Counterpoints: The Transgender Rights Bill, 2019
- Part 1 -

Santa Khurai / Rubani Yumkhaibam *

Trans-Gender (Nupi Manbi) Community of Manipur at work in Imphal :: March 10 2013
Trans-Gender (Nupi Manbi) Community of Manipur at work in Imphal in March 2013 :: Pix - Deepak Oinam

The Transgender Rights Bill, 2019 was approved by the Union Cabinet Ministry on July 10, 2019. The origin of the Bill goes back to August 2, 2016, when the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha. After referring the report of the Bill to the Standing Committee on July 17, 2017, the Bill was finally passed by the Lok Sabha on December 17, 2018.

On July 10, 2019, the Bill was approved by the Union Cabinet Ministry. Through brief article, we would like to point out the critical flaws in the Bill, and to relate the provisions of the Bill to the transgender subjects, nupi maanbis (transgender women) and nupa maanba (transgender men) in Manipur today.

The Bill has been consistently criticised by the transgender communities, lawyers, and many other collectives right from its passage in 2016. The main crux of the criticism is the task of defining the 'transgender identity'.

It must be mentioned here that in the 2016 version of the Bill, transgender identity was defined as one 'who is partly male or partly female, or neither male nor female'. Such a description of a transgender identity constructs the subjects as lacking a stable gender identity, which ultimately reinforces the marginalisation and prejudices against the subjects.

The transgender communities all over India protested against the implied humiliation of the trans identity. Following the outrage from various collectives, the terms of defining the transgender identity have undergone a few modifications, which has led to the current definition '"transgender person" means a person whose gender does not match with the gender assigned to that person at birth and include trans-man or trans-woman (whether or not such a person has undergone Sex Reassignment Surgery or hormone therapy or laser therapy or such other therapy), person with intersex variations, Genderqueer and person having such socio-cultural identities as kinner, hijra, aravani and jogta' (Page 2 of The Transgender Rights Bill, 2019).

This sub-section from the Bill gives a broad definition of a transgender identity. The definition recognises that a person whose natal gender is at odds with the real gender expression (of the same person) is legally recognised as a transgender. For such a recognition, no medical intervention is needed.

A genderqueer person, meaning a person whose gender cannot be confined within the man/woman binary, is recognised as a transgender. People whose identities have socio-cultural relevance in many communities of India, such as hijra, kinner, aravani and jogta are also recognised as transgenders.

What is problematic is the classification of intersex people as transgender. Intersex people do not relate themselves as transgender or transsexuals, and they need different understanding both in the legal and medical domains, for a fuller growth of the individuals.

The above sub-section that defines the transgender identity is complimented by another sub-section that states 'person recognised as transgender under sub-section (the one quoted above)(I) shall have the right to self-perceived gender identity.'

This sub-section connotes that a transgender person who wants to identify himself/herself with any gender, man or woman, may do so upon the testimony of self-perception, no requirement of medical intervention (to be identified as a man or a woman) is mentioned till this point of transgender gender identification.

However, a sub-section inserted later with regard to change of gender of a trans person introduces a problem with the right to 'self-perceived' gender.

The introduction of change in gender in section 7 sates -
'(1) After the issue of a certificate under sub-section (1) of section 6, if a transgender person undergoes surgery to change gender either as a male or female, such person may make an application, along with a certificate issued to that effect by the Medical Superintendent or Chief Medical Officer of the medical institution in which that person has undergone surgery, to the District Magistrate for revised certificate, in such form and manner as may be prescribed.'

This sub-section implies that a transgender person can be recognised as a man or a woman only after going through Sex Reassignment Surgery (SRS). The section clearly violates the gender subjectivity or the validity of 'self-perceived' gender, which only a can transgender person must exercised over himself/herself. Any external agency's determination in the perception of a transgender identity is conceptually contradictory.

It must be remembered that according to the Supreme Court verdict in NALSA vs. UOI (2014), a transgender person can recognise himself or herself as a man or a woman without Sex Reassignment Therapy or any form of hormone treatment. However, the lack of clarity and existing contradictions between a few sub-sections of the Bill regarding the transgender identification contradicts the purpose of both the Bill and the Supreme Court verdict.

The question to be raised is why is a Bill that concerns itself with extending rights and protection to transgender persons constantly trying to limit the experiences and personal autonomy of trans people?

