TODAY -

Contours of contempt of court: Law and practice in India

T. Bimolchand Singh *

 High Court building of Manipur at Chingmeirong, Imphal :: 16 September 2016
High Court building of Manipur at Chingmeirong, Imphal in September 2016 :: Pix - Sohajit Ng



"Silence is not an option when things are ill done" – Lord Denning

Introduction:

In common parlance, the phrase 'contempt of court' (contemptus curiae), or simply, 'contempt' is the act of being defiant or disrespectful towards the court of law and its officers. Lord Diplock in Attorney-General v. Times Newspapers Ltd [(1973) 3 W.L.R. 298; (1974) AC 273] defined it as "Contempt of Court is a generic term descriptive of conduct in relation to particular proceedings in a court of law which tends to undermine that system or inhibit citizens from availing themselves of it for the settlement of their disputes".

Civil and Criminal Contempt

Contempt may be civil contempt or criminal contempt. Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 defines "civil contempt" as "wilful disobedience to any judgment, decree, direction, order, writ or other process of a court or wilful breach of an undertaking given to a court".

Sec 2(c) of the said Act defines "criminal contempt" as "the publication (whether by words, spoken or written, or by signs, or by visible representations, or otherwise) of any matter or the doing of any other act whatsoever which-
(i) scandalises or tends to scandalise, or lowers or tends to lower the authority of, any court; or
(ii) prejudices, or interferes or tends to interfere with, the due course of any judicial proceeding; or
(iii) interferes or tends to interfere with, or obstructs or tends to obstruct, the administration of justice in any manner.

A contempt of Court may be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may to two thousand rupees, or with both (section 12 of the said Act). Section 14 prescribes the procedure where contempt is in the face of the Supreme Court or a High Court, section 15 the cognizance of criminal contempt in other cases and section 17 the procedure after cognizance.

Section 13(b) says that "the court may permit, in any proceeding for contempt of court, justification by truth as a valid defence if it is satisfied that it is in public interest and the request for invoking the said defence is bona fide.

No court shall initiate any proceedings of contempt, either on its own motion or otherwise, after the expiry of a period of one year from the date on which the contempt is alleged to have been committed (section 20).

Contempt proceeding can be initiated in the following ways viz.
(i) on its own by the Supreme Court or the High Court independently or on the presentation of an application to it by a private person,

(ii) on a motion by
(a) Attorney General or Solicitor General in relation to the Supreme Court
(b) Advocate General of the State in relation to the High Court
(c) Notified Law Officer in relation to the High Court of Delhi

(iii) on an application filed by a third person after getting the permission of Attorney General or Solicitor General in case of Supreme Court or Advocate General of the state(s) in case of High Courts or notified Law Officer in case of High Court of Delhi. In case of any contempt of a subordinate court, the High Court may take action on a reference made to it by the subordinate court or on motion made by the Advocate General.

Colonial hangover

In India, the law of contempt has colonial roots and sprouted during the British colonial era. When the East India Company came to India and started administration of justice, they introduced the English law of contempt of courts in the country. Being an imperialist, British had to supress any defiance of law by the 'natives' with iron hand. Thus, the Contempt of Courts Act, 1926 was enacted. It was amended in 1937.

Post-independence, India enacted the Contempt of Courts Act, 1952. The Sanyal Committee was constituted to look into the short comings of the 1952 Act. The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 was enacted by incorporating the recommendations of the committee. The Contempt of Courts (Amendment) Act, 2006 substituted new section for Section 13 of the 1971 Act.

Constitutional perspectives

Provisions relating to contempt are found in the following articles of the Constitution of India:
(i) Article 19(2) read with Article 19(1)(a) –Freedom of Speech with restrictions and contempt,
(ii) Article 129 – Supreme Court as court of record,
(iii) Article 215- High Court as court of record,
(iv) Article 227- Superintendence of High Courts and
(v) Articles of 142-Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court.

Criminal contempt: scandalising the court:

Of late, contempt cases centre around the issue of scandalising the courts or lowering the authority of court amounting to the offence of "criminal contempt" defined in section 2(c) (i) of Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The law of 'scandalising the court' originated from an undelivered judgment by Justice Wilmot in R. vs. Almon 1765 Wilmot 243 way back in 1765 CE.

It is intended as a wall of protection against the vicissitudes of judging. As eminent jurist Fali S. Nariman said, "Ours is a very litigious society and there are a number of odd citizens ("Nuts" they are sometimes called): persons who will make any type of allegation against anyone at the drop of a hat."

