TODAY -

Meiteis & Meiteilon never been Tibeto-Burman : Never mind the guess work

Dr Irengbam Mohendra Singh *



The joy of Independence Day permeated all over Manipur on August 14 1947. I was there. But, Manipur had an Achilles Heel, the Manipur State Congress. Another fatal weakness for the superficial was the inherent silliness of the premise that Meiteis and Meiteilon are Tibeto-Burman.

The aesthetic offence of the 1950's educational revolution, seduced by Grierson, was to dupe young Meiteis into believing something that is not true.

Like Meitei insurgents my love for Manipur remains undiminished. The coming of August 14, 2017 has bolstered my faith in the singularity of Meiteis and Meiteilon. The combination of realism and fairytale in its antithesis, plotting against each other, is so baroque that it gives a novelistic impression. As rationality remains a super tool with which to investigate our ethnic origin which is uncalled for, and language, even the most adherent fan of the Tibeto-Burman genre should carry on over any linguistic hurdles, and stop being Don Quixote, and believing in The Arabian Nights .

The beginning began with a couple of British ethnologists, and linguists like Grierson. Like early 19-century geologists who struggled in vain to reconcile their findings with religious biblical accounts, they had a wave of fashionable interest with unfulfilled intellectual appetite to turn a small-scale analysis into big-picture speculation, such as Meiteis and Meiteilon are Tibeto-Burman.

Some people will have to suspend their belief, though many won't struggle to do so for their minds have been opened by whatever kind of key causes people to believe. I've begun to avoid looking into the mirror as I always think: Wow … that's a big head. We need to be lost to find ourselves and not rely on old yarns of who we are.

I keep bringing up this subject with intermittent vigour because of newer evidence that crops up while the subject is still faced with the same runaway vehicle, carrying the old story clearly and cheerfully, with just the right speed and a whiff of adult satire of pedantic pretensions that might cause Grierson to squirm in embarrassment.

Meiteilon as Tibeto-Burman, abounds in literary allusions, with frequent references to linguistic bigwigs, such as Benedict, noting that, since Benedict's manuscript of 1941 and reconstruction in 1972, Meiteilon has been flipping on its head. There's now more evidence of linguistic immaturity in classifying Meiteilon, from the 9th International Conference on the Northeast Indian Linguistic Society, Tezpur University, Assam in February 2016.

Linguistics as a discipline has leapt to academic prominence since only 1960s. Knowledge of language is an inherent part of human beings. By the time we are three years old everyone can speak the native language. This leads some writers down the garden path to have the delusion that he/she is an expert in dealing with something as universal as language.

There are fables of Tibeto-Burman migrations, such as that of Meiteis coming from you know where; or the nonsense of a recent study (2015) that went as far as to posit Sherpas of Nepal, who have lived for thousands of years in the Himalayas, as being the ancestors of Tibetans, simply because of their adaptation to low atmospheric oxygen at higher altitudes. In 1994, a study concluded that the Sherpas migrated from Tibet about 600 years ago.

What's not outrageous is the new genetic proof that Meiteis are not Tibeto-Burman. A genetic study by 11 Indian researchers, including 4 Meiteis: Sanjembam YM, Devi KN, Nongthombam AD and Khangengbam SM at the Department of Anthropology, Delhi University, published in 2009, proved that Meiteis are not Tibeto-Burman; probably an Austroasiatic like the Khasi but with a mixed gene pool.

Another genetic study by 7 researchers including 2 Meiteis: Sanjenbam Yaiphaba Meitei, Khagenbam Somibabu Meitei at the Department of Anthropology, Vidyasagar University, W Bengal and Biochemical and Molecular Anthropological Laboratory, University of Delhi, published in 2012, independently confirmed that Meiteis are not migrants from Southeast Asia.

