Tobacco industry interests are in conflict with public health

Shobha Shukla *

Hazardous tobacco products
Hazardous tobacco products :: Pix - TSE

The WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) is the world's first global public health and corporate accountability treaty and to date 177 countries are Parties to it. By signing and ratifying this treaty, these countries are committed to adopt a range of measures to reduce tobacco use, including increasing taxes on tobacco products, banning tobacco advertising, creating smokefree public and work places, implementing health warnings, combating illicit trade and, above all, preventing industry interference in influencing health policies.

Article 5.3 of the FCTC requires countries that are Parties to the Convention to safeguard their health policies against tobacco industry interference. It says: 'In setting and implementing their public health policies with respect to tobacco control, Parties shall act to protect these policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law.'

Guidelines for implementation of Article 5.3 were subsequently developed and adopted in 2008 at the Conference of Parties to the FCTC to assist them to meet their legal obligations under Article 5.3. The purpose of the Guidelines is to ensure that efforts to protect tobacco control from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry are comprehensive and effective. These Guidelines acknowledge that 'There is a fundamental and irreconcilable conflict between the tobacco industry's interests and public health policy interests.'

The global tobacco industry is aggressively opposing and attacking health policies in every region of the world and sabotaging the fundamental right of governments to implement life-saving tobacco control policies. The tobacco industry's multiple and devious tactics include legal and economic threats, funding front groups to oppose health policies, making political donations and funding mass media campaigns to discredit health policy.

The FCTC requires Parties to the Convention to limit interactions with tobacco companies to a minimum and treat the tobacco industry differently from other industries because—(i) tobacco is the only legally available consumer product that kills people when used as intended. Tobacco is addictive and deadly and, unlike any other consumer product, it cannot be used without risk; and (ii) tobacco industry's behaviour has all along been dubious.

The United States litigation in 1998 forced tobacco corporations to turn over millions of previously secret internal documents, reviews of which have showed that although tobacco companies knew their products were addictive, harmful and killed their consumers, they deliberately hid this knowledge while publicly denying the addictiveness of tobacco and the dangers of tobacco use and exposure to second-hand smoke and targeted young people with advertising and promotions to perpetuate the use of their products. They still continue doing this, along with delaying, diluting and defeating global efforts to discourage tobacco use and protect people from second-hand smoke.

Some examples of tobacco industry interference in India

In India, the manufacturing of tobacco and tobacco substitutes are under the list of prohibited items for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). The Law Ministry has said it favours the Commerce Ministry's move to ban foreign direct investment (FDI) in wholesale trading in tobacco as well. Under the guidelines, foreign tobacco companies bringing in money for branding and advertising, while selling to retailers directly, can do so only by their Indian joint venture partner.

Yet, as elsewhere, the tobacco industry has gone all out to undermine public health in India. Its efforts include (i)avoiding marketing restrictions under the garb of 'corporate social responsibility (CSR)' activities; (ii)donating/investing money in parties and governments institutions; (iii) resorting to surrogate advertising and point of sale ads; (iv) making continuous efforts to delay, dilute and water down pictorial warnings over the years; spot advertising and brand placement in films;. There are numerous examples to substantiate that Big Tobacco is like a devastating typhoon which is out to devastate human lives in India.

As part of its CSR activities India's 2nd largest tobacco company, Godfrey Philips, presents Godfrey Phillips Bravery National Awards every year—an event which is generally graced (?) by political bigwigs and film stars, amongst others. This year the awards were presented by Mr Kapil Sibal, Minister for Communications and Information Technology in Delhi. Last year Mr Salman Khurshid, the then Union Law Minister was the chief guest at the programme held in Chandigarh.

India's largest tobacco company, ITC, was presented the 2012 World Business and Development Award for its rural initiatives in social and farm forestry programmes in India around the Rio+20 United Nations Summit at Rio de Janeiro. But later UNDP head said to CNS member in a written communication that it was an 'oversight' and measures will be taken to never engage with tobacco industry in future.

