TODAY -

School voucher for economically disadvantaged children : A policy alternative in Manipur

Yasin Khan *

 Primary School Children receiving Mid day meal at Praja High School, Lamshang :: 12th September 2013
Primary School Children receiving Mid day meal at Praja High School, Lamshang in Sep 2013 :: Pix - Deepak Oinam



One of my Professors, in Azim Premji University, was narrating about improving the livelihood of a poorest of the poor village in India through the microfinance services during his engagement with Basix. They were all deadlock what to do for the village, finally they realized to just give them money and let them decide what they want. That solved the problem without much effort from Basix. The programme which is now conventionally called as direct (conditional) cash transfer, which became popular model in the world of poverty elimination after Brazil's Conditional Cash Transfer named as Bolsa Familia. The whole argument here I want to draw your attention is the significance of freedom of choice to target beneficiary rather than forcing to choose what the state offers from the limited option, thereby allowing the market forces to alleviate the inefficiency in school education, and its impact on children's learning outcome. The argument concludes with my verdict of the debate and how can it be an alternative policy for quality education in Manipur.

The debate on voucher for school education goes back to 1955, the year of publication of Milton Friedman's critique of public education which suggested that vouchers would promote competition in the education market and greater efficiency in primary and secondary schools (Friedman 1955). The basic feature of voucher models involved government education funding on a per student basis to the school of the choice of the parent, which is almost similar to higher education scholarships.

So, argument starts with the deprivation of choice by state. I asked many people for couple of years to all age groups (undocumented) that why they don't choose government school. Recently I asked the same question to a boy in a remote village of Rajasthan, softly he answered "Sarkari school mei padai kaha hoti hei" (where does learning happen in Government school).

A street vendor woman who sell vegetable at Kurji Mor, Patna was narrating me that she enrolled her child to government school just to pass on the grades and in addition private tuition is must as government school does not make the future of children at all, she said. These are just few testimonials witnessed by myself rather than citing a bunch of publications. Moreover, we many times question why children of the teachers of government rural primary school hardly send their children to government school? The answer is almost same as given above by the boy.

It's already established that Low Fee Private (LFP) schools are proliferated even at the remote villages, yet children in government schools are dominated from economically backward or underprivileged families. Family income or wealth of the family is of one the strongest determining factor in parental school choice, meaning that those who are not accessing LFP schools are not doing so because they cannot afford it, as reported by parents (Harma, 2010). Caste and religion are also negatively significant determining factor that to be Muslim or Christian and to be Schedule Caste reduces the chance of accessing to LFP schools (Harma, 2010). Caste or religion per se does not determine wholly that children of these caste or religion goes to government school, rather family of these caste or religion mostly falls under economically underprivileged category.

The above argument supports that voucher for school will help economically underprivileged children get access to LFP schools, as per the choice of the parents. Now the question of the critique of the voucher model of funding school education is whether the private school really effective in terms of student learning outcome compared to government schools or not, is the crux of the debate.

The advocates of voucher school education views the theory of personal choice and market forces as a means of maintaining the social order and maximising the social order, personal choice being more important than social and collective ideals. The main supporting theme of market force is the competition, that competition effect will yield better outcome. Autonomy effect also comes in the picture here, that the assumption that private schools are more efficient and effective than government schools in achieving education outcome as private schools adapt quickly to change i.e. demand of the market (consumers means parents) and more freedom from the centralised bureaucracy. English has become more demanding and more functional which is why private schools pay more attention in learning English than Mathematics. In this context, opponents of school voucher argue that the autonomy will lead to indulge in more globalised culture reducing the preservation of indigenous in terms of linguistic and context. More explanation about impact on learning outcome is being discussed in the succeeding lines. The critiques of school voucher views that the system of voucher education will lead to downplay of social cohesion and equality of opportunity. Meaning, government schools have an inherent advantage in developing social cohesion and unifying social values and social capital, and promote equality of opportunity. My verdict of the debate is being discussed taking help of the findings from Indian context.

Following a debate thread at Mint's editorial titled "Building a schooling system that delivers'' that suggest school voucher will solve India's problem of school education, the counter view of Anurag Behar titled "Politics trumps economics" compelled me to dive into the findings of experimental evidence (Randomized control trail experiment) on the impact of a school choice programme in Andhra Pradesh (India) (the project named as Andhra Pradesh Randomized Evaluation Study (APRESt) that featured a unique two-stage lottery-based allocation of school vouchers.