The answer lies in the implication that the governmental rationality is seeking to confine the legitimacy and identity of those who do not conform to gender binary of the heteronormative society.

To put in other words, the Bill attempts to 're-orient' the transgender subjects to either/or logic of man/woman fixity, a rationale that has marginalised transgender persons for decades. The indecisive language of the Bill will ultimately deny the right to be different.

The lack of transparency in the definition of the transgender identity is particularly damaging to the transgender people, nupi maanbis and nupa maanbas in the Manipuri society. Among the transgender subjects of the contemporary Manipur, the sexed body, either through birth or Sex Reassignment Surgery or hormone therapy, does not play a vital part in the expressions of one's gender.

In our fieldwork among the nupi maanbis and nupa maanbas that we have conducted over the years, transgender persons who have not gone through hormone therapy or surgical reassignment identify themselves as man or woman according to their gender subjectivity.

Moreover, there are multiple expressions of transgenderism in the contemporary Manipur society, and consequently there are different ways of being a man or a woman among the indigenous subjects.

Thus, while some nupi maanbis are contented with a singular expression of transgender as a 'third gender', some others have been living their lives as a man or a woman outside the natal gender.

Indeed, this non-conformity between the sexed body and lived gender is the central experience of a transgender person. Society as a whole has the ethical responsibility to acknowledge and accept the diversity that exists amongst ourselves.

The fixity of sex/gender binary is a Western construct, and the imposition of such a straightjacket norm is tantamount to the erasure of the multiplicity of gender that has always been existing in the Manipuri society. Once again, the Bill has failed to address to the diversity of transgender expressions in different communities in India.

To be continued....

* Santa Khurai and Rubani Yumkhaibam wrote this article for The Sangai Express
Santa Khurai is an indigenous nupi maanbi gender activist.
Rubani Yumkhaibam is a researcher in queer identities/communities in Manipur.
This article was posted on 04 August, 2019 .