Lingering dialectic: Contempt vs. Freedom of Speech

"If the conduct of Presidents, Governors, Politicians and Chief Ministers – and a vast range of officials can be commented on, written about and criticised, there is no reason why the performance of Judges in their respective Courts cannot be..."(Fali S. Nariman) The law of contempt is an exception to the fundamental right of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1) (a) of the Constitution, the law must then be justified on the ground that it is a reasonable restriction under Article 19(2); otherwise it would be unconstitutional.

But to stifle criticism and stamp out dissent strikes the very root of the notion of democracy for the court to become intolerant of criticism or expressions of dissent would mark the beginning of the end of democracy. As Lord Atkin said in R. vs. Metropolitan Police Commissioner, 1968 (2) AER 319, "The path of criticism is a public way: the wrongheaded are permitted to err therein ......Justice is not a cloistered virtue: she must be allowed to suffer the scrutiny and respectful, even though outspoken, comments of ordinary men."

Unjust, unfair and ill temperate criticisms to undermine the authority of law, whether inside or outside the courts, bringing disrepute and disrespect to due administration of justice is not intended. Nobody has a right to denigrate others' right of person and reputation. Bona fide criticism of any system or institution including the judiciary cannot be objected to as healthy and constructive criticisms are tools to augment forensic tools for improving its function.

The Long Hand

Fair criticism of the conduct of a Judge, the institution of the judiciary and its functioning may not amount to contempt if it is made in good faith and in public interest. However, no contumacious behaviour of any person be allowed to tarnish, diminish or wipe out the confidence of the people in the courts of justice. The long hand of contempt of court is the weapon in the armoury of judicial repository which when needed can reach any neck howsoever high or far away it may be.

Free market of ideas vis-à-vis Contempt vis-à-vis Defamation

In P.N Duda vs. P. Shiv Shanker [1988 (3) SCC 167], the Hon'ble Supreme Court said, "...In the free market-place of ideas criticism about the judicial system or judges should be welcome so long as such criticism does not impair or hamper the administration of justice".

Further, in Re-Arundhati Roy [AIR 2002 SC 1375], the Apex Court said, "...Any expression of opinion would, therefore, be not immune from the liability for exceeding the limits, either under the law of defamation or contempt of Court or other constitutional limitations under Article 19(2). If a citizen, therefore, in the garb of exercising right of free expression under Article 19(1), tries to scandalise the court or undermines the dignity of the court, then the court would be entitled to exercise power under Article 129 or Article 215, as the case may be..."

Conclusion

The line between 'destructive attacks' and 'trenchant criticism' is always thin one. The nation wishes for an activist judiciary not judicial dictatorship loaded with judicial intolerance. However, no person can flout the mandate of law respecting the courts for establishment of rule of law under the cloak of freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution.

Freedom of speech and expression is not absolute, unlimited and unfettered at all times and in all circumstances: it is subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law. A fine balance between freedom of expression and fair and fearless justice is called for.

After all, as Krishna Iyer, J in Baradakanta Mishra vs. The Register of Orissa High Court & Anr., [1974 (1) SCC 374] said, "...Justice is not hubris; power is not petulance and prudence is not pusillanimity, especially when Judges are themselves prospectors and mercy is a mark of strength, not whimper of weakness..."


*(Views are personal ..... )