As cited above the main theme of the debate on voucher schooling is the impact on learning outcome. The finding from the APRESt reaffirm, as other research finding also does, that the there is no difference between the test scores of lottery winner and losers on Mathematics and Telegu (native language) as found by Muralidharan and Sundararaman (2013). The study finds no evidence of adverse effect on government school students who do not apply for the voucher, or on students who starts out to private school. This negates the argument of the opponents of private school that voucher schooling will lessen equality of opportunity and social cohesion. The study takes into account of the instructional timing. Private school pays more time in English, Social Science, Hindi (in the case of Andhra Pradesh) while government school pays more time in Maths and Telegu, even then the results of Maths and Telegu are of no difference between Private schools and Government schools. Meaning, private schools produce same result even when they invest lesser time in Maths and Telegu. Thus the finding claims that private schools are more productive than government schools.

Moreover, the study again claims that, which is consistent with those found by Harma (2010), one demographic group that seems to be significantly benefited from the voucher programme is Muslim students. Muslims are educationally most disadvantaged demographic group in India as per Sachar Committee Report, 2006. This again negates the hypothesis of the opponents of voucher schooling that it will reduce equality of opportunity; rather this reduces educational disparity among demographic groups.

Cost effectiveness is one the critical area of decision making for a policy. The total spending of government in schools is over 3.5 times the mean per child spending in the private schools in the sample of APRESt. Meaning, the average cost per student in the private school is less than one-third of the student of the per student costs in the government schools, and thus the value of the voucher was only around 40% of the per student costs in the government schools. So the finding concludes in terms of cost effectiveness that private schools produce better academic outcomes at lower cost and unambiguously both more productive and cost effective than government schools in Indian context. Therefore, it is to draw the conclusion that from all aspect vouchers for primary schools students would be the best alternative policy for universal quality education for all in India.

Now I would like to bring in the argument in the context of the educational condition of Manipur which is far below the satisfactory level as. The condition of government schools in Manipur are so pathetic (Salam, 2014) that almost all schools have now turned into Cow sheds or home to tall grasses. Government teachers are now doing their side business apart from getting salary of being a government teacher.

Schools are absent of students because of extreme lack of confidence from parents. Former member of steering committee of Vision 2020, N. Mohendra Singh regrets about the condition of education in Manipur stating that "unless the education system is improved at primary level, Manipur will remain backward even 10 to 20 years from now'' as compared to other states. Though the system run by the state is indifference to the situation, parents are sensitive and aware enough for the future of their children. The overall enrolment of students to private school has increased multi fold in rural areas across India. It is fascinating that Manipur is one of the poorest state in India and poorest among North East Council states with 47.1 percent in 2010 and estimated 36.89 percent Below Poverty Line (BPL) for 2011-2012, yet contrary Manipur has 70 per cent of children enrolled in private school which is highest in India, followed by Kerala with 68.6 per cent.

In the situation blend with almost dead state run elementary education and sheer demand of private school from the parents it is an urgent compelling to find an alternative for economically disadvantaged children to meet desirable level of equality of opportunity. I would not suggest for Public Private Partnership (PPP) model which would again demean the core mechanism of market force, the competition effect in bringing quality education. To conclude, the above arguments solely inform us to go for school voucher system especially in Manipur as a policy alternative to the current situation of state run school education which is completely indifferent to the demand of parents and future of the children of Manipur. This is also a policy alternative to cost effectiveness (as discussed above) and quality maintenance. This will partly effect on the economy of the state as the return to education increases, the production theory that returns to education increases as input to education increases. Finally I would like to draw the attention of intellectuals to the debate on the issue for a better Manipur.


* Yasin Khan wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is a Gandhi Fellow, Kaivaliya Education Foundation, Rajasthan and presently at Azim Premji University, who can be contacted at ansary(Dot)shent(at)gmailDot)com
This article was posted on September 05, 2014.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.


LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Kang Khichri chaba @Kwakeithel : Gallery
  • Plastic Surgery Day @RIMS : Gallery
  • Kang Chingba @Keishampat : Gallery
  • Human rights of women in our society
  • AFSPA Gesture and Better Alternative
  • Leisure :: Poem
  • Restore Life After Burns : Plastic Surgery
  • IM accuses AR of 'cold-blooded murder'
  • Konung Kang Chingba #1 : Gallery
  • Dont waste searching for word/phrases
  • Hill People & Merger of Manipur
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #5
  • U-Mangra for biofuel for economic devpt
  • Painting competition on environment
  • Condemn Moreh terror attack
  • Climbing Shirui Hills, Ukhrul #3 : Gallery
  • Ichangthoubi, Thotmungchan :: eMing
  • Kang Chingba - Rath Yatra : Book
  • Why the impasse at Manipur University
  • Condolence Message for Tamenglong
  • Maharaj parleys Bizando
  • Opt for fruit/vegetable beauty product
  • DG Assam Rifles meets Governor
  • Recreation - a Serious Business
  • Tuilha Kolt waterfall @Kpi #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • Lamjing Meira Ningsing Numit #2 : Gallery
  • Who Created the Border Pillar Conflict ?
  • EEVFAM amidst Numbness and Noise
  • Special Olympics Unified Cup 2018
  • Path for youth's bright future
  • Addressing core issues
  • Students Vs Centre's man : MU
  • Thangjam Manorama Anniversary: Gallery
  • A reflection on POCSO Act, 2012
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • Fear :: Poem
  • War veterans laboured to clean compound
  • Free Career Counselling Program
  • NEFIS writes to University bodies
  • Sit-in-Protest Against House Search
  • 50th World Population Day celebrated
  • Something worrying
  • Congress : 2 days session too short
  • Jadugi Chei :: Funga Wari
  • Tribal protest for MU normalcy : Gallery
  • Framework Agreement: What is it ?
  • Some cairns from the way: Artist's retake #2
  • Cry of a Dying River # 36 :: Poem
  • Overview on Manipur University imbroglio
  • Tribal Students memo to HRD on MU
  • India-Vietnam Film Show 2018 at Delhi
  • Why the CM is helpless ?
  • No end in sight to MU crisis
  • Indo-Myanmar Pillar 81 @Kwatha #1: Gallery
  • Global Bamboo Congress @Beijing : Gallery
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #4
  • Kamesh Salam : Speaker at BARC, Beijing
  • Career in Cooperatives
  • Nagaland CM's speech at NEC
  • NPF Rejoinder to JD (U) of July 9
  • The Killing Fields - 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Unfair Game
  • Expecting documentary proof from villagers
  • Lamjing Meira Ningsing Numit #1 : Gallery
  • Woken Youth Clubs in season of World Cup
  • Converting tourism potential into reality
  • Let me live in your heart :: Poem
  • D-Jent.... Djentleman... Anyone ?
  • Socialism or destruction of humanity ?
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Demand action against KSO activists
  • 3 Manipur girls in BCCI U-19 squad
  • Rights meet on bill outcome
  • Naga integration will be democratic..
  • Ichangi Laidhi #3 :: eRang
  • Modernizing Manipur University Library
  • In the grip of nothingness :: Poem
  • Password protection - I
  • Congenital Heart Defect operated
  • Hill area bandh relaxed temporarily
  • State & central govt must stop conflict
  • Cohesion is sports
  • Explain 'devious purpose'
  • Willong Khullen, Maram #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur merger agreement 1947
  • Wari Jalsa at New Delhi
  • Congress grass menace in North-East
  • M A Thomas National Human Rights Award
  • What does worry do to us ?
  • Is Manipur a part of India ?
  • Rumours of child lifters : Dangerous
  • List of MLA (Jan 2018) #3 : Gallery
  • Forest Rights Act 2006 -context of Manipur
  • Supreme Court Hearing on EEVFAM case
  • Cry of a Dying River - 35 :: Poem
  • Terirama Th. met South Korea's first lady
  • Securing security cameras: invisible eye
  • Rejoinder to Nagaland CM's statement
  • Meitei Mayek - are the scales tipped now
  • Patronising non-locals : Nail the insiders
  • UNC oppose indefinite Manipur bandh
  • Tribal University @ Senapati : Gallery
  • Rally to remove MU VC #2 : Gallery
  • Some cairns from the way: Artist's retake #1
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #3
  • UN experts on 'fake encounter' killings
  • Nagaland CM Rio statement on July 4
  • Condemns inhuman eviction by Govt
  • Trainees Certificate of RPL at Kamrup
  • Minor reunited with mother after 26 days
  • Non-Operative Closure of "hole in the heart"
  • We are for the people, for the society
  • Over 30 days : Centre sleeps, MU 'burns'
  • Thokchom Brindashabi Devi :: Profile
  • Kshetri-bengoon Eviction Protest : Gallery
  • Successive pay commissions: It's impact