Endlessly reproduced, parodied and ripped off is the legendary work of Grierson that interleave Meiteilon as Tibeto-Burman. What bristles against this circumscribed linguistic fantasy is the logic that, if Meiteis are proven non- Tibeto-Burman, their native language cannot be Tibeto-Burman.

There are footnotes and endnotes, and our ambiguous narrative in the present tense, germinated from a motley few English-educated Meiteis in post WWII, with their approach to literacy that stressed the acquisition of appropriate verbal and cognitive skills. At the heart of this scholastic reasoning lies the inadvertent theme of 'betrayal' of the true nature of Meiteis and Meiteilon, like all John Le Carre's spy novels.

In post-WWII, a few Meiteis having read citations from books written 100 years ago by colonialists, who after looking at our facial physiognomy (Mongoloid), conveniently clumped Meiteis and Meiteilon together with Tibeto-Burman, lost reason-d'etre of the uniqueness of Meiteis and Meiteilon. Unlike our Meitei forefathers who did not have the propensity to radicalise self-invention, they fell hook, line, and sinker for the fabricated Meitei origin and Meiteilon. There are linguistic experts, but all academic publications aren't trustworthy. New findings may later supersede them.

There are some in the Brave New World, who challenge conventional beliefs. One is Heath Robinson, English cartoonist, who invented a contraption 'to overcome the difficulties of conveying green peas to the mouth'. Understanding that, by using observation and critical thought it is often possible to discover the truth, rather than searching for answers in fantasy, I propositioned in my book (2008) The origin of the Meiteis of Manipur & Meiteilon … that, as a genetic and geographic subgroup "Meiteis were just here" in Manipur as yelhoumee – autochthons, from time beyond memory.

My hypothesis fits in with Graham Thurgood, professor Emeritus of California University, Ohio, US and Randy J LaPolla, professor of Linguistics, Nanjing Technological University, Singapore. They write in their book 'Foreign Language study' (2006. p188): "As with Karbi, it seems safe to leave Meitei (Meiteilon, Manipuri) by itself.

LaPolla says: "We should constantly challenge our most basic assumptions with arguments presented with a view to convincing us to change our conception of Sino-Tibetan [Tibeto-Burman] and to change the name of the family. The amount of research on them, both diachronic and synchronic, has multiplied in the last few decades."

Robbins Burling, an American professor of anthropology and linguistics found that, "The people of Northeastern India often construct migration stories in an attempt to explain the history and the present distribution of tribes. 'Where did the so-and-so come from?' is a question that has no meaning. While people certainly migrate, they rarely do so as coherent tribes. Westerners should understand while contemplating Northeastern Babel [Babel in the Bible as a source of single language], it is hard to avoid the suspicion that languages have been manipulated in order to be different."

The fundamental of my thinking against Grierson's is narcissistically a monster of debate but not without apologists, such as Prof Sobhana L Chelliah, University of North Texas, Sohini Ray, Prof (Emeritus) of Anthropology & Linguistics, University of Michigan, and Prof Robbins Burling, who has a deeper understanding of Northeast languages.

Recently, I read an article (April 2011) by Pauthang Haokip, Linguistics, Assam University, Silchar. He writes scholarly that, "Manipuri is often regarded as constituting a genetic subgroup within the so called Kuki-Chin-Naga group. But Burling and Thurgood in 2003 pointed out that there is no clear evidence to show that. Manipuri shares only some lexical similarities with the Kuki-Chin languages and Tangkhul due to prolonged contact between these languages. The position of Manipuri within Tibeto-Burman is yet to be properly determined.

The exact number of Manipuri dialects is somehow not made clear by previous researchers working on the language. According to Yashwanta (1995), there are four major Manipuri dialects, though Thoudam (1980) lists eight dialects. Chelliah (1997) suggests the list of dialects given by Thoudam is just geographical names rather than dialectal names of Manipuri."