* T. Bimolchand Singh wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is a freelancer, and can be reached at bimol94mei(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was webcasted on August 18 2020.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • How Irawat became a Marxist revolutionary
  • COVID-19 Status 29 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • October Calendar for Year 2020 : Tools
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Licypriya urges everyone to plant a tree
  • A roadblock to NEP 2020: Rote learning
  • Second online Lok Adalat of Manipur held
  • What lesson has Covid-19 taught us ?
  • Being the junior partner in Govt
  • Attracting tourists: few pointers..
  • Manipur Art Fest 2019 #3 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 28 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Mushroom cultivation @Singjamei : Gallery
  • Ownership of mineral rights : A case study
  • My idea of justice
  • NPF Legislature meets with NEDA Convener
  • How to use glycerine on the face
  • Mantra of trace, test and treat
  • Criminalization of politics
  • Irrelevance of 66 MW Loktak Downstream HEP
  • Thangol adu maya thangu thouna hey lao-uba
  • Inauguration of Destination NE 2020 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 27 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Programme on Irabot's Death Anniversary
  • RIST Popular Talk -45 : Quantum chaos
  • Salad days :: Poem
  • NPP : Adopt the wait & watch strategy
  • Last Day : Sangai Festival 2019 #2: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 26 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Irabot, one & only leader of oppressed mass
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Mavopam, Daikho, Rangnamei: eMing
  • World Tourism Day 2020
  • Belated Happy Birthday
  • In Unison with Divinity :: Poem
  • COVID Care Centre @UNACCO #2: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Hijam Irawat : Irawat the Legend #3
  • We do not stop playing because we grow old
  • Naga Talent Scouting Contest
  • 'Nagaland financial published is deceptive'
  • Politics of drop and induct Ministers
  • Playing a risky game
  • Swearing in @ Rajbhavan [24 Sep] : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 24 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Licypriya - Parliament to pass Climate Law
  • Hijam Irawat : Irawat the Legend #2
  • Petition to PM by farmers of Ningombam
  • Low ease of doing business in Manipur
  • My idea of justice
  • Offensive against party hopping
  • Politics is more than a game of numbers
  • RK Bikramjit (Flutist & Composer) : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 23 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2020 #4: Gallery
  • Hijam Irawat : Irawat the Legend #1
  • Nurturing young minds amidst lockdown
  • Training on mushroom cultivation
  • A hot test in a Darjeeling lodge
  • Number games before reshuffle
  • Preserving biodiversity amidst uncertainty
  • Barak: Our economic & ecological security
  • COVID-19 Status 22 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Loan Distribution- Street Vendors : Gallery
  • Imposing fresh curbs, need of the hour
  • Youthful Years :: Poem
  • International Day of Peace 2020
  • 3rd Poshan Maah: Drive against malnutrition
  • New advisory for COVID-19 positive patients
  • Peace: an elusive concept
  • Foundation Day- Journalist Union #2 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 21 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Irabot Day & practice of volunteerism
  • Morung Dialogue: To Freedom: A Human Story
  • Mushroom Growth of Social media Influencer
  • Observance of Kuki Black Day Sahnit Ni 2020
  • Nagaland Lokayukta investigation into Dy CM
  • Spirit of Art 164-1 (A)
  • Significance of September 19
  • Nongin, the State bird of Manipur
  • COVID-19 Status 20 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Financial Assistance for Journalist Phase-1
  • National Education Policy - Review #5
  • Condemn Moreh Police on Child Rapist case
  • Music video chronicling true naga spirit
  • What is trademark ?
  • Below par recovery rate
  • World Bamboo Day 2020 : A Report
  • COVID-19 Status 19 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Pukning Pothasang #LetsTalkAboutDementia
  • 7th Khangminashi Lecture: Nanotechnology
  • Cancellation- Hyderabad Univ entrance exam
  • Condemnation on rape of 3-1/2 year girl
  • Calling social entrepreneurs from NE for UNDP
  • The Bright Lights :: Poem
  • Ensure health care service during COVID
  • Shirui Village, Shirui Hill, Ukhrul : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 18 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Life moves on
  • JRF (on Chakhao) @ICAR, NEH Meghalaya
  • Fruit face packs
  • BA/BSc Exam at Lilong Haoreibi College
  • Fingering of Ladakh
  • Shadow of Greater Lim or Nagalim
  • Calls for change in election campaign
  • Tongjei Maril 1942: Bridle Path to Motor Road
  • COVID-19 Status 17 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Khutheibam Abdur Rahman- Poet & Activist
  • Manipur StartUp Conclave 2020 : Gallery
  • Karmayogi Mission for reforms in civil services
  • Training on mushroom cultivation
  • Foundation Day- Journalist Union #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 16 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • The thirst for reopening schools
  • Vale of Tears: Untold stories of violence : Rvw
  • Career option in Ethical Hacking
  • Monkey justice
  • Tribal Ministry for seamless implementation
  • Disturbing daily spike & total figure
  • Rani Phi design on 'Doctor in 2020' :: Gallery