There have also been instances of investments by Public Financial Institutions in tobacco companies. According to media reports, the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) and the United Trust of India (UTI) have invested in ITC Limited-- LIC (93,52,41,572 shares), UTI (89,68,68,810 shares). Then again under a right to information (RTI) disclosure, the Union government was forced to reveal that in 2009-10 ITC has made donations to several political parties, including the Congress, the BJP, Samajwadi Party, Rashtriya Janata Dal, DMK, Shiv Sena and the Nationalist Congress Party (Sources: Economic Times and invest ).

The tobacco industry has time and again been instrumental in diluting/delaying pictorial health warnings. Due to tobacco industry pressure over the Indian government, implementation of pictorial warnings got delayed for two years, during which time the government replaced stronger warnings with milder ones, reduced size of the warnings from 50% of the principal display area to 40%. Finally pack warnings came into effect on 31 May 2009.

According to news published in The Economic Times the failure of the government lawyer to turn up on the dates appointed for hearing over the point of sale of tobacco advertisement case was quite intriguing and an indication of intense tobacco industry pressure on the government. The tobacco industry again protested against the replacement of the then existing pictorial warnings with newer and effective field tested ones, due to which the implementation of new field tested warnings got delayed for one and a half years. Despite evidences which suggest that smoking scenes in films are the biggest cause of early initiation of tobacco use by the youth, Indian films continue to depict smoking scenes albeit accompanied by a statutory warning that smoking is injurious to health.

Miffed at the government's stand on several such blatant interferences by the tobacco industry, the Supreme Court in one of its recent orders blamed the government for 'conniving' with tobacco companies. Citing the health hazards of tobacco, the Apex Court said: "Of course, you [Central government] are not bothered. You are more bothered about money."

"Any such act that gives legitimacy to tobacco firms is against the spirit of the law enacted against tobacco in 2003, which was done in line with the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control [FCTC]," says renowned Indian lawyer and activist Mr Prashant Bhushan.

India currently boasts of around 275 million tobacco users and over 1 million tobacco related deaths every year. According to Global Adult Tobacco Survey 2010, an estimated 34.6% of adults use some form of tobacco--25.9% are smokeless tobacco users, while 5.7% smoke cigarettes and 9.2% smoke beedis. One variant of chewing tobacco called gutka (which is a mixture of tobacco, areca nut, catechu, paraffin, slaked lime and sweet flavourings) is widely popular in the masses.

It is known to be highly addictive and causative of oral cancer and periodontal and other diseases. The Supreme Court has banned the sale and manufacture of gutka and paan masala under the regulation 2.3.4 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2011 clarifying that, "Since pan masala, gutka or supari are eaten for taste and nourishment, they are all food within the meaning of Section 2(v) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act."

Regulation 2.4.3 of The Food Safety and Standards ACT (FSSA) 2006, notified for implementation from by the Government of India said: "Tobacco and nicotine shall not be used as ingredients in any food products."

Still the ban has yet to be imposed all over the country with some states still defaulting on it. The government of Uttar Pradesh, a state with very high rates of oral cancer attributed to gutka chewing enforced the ban only from April 2013 after several delays, perhaps due to intense lobbying from the tobacco industry. Also even in states where gutka is banned, the gutka industry has not lost its business and has come up with alternative ways to safeguard its profits. With no ban imposed on chewing tobacco, the industry continues to reap a rich harvest by legally selling tobacco and mouth fresheners together but in different pouches. Gutka also continues to be sold illegally at increased prices in the absence of proper implementation of the ban.

Dr Ehsaan Latif, Director Tobacco Control at the International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (The Union) spoke with Citizen News Service – CNS and explained the situation in a nutshell: "In countries where poverty is still a challenge, any donation by the tobacco industry is seen by the policy makers as a generous gift. These policy makers need to realize how the industry manipulates the system to interfere with public health policy and these 'charitable donations' only serve to open doors for the industry to expand their businesses, provide legitimacy to their actions and to block effective tobacco control policies.

In the guise of helping a few people, they seek to impress the policy makers. Yet they do not take responsibility of the millions who have died pre-maturely from the use of their products. It is high time that governments in South East Asia adopt policies consistent with Article 5.3 of The FCTC and look at taxation of tobacco products as a sustainable source for tobacco control not these insignificant donations to subvert tobacco control."

So, it is imperative for governments to make their domestic tobacco control laws in line with WHO FCTC Article 5.3 and implement them strictly to protect tobacco control movements and public health measures from tobacco industry interference.

* Shobha Shukla , Citizen News Service – CNS wrote this article for
The author is the Managing Editor of Citizen News Service - CNS. She is a J2J Fellow of National Press Foundation (NPF) USA and received her editing training in Singapore. She has earlier worked with State Planning Institute, UP and taught physics at India's prestigious Loreto Convent. She also co-authored and edited publications on childhood TB, childhood pneumonia, Hepatitis C Virus and HIV, violence against women and girls, and MDR-TB. Email:, website:
This article was posted on September 20, 2013.

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.

  • Relief Services in 5 dists #1 : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 31 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Lockdown Relief Services in 5 districts
  • Covid-19 : Impact in Manipur :: News Timeline
  • COVID Saab & Brain Gain
  • Tech Determinism: Privacy vs Surveillance
  • Covid-19 Curfew Violators - 31 May
  • Gulmohar :: Poem
  • 'COVID-19- broken governance in Nagaland'
  • COVID-19 : Trace, Test and Treat
  • Thang Ta at Sangai Fest #3 : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 30 May : Govt of Manipur
  • June Calendar for Year 2020 : Tools
  • Consent in Medical Practice
  • India-Taiwan/ Global Bamboo-Tech Forum
  • Rise in gender-based violence during COVID
  • Covid-19 : Govt Order - 30 May
  • Another blessing in disguise
  • Rajkumari Muktasana - Artiste : Gallery
  • A novitiating criminal lawyer's reflections
  • Childline Thoubal, frontlines during lockdown
  • Webinar on 'Dynamics of Online Education'
  • Share market as career options
  • The Beauty of It :: Poem
  • Countdown to May 31
  • Contemplating on the impending changes
  • Train @Jiri [May 28] #1 : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 28 May : Govt of Manipur
  • 'Fisabishiing Thabak Suhanbiyu'
  • Thoughts random: In times of coronavirus - V
  • Appeal to CM from Students in Delhi
  • Deadly Darkness :: Poem
  • 'Avoid stigmatization against Returnees'
  • Martin Ennals Award 2021 : Nominations
  • Make information come more freely
  • Need for greater aggression & sterner actions
  • Stuctures @ Willong Khullen, Maram : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 27 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Discussion with tribal leader- 27 May : Gallery
  • A walk to remember :: Poem
  • School at Senapati as quarantine center
  • Delhi Declaration- environmental conservation
  • Letter to Governor on Lhukhosei Zou's case
  • Increase of COVID-19 +ve cases in Nagaland
  • Dialogue: Inequality-Bridging the Divide
  • Learning to live with COVID-19
  • I Rise :: Film Synopsis & Biography
  • Covid-19 Status 26 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Legal framework behind Lockdown, Curfew
  • Furnishing of Fees Info from Private School
  • Curfew Violators - 26 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Continuing woes of people in Manipur
  • Increasing positive cases of COVID-19
  • Measures @ Imphal Airport - 25 May : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 25 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Modified SOP for Air Traveller- 25 May : GOM
  • Haoginlun, Chingdakoiba: eMing
  • Drug Rehabilitation Centre in Manipur
  • COVID-19 & ecology, environment in Manipur
  • Vegetable flood at Wabagai during lock down
  • Technology to the rescue
  • M.K Binodini Devi's Sense of Beauty
  • Covid-19 Status 24 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Monkeys seen on the streets of Imphal
  • Id-Ul-Fitr :: Book
  • Make in Manipur, try Yu
  • SOP for Air Traveller- 24 May : Manipur Govt
  • Economic Relief package for small business
  • Manipur Muslims stranded in Gujarat
  • Bracing up for arrival by air
  • Motsillaba Mingsel : Film Synopsis
  • Covid-19 Status 23 May : Govt of Manipur
  • COVID-19 emergency response- observation
  • Ugly side of lockdown during COVID-19
  • International Day of Biodiversity 2020
  • Requests for Orders on 7th UGC Pay
  • Mother - A Deity :: Poem
  • Preparing for the inevitable change
  • Phisakol #3 :: eRang
  • Covid-19 Status 22 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Two students at 'Model Conference of Parties'
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • It's a cup of my Tea - International Tea Day
  • Govts' accountability in response to COVID-19
  • Online Faculty Development Program at RGU
  • Verse for Schoolchildren :: Poem
  • Growing number of positive cases
  • Tending to the trivialities in time
  • International Day for Biological Diversity
  • Covid-19 Status 21 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Issues of Manipuri nurses in Kolkata
  • Item Distribution to Quarantine centres
  • Orders/Memo - 21 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Workshop On Writing Research Paper
  • Appeal to all the Stranded Denizens
  • 'Reverify the lists of evacuees'
  • Helpline for Women Entrepreneurs of NE
  • Focus on quarantine centres
  • Counting on our collective responsibilities
  • Art has no gender & neither do Artists
  • Covid-19 Status 20 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Medical assistance to journalist awarded
  • 13th Manipur State Film Awards, 2020
  • Power loom weave intricately designed cloth
  • Dilemma after High School
  • Quarantine Centre- Negligence at Saitu, Kpi
  • 'This is no time to politicize the pandemic'
  • Highest spike on single day with 16
  • Foresight & vision - need of the hour
  • Distribution for Manipuri @ Blore: Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 19 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Hand sanitizer to Journalists : Gallery
  • Manipur Migrants in Bengaluru's Safety Net
  • Orders/Memo [19 May] : Govt of Manipur
  • A Forbidden Love : Poem
  • Social advocacy as career choice
  • Total curfew : Confusing the people
  • Preparing for the long haul
  • Tungjoi Glory Day #2 : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 18 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Gandhi's talisman.. to reform public health
  • A view of the Thames
  • COVID-19 knocks our education system
  • Clarification from Mumbai Returnee [May 18]
  • Nagaland : Demand for Special Trains
  • Beating China on the tally
  • Turning threat into opportunity
  • How Lockdown impact Textile Industry
  • Covid-19 Status 17 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Fight COVID-19 !! :: Poem
  • Thoughts random: In times of coronavirus- IV
  • Webinar series with a focus on COVID-19
  • COVID-19 gi matangda suggestion khara
  • Urges to impose curfew on Eid-ul-Fitr
  • Hundreds and hundreds returning
  • Emotional reverberations during COVID-19
  • Covid-19 Status 16 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Ningombam Sunibala : NE Success Stories
  • Home Sweet Home vis-a-vis Lockdown Exodus
  • Issue of Curfew Pass [May 16]
  • e-Videos Learning should be made in English
  • The Old Man in the Evening :: Poem
  • The silver lining
  • Kabui Lai of Kakching
  • Covid-19 Status 15 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Have you ever sanitize your mind ?
  • Challenges in the new normal
  • We Real Brave :: Poem
  • Know our health care system
  • How about the 14 days quarantine ?
  • Psychological side of COVID-19 epidemic
  • Associates & Junior Associates at MaolKeki
  • Know our health care system & shortcomings
  • Quarantine Centre @Thangmeiband: Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 14 May : Govt of Manipur
  • The Princess & The Political Agent : Preview
  • Self-Sufficiency: A Shibboleth ?
  • Running business not just to survive lockdown
  • A Symphony on Spring :: Poem
  • 'No concrete roadmap by Nagaland govt'
  • Coronavirus, lockdown, stranded people
  • Unattended struggle of Phige Weavers
  • Covid-19 Status 13 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2020 #2: Gallery
  • Relief exchange- Moidangpok & Keikao, Tml
  • Unheeded Balance :: Poem
  • Arsenal's new home
  • Getting ready for lockdown 4.0
  • Preparing for the shifting battle line
  • Barak River, Tamenglong #1 :: Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 12 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Bishnupur Dist. Orders / Memo [May 12]
  • Vaccination of cattle at Khumbong
  • Bus for Stranded Manipuris in Guwahati
  • Startups in the time of corona crisis
  • Naming children after pandemic
  • Growing number of infected
  • Adversity to opportunity
  • The Princess & the Political Agent : eBook
  • Covid-19 Status 11 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Huishu village, Chingai, Ukhrul Dist. : Gallery
  • Nurse unite to demand universal public health
  • Transport of stranded students from Shillong
  • Of kombirei and daffodil
  • Impact of lockdown on economy of Manipur
  • Opening the doors amid the lockdown
  • Preparing for the inevitable future
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Quarantine Centre @Kwakeithel : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 10 May : Govt of Manipur
  • SOP : Returning by Train to Manipur
  • Foreign Nationals stranded in Northeast
  • The International Mother's Day 2020
  • Lonely Days at Home :: Poem
  • Keep helping the poor amid COVID-19
  • From chinky to coronavirus
  • Rajkumari Muktasana : Dance Artiste
  • Covid-19 Status 09 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Impact on children during lockdown
  • Movement Pass Register - Resident Govt
  • Mother, The Giver ! :: Poem
  • Improving English during lockdown
  • Nagaland Govt to bring back stranded citizen
  • Road to unity
  • Paoki Fest @ Purul, Senapati: Gallery
  • Taja mgidi ya_Aodbr :: Seireng
  • A view on soccer training
  • Covid-19 Status 08 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Wetlands of Manipur : Documentary Film
  • Contribution of AR in Empowerment of women
  • Understanding stranded persons
  • nuHsi K_waHceY :: Seireng
  • Covid-19 Status 07 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Vagabond :: Poem
  • Best materials for homemade mask
  • E-Learning during COVID-19 Lockdown
  • Our careers and COVID-19
  • Need to expand commercial centres
  • Normalizing the act of humanism
  • Landscape to Dzukou Valley #4 : Gallery
  • Covid-19 Status 06 May : Govt of Manipur
  • Our part in the coronavirus lockdown
  • Quick nutrition garden during COVID-19
  • Lockdown Order from 6 May: Manipur Govt
  • Relief material to families at Keibul Lamjao
  • What to foresee from a Free Haircut ?
  • May 6, 2020 : Yet another day of drama
  • For Manipur, it is not COVID-19 alone
  • Luira Phanit @Kamjong #2 : Gallery
  • Distribution @Benguluru -2 May : Gallery
  • Manipur Looks Flat - Hingminnasi Eikhoi
  • MK Binodini Book Reading : Gallery
  • Europe zooms MK Binodini Devi's Literature
  • Why not carve out a future in Chakhao #2
  • Bangladeshki Sana Tampha #2 :: eRang
  • Thang Ta - Sangai Fest 2018 #2 : Gallery
  • Pallel & Kakching Keithel : Gallery
  • Tangkhul Forum vegetable for valley: Gallery
  • Items distributed to Tarao -Apr 23 #2: Gallery
  • Covid-19: Impact in Manipur :: Photos/News..
  • Language affinity betn Meiteis & Tangkhuls
  • Helpline Number for Students/ people from NE