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Heikat-Leikat [13 Aug] #2 : Gallery
  • 13 August: Day to remember the heroes #2
  • Dynamic groundwater resources...
  • Lukanand Ksh & Langpoklakpam Melody
  • Meiraba winner @ All India Badminton
  • Archers win at World Police & Fire Games
  • 73rd Independence Day: One Constitution
  • Preparatory Revision Course at Sanakeithel
  • IIT Guwahati's half marathon
  • Getting the best out of Govt schools
  • Babysana: Student - Aug 10 #2: Gallery
  • Jhulon @ Imphal #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • A Soldier speaks over Timeline of Kashmir
  • Tamenglong not be used as a money field
  • Food intolerance - Diagnosis & tests
  • That Jungle of a Garden :: Poem
  • International Day of Indigenous People
  • Saving future Manipur- need of the hour
  • Chayom Thupki (Meetei Philosophy) #9
  • Independence Day : Gallery
  • Suicide: how it looks like & what is
  • Manipur's 1st photojournalist, Santosh Ph
  • Mutum Ramo : President's Police Medal
  • A Letter to my Mother
  • Candle Light at Delhi for Babysana
  • In search of the elusive unity
  • Naga solution anytime soon, says Ravi
  • Landscape Dzukou Valley #1 : Gallery
  • Indigeneity: Expression & Experience : Book
  • Cry of a Dying River - 89 :: Poem
  • Career in youth development
  • The Wind Will Carry Us : Film screening
  • Communication Course for Development
  • Impact of Christianity among Vaiphei #1
  • Dolaithabi Barrage: An emerging failed Dam
  • Chamba, Ayung, Paomilal :: eMing
  • New India in Konung Lampak
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • High Court & Workers on Sand Quarrying
  • Niranjoy attempt to break Guinness Record
  • Scripting Congress Mukt slogan
  • Bharat Mata has no place on August 13
  • Heikat-Leikat [13 Aug] #1 : Gallery
  • 13 August: Day to remember the heroes #1
  • Jallianwala: Manglen Onkhraba Lamjao
  • Lets us preserve indigenous languages
  • Hepatitis and pregnancy
  • On statement by Hoho & Naga Mother
  • Thangmeiband : Distasteful politics
  • Remembering patriots
  • UN Human Rights: Manipur Experience #5
  • Patriots' Day @ Pune : Gallery
  • Historical War fought by Manipur :: Articles
  • Police adapting to challenge by trafficking
  • Preventing TB is rooted in medical ethics
  • In the name of Love :: Poem
  • Expensive motor laws on the way
  • 13th August observed at Pune
  • Youth conclave with a difference
  • Alarming State of Students Life in Manipur
  • Babysana: Student - Aug 10 #1: Gallery
  • On Manipur Handlooms: A Clarion Call
  • Dzuko - A piece of heaven on earth #2
  • Of Colours and Sunset
  • A Beautiful Mind :: Poem
  • An apple a day keeps wrinkles at bay
  • From hostels to the school
  • Renaissance of Meitei Hinduism
  • Babysana: State bandh - Aug 9 #2: Gallery
  • Id-Ul-Azha - Id Festival :: Book
  • Would any journalist dare to stand up #2
  • Artic Haobam won 1st ArP championship
  • Invitation : RIST Talk - 40 @ MU
  • Condole demise of Phanjoubam Santosh
  • Making a New India & fate of Manipur
  • Babysana: State bandh - Aug 9 #1: Gallery
  • Some basics that many people ignored
  • House building of the Zeliangrong #2
  • Condolence : Photo Jounalist Ph Santosh
  • World Indigenous Peoples at Khumulwng
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Zo Forum celebrates Indigenous day
  • Lukanand Ksh wins at Mister North East
  • Post mortem reports fail to cut ice
  • Babysana: Student protest- Aug 8: Gallery
  • Counterpoints: Transgender Rights Bill #2
  • Manipur topped rankings in Breastfeeding
  • Cry of a Dying River - 88 :: Poem
  • World Indigenous Peoples Day
  • Criticizes scrapping of Article 370
  • Naga leader compromise Naga future
  • Free Children Heart Surgery Camp
  • Another bandh after 12 hours bandh over
  • Babysana death: What ails this society
  • Folklore of Hao communities #3
  • Programm @Sangai Fest #4 : Gallery
  • 'Tamenglong & Manipur' Amur Falcons #2
  • Haris Adhikari: Finest Whiskey in Writing
  • Manipur bag 6 medals at National Fencing
  • Agriculture and skill training
  • Resolutions on Naga Political Issue
  • Need for Imphal to reach out to hill CSO
  • ..should be justice for 1000s babysanas
  • Ibudhou Pakhangba Haraoba #2: Gallery
  • Mob Culture in Manipur
  • Dzuko - A piece of heaven on earth #1
  • Abrogation of Article 370
  • Issue of illegal mining of minor minerals
  • Annual Legal Awareness Program at Pune
  • Power, Works back to Biswajit
  • Redefining India
  • Gandhari (Dance Drama) #1 : Gallery
  • Would any journalist dare to stand up #1
  • The Truth Lie :: Poem
  • An opportunity to end AIDS & TB
  • Soft skills?? What are soft skills
  • Community - Road to healthy environment
  • Scrapping Articles 370, 35A
  • Matsyanyaya: Law of the Fish
  • Babysana: protest @Khuyathong : Gallery