Chelliah hit the nail on the head. I think Yashwanta is a scholar and Thoudam is pedantic. As for pragmatic competence, Chelliah wrote to me: "the position of Meiteilon is still uncertain. It needs a PhD thesis". It is for the linguistic department of Manipur University, to research but, with the predicate that Meiteilon is NOT Tibeto-Burman.

Burling has scoffed Matisoff and Grierson: Matisoff for "a laudable admission of ignorance for grouping Northeast Indian languages as 'Kamarupan' as there is nothing like any convincing genetic classification, and Grierson "for nonsensical classification as 'North Assam branch' which was no better substantiated."(having an interest in Meiteilon I went to see Matisoff in 1989 at Berkeley by the undersea train across San Francisco Bay).

Burling emphasises that "When reliable comparative phonology is lacking, as it generally is in Northeastern India, even judging cognate status often requires an uncomfortable amount of guesswork. In the absence of reliable phonological analyses or good description of morphology and syntax, we have no choice but to rely primarily upon the lexicon for tentative judgements and to toss languages together under arbitrary geographic labels that do more to hide than to clarify the relationship among languages."

Meiteilon is enigmatic, and the most enduring Manipuri literature like the legend of the Holy Grail, Christ's cup of the Last Supper. It is searching for the elusive truth. We haven't heard the last about Meiteilon.


* Dr Irengbam Mohendra Singh wrote this article for The Sangai Express
The writer is based in the UK. Website: www.drimsingh.co.uk
This article was posted on August 12, 2017.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.


LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Gaan-Ngai @Majorkhul #1 : Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • CAB, 2016: Ethnocide of Indigenous People
  • When 7th Pay & UGC regulations for college
  • Truthfully Yours :: Poem
  • Detox your hair
  • Job Openings at PR Enterprises, Imphal
  • Police action to protestors in Tripura
  • India in grave danger
  • Issues, issues everywhere, anytime
  • Match: 4th Women's Polo #1: Gallery
  • CAB Protest [17 Jan] : Gallery
  • Ranjit Ningthouja : Profile of a playwright
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #3
  • Bird's Eye view at 'Go To School' Mission
  • 10 % reservation & ST demand ?
  • Poetic Justice - III :: Poem
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) Demand :: Timeline
  • Legislative Assistant to MP- Fellowship
  • The changing face of Manipuri youths
  • Rolling up sleeves for ST tag
  • Symbolism in the Tribal Art #1
  • Chongdeinem, Abothem :: eMing
  • ST Demand - Poster Campaign : Gallery
  • Retrospective View On Driver's Day
  • Integrated farming & its importance
  • Nightingales in winter :: Poem
  • Tour to Delhi for border area students
  • Nagaland Cabinet Meeting on CAB
  • Gaan-Ngai @Chingmeirong : Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai - festival of Kabui #1
  • Protest against CAB [Jan 15] #2: Gallery
  • Gaan-Ngai, Festival of Zeliangrong
  • Understanding Mao Tse-Tung
  • Of Vernacular & my Enlightenment..
  • Teacher wanted at Tekcham High School
  • Demanding release of Kishorechandra
  • BJP's Agenda : Curtain raised
  • Topping in enrolment in pvt schools
  • Imoinu Erat Thouni #1 : Gallery
  • Gaan Ngai :: Flash Presentation
  • CAB Protest [16 Jan] : Gallery
  • Dr Thokchom Asha: Teacher Award
  • Cry of a Dying River - 62 :: Poem
  • Occasion & festivity as career choice
  • Rejoinder to NDPP on CAB by NPF
  • Saving tomorrow for our children
  • Open invitation to Mission schools
  • Women's Intl Polo [Jan 17] : Gallery
  • A Hymn for Goddess Emoinu
  • Manipur tops enrolment in private schools
  • Variance of laboratory results
  • A Christian perspective on solidarity #2
  • Naga International Trade Fair at Dimapur
  • Has Loktak mortgaged to Company
  • CAB: Lining up public convention on Jan 20
  • Purnima Ngangom (Printmaker) :: Profile
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #3 : Gallery
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #2
  • CAB & scoring 21 out of 25 ?
  • Complications :: Poem
  • North East Business Summit at Delhi
  • Almond oil is the ultimate skin care
  • The Bill that haunt the government
  • Over 50 police personnel chargesheeted
  • Insurgency related incidents in NE states
  • Myanmar border fence going nowhere
  • Protest against CAB [Jan 15] #1: Gallery
  • Crop diseases & organic way of managing
  • War and Poetry :: Poem
  • Landeng-Pena yakaiduna Poster Campaign
  • The Killing Fields 2013-18 : News Timeline
  • Condemns communal nature of CAB 2016
  • PCC, Arunachal Pradesh on CAB, 2016
  • CAB and other issues before LS polls
  • Sit-In against CAB [Jan 14] : Gallery
  • CAB : Our Identity & Culture is at stake
  • Re-Imagining the Naga Peace Process
  • Demand for ILP :: Articles/Photos...
  • Northeast Startup Summit 2019
  • Ponder them to live like human beings
  • No Shield for Manipur against CAB
  • Missing link: NE, CAB & obscure assurance
  • JCILPS Protest against CAB : Gallery
  • AMUCO Rally against CAB : Gallery
  • Poetic Justice - II :: Poem
  • Makar Sankranti Musing
  • Biren should release Kishorchandra
  • New archaeological site in Senapati
  • A Christian perspective on solidarity #1
  • New craft gallery to promote NE products
  • Rights body warns Nagas on Article 371 (A)
  • NE Black Day against CAB : Gallery
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #2 : Gallery
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #2: Gallery
  • Myanmar-India Business Summit, Sagaing
  • Cry of a Dying River - 61 :: Poem
  • Preventing the Dengue threat
  • NPF on Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016
  • Nagaland Chief Minister On CAB 2016
  • Hijacking by pseudoscience
  • Mr. CM, you can't fool people on CAB
  • CAB 2016: Adoption of foreign citizens
  • CAB Protest [11 Jan] #1 : Gallery
  • CAB & question of India's North East
  • Poetry Of Manipuri Women Authors #1
  • Local actions for #GlobalGoals
  • Know your HIV status
  • Pope Francis - the last Pope!
  • CAB is unsecular discriminatory bill
  • When Govt. disregard Constitutions...
  • Citizenship Bill: An exceptional exception