  • Aquapreneurship & present Fishery status
  • Discussion: Crime Against Women in Manipur
  • World Ozone Day 2020
  • National Education Policy - Review #4
  • Sole meaning of life is to serve humanity
  • Covid-19 accentuates the job crisis
  • BJP versus Cong versus NPP
  • Brahmacharimayum Roji: Actress #2 : eRang
  • COVID-19 Status 14 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Cultivating the common ground : FNR
  • Reimagining Immunity & Immune System
  • Happy Engineers' Day
  • My Teacher - I Salute Thee ! :: Poem
  • Today a reader, tomorrow a leader !
  • Discussion : Myanmar's 2020 Election
  • Daily spike of 90 thousand plus
  • Buning Meadow / Piulong Valley #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 13 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Discovery of a novel biopolymer
  • Mrs. Laldinpuii : Success Stories from NE
  • Remembering our heroic martyrs
  • Alternative to online teaching during COVID
  • Teenage skin care
  • Tree Planatation at Chandel
  • Final pact sans NSCN (IM)? Uneasy peace
  • The cry for Justice! Kuki Black Day
  • COVID-19 Status 12 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Flood-like situation @Thangmeiband :: Gallery
  • Khumang : e-Conference on 'Science & Tech'
  • National Education Policy - Review #3
  • Demand for a DNA Testing Machine Lab
  • Lilong Haoreibi College resumed functioning
  • A song of appreciation :: Poem
  • COVID-19 & after: Need for change in plans
  • On the Flag that was hoisted at Kangla
  • COVID-19 Status 11 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Ambulance to Chief Medical Officer : Gallery
  • Highway projects in Manipur & agriculture
  • Keeping an eye on 'Eye health'
  • Academic Year Online for Assam DB Univ
  • Need to go in for more after RAT
  • By-election; play a fair game
  • Ras Leela @JNMDA, Imphal :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 10 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Southeast Asia: Strategic for Competition
  • Memory of Pranab Babu
  • Gandhi, self-help, khadi & Atmanirbhar Bharat
  • The reality we live today :: Poem
  • NEET & JEE: Balance betn student & health
  • 21 years of reaching out to the readers
  • Non Positive
  • Agri Fair at CAU Iroisemba #3 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 09 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Suicide: Chasing death
  • Women rights-based access to contraceptives
  • Delimitation & limitation of valley minorities
  • Understanding CET
  • Himalaya Diwas at IBSD, Takyelpat
  • Noting post Covid complications
  • Rechecking hospital's modus operandi
  • Azad Hind: Its Forgotten Govt & the Army
  • COVID-19 Status 08 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • MPSC 2016: Social media mob injustice
  • Manipur women weave success in pandemic
  • FEGOCTA to resume academic activities
  • Live one day at a time :: Poem
  • Should animal be given same right as human
  • Countdown to by polls
  • Tungjoi Glory Day (Senapati) #3 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 07 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Skill Development Prog by CM: Gallery
  • National Education Policy - Review #2
  • Hope : The reason we keep living !
  • International Literacy Day 2020
  • Beauty benefits of rice water
  • Targeting young girls : Minds of retards
  • Should trading Frog amount to smuggling
  • Rendezvous with RK Bikramjit (Flutist)
  • COVID-19 Status 06 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Reminiscence of coming & journey : Book Rvw
  • And I sleep for the hunger of you : Poem
  • MPSC propose re-examination is not justified
  • Increasing local transmission
  • COVID Care Centre @UNACCO #1: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 05 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Naga story in Indigenous People movement #2
  • Revoke Agreement on 66 MW Loktak Project
  • My homage to Pranab Mukherjee
  • Eventide :: Poem
  • Protest against gangrape of a minor
  • Condemnation against the gang rape
  • Heat of the Internet
  • Sirarakhong Hathei Phanit #3 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 04 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Loans to vendors [Aug 25] : Gallery
  • Haipou Jadonang : A social reformer #3
  • National Education Policy - Review #1
  • Menstruation needs to be discussed openly
  • Serious internet jokes & reflections
  • Climbing number of cases, deaths
  • Akhunba Takhellei #2 : Film scene :: eRang
  • COVID-19 Status 03 Sept : Govt of Manipur
  • Naga story in Indigenous People movement #1
  • Tribal Resource Conservation Ethics
  • Vilification of MCSCCE selected candidates
  • Grand Chef Manipur at Luwangshangbam
  • Monument of friendship :: Poem
  • How will the Naga CSOs respond ?
  • Irritating season
  • Yaoshang Halankar #3 : Gallery
  • Tarpon: Annual offerings to dead by living
  • Legal awareness on 'Right to Food' at Lamlai
  • First E/online Lok Adalat held
  • Teacher for JEE Main & tutorials
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #2 : Gallery
  • Landscape to Dzukou Valley #5 : Gallery
  • Haipou Jadonang : A social reformer #1
  • Chaklam Khongchat Numit #1 : Gallery
  • Moirangthem Mani : Kalabhusan (Thang-Ta)
  • 13 August @BT Park #2 : Gallery
  • Patriots' Day @ Kangla #2 : Gallery
  • 16th Death anniv of Chittaranjan : Gallery
  • Manipur Independence Day [14 Aug]: Gallery
  • 'Zehara' - Manipuri Movie :: eRang Classic
  • Hentak :: An indigenous Manipuri food
  • HSE Toppers - Commerce stream : Gallery
  • HSE Toppers - Science stream : Gallery
  • HSE Toppers - Arts stream : Gallery
  • SPONSORED ADS