliye kabita Ama :: Seireng
  • Karong Children home wash away:: Gallery
  • State bids adieu to Rishang :: Gallery
  • Rishang Keishing : A profile
  • Tribute to Rishang Keishing #2 :: Gallery
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • Nungbi Khullen, Ukhrul #2 :: Gallery
  • Landscape of Ukhrul District #2:: Gallery
  • Landscape of Manipur #7: Wallpaper
  • Featured Photo for 2017 #3 :: Gallery
  • SPONSORED ADS