  • Road from Haochong to Noney : Gallery
  • House building of the Zeliangrong #1
  • The World We Want
  • My Lil' Hamlet :: Poem
  • CM meet with CSO: Naga solution at hand?
  • Aliyah #2 (Film Scenes) :: eRang
  • Old Age Home Kumbi : Gallery
  • Counterpoints: Transgender Rights Bill #1
  • 'Tamenglong & Manipur' Amur Falcons #1
  • Vocationalisation of education in Manipur
  • Tourism Festivals & Tourists in Manipur
  • The World Turned Upside Down :: Poem
  • Think about the future
  • Nachom : used traditionally by Meitei
  • Kanglen Kang Chingba #2 : Gallery
  • Trend of private drug rehabilitation centre
  • Saffronites unhappy with power politics
  • IABP (Balloon Pump) saved life
  • Mega Mister & Miss North East
  • Anti-terror laws & victimization of innocent
  • The state today: blame the representative
  • Will remain true to Framework : IM
  • Laonii Fest @Phuba #1 : Gallery
  • No #endAIDS without #endTB
  • Cry of a Dying River - 87 :: Poem
  • Green your skills for green jobs
  • Ji Ingobi Chingtham: Bicycle tour
  • Will surrogacy law be really effective?
  • Vacancies at Hadron Techs, Imphal
  • 14 hours out of 24 hours
  • When people turn violent against HC order
  • Babysana's last rites performed: Gallery
  • August Calendar for Year 2019 :: Tools
  • Parade @ Manipur Police, Pangei: Gallery
  • War with Climate
  • Matric, UG & PG days of an aerobiologist
  • Invitation : Workshop on Mathematica
  • Job vacancies at Makok Technologies
  • Liver Function Tests
  • Arrested but not on murder charge
  • Threatened future and the way out
  • Downside of Khuga Multipurpose Project
  • Manipur State Drug Policy #2
  • Scope of career in legal field
  • Demising the Adolescent Miss :: Poem
  • Threats against Rights defender Sobita
  • Demands action against scribe-assailants
  • Back home after Delhi's suggestion
  • Babysana's death and its questions
  • Licypriya: Abdul Kalam Children Award 2019
  • Two positives attracting each other
  • Kakching World War-II Memorial Run
  • Assessment your Tax for ITR
  • Who is responsible ?
  • Rejoinder to branding me as Fortune Teller
  • From Dec 8, 2016 to July 29, 2019
  • Of faith and failed justice
  • Neli Chachea: Doll Maker : Gallery
  • Traditional Practices of the Kukis: Book
  • Zero HIV transmission is must to #endAIDS
  • North-East students of Aryans Group shine
  • Th Tababi: gold at Asian-Oceania Judo
  • Mary Kom: Gold at President Cup, Indonesia
  • Rio on contribution of Himalayan States
  • Stand off to Babysana's death
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #4: Gallery
  • CMHT cards to journalists : Gallery
  • Understanding land for peace
  • Politics & farmers waiting for a downpour
  • An Endless Summer :: Poem
  • Tobacco harm reduction - A realistic option
  • NDPP reacts to statement of NPF President
  • The fools think we can be fooled easily
  • Twinkle Twinkle Scientists Star
  • Rohan Philem Reception @Pune : Gallery
  • Keisham Geenita : tops AIEEA-PG-2019
  • Are we putting efforts on grassroot football
  • Condemns insensitive attitude of police
  • Skin problems that arise during monsoon
  • Countdown to Year 10 of Weekender
  • Light at the end of peace process
  • Of human rights and open world
  • General strike on Babysana : Gallery
  • Manipur State Drug Policy #1
  • Kindness - A Virtue
  • L Sarita nominated at AIBA commission
  • We don't lack talents :: Hidam Rajeev
  • Cry of a Dying River - 86 :: Poem
  • Courses on Information Technology
  • Three decisions vis-a-vis Babysana's death
  • Corporal punishment - violation of RTE
  • Trekking to Dzukou Valley #2: Gallery
  • Haj pilgrims send-off : Gallery
  • Is Lack of rain a problem for Paddy ..
  • Mission 'School Phagat Hanshi'
  • Labour Codes threaten Press Freedom
  • Program for IHGF Delhi Fair at Kakching
  • Heart Camp at Health Centre, MU
  • Questions on safety of school hostels
  • Babysana's case, safety of our children
  • Nupi Pali @ Kang festival: Gallery
  • Some Chase Goal, Some Hunt Goal
  • Himalayas: Where India Meets China..
  • Preventing TB is critical to #endAIDS
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Career option in Anthropology
  • Deafening silence of Govt
  • BJP's image in serious trouble
  • Gandhari (Dance Drama) : A synopsis
  • Social service @Ibudhou Thangjing: Gallery
  • Sanamahi Cheng Hongba #2: Gallery
  • Weaving at Nongpok Sanjenbam : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2019 #3: Gallery
  • Social service @ Moirang : Gallery
  • World Music Day @Yaiskul #3: Gallery
  • 3rd Singcha Wuyawon Festival 2019
  • seL tiHZakaNdta nuHZa_Iba :: Seireng
  • Cracks at Thong Nambonbi : Gallery
  • Yumnam Shamu : Natbhusan (Duhar)
  • The Great June Uprising #5: Gallery
  • Tolloi, Ukhrul :: 360 Panorama View
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2019 : Download