  • The Walking Lady : A Short Story
  • 4th Convocation Ceremony of CAU
  • The Voice of Silence :: Poem
  • Against CAB 2016 : 6 Student Bodies
  • Need for a separate time zone
  • BOOM MMA : 'Manipur Top Team' members
  • Against Citizenship Bill Act 2016
  • Lt Gen Rajeev Sirohi at Spear Corps
  • Is the middle man responsible
  • Economically weak at Rs 8 lakh per annum ?
  • Umanglai Haraoba: Traditional Institution
  • Strike against CAB : Gallery
  • People - animal conflict
  • Fine on relieving in public
  • Flawed/divisive Citizenship Bill dangerous
  • Broken :: Poem
  • Meetei gi mayokta leiba Political party..
  • NE uniting under shutdown call : CAB
  • Trains in NE to get 'glass-top' coaches
  • Yubi Lakpi #2 : Gallery
  • Freedom's fault lines
  • Traditional Manipuri Curries
  • Governance in Multi-Ethnic States
  • Understanding animal welfare
  • Unite against corruption for development
  • Manipurgi Maraibk Kari Oihougani
  • On restoring of director of CBI
  • Citizenship Bill : scourge for NE
  • Feel good factor from UNC
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #2: Gallery
  • A tale of two falcons
  • Artificial Insemination in livestock
  • The Naked Truth :: Poem
  • My itinerary visit to Veeranapalya
  • Test for Free Coaching for IIT/AIIMS
  • Critique of Transgender Persons Bill
  • Press Rejoinder from NPF [7 Jan]
  • Nagaland Cabinet on Citizenship Bill
  • Can we expect something from govt
  • Mova Cave, Ukhrul #2 :: Gallery
  • Sangai Fest: Sumo Wrestling #2 :: Gallery
  • Maipaksana RK: Entrepreneurship Award
  • Poetic Justice - I
  • IIT-G Technology Incubation Centre
  • Sana Chahi Ahum & 1857 revolt #2
  • Economics of climate change & growth
  • Singhat Students tour to Delhi & Agra
  • Congress against Modi on Rafale Deal
  • Press Club celebrates foundation day
  • NSF to impose 11-hr bandh on Jan 8
  • 518 drug traffickers arrested in 2018
  • Gangmumei Kamei Memorial lecture
  • Taking the Street Vendor seriously #1
  • WWII museums in Japan: Gallery
  • Schedule : HSLC Examination 2019
  • Schedule : Class XI Examination 2019
  • Schedule : HSE Examination 2019
  • Caste System in Contemporary India: Book
  • Save energy and save your skin
  • Benefits of henna for beauty
  • Coronary In-stent obstruction treated
  • A take on PM visit to Imphal
  • No over the top promises, assurances
  • Narendra Modi @ Imphal #1: Gallery
  • Management of commercial broiler farming
  • 61st CC Meet Football Tournament 2019
  • Noise Ruins & Blights Lives
  • Social media & freedom of speech
  • Cry of a Dying River - 60 :: Poem
  • Declare war against air pollution
  • Winter relief at Thanga
  • Of monologues and conveniences
  • Raising posers before PM's arrival: Cong
  • Irengbam Bedamani :: eRang Photos
  • Poireiton Chakhao at Loktak Lake
  • Hojang :: Poem
  • New Year: Challenges & opportunities
  • One Rank One Pension Paper (OROP)
  • Naga Peace Process :: News Timeline
  • New Year picnic at Sekmai #1: Gallery
  • May the Year 2019 bring integrity of Manipur
  • Sangai Fest: Evening Prog #2: Gallery
  • What I learned from Kishorchandra detention
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #4: Gallery
  • Village Authority in Hill Areas of Manipur #2
  • From nomenclature conflict of oral tradition
  • Bye Bye 2018 !!! : Gallery
  • Manipuri Calendar for 2019 : Download
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2018 #6: Gallery
  • Unforgettable Revolutionary NK Sanajaoba
  • Certificate distribution at Namsai, ArP
  • Top 5 Indie/Alternative Picks of 2018
  • Sangaithel Park @Sangai: Gallery
  • A view of Ukhrul Town #1: Gallery
  • January Calendar for Year 2019 :: Tools
  • National Mathematics Day & Ramanujan
  • Thougal Jagoi @Sangai: Gallery
  • Snowfall @Tamei, Tamenglong : Gallery
  • China spreads across Indochina Peninsula
  • Ningol Chakkouba Shopping #2: Gallery
  • Xmas: Churches @Lamphel : Gallery
  • 27th Imphal Book Fair #2 : Gallery
  • The Crying Call of Motherland :: Poem
  • Kwatha Festival #3 : Gallery
  • 12th Manipur Polo Intl #2 : Gallery
  • Harvard Leadership Program at Don Bosco
  • Christmas @Churachandpur : Gallery
  • UN Rapporteur briefed on Kishorechand
  • Nupi Lal Ningsing Lamjel #3: Gallery
  • Irengbam Bedamani - Actress :: eRang
  • List of Restricted Holidays for 2019
  • List of Public Holidays for 2019
  • List of General Holidays for 2019
  • Ningol - mapam lamdam : Gallery
  • Fabrics of Bangladeshi Manipuri: Download
  • Manglandasu Nang - OST :: e-pao Radio
  • Old Manipuri Movie #1 :: eRang Classic
  • SPONSORED ADS