  • Research Support @ R-Square Design
  • leingakki thouwong - state terrorism
  • Rebuttal: Interview of Ranju Singh
  • Different forces pulling Manipur : Lim
  • Pakhangba Cheng Hongba #3 : Gallery
  • Some ideas for prevention of flood
  • Satisfaction :: Poem
  • Supreme Court hearing on EEVFAM - 2 July
  • Dark lips .. causes and care
  • Training on Handloom Weaver at Hojai
  • CME on 'Congenital Heart Diseases'
  • Nagaland CM should make his stand clear
  • 2019 LS polls : BJP on the offensive
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #4 : Gallery
  • Naga American conference in California
  • Life of an army officer's daughter
  • The Winter Blues :: Poem
  • 16th Mega Miss North East
  • NDPP on Naga integration
  • Allegations against VC holds no ground
  • Rally to remove MU VC #1 : Gallery
  • July Calendar for Year 2018 :: Tools
  • A Washed-Out Summer Vacation in MU
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #2
  • My short interaction with Penna Donna
  • 9th Men Mega Mister North East
  • Memo submitted to Kiren Rijiju
  • India- no interest to protect its boundary
  • Idea of who is a citizen of the land
  • Poumai Purul Hiimai Paoki #3 : Gallery
  • Dr Thingnam Kishan Memorial : Gallery
  • Black sheep in movement for ILPS #3
  • Our Common Crisis: What are We to Do #2
  • Jackichand Singh signs for FC Goa
  • No co-operation to MU VC
  • Nagaland CM contradicting himself : NPF
  • Career Guidance Workshop at Ukhrul
  • The tales of a forgotten University
  • Pulling at idea of Manipur : Lim, ATC
  • Climbing Shirui Hills, Ukhrul #2 : Gallery
  • Moirangthem Arup: 90 Km Marathon, Africa
  • Pitfalls on land acquisition for Mapithel Dam
  • Chinese dominance in 21st century
  • Caring for the elderly
  • IIT-G's Technothlon prelims at UAE
  • Mass Rally from Manipur University
  • Nagaland CM releases book by teenager
  • Why trying to dictate media time & again
  • MU, border pillar, Citizenship Bill
  • Oinam Dilip's Painting Exhibition
  • Intl Day Against Drug Abuse : Gallery
  • The Manipur Merger Agreement 1949
  • A road to Mandalay
  • Keeping up: medical diagnostics tech
  • The mother of all preventive strategies
  • Relief camps for Flood affected families
  • The dark side of Indian democracy
  • From three time CM to Oppn leader
  • Khumang Pokpa Haraoba #1 : Gallery
  • Enduring Theatre of Guerrilla War
  • Intl Day in Support of Victims of Torture
  • Impact of trade & floods on economy
  • Imparting training as profession #2
  • Najmaji's flood fixing formula
  • History of Yoga
  • Intl Day against Drug Abuse
  • Politicising MU issue: by whom ?
  • Effective ban on plastics needed
  • Thaunaphaba Marup :: Funga Wari
  • Naga Nationalism & Naga Integration
  • Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 #1
  • If I were :: Poem
  • Is football an anathema to the Indians ?
  • Miss, Mister North East contestants
  • MU Imbroglio: Power games now
  • MU crisis : Centre must act fast
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #3 : Gallery
  • Lamka's Dark Light House
  • Our Common Crisis: What are We to Do #1
  • Cry of a Dying River -34 : Poem
  • Textile industry in Manipur
  • Blood Donation Camp at New Delhi
  • Rahmani Program of Excellence
  • Mova Cave, Hungpung, Ukhrul #1 : Gallery
  • Expanding Economy Beckons :: Speech
  • Before trains arrive, must read
  • Impact of the Shirui Lily festival
  • Securing Wi-Fi: Negating doorstep threat
  • Blood donation drive in North East
  • Expecting changes in dealing SoO
  • Scourge of drug trafficking
  • Tribal Cultural Festival #2 : Gallery
  • Letter to JS-MHRD from MUTA
  • JS-MHRD did not meet with MUTA
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #2 : Gallery
  • Yoga Day: Celebrating Your Health
  • Chak-hao - black gold of Manipur
  • In response to the culture of shaming
  • 3rd Documentor Imphal
  • General Thangal Eco Park : Gallery
  • Deadline of 5 days time set : MU crisis
  • Garlic Festival @Ukhrul #4 :: Gallery
  • Flood in Imphal [14 June] #3 : Gallery
  • Dzuko valley #4 :: 360 Panorama View
  • Phumdigi Tantha : Dance Drama : Gallery
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Laitonjam Rajnikanta : Profile
  • Amuktang-Ga Haikho #1 : eRang
  • Kang Tournament @ Yaiskul : Gallery
  • HSLC 208 Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • HSLC 2018 :: Toppers Listing
  • HSLC 2018 :: Check Result
  • HSLC :: Statistical/Subject Topper
  • HSLC 2018 :: External
  • Aerial view from Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Front Page Photo 2018 #2: Gallery
  • Class XII Exam Toppers : Gallery
  • Temples of Manipur : Gallery
  • Recipients of Akademi Awards for 2014
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS