TODAY -

Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958 : A critique

N Brajakanta Singh *

 School children participating in rally against AFSPA in Naga Inhabited areas :: 11 August 2016
School children participating in rally against AFSPA in Naga Inhabited areas in August 2016 :: Pix - Tenno Pheiray



The recent developments in Manipur and Nagaland have once again brought into focus the continuous imposition of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958 (AFSPA) in the North-East.

This article examines whether the Indian Parliamentary legislation authorizes a defacto proclamation of Martial Law in these region empowering the armed forces of the Union to act independent of local civil authority and control. The article also examines the Supreme Court’s decision upholding the Constitutional validity of the AFSPA.

Is AFSPA a Martial Law ?

The Indian Parliament enacted the AFSPA on September 11, 1958 in order to curb the violence caused by Naga rebellion and restore normalcy in the region with the use of military forces by aiding the State administration. The whole of Manipur has been declared a ‘disturbed area’ under section 3 of the AFSPA since 1980, in the wake of rising insurgency activities by armed opposition forces.

Although the AFSPA was supposed to enforce only when the law and order situation becomes so deteriorated that the State police force is unable to contain it, but the law is operating even in normal times. The phrase ‘armed forces’ is defined in AFSPA to mean “the military forces and air forces operating as land forces, and includes other armed forces of the Union so operating.”

The law under section 4 enormously empowers the military officers to use deadly force on people who are violating the rule prohibiting assembly of five or more persons, or carrying weapons or things capable of being used as weapons. In the name of maintaining law and order, the armed forces of the Union were empowered to shoot any person on mere suspicion.

The recent botched ambush by the Army on December 4, 2021 during which 13 innocent civilians were killed in Oting, Nagaland is just a glaring example of how the armed forces of the Union abused the sweeping power of the license to kill even innocent civilians.

The Army was acting independent of civilian authority and control in a geographical area where defacto Martial Law is promulgated in disguise. When the military acting independent of the control of civilian authorities, there is Martial Law in operation and there is no need to have a formal promulgation of the same. The most important feature of Martial Law is the military acting independent of civilian authority and control.

When a geographical area is placed under Martial Law, the military commander is under no legal obligation to take orders from civilian authority of the area and he is allowed to take his own decisions. The functioning of civilian authorities and Courts does not mean that we are not in a state of Martial Law. Frederick Pollock in his article ‘What is Martial Law’ writes that the absence of visible disorder and continued sitting of Courts are not conclusive evidence of a state of peace.

The pertinent question is whether the military is under the control of the civilian authority or whether it is acting independent of the civilian authority. If the military is acting independent of the civilian authority and the Courts, such would be a state of de facto Martial Law whether or not it is so called.

Under the AFSPA, the military also have the power to arrest and search without warrant. There is also provision for handing over of arrested person under section 4(d) which provides that any person arrested and taken into custody under the AFSPA shall be made over to the officer in charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay, together with a report of the circumstances occasioning the arrest. It empowers the military to hold a prisoner until the order is restored and he can be safely turned over to the civil authorities for trial, another feature of Martial Law.

It is now clear that Martial Law prevents but it does not punish. However, the AFSPA under section 6 provides full legal immunity to any person who acts under its authority. The Union Ministry never grants prosecution sanction for trial of any erring military personal involved in human rights violations in Manipur. Further, the issuance of a ‘Disturbed Area Notification’ under the AFSPA is in fact defacto promulgation of Martial Law in the region.

Constitutionality of the AFSPA

The Constitutional validity of the AFSPA was questioned in the case of Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights vs Union of India, AIR 1998 SC 431, before the Apex Court of India. Since the case involved a substantial question of interpretation of the Constitution of India and, as mandated under Article 143, the case was referred to a Constitutional Bench of five Judges of the Supreme Court.

It was argued, on behalf of the petitioners, that the use of the Armed forces in aid of civil power contemplates the use of Armed Forces under the control, continuous supervision and direction of the executive power of the State and that Parliament can only provide that whenever the executive authorities of a State desire, the use of Armed Forces in aid of the civil power would be permissible but the supervision and control over the use of the Armed Forces has to be with the civil authorities.

It was also argued that the military cannot act independent of the control and supervision of the civilian authority. It was also argued that the State in whose aid the Armed Forces are so deployed shall have the exclusive power to determine that purpose, the time period and the areas in which the Armed Forces should be requested to act in aid of civil power and that the State remains a final directional control to ensure that the Armed Forces act in aid of civil power and do not supplant or act in substitution of the civil power.

The Supreme Court of India rejected the arguments of the petitioners by observing that the hon’ble Judges were, however, unable to agree with the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners.

The Apex Court, in another paragraph, also observed that the expression ‘in aid to civil power’ in Entry 1 of the State List and in Entry 2A of the Union List implies that deployment of the Armed Forces of the Union shall be for the purpose of enabling the civil power in the State to deal with the situation affecting maintenance of public order which necessitated the deployment of the Armed Forces in the State.

The hon’ble Court unanimously upheld the Constitutional validity of the law on the ground of Parliament’s power to enact such legislation. The Court noted that the AFSPA concerned ‘the use of Armed Forces in aid of the civil power,’ which was within the domain of Parliament and not ‘public order’, which was within the authority of the State legislatures.

The Court also relied on Article 355 of the Constitution, which imposes a duty on the Union of India to protect every State from internal disturbance. A learned author observed that the Court should have examined the law on the touchstone of right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

Conclusion

It may be concluded that view of the Supreme Court is that the military is not subject to the control and direction of the civil authorities in a State where defacto Martial Law is promulgated. Any concerned citizen would agree that military can be used in internal disturbances as well as in containing armed opposition forces.

When the military is deployed in an area under the AFSPA, it is anticipated that they should cooperate with the civilian authorities. They should not act unbridle, but police representatives must be associated with every operation conducted by Armed Forces of the Union. They must not carry out blind operations against innocent civilians in locating militants without specific intelligence report.

They must avoid indiscriminate arrests and harassment of people out of frustration for not being able to detect and locate the real assailants. Any personnel involved in violation of law should not be protected. A democratic country is governed by Rule of Law not by rulers.


* N Brajakanta Singh wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer is a Guest Faculty, Department of Law, MU.
This article was webcasted on December 30 2021.



* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Phuba Thapham, Senapati #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 25 May : Govt of Manipur
  • War on Drugs and Alcohol (Ju)
  • CubeTen: Awarded at British Parliament
  • Advancements in TB science in spotlight
  • Why should people join politics ?
  • COVID-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • Fisheries development in NE Region #2
  • Poor roadways denting prospect of tourism
  • From district level to State level
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Lam Thokpa #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 24 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Shirui Lily Festival 2022: Program Detail
  • The fruition of mass communication
  • Grow drumstick for good health
  • Political Stand of Naga People's Front
  • Medicinal Plants for Rural Livelihood in NE
  • Thangjing pact: Test ahead for signatories
  • From 2013 to charge hearing in 2022
  • Kwatha (Indo-Myanmar border) #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 23 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • NDPP's biggest challenge & opportunity
  • Languages soul of India & Hindi up to Ten
  • How Market Innovations made America great
  • Kahulong Primary School renovated
  • Conservation of wildlife need of the hour
  • Disturbing street brawl: Reflecting society
  • Licypriya speech at East Timor :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 22 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Licypriya delivers Speech at East Timor
  • Tobacco epidemic continues...
  • Dry Manipur still Wet and 'High'
  • Insects as feed for aquaculture
  • Inflation worries real but a passing phase
  • Dealing with suspected forest encroachers
  • Morphine to heroin to WY
  • English phonetic sounds :: Book download
  • COVID-19 Status 21 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Rs 2,80,000 assistance to 6 Journalists
  • Manipur Roads: A rainy season Nightmare
  • Workshop on "Research Ethics" at MU
  • Tacitly tacit
  • Gleanings from Buddhism
  • Thaopai Shithaine @ Phuba #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 20 May : Govt of Manipur
  • North-East Research (NER) Conclave
  • Fisheries development in NE Region #1
  • North East LSN Partners Meet 2022
  • Cold facial during Summer
  • Check gate closure: Boon or bane for driver
  • Covid free after 26 months: A brief look back
  • Wakhom Leikai Lairembi Haraoba #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 19 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Shija celebrates 26 years of surgery
  • International Webinar: Computing Trend in AI
  • New MAHUD for a new Imphal City
  • R&D initiatives of Ministry of Info Tech
  • PMFBY - Every cloud has a silver lining
  • Banking on Modi to eradicate plastic malaise
  • One step down from Greater Lim ?
  • Flood Watch: Nambul Turel [18 May] :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 18 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Ambassadors for Christ
  • "... where women are not respected"
  • Nursing as a career choice
  • Conquest of the last frontier
  • Dry Manipur among top 5 liquor states!
  • Scoring high on liquor consumption
  • Flood Watch: Imphal Turel [17 May] :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 17 May : Govt of Manipur
  • World hypertension day : 17th May 2022
  • Taking advantage of dying sedition law
  • Market innovations & vertical integration
  • Soram Oscar: Mr India Intl Tourism 2022
  • Cyber Security Lecture at Tamenglong
  • Involve village chief in Save Singda Movement
  • Reaching out to SC Jamir
  • Jalakeli Offering @ Govindajiu :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 16 May : Govt of Manipur
  • On 200th Anniversary of MK Binodini Devi
  • East Timor : Licypriya Kangujam invited
  • Carbon Sequestration in Dailong Site #2
  • Semiotic interpretations of traffic policing
  • Citrus Marcoptera: Rare Citrus species in NE
  • Same old healthcare issues for new minister
  • Rain : Bringing out the dirt of Imphalites
  • Art Exhibition @Imphal Art #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 15 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2022 #2: Gallery
  • Soil rejuvenation through plants
  • Harrowing memories of a blast victim
  • Pristine Death :: Poem
  • Odisha File
  • Anti-poppy vows: Govt shouldnt be taken...
  • After more than 2 decades of talks
  • River & River Based Communities
  • COVID-19 Status 14 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Second National Lok Adalat
  • Manipur Cabinet: Blurry representation
  • Tips for summer party make up
  • Harvesting Fest of Tarao #4 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 13 May : Govt of Manipur
  • The USP of Churachandpur
  • Pranks unloaded: From fiction to mundanity
  • Radio comes to our rescue in pandemic
  • 3rd North-East Foodtech begins
  • Irreparable damage done to environment
  • Promotion of nurseries for plantation crop #2
  • Issues staring at the face of Manipur
  • Yaoshang Thabal Competition #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 12 May : Govt of Manipur
  • International Nurses Day 2022
  • Carbon Sequestration in Dailong Site #1
  • Various voices on reduced areas of AFSPA
  • IBSD, Imphal signed MoU with CSIR
  • Stay on sedition case smack on political elite
  • Identifying a district with one group ?
  • Kakwa Lairembi Haraoba #1 :: Gallery
  • Understanding Environmental Problem
  • Pre Recruitment Training at Keithelmanbi
  • Three rain catchers feted
  • How India is empowering women...
  • War-era bridges amid development rhetoric
  • Aerial route over heart of Imphal ?
  • SN Chand: The father of Manipuri cinema #1
  • COVID-19 Status 10 May : Govt of Manipur
  • NPF Kohima consultative meeting
  • Market creating innovation & business model
  • The element of surprise
  • 3rd North-East Foodtech at Guwahati
  • Growing support to 'war on drugs' mission
  • Backing the War on Drugs call
  • Mao-Imphal Market @ Kabo Leikai :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 09 May : Govt of Manipur
  • We live in the best of times to preach
  • Mixed Marriages & our Heritage !
  • Review Meeting on National Lok Adalat
  • Road blocking for everything
  • Promotion of nurseries for fruits & crop
  • Cong vigil essential to expose Govt
  • Thangjing Hill : Mischievous restrictions
  • Student appearing HSLC Exam #3 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 08 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Workshop with Vice-Chancellors of NE
  • BJP's major challenge in Nagaland - Church
  • Motherhood : A symbol of Love
  • Song of spring :: Poem
  • Mother's Day at Tamenglong
  • Stringent only means to deter poppy grower
  • Congress : Uncharacteristically quiet
  • 4th Documentor Imphal [7 May] :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 07 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Being a scapegoat for ages in this disaster
  • Entrepreneurs invest 8 lakhs to documentary
  • 12th Mahousa Ima Ningsing Tha
  • Float Festival of Tamil Nadu Temples
  • Yaoshang Thabal Competition #1 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 06 May : Govt of Manipur
  • On custodial death of Arambam Nanao
  • Placating Sharmila : The Iron Lady
  • Service Engineer @Info Trade, Imphal
  • Integrated farming- 2x farmers' income #3
  • Tree Plantation Programme at Kangla
  • Greed blinding rogue police elements
  • War on Drugs : Give it more teeth
  • Artisan Lourembam Bino Devi :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 05 May : Govt of Manipur
  • The Truth Alone Must Triumph
  • ICU bed facility launched in Tamenglong
  • World Hand Hygiene Day 2022
  • Workshop on Climate Change at Lilong
  • Water education for food security
  • Torpid tourism sector
  • Separate flag & constitution
  • Id-ul-Fitr @Hatta Golapati :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 04 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Lavish event management gone wrong
  • World Veterinary Day 2022
  • Condemnation on the killing of Nanao
  • Summer skin care tips for a natural glow
  • Centre's push for NSU commendable
  • Powerless power
  • Ole Wangkheimayum : Making a difference
  • COVID-19 Status 03 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Last surviving Naga regionalist- Shurhozelie
  • DoNER Minister visited NSU, Khuman Lampak
  • Market creating innovations & economic
  • Kuzholuzo takes charges as NPF Leader
  • Swachhata Pakhwada at IBSD Imphal
  • Jiribam Keithel #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 02 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Cheilaoba : A short story
  • A tribute to Asok Potsangbam
  • Id-ul-fitr :: From a book
  • Building India to be the world's master
  • Rapists don't deserve mercy
  • Taking the case to a higher Court
  • Cheirao-chingkaba #2 :: Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 01 May : Govt of Manipur
  • May Calendar for Year 2022 : Tools
  • Nirupa Sanjenbam, Woman Achiever NE Fest
  • Student Centre for Excellence at Bishnupur
  • MPSC : Re-recruitment of MCS/MPS officers
  • Integrated farming- 2x farmers' income #2
  • Alangtakhou waterfall @Tml #1 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 30 Apr : Govt of Manipur
  • Blood Donation camp @Keisampat : Gallery
  • Appeal in High Court against Zou acquittal
  • Jubilee Celebration of Manipuri Cinema
  • Labour Day (May Day) -Chennai Connection
  • 24th - 30th April is World Immunization Week
  • Yaoshang Thabal @Mongshangei #4 : Gallery
  • COVID-19 Status 29 Apr : Govt of Manipur
  • Foundation Day celebrated at IBSD Imphal
  • Alone but not lonely :: Poem
  • Gender balanced workforce
  • Govt North East plan: Repealing AFSPA
  • AFSPA repeal vow galore as NE enjoys peace
  • Promise of AFSPA free NE
  • The hike to the summit of Koubru
  • Lunghar in Ukhrul district #2 :: Gallery
  • Student appearing HSLC Exam #2 :: Gallery
  • Sajibu Cheiraoba Chak Katpa #3 :: Gallery
  • Tributes on Khongjom Day :: Gallery
  • Tongjei Maril (Old Cachar Road) :: Gallery
  • Painting Competition on 'Tribal' #2 :: Gallery
  • Floral tributes @ Cheiraoching #2 :: Gallery
  • Yaoshang Sports @Bamon Leikai :: Gallery
  • Rules of English Pronunciation : Download
  • Cheiraoba Chak Katpa [Apr 14] :: Gallery
  • Shajibu Cheiraoba @Pune :: Gallery
  • Yaoshang @Bengaluru #2 :: Gallery
  • Sajibu Cheiraoba Shopping :: Gallery
  • Sub-Syllables in English : Book Download
  • Learn English pronunciation: Book Download
  • Learning calculating skills : Download Book